Jump to content

Talk:Joseph Hudson

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Redirect changed to disambiguation

[edit]

I'm changing the redirect to a disambiguation page instead, because

  1. the name is very common
  2. the Army Spc. subject, Joseph Hudson, (1982-) US Army Spc. captured with American P.O.W.s in 2003 Invasion of Iraq is not notable enough for a dedicated article even as long as five years after his temporary notice in the news
  3. there are/have been hundreds of thousands, millions, of prisoners of war over centuries and
  4. if only 1/10 of 1% of them are WP:Notability (biography) notable, for example high ranking officers, remarkable escapes, turncoats, horrific tortures, then that would be 1,000 Wikipedia pages and
  5. this particular POW Joseph Hudson was only briefly held and very ordinary in the context of historical captures and imprisonments and
  6. if other opinions do not concur, then he should be given a dedicated page, to see if it survives the Wikipedia review process on its own merits..Steven Russell 07:12, 25 August 2007 (UTC)[reply]