Jump to content

Talk:Jonathan Greening

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Major vandalism

[edit]

There has been major vandalism made on this page by an unregistered user of the IP address 158.112.84.2, made on 11:45, 3 August 2006. I call for this IP address to be banned. The changes to this page by this unregistered user are just absolute random shit that makes no sense. --  MATTYTHEWHITE  yap  stalk  3/8/06

I have now restored the article back to a version which makes sense. --  MATTYTHEWHITE  yap  stalk  3/8/06

Contradiction?

[edit]

This article contradicts itself. At the top we have "Greening's favoured position is as a left-sided attacking midfielder", but in the "Style of Play" we have "Although naturally right-sided, Greening can operate anywhere across the midfield.[31]". He can't really be naturally right-sided and favour being left-sided, it's a bit of a contradiction. Though he is really a defensive midfielder now it would be way better if the internal consistency worked. Chavster01 (talk) 21:23, 19 July 2011 (UTC)[reply]

I think the article means that he's naturally right-footed, since it's not really possible for someone to favour a football position by nature. Furthermore, I don't think we can say he "favours" playing on the left without a reliable source, only that he was regularly deployed on the left by Roy Hodgson, who liked to have right-footed players on the left and left-footers on the right. – PeeJay 21:50, 19 July 2011 (UTC)[reply]