Jump to content

Talk:Irene Parlby/GA1

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

GA Review

[edit]
GA toolbox
Reviewing

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Edwininlondon (talk · contribs) 12:21, 18 June 2022 (UTC)[reply]

I'm happy to review this, with the caveat that I am not a subject matter expert. It looks like an interesting article. Review soon. Edwininlondon (talk) 12:21, 18 June 2022 (UTC)[reply]

Prose

[edit]

Overall good quality. Coverage is good. Just a few comments:

  • I'm not so sure about the section headers: Early life and Personal life don't sit so well together, as the later surely includes the former. One alternative to consider is to take the first bit of Personal life and put it into its chronological place at the end of Early life and put the bit about her death into the Legacy section, renamed Death and legacy.
 Done
  • Parlby was born on --> I think it should start with "Mary Irene Marryat was born on .." and then explcitly mention the name change upon marriage. There is some guidance on names here: MOS:CHANGEDNAME And here are some examples of articles with a name change: Bronwyn Oliver and Zelda Fitzgerald. What is a bit unusual here in this article is that you have her marriage all the way at the end. More common is to have things in chronological order as per MOS:CHRONO.
 Done changed to "Parlby was born Mary Irene Marryat on ..." similar to the style of Bronwyn Oliver
  • The Marryats were one of the oldest families in the country --> that is quite a statement! I wonder how one would determine that. Perhaps when only looking at those people for whom records were kept. Do we need this statement? Can we rephrase it such that it is less controversial and still conveys what you want to convey? The source says the family came with William the Conquerer, that might be better to use than the "one of the oldest"
 Done removed that statement entirely, probably half of England is descended from William the Conqueror so it's not that relevant
 Done
  • they were taught --> the children were taught
 Done
  • became the first local of the UFWA --> is there a word missing after local?
Per the definition of local: "a local branch of an organization, especially a labor union."
On second thought, I've changed it to "local branch" as that will probably make more sense to readers
  • including fellow Famous Five members Emily Murphy and Nellie McClung --> no first names and no links, as they have already been introduced
 Done
  • The Act disproportionately affected socially vulnerable people, including those of females and young adults --> not sure what you mean here: children of females and young adults?
 Done changed to "... including females and young adults."
  • honorary senators." --> honorary senators". as per MOS:INOROUT
 Done
  • In 2000, --> is there a reason why these legacy items (2009, 2000, 1966, 1997, 1935) are not in chronological order starting with the earliest?
 Done
  • In May 1966, Irene Parlby --> just Parlby, no irene
 Done

Media

[edit]

Well illustrated. Rights ok.

  • Board of Directors of the United Farmers of Alberta in 1919. Parlby is third from the right on the bottom row --> perhaps link United Farmers of Alberta
 Done
  • Caucus of the United Farmers of Alberta in 1921. --> no full stop if caption is not a full sentence
 Done
  • Statue of Irene Parlby in Calgary, Alberta --> consider adding it is part of a group of statues, of the Famouse Five
 Done

Sources

[edit]

Reliable sources. Formatting generally okay, but some comments:

  • 1 needs a page number, publisher
 Done
  • 3 needs a better website tag, wayback.archive-it.org is the archive-url
 Done
  • 4 I think this is a chapter in a book so needs add chapter= and Catherine A. Cavanaugh as author and Cavanaugh, Catherine; Warne, Randi as editors. And we need more specific page numbers for a b and c because 100-117 is too broad a range
 Done
  • 5 again page numbers are needed for each of a through g. The name seems to be Clare Mary McKinlay
 Done
  • 6 again, 12 pages is too broad a range
 Done
  • 7 same as 3
 Done
  • 9 I would say the title is just Irene Parlby and the website = Library and Archives Canada
 Done
 Done
  • 12 same problem as 11
 Done
  • 13 same
 Done
  • 24 I would say the title = Statues and Monuments
 Done

Sources spotcheck: 3 11 15 24 27 all ok

Thank you for bringing this article to GAN. I hope my comments are clear enough. Just ask if not. Edwininlondon (talk) 17:32, 18 June 2022 (UTC)[reply]

@Edwininlondon I've completed all of the suggestions. I think I've done the page citations properly (it looks right, at least) but I haven't done those much before. >>> Ingenuity.talk(); 20:04, 18 June 2022 (UTC)[reply]
All good. I believe this article now meets all the GA criteria. Nice work. Promoting. Edwininlondon (talk) 22:07, 18 June 2022 (UTC)[reply]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Irene_Parlby/GA1&oldid=1093799962"