Talk:I Know What You Did Last Summer (song)/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: CaliforniaDreamsFan (talk · contribs) 01:34, 30 December 2015 (UTC)[reply]

Hello, I'm CaliforniaDreamsFan . This is my first time reviewing, and I have managed to accumulate fifteen song articles into GA status, so I'll be reviewing this article for you Unfortunately, I am seeing a bit of issues with this article that needs a lot of attention in order for it to be nominated, and potentially, be awarded GA status. I will be quick-failing this article based on point 3 and point 6 of the Good article criteria because I believe it will not be able to reach a seven-day On-hold status. These two points then leads onto the main issue with the article (listed below the Immediate failure criteria); "It is a long way from meeting any one of the six good article criteria."

I feel the article itself is slightly unfinished and insufficient, and I'll quickly point out below why they are issues and some tips to improve;

The Lead/opening section features no other points that are noted throughout the article and infobox, only who it is performed by and its release date.
The Background and concept is fine, but can be worked on a little bit to make it more even and cohesive. Plus, why is there no info on who wrote it, what label released it, produced, composed, etc.?
While the Composition section has points of sampling and key notes, there is no genre, musical anaylsis, and examples in it (or any possible comment from the articles/producers about the sound).
Why is there no details about the Critical reception, Commercial performance, Certifications (if any for the latter), or even Personnel and Track list?!?
Not much detail about the Music video section (not even a useful visual/image?).
Live performances is fine.

Also, there are one/two citations that are not referenced properly. Overall, these are some of the issues that need to be worked on a lot in order for the article to get to GA status. A mere two or three sentences, like in Compositon, the lead section and Music Video isn't good enough. I personally saw some articles and webpages about the song that are worthy to include on Google, but I need to leave that with you to research and write about. If you can't find anything to improve it online, I suggest you leave the article as it is. Until then, best of luck for the next re-nomination , CaliforniaDreamsFan (talk · contribs} 01:34, 30 December 2015 (UTC)[reply]