Jump to content

Talk:I Disagree

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Genre citations in "Composition" section

[edit]

A hidden comment currently states to not add more genres since there's a lot but I think some of these should be taken out as a whole... Some are too similar to even be noticed (And genre fusions make this worse; pop-metal directly follows metal and pop being cited, it's basically unnecessary) and others aren't in the album at all even though there's citations following them. Electropop, hard rock, dubstep, experimental pop, thrash, deathcore, acoustic pop, r&b, k-pop could go easily (while the j-pop influence is noticeable in earlier Poppy albums it's barely in this one but I understand it being included) with arguments possible for others.

While genres are up to interpretation a lot of time, most of those can only be resembled in brief periods of songs. I Disagree is an incredibly eclectic album which ends up sort of being its main attraction point but I feel like that section just causes redundancy and confusion 0dlcfy (talk) 12:59, 23 October 2023 (UTC)[reply]