Jump to content

Talk:Girl Scout Cookies/Archive 2

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Archive 1Archive 2

Updated changes proposed April 18

I wanted to take my original proposed changes from the section above and present them again here, having changed them based on the feedback I’ve gotten from the other involved editors. I'd also like to add some historical images to the article. @North8000, Chrisvls, and Btphelps: I’d appreciate any additional feedback or comments any of you might have.

#1

Original text: Each Girl Scout regional council decides which licensed baking company to use for cookie sales in that council, thus determining which varieties are available in the area covered by the council.[1][2]

Girl Scouts sell cookies to relatives, friends, neighbors, and others in their town or city. In recent years, because of safety concerns, an increased emphasis has been placed on cookie booths, where girls sell from tables in public areas under the supervision of adult troop leaders, rather than door-to-door. Many councils offer the option for customers to sponsor boxes of cookies to be sent to U.S. servicemen and women.[3] Cookies are also available online.[4]

Proposed text: Girl Scouts sell cookies to relatives, friends, neighbors, and others in their town or city. Some councils offer the option for customers to sponsor boxes of cookies sent to U.S. servicemen and women.[5] The Girl Scout organization asks that members adhere to strict safety guidelines, including the cookie sale. For example, Girl Scouts, depending on their age, must be accompanied or supervised by an adult when selling Girl Scout Cookies and must always use the buddy system.[6] Girl Scouts also sell cookies through the Digital Cookie platform.[4] Each Girl Scout council decides which licensed baking company to use for cookie sales in that council, thus determining which varieties are available in the area covered by the council.[1][2] Each of the Girl Scout councils sets its own price based on its needs and knowledge of the local market.[7]

Reason: The way the safety concerns content was previously written wasn’t supported by a secondary source and implied a causal relationship between safety concerns and an increase in booth sales. The proposed version gives a summary of the actual safety guidelines.

FYI, this article may interest other editors: Boy Scouts Are Just Scouts Now, and That’s Making Girl Scouts Mad. — btphelps (talk to me) (what I've done) 03:46, 19 April 2019 (UTC)
@Btphelps: Thanks for sharing that news article. Where do you think this fits in the Girl Scouts of the USA Wikipedia article? Or maybe can you help me with what content in the news article you've shared is specifically relevant to the petition above? If you can help me understand where you're coming from, I'm open to hearing how that news article helps the Wikipedia reader understand the Girl Scouts Cookie Program.--FacultiesIntact (talk) 16:06, 19 April 2019 (UTC)
I think BTPhelps said it was more of a "of possible interest" North8000 (talk) 23:42, 19 April 2019 (UTC)
@North8000: thanks for the clarification. Do you or @Btphelps: have any feedback on my proposed version of the text?--FacultiesIntact (talk) 01:19, 26 April 2019 (UTC)
Looks fine to me except....use of their internal jargon "Digital Cookie Platform" (with no explanation) as the core statement makes that sentence uninformative at best. To keep things move i'm going to put it in without that sentence and you / we can edit from there or, anyone please revert me if they do not agree. North8000 (talk) 11:28, 26 April 2019 (UTC)
I did that. North8000 (talk) 11:39, 26 April 2019 (UTC)
@North8000: thanks for making the update. I can see where “platform” strays into jargon, especially without any context. I do think it’s important information to include though, as previously sales were done door-to-door or via a booth. How would feel about the following version: "As of 2015, Girl Scouts can also sell cookies online through the Digital Cookie mobile app."--FacultiesIntact (talk) 19:45, 26 April 2019 (UTC)
IMO that sounds better. I guess you hit a couple of my pet peeves with the previous one.  :-) it's not that it's jargon, it's that it's the internal jargon unique to the organization, and it is the basis of the main statement in the sentence.  :-) North8000 (talk) 03:22, 27 April 2019 (UTC)
@North8000: I can definitely see where you're coming from, and I'm glad we could work that out. Would you mind making the update?--FacultiesIntact (talk) 23:35, 28 April 2019 (UTC)
Happy to. I put it in. North8000 (talk) 11:17, 29 April 2019 (UTC)

#2

Original text: Elizabeth Brinton, also known as the "Cookie Queen", sold a record 18,000 boxes of cookies in a single sales season, and more than 100,000 boxes in her time as a girl scout.[8] She is known for selling cookies to sitting president Ronald Reagan. Her record held for more than twenty-nine years, until Katie Francis, 12, sold 18,107 boxes in 2014.[9] In 2017, Charlotte McCourt, a girl scout from New Jersey, sold over 25,000 boxes of cookies, breaking the record.[10]

Proposed text: Elizabeth Brinton, also known as the "Cookie Queen", sold a record 18,000 boxes of cookies in a single sales season, and more than 100,000 boxes in her time as a Girl Scout.[11] Her record held for more than 29 years, until Katie Francis, 12, sold 18,107 boxes in 2014.[12] In 2017, Charlotte McCourt, a girl scout from New Jersey, sold over 25,000 boxes of cookies, breaking the record.[13]

Reason: Brinton is not notable for selling cookies to Reagan, but for holding the cookie sales record. In the context of this article, focused on the cookies themselves, it distracts from the primary subject.

IMO there's no reason to remove the "sold to Reagan" part, and I disagree with the rationales given. First there is no notability requirement for inclusion of content in articles. Second, we do guide ourselves by coverage in sources, and the Reagan sale apparently was prominent in sources. I do think that degree of relevance is important, and feel that such is satisfied for the actual topic of the article (which is broader than just the cookies themselves) IMO it is also an interesting addition that the #1 seller also sold cookies to the president. Sincerely, North8000 (talk) 13:21, 19 April 2019 (UTC)

#3

Original text: Also, award badges exist for sales: Cookie Count, Smart Cookie, The Cookie Connection, Cookie Biz, and Cookies & Dough.[4]

Proposed text: Also, award badges exist for sales: Talk It Up, Cookie CEO, P&L, and Customer Loyalty.[14]

Reason: The current list of badges is outdated. Chrisvls helped source this new list.

I put this in. Looks like a slam dunk sourced correction of what is now a factual error. Anybody please revert if you do not agree. North8000 (talk) 02:08, 19 April 2019 (UTC)

#4

I’d also like to propose adding File:1963 Girl Scouts and cookies.tiff to the Sales section alongside the image of a girl selling cookies in 2013, and File:Girl Scout Brownies fresh cookies.tiff and File:Girl Scout Shortbread Cookie Box, circa 1960.jpg to the history section. Are there any objections to me adding the images directly?--FacultiesIntact (talk) 21:19, 18 April 2019 (UTC)

My opinion is that you should put it in. North8000 (talk) 02:09, 19 April 2019 (UTC)
@North8000: thanks again for all the help! I went ahead and added the images, as well as fixed some minor typos, specifically about referring to the organization in a consistent manner. I truly appreciate all the effort that you've put into helping improve this article.--FacultiesIntact (talk) 22:20, 19 April 2019 (UTC)

References

  1. ^ a b Duncan, Argen (March 9, 2008). "Girl Scout Cookies Take on New Shape". El Defensor Chieftain. Archived from the original on January 19, 2009. {{cite news}}: Unknown parameter |dead-url= ignored (|url-status= suggested) (help)
  2. ^ a b Abraham, Lisa (March 5, 2008). "Girl Scout Cookie Fans are Tasting a Difference". Akron Beacon Journal.
  3. ^ Quinn, Christopher (March 13, 2008). "Girl Scout Cookies Bound for Troops Overseas". Atlanta Journal-Constitution.
  4. ^ a b c Cite error: The named reference bi was invoked but never defined (see the help page).
  5. ^ Quinn, Christopher (March 13, 2008). "Girl Scout Cookies Bound for Troops Overseas". Atlanta Journal-Constitution. Archived from the original on 29 June 2011.
  6. ^ "Safety Tips for Product Sales" (PDF). Girl Scouts of the USA. Retrieved 18 April 2019.
  7. ^ McConville, Christine (April 2, 2006). "Thin Mints can be Cheaper by the Troop". The Boston Globe. p. 14.
  8. ^ Durando, Jessica (25 March 2014). "Okla. Girl Scout claims national cookie-selling record". USA Today. Retrieved 29 June 2015.
  9. ^ Stampler, Laura (25 March 2014). "Sixth-Grade Business Maven Sells 18,107 Girl Scout Cookie Boxes". Time. Archived from the original on June 29, 2015. Retrieved 25 March 2014. {{cite news}}: Unknown parameter |dead-url= ignored (|url-status= suggested) (help)
  10. ^ Rosenbaum, Sophia (2017-02-07). "Brutally honest Girl Scout is country's best seller". Nypost.com. Retrieved 2018-04-18.
  11. ^ Durando, Jessica (25 March 2014). "Okla. Girl Scout claims national cookie-selling record". USA Today. Retrieved 29 June 2015.
  12. ^ Stampler, Laura (25 March 2014). "Sixth-Grade Business Maven Sells 18,107 Girl Scout Cookie Boxes". Time. Archived from the original on June 29, 2015. Retrieved 25 March 2014. {{cite news}}: Unknown parameter |dead-url= ignored (|url-status= suggested) (help)
  13. ^ Rosenbaum, Sophia (2017-02-07). "Brutally honest Girl Scout is country's best seller". Nypost.com. Retrieved 2018-04-18.
  14. ^ "Award and Badge Explorer". Girl Scouts of the USA. Retrieved 18 April 2019.

Changes proposed May 10

In reviewing the current version of the article, I noticed a few minor (but important) things that could be corrected in the lead, Sales, and Production sections, respectively.

#1

Original text: These skills are reinforced with scouting badges, such as "Cookie CEO."

Proposed text: These skills are reinforced with Girl Scout badges, such as "Cookie CEO."

Reason: The term “scouting” can apply to any number of other scouting organizations, so we should use a more specific term to avoid any potential confusion.

Done North8000 (talk) 23:44, 10 May 2019 (UTC)

#2

Original text: Also, award badges exist for sales: Talk It Up, Cookie CEO, P&L, and Customer Loyalty.

Proposed text: Also, award badges exist for sales, including Talk It Up, Cookie CEO, P&L, and Customer Loyalty.

Reason: There are more than the four badges listed, and the statement should be qualified to mitigate any chance of the reader thinking that the relevant badges are limited to these four.

Done. North8000 (talk) 23:46, 10 May 2019 (UTC)

#3

Original text: Operation Thin Mint is a program by the Girl Scouts of the USA, led by Girls Scouts from the San Diego-Imperial Council, to provide military members with donated cookies.

Proposed text: Operation Thin Mint is a program led by Girl Scouts from the San Diego Council, to provide military members with donated cookies.

Reason: The program is not a national program, but one developed and led specifically by Girl Scouts from San Diego. Additionally, the San Diego-Imperial Council link points to a Boy Scouts council article, rather than correctly pointing to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scouting_in_California#Girl_Scouts_San_Diego.

Done North8000 (talk) 23:50, 10 May 2019 (UTC)

Does anyone have a minute to take a look and review these changes? @North8000: you've been a huge help with this already. Do you have any more time to take a look? Any comments or feedback are always appreciated.--FacultiesIntact (talk) 21:58, 10 May 2019 (UTC)

Happy to. I put them all in......looked like slam dunk clear cut. North8000 (talk) 23:52, 10 May 2019 (UTC)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Girl_Scout_Cookies/Archive_2&oldid=1233155154"