Talk:Functional database model

Copyright, WP:COI, and WP:OR Concerns

This article substantially duplicates a document from IBM originally intended for publication. The document does not appear to have been published. I cannot tell whether IBM retained copyright or had copyright to begin with, though the report was written while he was employed at IBM. Whether this version of the document is sufficiently different to allay concerns about Kimelman's possible copyright is another problem.

The WP:COI concern is obvious from the editor's username. The WP:OR concern is, well hey, the editor is the author?! Do the refs offset that?

A Functional Data Model for Analytics By: Doug Kimelman, Manny Perez ; Published in: RC25412 in 2013
A Functional Data Model for Analytics (pdf) ; Doug Kimelman ; Manny Perez ; IBM
The Functional Database Model By Manny Perez ; Published on June 9, 2015

immediately after article created here, via Linkedin by someone from Cubewise

Manny Perez at Linkedin

now working at Cubewise since May 2015 (date of article June 2015)
article author Manope256 (talk · contribs)

I think someone knowledgeable with the subject domain would have to judge whether this is a 'puff' piece. This article looks very irregular, though perhaps not fatally. Shenme (talk) 04:33, 28 November 2017 (UTC)[reply]