Talk:Dresden/GA1

Failed GA

As of [1], the article during my review, I failed this article for Good Article status. Per WP:WIAGA,

1. The article is undercited. There are a lot of unsourced sections.
2. There is a {{cleanup}} template since 1 December 2006.
3. Too many unnecessary external links, per WP:EL.
4. Too many images; they are cluttering the article. Some images do not relate with the current paragraph and its captions are not well informative. I didn't look all of those images, but found Image:Dresd 4.jpg has no fair use rationale and Image:Dresdenschool.jpg has an obsolete license tag.

When all of those issues are resolved, this article can be renominated back. As always, if you feel disagree with my reviews, you may ask for re-reviews. — Indon (reply) — 15:02, 2 January 2007 (UTC)

• Indon might have also pointed out that the article needs some drastic copy-editing and there are some factual errors and elisions. Eusebeus 15:03, 4 January 2007 (UTC)