Talk:Cotter family

Girod MacCotter - article deleted (?)

Dear All, both myself and my associate have published this article below, with the 'author unknown' poem about the Viking Sir Girod MacCotter.

Unfortunately someone has deleted the article twice now, without giving any explanation, comment or note as to why, and thus no help. We are both a little perplexed as to this form of deletion without comment, note or help of any kind.

The article below is part of an article, that had been copied, and was given to me by the 6th Baronet of Rockforest, Lt. Col. Sir Delaval Cotter D.S.O, who lived at Rockforest. I had the privilege of interviewing him many years ago. It is a short section of an original Cotter document (I was given a typed version) and thus impossible to reference, as no online article deals with this.

Question: would either the person who has deleted this article, or someone who knows more about this than we obviously do, please be kind enough to explain how one references a handwritten manuscript, that cannot be referenced, so that this rather interesting short article and poem can remain on the 'Cotter' page for all to see, appreciate and read.

(NOTE: Ballincotter in the poem, I believe, refers to Ballymacotter, possibly? And and Famry Cotter in the article could refer to Farrancotter / Fhearann Mhic Coitir - https://www.logainm.ie/en/12086)

Any help would be very much appreciated, especially as this comes from a direct source.

Regards Jack (Jac752023)

ARTICLE:

'After 1174, many Danes returned to Denmark, as they were looseing their grip on power. Sir Torfin MacCottyr, son of Therulfe, a brave warrior and leader of the Danes, stayed and built a stronghold (c. 1236) in the county of Cork, named Famry Cotter. His son, Sir Girod MacCotter, a chieftan gained hold of various 'townlands' in Imokilly. Some of these towns and villages still bear his name, DowneMacCotter, Scarth Mac Cotter ans BalyMacCotter/Ballymacotter. The following verse was written about him:

'On ye heights of Ballincotter, Gazing on that rugged shore, A Danish chieftan, bold Sir Girod, Thought upon the days of yore, With faded cheeks and rusted armour, Slowly pacing up and down, Ye Lord of Ballincotter mourned His race their loss of royal crowne'. (Author unknown)' — Preceding unsigned comment added by Jac752023 (talk • contribs) 11:35, 22 September 2024 (UTC)

If material cannot be verified by a sufficiently interested reader or other editor, then it amounts to 'own research', which is very much beyond the pale on Wikipedia and as such is not admissible, especially to an otherwise quite citation-heavy article. G de P Cotter published an article in a journal in the 1930s, which was a digest of an earlier, now lost, manuscript. This is cited in article, because it is a published secondary source that is available online and presumably in libraries or repositories. Anything in the article referring to this work is independently check-able by anyone. Your additions cannot be verified, they amount to 'hearsay' and your own back projection from place names to people, that may or may not have existed. Your inescapable problem with this material is lack of verifiability. In Wikipedia core policy any text that is not verifiable through a reasonable quality (usually published) reference source can be removed, and should be. Urselius (talk) 14:03, 22 September 2024 (UTC) I am also more than a little suspicious that by the 12th, never mind, the 13th century the Ostmen of Ireland would have been identified, by others or themselves, as 'Danes', or 'Norwegians' for that matter.

Please also note that the G de P Cotter material, though backed by a verifiable source, is not baldly presented as being factual. It is essentially family tradition, though written down and at least partially published, and as such is not historical fact. This is an important distinction. Urselius (talk) 07:10, 23 September 2024 (UTC)

Cousins

Hi Cotters. You may not be aware of it but you actually have distant cousins relatively nearby, and they are Gaelic aristocrats no less. Have a look at O'Donovan#Norse period and then maybe visit Lough Cluhir and see if you catch Ímar Ua Donnabáin on the deck of his enchanted ship. Knowing Ireland's pressures I am sure the O'Donovans were completely unaware of your existence until I put you in our article, and you were completely unaware of our existence until this moment. I myself discovered you by accident in this wonderful little book I recently received, where you are the only family of Norse extraction covered. The Coppingers and Skiddys would appear to be nearly extinct. I don't know a great deal about the other Norse-Gaelic families of Ireland but I know there is some debate about the origins of the Doyles and Reynolds. Yours is the only one I have ever come across proof for, besides ours. We got ourselves into a great deal of trouble for bringing in too many Nordic girls, and the only Irish who ever cared for us afterwards were the MacCarthy Reaghs, bless them. Thanks to the O'Briens everyone else hates us or at the very least feels some disdain, if they even know we exist. Now the main family are considered too English by some and so we apparently can't do anything right. We are an utter failure, but you are an Óttar success! DinDraithou (talk) 19:39, 22 July 2010 (UTC)

Let me rephrase a little of that. I was completely unaware of your Norseness, not of your actual existence or Gaelicness. I own a fine piece of scholarship, incidentally, by one Paul MacCotter, whose work is now everywhere, for example in trícha cét. It is Medieval Ireland: Territorial, Political and Economic Divisions. Dublin: Four Courts Press. 2008. It is an invaluable resource for the political structure and little kingdoms all over the island, but he fails to mention his own family even once, anywhere, although he covers Imokilly, where Ó Murchadha states they first settled. Thus I conclude the Cotters are partly failing at self promotion.

I have brought you to the attention of one of our cousins in Scotland, who is a bit of an expert. See User_talk:Brianann_MacAmhlaidh#Cotters. He has already found a Cotter, one Murdo MacCotter, fighting abroad in Scotland in the 1400s. This is very important, being early evidence of both warlike quality and "foreign" connections. Once it's ready we'll add it to this article. DinDraithou (talk) 21:44, 23 July 2010 (UTC)

Hello DinDraithou,

The Cotter family, primarily from County Cork, Ireland, are of Norse (Norwegian) ancestry. They have been in south-east Ireland from around 800 AD. The family name came from MacOttar (Sons of Ottar) and is associated with the Ottar Dynasty which ruled over the Scottish Hebrides, Isle of Man, Anglesey (Ynys Môn to the Cymry), and south-east Ireland (ancient Kings of Dublin, Waterford, Wexford and Cork). They lost control of Anglesey when the Welsh, with a mercenary Scottish army, drove them out.

They arrived in Ireland from Norway following two major events; the Geats (Goths) conquered their homelands in Uppsala, Sweden and drove them westward into Norway (hence the family name Ottar or Ohthere, from Ottar Vendelcrow of Uppsala), which was followed by the last major migration of the Caucasian Naphtalite Huns tribe from Armenia in the Caucasus during the 7th century AD, where they had resided since the time of the Assyrian exile around 800 BC. Norway was overcrowded in 600 AD hence the westward migrations to the Atlantic isles of Iceland, Faroe Islands, Orkney Islands, and down into the southern Irish Sea to the Hebrides, Isle of Man, Anglesey and the harbour towns of Dublin, Wexford, Waterford and Cork.

The Cotters are associated with the Gaels (Norse and Celts in the Hebrides), and are permitted to wear the kilt of the Scottish clan Maclean according to Scottish etiquette, even though they are of Norse / Irish ancestry.

The Norse kings of Dublin retained an interest in Welsh politics and they sent armies from time to time to support various Welsh princes in their internecine wars which indicates that a family connection remained even though they had lost control of Anglesey. The historian and writer August Hunt claims that Uther Pendragon (Uther the Chief Warrior) was Jarl Ohthere, the founder of the Ohthere / Ottar Dynasty. The English Tudor Dynasty started with King Henry VII, a descendant of Henri Tewder from Anglesey, and Henry VII claimed that he was a descendant of the fabled King Arthur. If this was the case, then the Tudor Dynasty represents the re-emergence of the ancient Scylfing dynasty.

Arthur is a Norse name which means bear-man, the equivalent in ancient English is Beowulf. Similarly, Anglesey is a Norse name.

The Norse continued to rule the Irish Sea for many years and became known as the Ostmen (East men). They protected Ireland from many invaders though they were eventually defeated by the Normans, the Viking battle-axe and sword is no match to the Norman long bow in naval warfare.

Further reading if it’s of interest: Wikipedia article about the Irish Cotter family: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cotter_family The connection of the Norse Sagas and Arthurian legends: http://miriamellis.com/geneaology1.shtml The Naphtalites in Norway: http://britam.org/naphtali.html Son of Ottar (talk) 14:14, 15 December 2017 (UTC) Son of Ottar

Earl Ottir

I'm fairly confident I've found someone you can claim as your ancestor, and he's famous. What's funny is that anyone could have done it and it was bound to happen eventually. That Ó Murchadha missed it is surprising because the Cogad Gáedel re Gallaib is a famous work, and though unreliable in places I see no reason to doubt the relevant passage concerning Ottir and Cork. In fact for all we know there is a book out there making the proper claim. This was too easy.

If you are in fact descended from this person in any way then it is fairly incredible. DinDraithou (talk) 19:11, 24 July 2010 (UTC)

Óttar svarti

So now we have at least two Óttar the Blacks. What this reminds me of is the habit of many Irish dynasties. I don't know about elsewhere, but in the south of Ireland first the MacCarthys,[1][2] and later the O'Sullivans,[3][4] and also the O'Donovans,[5], became obsessed with the name Domhnall or Donal and it is difficult and sometimes impossible to tell these dynasts apart. Most were given epithets but these are not always helpful. The MacCarthys went even further by sometimes repeating their epithets and so we have examples like Cormac Laidir or "Cormac the Strong" and Cormac Laidir Oge or "Cormac the Strong the Younger". The O'Donovans themselves developed the further interesting habit of often not using their given names at all and simply calling themselves "O'Donovan". Which one?

It looks to me like the Óttars were ahead of their time. I wonder, did they start the whole great trend?! DinDraithou (talk) 16:22, 29 July 2010 (UTC)

Relations of the 4th Baronet

The 4th Baronet's mother was Helena Tryndall Lombard, whose mother Ann Becher was a daughter of Mary O'Donovan, a descendant of Donal IV O'Donovan, ancestor also of Edmond Roche, 1st Baron Fermoy and his noble descendants. Thus the present baronets are now cousins to the Spencers and the British Royal Family, as well as having been for some generations cousins to the Chiefs of the Name of the O'Donovan family. I find also the Wrixon-Becher Baronets,[6] and through the prolific Bechers and others there are surely plenty more notables to be found. DinDraithou (talk) 19:52, 30 January 2011 (UTC)

Óttarson

"The name of the family in Scandinavia would have eventually become, undoubtedly, Óttarsson."

I suggest to delete this passage as it is quite simply wrong. The Scandinavian -son names are pure patronyms (at least when, as in this case, they are given in Old Norse. There are some modern East Scandinavian names ending in -son that have ossified into classical surnames).

Only the direct male descendant of Jarl Òttar (i.e. his son) would have been called "Óttarson". There are dynasty-names (i.e. Völsungar, Ynglingar...) in Old Norse sources but they are formed differently. And these dynasties are usually only mentioned in a (semi-)mythological context. It is doubtful that the descendants of a jarl would assume such a name.

Matt — Preceding unsigned comment added by 192.52.18.196 (talk) 16:18, 2 April 2012 (UTC)

Since nobody has answered yet I deleted the passage.

Matt — Preceding unsigned comment added by 192.52.18.196 (talk) 15:03, 3 April 2012 (UTC)

I agree.  — Breadbasket 20:18, 3 April 2012 (UTC)

I see someone has changed it back. Now I am no Wikipedian and I have no way to prove this but I am a scholar of medieval Scandinavian and I can tell you that there is no way the name would have become Óttarson. It seems that for some reason a member of the family would like to believe it would but it is simply not true. I will change it back now and I ask someone with a better knowledge of Wikipedia rules to tell me what I can do that it stays that way. Matt — Preceding unsigned comment added by 132.230.239.23 (talk) 09:58, 6 May 2012 (UTC)

In case you don't believe me, please read the article on Scandinavian family name etymology: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scandinavian_family_name_etymology It clearly states that early Scandinavian "surnames" were patronyms.

Matt — Preceding unsigned comment added by 132.230.239.23 (talk) 10:01, 6 May 2012 (UTC)

Death of Cotter in India

This is information passed to me through generations in my family in India. I am wondering if anyone in the Cotter family has any additional information related to this.

In 1804 Velu Thampi Dalawa then Prime Minister of Travencore Kingdom in India revolted against the British rulers. The British decide to assassinate Velu Thampi Dalawa and under influence and pressure from the British the King also turned against him. So he went to hide at the home of my grandfather's grandfather Padmanabhan Nair who was a landlord and large large contingent of martial artists warriors. Padmanabhan Nair himself was a top class martial artist who had outstanding mastery of flexible sword (urumi) and other Kalarippayattu weapons. The British sent a troop of about 250 solders under the leadership of a Colonel Sir John D. Cotter to search and kill Velu Thampi and they came to raid my ancestral home. In that fight my ancestors prevailed and they killed the Colonel, burned his body and blew his ashes away so the British cannot recover his body, not even his ashes. The place the fight took place is even today known locally as "Cotter Kari" which translates into "Cotter burned" in the local language.

I am wondering if anyone related to the Cotter family can share any info available in their family history related to this incident that happened a little over 200 years ago. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 69.181.252.128 (talk) 03:42, 22 October 2019 (UTC)