Talk:Characters in the Halo series/to do
- The vast majority of information comes from an in-universe perspective, in violation of WP:FICT.
- Although the article is not titled as a list, it still retains the basic organizational structure of a list - admitted to in its first sentence. There is little attempt to give an overview of the subject, instead, essentially, serving as a series of short mini-articles. This is not suitable for a good article - more breadth of focus is required, instead of a multitude of specificities.
- The excess of fair use images is in violation of our image policies.
- The individual profiles lack context - this article seems to not make any sense to someone who doesn't already know a fair deal about Halo. Compare to an article like Spoo, which is on an extremely specific fictional topic, but remains accessible to a non-expert reader.
- The excess of fair use images is in violation of our image policies.
- Although the article is not titled as a list, it still retains the basic organizational structure of a list - admitted to in its first sentence. There is little attempt to give an overview of the subject, instead, essentially, serving as a series of short mini-articles. This is not suitable for a good article - more breadth of focus is required, instead of a multitude of specificities.
Talk pages are where people discuss how to make content on Wikipedia the best that it can be. You can use this page to start a discussion with others about how to improve the "Characters in the Halo series/to do" page.
