Talk:Bedtime Story (Madonna song)/GA2

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Carbrera (talk · contribs) 18:24, 28 June 2016 (UTC)

Side note

I love this song and Björk so much and would be glad to review this!! :)

Lead

• "...American singer Madonna forher sixth studio album..." --> "...American singer Madonna for her sixth studio album..."
• "was written by Björk...and was the first time the former wrote a song for a Madonna album." --> Wasn't it also the only time she wrote a song for Madonna?

Background and release

• "...on the soul musical scene," --> soul musical scene? Shouldn't it be soul music scene?
• "Madonna also wanted to explore the British club musical scene" --> Same here

Recording and composition

• Doesn't sound right to me; shouldn't it be: "Unlike Madonna's more up-tempo, melodic work, the song is slower and has less melody but complex rhythmic structure.[9]" --> "Unlike Madonna's more up-tempo, melodic work, the song is slower and has less melody but a more complex rhythmic structure.[9]"
• Rest is great

Critical reception

• "in a review for the album as a whole..." --> "in a review for the parent album as a whole..."
• "author Victor Amaro Vicente wrote in his book," --> "Author Victor Amaro Vicente wrote in his book,"

Commercial performance

• "she would have achieved a consecutive string of 33 top 40 hits, starting from her single "Holiday" (1983)." --> "She would have achieved a consecutive string of 33 top 40 hits, starting from her single "Holiday" (1983)."
• "On the Canadian RPM Top Singles chart it reached a peak of number 46.[28]" --> "On the Canadian RPM Top Singles chart, it reached a peak of number 46.[28]"

Music video

Background and development

• "About 20 days later Shaffer dropped the final sketches at Propaganda Films, who were producing the video.[38]" --> "About 20 days later, Shaffer dropped the final sketches at Propaganda Films, who were producing the video.[38]"
• Rest is flawless; great work! :)

Reception and analysis

• "The music video has also drawn comparisons to Tarsem Singh's films, The Fall (2006) and The Cell," --> What year was The Cell released in to stay consistent?

Live performances and legacy

• "A Junior Vasquez remix of the song was performed at the 1995 Brit Awards, Madonna wore a white Versace dress and long hair extensions, an image similar to the Versace advertisement campaign she was promoting." --> A comma in between "Brit Awards" and "Madonna" is incorrect and should be either a period or a semi–colon.

Track listings and formats

• Fantastic!

Charts

• Great! :)

End of GA Review:

• Absolute great work IndianBio! I love this song and am glad I was able to review it! Please @PING me once you have finished making any changes, or if you have any questions for me. Thanks! Cheers, Carbrera (talk) 22:18, 28 June 2016 (UTC).

@Carbrera: all done here and Human Nature as well. —IB ^{[ Poke ]} 09:16, 29 June 2016 (UTC)