Jump to content

Talk:Aratta/article

Page contents not supported in other languages.
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Aratta is a land that appears in Sumerian myths surrounding Enmerkar and Lugalbanda, two early and possibly mythical kings of Uruk. According to the Sumerian king list, they would have ruled ca. the 27th century BC.

Role in Sumerian literature

[edit]

Aratta is described as follows in Sumerian literature:

  • It is a fabulously wealthy place full of gold, silver, lapis lazuli and other precious materials, as well as the artisans to craft them.[1]
  • It is remote and difficult to reach.
  • It is home to the goddess Inana, who transfers her allegiance from Aratta to Uruk.
  • It is conquered by Enmerkar of Uruk.

Mentions in Sumerian literature

[edit]

Enmerkar and the Lord of Aratta [1] - The goddess Inana resides in Aratta, but Enmerkar of Uruk pleases her more than the (unnamed) Lord of Aratta. Emmerkar wants Aratta to submit to Uruk, bring stones down from the mountain, craft gold, silver and lapis lazuli, and send them, along with "kugmea" ore to Uruk to build a temple. Inana bids him send a messenger to Aratta, who ascends and descends the "Zubi" mountains, and crosses Susa, Anshan, and "five, six, seven" mountains before approaching Aratta. Aratta in turn wants grain in exchange. However Inana transfers her allegience to Uruk, and the grain gains the favor of Aratta's people for Uruk, so the Lord of Aratta challenges Enmerkar to send a champion to fight his champion. Then the god Ishkur makes Aratta's crops grow.

Enmerkar and En-suhgir-ana [2] - En-suhgir-ana, the lord of Aratta, challenges Enmerkar of Uruk to a contest of champions over the goddess Inana, and his champion is defeated. But a sorcerer offers to make Uruk submit, and an advisor says he will make Uruk transport its own goods to Aratta by flotilla. The sorcerer then bewitches Uruk's animals, but a wise woman outwits him, and En-suhgir-ana admits defeat, and the loss of the goddess Inana to Enmerkar.

Lugalbanda in the Mountain Cave [3] - is a tale of Lugalbanda, who will become Enmerkar's successor. Enmerkar's army travels through mountainous territory to wage war against rebellious Aratta. Lugalbanda falls ill and is left in a cave, but he prays to the various gods, recovers, and must find his way out of the mountains.

Lugalbanda and the Anzud Bird [4] - Lugalbanda befriends the Anzud bird, and asks it to help him find his army again. When Enmerkar's army is faced with setback, Lugalbanda volunteers to return to Uruk to ask the goddess Inana's aid. He crosses through the mountains, into the flat land, from the edge to the top of Anshan and then to Uruk, where Inana helps him. She advises Enmerkar to carry off Aratta's "worked metal and metalsmiths and worked stone and stonemasons" and all the "moulds of Aratta will be his". Then the city is described as having battlements made of green lapis lazuli and bricks made of "tinstone dug out in the mountains where the cypress grows".

Other mentions in Sumerian literature

[edit]
  • Praise Poem of Shulgi (Shulgi Y)[5]: "I filled it with treasures like those of holy Aratta."
  • Shulgi and Ninlil's barge[6]: "Aratta, full-laden with treasures"
  • Proverbs[7],[8],[9]: "When the authorities are wise, and the poor are loyal, it is the effect of the blessing of Aratta."
  • Unprovenanced Proverbs[10]: "When the authorities are wise, and the poor are passed by, it is the effect of the blessing of Aratta."
  • Hymn to Hendursanga (Hendursanga A)[11]: "So that Aratta will be overwhelmed (?), Lugalbanda stands by at your (Hendursanga's) behest."
  • Hymn to Nisaba (Nisaba A)[12]: "In Aratta he (Enki?) has placed E-zagin (the lapis lazuli temple) at her (Nisaba's) disposal."
  • The building of Ninngirsu's temple[13]: "pure like Kesh and Aratta"
  • Tigi to Suen (Nanna I) [14]: "the shrine of my heart which I (Nanna) have founded in joy like Aratta"
  • Inana and Ibeh[15]: "the inaccessible mountain range Aratta"
  • Gilgamesh and Huwawa (Version B)[16]: "they know the way even to Aratta"
  • Temple Hymns[17]: Aratta is "respected"
  • The Kesh Temple Hymn[18]: Aratta is"important"
  • Lament for Ur[19]: Aratta is "weighty (counsel)"

Location hypotheses

[edit]

Although Aratta is known only from myth,[2] some Assyriologists and archaeologists have speculated on possible locations where Aratta could have been, using criteria from the myths:[3][4]

1) Land travelers must pass through Susa and the mountainous Anshan region to reach it.
2) It is a source of, or has access to valuable gems and minerals, in particular lapis lazuli, that are crafted on site.
3) It is accessible to Uruk by watercourse, yet remote from Uruk.
4) It is close enough to march a 27th century BC Sumerian army there.

In 1963, Samuel Noah Kramer thought that a "Mount Hurum" in a Lugalbanda myth (which he titled "Lugalbanda on Mount Hurrum" at the time) might have referred to the Hurrians, and hence speculated Aratta to be near Lake Urmia.[5] However, "Mount Hurum", "hur-ru-um kur-ra-ka", in what is now called Lugalbanda in the Mountain Cave,[20] is today read "mountain cave",[6] and Kramer subsequently introduced the title "Lugalbanda, the Wandering Hero" for this story.[7]

Other speculations referred to the early gem trade route, the "Great Khorasan Road" from the Himalayan Mountains[8] to Mesopotamia, which ran through northern Iran.[9][10][11] Anshan, which had not yet been located then, was assumed to be in the central Zagros mountain range.[12] However, when Anshan[13] was identified as Tall-i Malyan in 1973,[14] it was found to be 600 km south-east of Uruk, far removed from any northerly routes or watercourses from Uruk, and posing the logistical improbability of getting a 27th century BC Sumerian army through 550 km of Elamite territory to wage war with Aratta.[15] Nevertheless, there have been speculations referring to eastern Iran as well.[16][17]

By 1973, archaeologists were noting that there was no archaeological record of Aratta's existence outside of myth,[2] and in 1978 Hansman cautions against over-speculation.[18]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ Cohen (1973) p. 55 notes: "Aratta became a epithet for "abundance" and "glory"."
  2. ^ a b Cohen (1973) p. 61. Cohen states: "it is indeed strange that the name of such an important trade center should as yet remain unknown to us from any economic, administrative or other non-literary texts from the Ur III or Old Babylonian period".
  3. ^ Kramer (1963), Gordon (1967) and Cohen (1973)
  4. ^ Herrmann (1968), Hansman (1972, 1978) and Majidzadeh (1976)
  5. ^ Kramer (1963) p. 275.
  6. ^ see e.g. Lugalbanda in the Mountain Cave, ETCSL (2006) line 102, etc.; Reallexikon der Assyriologie und Vorderasiatischen Archäologie (1990) vol. 7, p. 121; Black (1998) p. 136; Vanstiphout (2003) p.110-111, etc.
  7. ^ Reallexikon der Assyriologie und Vorderasiatischen Archäologie (1990) vol. 7, p. 121
  8. ^ The only source of lapis lazuli for the ancient world was Badakhshan, Afghanistan (see Clark (1986) p. 67).
  9. ^ Gordon (1967) p. 72, note 9. The Sanandaj area.
  10. ^ Herrmann (1968) p. 54. South or southeast of the Caspian Sea (cited in Majidzadeh (1976)).
  11. ^ Cohen (1973) p. 60. The Hamadan area.
  12. ^ e.g. Gordon (1967) p. 72 note 9. Kermanshah; Mallowan (1969) p. 256. Bakhtiari territory (cited in Mallowan (1985) p. 401, note 1).
  13. ^ In contrast to Aratta, Anshan is well documented beyond literary texts (c.f. Hansman (1985) pp. 25-35).
  14. ^ Reiner, Erica (1973) "The Location of Anšan", Revue d'Assyriologie 67, pp. 57-62 (cited in Majidzadeh (1976), Hansman (1985)).
  15. ^ Cohen (1973) p. 59. Cohen also notes that the farthest east that any Assyrian king ever went was Hamadan.
  16. ^ Hansman, John F. (1972, 1978). Shahr-i Sokhta.
  17. ^ Majidzadeh (1976) Shahdad.
  18. ^ Hansman (1978): "In the case of Aratta, where no inscriptions or texts are currently available to favor any one site, the mechanics of identification depend largely on inductive inquiry. At best such methods provide indications from which a location may be postulated as being reasonable or possible. But one cannot assume too much, for then the hypothesis becomes subjective rather than objective."

Bibliography

[edit]
  • Black, Jeremy (1998). Reading Sumerian Poetry. Cornell University Press. p. 136. ISBN 0801433398. {{cite book}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help)
  • Hansman, John F. (1972). "Elamites, Achaemenians and Anshan". Iran. 10: 118, footnote 97. {{cite journal}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help); Unknown parameter |note= ignored (help)
  • Herrmann, Georgina (1968). "Lapis Lazuli: The Early Phase of its Trade". Iraq. 30: 36, 54. {{cite journal}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help); Unknown parameter |note= ignored (help)
  • Majidzadeh, Yousef (1976). "The Land of Aratta". Journal of Near Eastern Studies. 35: 105–114. Retrieved 2005-03-15. {{cite journal}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help)
  • Mallowan, Max (1969). "Elamite Problems". Proceedings of the British Academy. LV. London: 256. {{cite journal}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help); Unknown parameter |note= ignored (help)
  • Movsisyan, Artak (2001). Aratta: Land of the Sacred Law. Yerevan. {{cite book}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help)CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  • Potts, Daniel T. (2004). "Exit Aratta: Southeastern Iran and the Land of Marhashi". Name-ye Iran-e Bastan. 4/1: 1–11. {{cite journal}}: Cite has empty unknown parameters: |note= and |coauthors= (help)
  • Reiner, Erica (1973). "The Location of Anšan". Revue d'Assyriologie. 67: 57–62. {{cite journal}}: Cite has empty unknown parameter: |coauthors= (help); Unknown parameter |note= ignored (help)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Aratta/article&oldid=205909049"