Talk:2019 Cricket World Cup/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Ianblair23 (talk · contribs) 11:36, 2 February 2020 (UTC)[reply]

Hi HawkAussie, please see my comments below:

Lead

with both teams scoring 241 add runs

Qualification

Ireland also missed the competition for the first time since 2003 link 2003 Cricket World Cup

Venues

All of the venues used are in England except for Sophia Gardens, which is in Wales add this ref [1]
Refs are required for the capacity figures
Capacity of The Oval is 25,500 according to [2]

Match officials

Swap David Boon and Chris Broad to correctly list alphabetically

Warm-up matches

These matches did not have One Day International (ODI) status include that they did not List A status either and add this ref

Opening ceremony

Jaya Ahsan, Damayanthi Dharsha, Chris Hughes, Sean Fitzpatrick and Pat Cash attending the opening ceremony is not supported by the ref
Add that prior to the ceremony a reception was held at Buckingham Palace where the Queen and Prince Harry welcomed the ten captains. [3]

Group stage

The top four teams from the group stage progressed to the knockout stage. If teams were tied on points, then the number of wins and then the net run rate was used to separate them. add ref
A similar format was previously used in the 1992 Cricket World Cup, though that tournament featured nine teams instead of ten. add this ref

Week 1

the West Indies bowled out Pakistan for just 105 add the lowest completed innings score of the tournament (ref)
At the Oval, in the fifth match of the group stage → The Oval
as South Africa fell short by 21 runs technically South Africa fell short [of their target] by 22 runs but they lost by 21 runs.
The following day saw Pakistan cause an upset over one of the tournament favourites, as they beat England by 14 runs at Trent Bridge. This was despite Joe Root (107) and Jos Buttler (103) both scoring centuries in the chase, as they became the first and second batsmen to score hundreds at the tournaments. add that England became the first team in World Cup history to lose despite having two century-makers. [4] also add this ref which explicitly lists Root and Buttler as the first two to score a century in this World Cup.
Sri Lanka got off to a good start in their game against Afghanistan in Cardiff, reaching 144/1 in the 21st over. This was before three wickets in five balls from Mohammad Nabi provided the catalyst for a collapse that saw Sri Lanka bowled out for 201. Kusal Perera top-scored for Sri Lanka with 78, while Nabi took another wicket to finish with four for the innings. Rain reduced Afghanistan's innings to 41 overs, but by the 14th over, they had already fallen to 57/5. A partnership of 64 from Najibullah Zadran (who top-scored with 43) and Gulbadin Naib steadied the innings for Afghanistan, but it was not enough, with Nuwan Pradeep taking two quick wickets as Afghanistan fell 34 runs short of their revised target. At five sentences long, this is longest summary for any match in the group stage. Suggest trimming this one back.
the Black Caps went from 160/2 to 191/5 chasing 244 New Zealand's target was 245

Week 2

with Australia having an early batting collapse to fall to 38/4 early in their innings against the West Indies early is mentioned twice, suggest removing the first
In Taunton, a five-wicket haul from Kiwi bowler James Neesham add it was his maiden ODI five-wicket haul [5]
In the run chase, Australia were behind the required run rate for much of their innings, despite half-centuries from David Warner, Steve Smith and Alex Carey, and were bowled out for 316, Bhuvneshwar Kumar and Jasprit Bumrah taking three wickets each. Split this long sentence.

Week 3

after going off after the eighth over → after leaving the field in the eighth over
This was thanks to a century from Bangladeshi all-rounder Shakib Al Hasan, who scored 124 from 99 balls as they chased down the target of 322. In the West Indies' innings, Shai Hope top-scored with 96 runs from 121 balls as he and Evin Lewis (70) got the West Indies to 321/8 from their 50 overs. Reverse these sentences as the West Indies batted first and also add that this was Bangladesh's highest successful run chase in ODIs and that this was the second highest successful run chase in World Cup history
leading the hosts to a total of 397/6, the highest total of the tournament so far remove 'so far' as it ended up being the highest [6]
Hashmatullah Shahidi managed 76 in response for Afghanistan, but they were always behind the required rate and fell 150 runs short, managing 247 from their 50 overs. Afghanistan fell 151 runs short of their target for victory and move ref 68 to the end of this sentence.

Week 4

Week four saw David Warner score 166, aided by a score of 89 from Usman Khawaja in Nottingham. Australia's total of 381/5 proved out of reach for Bangladesh, despite Mahmudullah and Mushfiqur Rahim getting them within 48 runs of the target. Expand on this to included that Warner's 166 was the highest individual innings of the tournament [7]; that Bangladesh's 333/8 was their new highest total in ODIs surpassing the record they set against South Africa 18 days earlier; [8] and that the 714 runs scored is the highest match aggregate in a World Cup match. [9]
Stokes, who was left stranded on 82* replace asterisk with 'not out'
England fell 20 short all out 21 runs short
saw Afghanistan fall 11 runs short 12 runs short
within five runs of the target six runs
caught by Trent Boult at long on link Fielding (cricket)#Fielding position names and locations
as New Zealand won by only five runs remove 'only'

Week 5

The fifth week of the tournament started with India demolishing 'demolishing' is peacock term
out for only 143 remove 'only'
Starc became the first player to get three five-wicket hauls at a World Cup → Starc became the first player to take three five-wicket hauls at the World Cup and link to List of Cricket World Cup five-wicket hauls
before a century partnership between Khawaja and Carey Usman Khawaja and Alex Carey
New Zealand managed just 157 remove 'just'
add that Trent Boult took the second hat-trick of this World Cup
saw Afghanistan set 228 against Pakistan 227 [10]
Pakistan home to a three-wicket victory with only two balls to spare remove 'only'

Week 6

Despite Bangladesh losing the match, Shakib Al Hasan finished his tournament with 606 runs, surpassing Sachin Tendulkar's record for the most runs in the group stage of a World Cup. Shakib's record would very soon be surpassed by Rohit Sharma and David Warner by the end of the group stage, with former top-scoring in the group stage with 647 runs Ref 79 needs to move to end of the first sentence and this ref needs to be added to end of the second sentence.
India cruised to a seven-wicket victory over Sri Lanka off the back of centuries from K. L. Rahul and Rohit Sharma as they chased down a target of 265 runs with seven wickets to spare. 'seven wickets to spare' is redundant
Add that Rohit Sharma became the fist batsman to score five centuries in a world cup and equalled Tendulkar's record of six overall.
Angelo Mathews scored his third ODI century for Sri Lanka, all of which had come against India. this is not supported by ref 91. But this ref does
India finished top first or top of the table
the victory by only 10 runs redundant

Fixtures

All times are in British Summer Time (UTC+01:00) no times are listed

Knockout stage

If any match ended in a tie, a Super Over would be used to determine the winner; each team would select three batsmen and a bowler, with the full team available to field. There would be no penalty for the loss of a wicket, but the loss of two wickets would end the Super Over. If the scores in the Super Over were also tied, the winner would be determined by the two teams' overall boundary count, including both the match itself and the Super Over this is not supported by ref 95.

Semi-finals

85 off just 65 balls remove 'just'
Add the Mitchell Starc took his 27th wicket, the most in a single world cup. [11]
Add that Rohit Sharma also finished as the tournament's top run-scorer overall with 648 runs. [12]

Final

After two dot balls link Glossary of cricket terms#D
despite the Laws of Cricket Laws of Cricket should be in italics
Stokes left unbeaten with 84* remove asterisk

Notes

Note B requires a reference

References

Ref 1 – (ICC Men's Cricket World Cup 2019 shatters audience records) add date = 12 July 2019
Ref 4 – (Cricket World Cup 2019 to stay at only 10 teams) add author = Stephan Shemilt
Ref 5 – (Afghanistan and Ireland receive opportunity to qualify for the ICC Cricket World Cup 2019 with Full Members) link is now at: https://www.icc-cricket.com/news/180940 and add date = 28 January 2015
Ref 6 – (Sri Lanka qualify for ICC Cricket World Cup 2019) replace with a cite web template and add date = 19 September 2017
Ref 7 – (ICC's Richardson wants more teams in World T20) link is now at: https://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/26169975/icc-dave-richardson-wants-expand-world-t20-first-round-18-teams-super-12-phase and correct date to 4 April 2016
Ref 8 – (West Indies reach 2019 Cricket World Cup as Scotland are denied by rain in Qualifier) add date = 21 March 2018
Ref 9 – (Afghanistan qualify for CWC19) add date = 23 March 2018
Ref 11 – (Ireland miss out on World Cup for the first time since 2003) add agency = PA Media
Ref 13 – (Cricket World Cup: The Final 10) add date = 23 March 2018
Ref 16 – (ECB considering using Olympic Stadium to host 2019 Cricket World Cup games) remove 'Exclusive by'
Ref 17 – (London Olympic Stadium gets ICC approval) link is now at: https://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/18536389/london-olympic-stadium-gets-approval-2019-world-cup and add author = Tim Wigmore
Ref 19 – (The many shapes of England’s cricket stadiums) add author = Shadab Nazmi
Ref 22 – (Uncapped Blundell named in New Zealand World Cup squad, Sodhi preferred to Astle) add date = 2 April 2019
Ref 24 – (Top 10 Oldest Players in ICC Cricket World Cup 2019) add author = Vipul B
Ref 25 – (Match officials for ICC Men's Cricket World Cup 2019 announced) add date = 26 April 2019
Ref 26 – (Umpire Ian Gould to retire after World Cup) link is now at: https://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/26608204/umpire-ian-gould-retire-world-cup and add date = 26 April 2019
Ref 30 – (A royal party opens Cricket World Cup on the Mall ahead of today's opening match) add date = 30 May 2019
Ref 34 – (ICC Cricket World Cup 2019 Opening Ceremony Highlights: Team captains meet the Queen as opening party concludes- Firstcricket News, Firstpost) add date = 29 May 2019
Ref 37 – (Will violence prevent India vs. Pakistan World Cup showdown?) add date = 26 February 2019
Ref 39 – (ICC warns BCCI: India likely to lose proposal to ban Pakistan from World Cup) add author Jepher Nickels
Ref 40 – (ICC to BCCI: Severing cricket ties with countries not our domain) add date = 3 March 2019
Ref 41 – (International Cricket Council Turns Down Indian Board's Request On Terrorism: Report) add author Santosh Rao
Ref 43 – (West Indies annihilate Pakistan in brutal World Cup opener) add agency = AAP
Ref 48 – (Cricket World Cup 2019 - Pakistan stun England) add agency = AFP
Ref 53 – (Pakistan and Sri Lanka share the points as rain leads to World Cup washout) add agency = AP
Ref 64 – (Proteas down Afghanistan for first victory) correct spelling of Supersport
Ref 66 – (Superb Kuldeep Yadav puts Pakistan in a spin to turn match India's way) The Guardian should be in italics
Ref 67 – (World Cup 2019: Shakib Al Hasan, Liton Das power Bangladesh past West Indies in record chase) added Scroll.in and agency = AFP
Ref 70 – (David Warner hits century as Australia return to table top with win over Bangladesh) The Telegraph should be in italics
Ref 71 – (England vs Sri Lanka: Malinga Inspires Lanka to 20-run Win at Headingley) add News18
Ref 73 – (NZ defeat West Indies in absolutely thrilling Cup contest) add news.com.au and agency = AP
Ref 75 – (Shakib al Hasan matches Yuvraj Singh's World Cup record for best all-round performance) add Indian Express
Ref 76 – (Bangladesh keep hopes alive as Shakib Al Hasan sinks Afghanistan) The Guardian should be in italics
Ref 78 – (World Cup 2019: Pakistan keep semi-final hopes alive after handing New Zealand 1st defeat) India Today should be in italics
Ref 80 – (Virat Kohli and Mohammed Shami lead India's demolition of West Indies) The Guardian should be in italics
Ref 81 – (Cricket World Cup: Sri Lanka stung by South Africa after bees stop play) The Guardian should be in italics
Ref 83 – (Pakistan's Imad Wasim holds nerve to see off Afghanistan in thriller) The Guardian should be in italics
Ref 85 – (Avishka Fernando hits high notes and Sri Lanka hold nerve against West Indies) The Guardian should be in italics
Ref 86 – (Shakib Al Hasan first to 500 runs and 10 wickets in single World Cup) remove 'Team Sportstar' as the author and remove The Hindu
Ref 87 – (India qualify for Cricket World Cup semi-finals after Rohit Sharma's ton against Bangladesh) The Telegraph should be in italics
Ref 88 – (England v New Zealand: Hosts reach World Cup semi-finals) BBC Sport should be in italics
Ref 89 – (Afghanistan and Ikram give West Indies fright but still end up winless) The Guardian should be in italics
Ref 90 – (Pakistan thrash Tigers) The Daily Star should be in italics
Ref 91 – (India pile tons on Sri Lanka and end up leapfrogging Australia) The Guardian should be in italics
Ref 97 – (Cricket World Cup: Australia beaten by South Africa in Manchester) add Amy Lofthouse as the author and 6 July 2019 as the date
Ref 98 – (India v New Zealand semi-final to resume on Wednesday after rain delay) The Guardian should be in italics
Ref 101 – (England thrash Australia to reach their fourth Cricket World Cup final) The Guardian should be in italics
Ref 107 – title needs correcting, date and newspaper to be added
Ref 112 – (Live from Cricket World Cup: Sunset+Vine execs discuss storytelling and adding production 'gloss') add date = 10 July 2019
Ref 114 – (Cricket World Cup 2019: Prime TV will air the Black Caps in Lord's final) add date = 11 July 2019
Ref 115 – (Hotstar sets global streaming record during India-New Zealand semi-final) add author = Ed Dixon and date = 17 July 2019
Ref 117 – (Willow TV to Broadcast Cricket World cup 2019 Live in USA) link is dead

Images

All images need alt text.
Add this ref to the caption for the Root image.
For Hasan's image caption Shakib Al Hasan (pictured in 2009) became the only cricketer in the World Cup history with 600 runs and 10 wickets. specify that this was in a single World Cup. But to a wider point, the image is included in the Week 5 paragraph which is where he broke 500 runs. So reader as I went down it mentions 600 which I thought was an error. It is not until you reach the Week 6 paragraph that you find that he actually scored 600 runs. So I suggest that the caption is changed to list 500 runs or move it down to the Week 6 paragraph.

@Ianblair23: Right I have gone through and done the modifications as you suggested but I have left out some of those thoughts.

The Mitchell Starc and Rohit Sharma leading takers have been moved into the statistics to have some prose for that section as I felt like that bit was lacking.
Putting the fact that James Neesham getting his maiden five wicket haul doesn't quite fit into a summary sort of style.
Trent Boult took the second hat-trick of this World Cup - Again we are trying to summarise a tournament not needing to expand it.
I might have a missed a couple of things while going through the big list but when their is over 30 kilobytes of prose, you can sometimes miss stuff out. HawkAussie (talk) 03:48, 7 February 2020 (UTC)[reply]

Hi HawkAussie, thanks for making these changes. Please see my review below:

GA review (see here for what the criteria are, and here for what they are not)

It is reasonably well written.
a (prose, spelling, and grammar): b (MoS for lead, layout, word choice, fiction, and lists):
No issues.
It is factually accurate and verifiable.
a (reference section): b (citations to reliable sources): c (OR): d (copyvio and plagiarism):
All claims are supported by an appropriate reference with no original research, plagiarism or copyright issues.
It is broad in its coverage.
a (major aspects): b (focused):
Coverage is excellent, includes all sections that is found on international sporting tournaments articles.
It follows the neutral point of view policy.
Fair representation without bias:
Article complies with NPOV including all match summaries.
It is stable.
No edit wars, etc.:
The edit history is fairly stable now that the tournament is completed.
It is illustrated by images and other media, where possible and appropriate.
a (images are tagged and non-free content have fair use rationales): b (appropriate use with suitable captions):
All images are appropriately licenced, have suitable captions and alt text.
Overall:
Pass/Fail:
Excellent work on this article HawkAussie. This article has promoted to Good article status. Cheers – Ianblair23 (talk) 10:36, 9 February 2020 (UTC)[reply]