Talk:İş Bank commercial featuring Atatürk/Archive 1
 | This is an archive of past discussions about İş Bank commercial featuring Atatürk. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current talk page. |
| Archive 1 |
GA Status
The article has passed Sections 4) and 5). Work needs to be done on Sections 1), 2), 3) and 6).
Overall, the assessment is ON HOLD.
1) Style
Plot Section
- Add, "Awe struck" before "the boy asks how,,,"
- Replace "Shocked" with "Over-awed"
- Put quotation marks around "whether he isn't Ataturk?"
- Replace "still shocked" with "still in awe"
Production section
- Put "black and white" in commas
- Remove "itself"
- Replace "made out of" with "made up of"
- Replace "was acted by" with "was played by"
- Replace "take" with "shoot"
- Replace "agreement concluded with" with "agreed upon"
- Remove "had"
Reception section
- No contractions allowed in Wikipedia, other than in direct quotes, replace "wasn't"
2) Accuracy
Infobox
- Gürkan Kurtkaya
- Hakan Büyüktopçu
are all non-existent links.
Plot Section
- Expound on the meaning of the "lesson". There will be some readers who will not understand that Ataturk means that achievement requires hard work and pain. Make the meaning of the "lesson" clear.
Production section
- Gürkan Kurtkaya
- Rıdvan Akar
- Hakan Büyüktopçu
- Vittorio Sodano
- Suzan Kardeş
- Nalan Türkoğlu
- Paşabahçe
are all non-existent links.
References section
- Haber Türk
- Akşam
are all non-existent links.
3) Coverage
Introduction
- Expand the Introduction, include a reference on how the commercial was received by the Turkish media. Add a paragraph on how Ataturk has been depicted in the Turkish media since his death. You have to make the case why this commercial is notable. See WP:Lead. Is this commercial a break in tradition in the way Ataturk has been portrayed in Turkey ?
Production Section
- Who is Ridvan Akar ? and why was he specifically consulted ?
Reception section
- Expand Reception. How has Turkish media reacted to this commercial ? Have there been any commentaries, debates ? How have İş Bank's customers' reacted to the commercial ?
4) Neutrality
Article is neutral in tone.
5) Stability
Article is stable. No major edit wars.
6) Photos
A Fair Use screenshot is used, however, the Fair Use Template is not. Rewrite Fair Use rationale using the template : Template:Non-free use rationale.
The corrections, as specified above, must be done by 17 December 2007. Contact me when they have been and I shall re-assess.
Tovojolo (talk) 21:07, 10 December 2007 (UTC)
GA Status Fail
I note that the work, that was required to achieve GA Status, was not done. I, therefore, have no alternative but to declare that the article has now been assessed as a FAIL