Indicating in a nine out of ten from Cross Rhythms, Stephen Luff says, "is the start of something very special."[2] Ben Cardenas, rating the EP three and a half stars for Jesus Freak Hideout, writes, "She has extensive talent and is creative and true in her style."[3] Awarding the EP four stars by New Release Today, Kevin Davis describes, "Great debut album...very impressed by Sarah’s singing and songwriting".[4] Michael Dalton, giving the EP a four out of five at The Phantom Tollbooth, states, "This debut is well-crafted and appealing. It sounds modern and fresh."[5]