Soviet atrocities committed against prisoners of war during World War II

During World War II, Soviet Union, while publicly declaring its support for humane treatment of prisoners of war, routinely ignored them, committing various atrocities against POWs. These actions were carried out by the People's Commissariat for Internal Affairs (NKVD) and the Red Army. In some cases, the crimes were sanctioned or directly ordered by Joseph Stalin and the Soviet leadership.

Before the German invasion of the USSR, USSR which recently annexed parts of Poland as well as the Baltic states, carried out the Katyn massacre of 1940, a series of mass executions of over 20,000 Polish citizens, including 8,000 Polish Army officers, and smaller scales massacres of Baltic states officers. After being invaded by Germany, USSR carried out various massacres of mostly German POWs. The most infamous included the torture and murder of 160 wounded German soldiers in the massacre of Feodosia (1941-1942), and the 1943 torture, rape and murder of Axis 596 POWs and civilians in the massacre of Grischino. Estimates of German POWs who died in Soviet custody range from over 350,000 to one million. The mortality rate of German and Italian prisoners in Soviet custody was high, estimated at over 30% and over 70%, respectively.

1939-1941

Poland

While the Soviet Union did not consider itself engaged in World War II until Operation Barbarossa in 1941, already on 17 September 1939 it invaded Poland, alongside Germany, in accordance with the Molotov–Ribbentrop Pact.^[1]^[2]^: 20–21 Neither Poland nor Soviet Union actually declared war on one another, which made the status of Polish prisoners of war in Soviet custody somewhat unclear in terms of international law, and facilitated Soviet classification of them as "counterrevolutionaries" rather than POWs and related mistreatment.^[2]^{: 22, 39–41}

The Soviets often failed to honor the terms of surrender. In some cases, they promised Polish soldiers freedom after capitulation and then arrested them when they laid down their arms; this happened to soldiers under command of Generals Władysław Langner and Mieczysław Smorawiński, among others.^[2]^: 23^[3] Soviet treatment of POWs included "reprisals such as torture, humiliation, robbery and killings through shooting or bayoneting".^[2]^: 41 Some Polish soldiers were murdered shortly after capture in numerous incidents.^[2]^: 41^[4]^[5]^: 76–88 The highest profile victims of Soviet atrocities of that period included General Józef Olszyna-Wilczyński, who was taken prisoner, interrogated and shot together with his adjutant on September 22.^[2]^: 23^[6]^[7] Around that time, the NKVD also executed about 300 Polish defenders taken captive after the battle of Grodno.^[8]^[9]^[10] On September 24, 25 Polish POWs were murdered in the aftermath of the Battle of Husynne.^[5]^: 55 On September 25, the Soviets murdered staff and patients at a Polish military hospital in the village of Grabowiec near Zamość;^[4]^[11] Tadeusz Piotrowski mentions the death of 12 officers in this context.^[12] After a tactical Polish victory at the battle of Szack on September 28, where the combined Korpus Ochrony Pogranicza (KOP) or Border Protection Corps forces, under General Wilhelm Orlik-Rueckemann, routed the Soviet 52nd Rifle Division, the Soviets executed Polish officers they captured; 18 victims were identified.^[13] Also on 28 September 1939, 18 prisoners of war from the Riverine Flotilla of the Polish Navy were massacred in the Makrany massacre [pl].^[14] Overall, it is estimated that during the invasion, approximately 2,500 Polish soldiers were murdered in various executions and reprisals for offering resistance, by Soviets and Ukrainian nationalists; officers were more likely to be murdered in such way than rank-and-file soldiers.^[2]^: 23

Some lower ranking soldiers (privates and NCOs), about 60,000, were used as forced laborers before being eventually released. Some were transported to Soviet's Far East (Komi Republic). According to Edmund Nowak, the "were decimated... by inhumane treatment, extremely hard work conditions, cold, diseases and chronic hunger".^[15]^: 117^[16]

One of the Soviet Union's earliest and largest crimes against prisoners of war occurred in the aftermath of the invasion. After the fighting ended, the Soviet Union ended up with several hundred thousands of Polish prisoners of war. Some escaped, were transferred to German custody, or released, but 125,000 were imprisoned in camps run by the NKVD. By mid-November the number of Polish POWs in Soviet custody decreased to about 40,000.^[2]^: 42^[17] However, in December of 1939, a wave of arrests resulted in the imprisonment of additional Polish officers (about a thousand).^[17]^[16] Once at the camps, from October 1939 to February 1940, the Poles were subjected to lengthy interrogations and constant political pressure to accept the dogma of communism and friendship of the Soviet Union. If a prisoner could not be induced to quickly adopt a pro-Soviet attitude, he was declared a "hardened and uncompromising enemy of Soviet authority".^[18]^[19]^[2]^: 65–70^[15]^{: 117–119, 126} On 5 March 1940, the Soviet Politburo signed an order to execute over twenty thousand of Polish "nationalists and counterrevolutionaries" deemed unperformable (declared "avowed enemies of Soviet authority"), kept at camps and prisons in occupied western Ukraine and Belarus.^[2]^: 77–82^[20] The resulting massacre is known as the Katyn massacre, a series of mass executions of nearly 22,000 Polish intelligentsia, including about 8,000 military officers (mostly prisoners of war from the invasion of September 1939), carried out by the NKVD in April and May 1940.^[17]^[21]^[22] This was done to deprive a potential future Polish military of a large portion of its talent, and to reduce future opposition to the Soviet rule, and was part of a wider plan of oppression of Polish populace in the occupied territories.^[2]^: 23^[17]^[23]

Overall, the situation of Polish POWs in Soviet camps were much worse than those in German camps, even through most Polish POWs spent significantly less time in the former. Approximately 2-3% of Polish POWs in German camps died during the war; according to Nowak, "the mortality rate among the [Polish] POWs remaining in the Soviet captivity was much higher".^[15]^{: 125–126} For the officers, most of whom perished in the Katyn massacre, it was a stark 97%.^[3]^[15]^{: 125–126} A more general estimate for "mortality rate among deportees and POWs from 1939-1941" gave the odds at 20% for adults and 30% for the children. The mortality rate for the military enlisted has been estimated at 35% to 40%.^[3]

Baltic states

Soviets also committed atrocities against POWs from the armies of the Baltic states following their occupation of that territory in 1940. For example, two hundred Latvian officers were shot in Litene and 80 in Riga; and 560 were deported to Siberian gulags. Only 90 of them returned from Siberia after Joseph Stalin's death.^[24]^[25]^[26]

After German invasion of the USSR (1941)

Throughout the Second World War, the Wehrmacht War Crimes Bureau [de] (Wehrmacht-Untersuchungsstelle, also known as WuSt) collected and investigated reports of crimes against the Axis POWs. According to Alfred de Zayas, "For the entire duration of the Russian campaign, reports of torture and murder of German prisoners did not cease. The War Crimes Bureau had five major sources of information: (1) captured enemy papers, especially orders, reports of operations, and propaganda leaflets; (2) intercepted radio and wireless messages; (3) testimony of Soviet prisoners of war; (4) testimony of captured Germans who had escaped; and (5) testimony of Germans who saw the corpses or mutilated bodies of executed prisoners of war. From 1941 to 1945 the Bureau compiled several thousand depositions, reports, and captured papers which, if nothing else, indicate that the killing of German prisoners of war upon capture or shortly after their interrogation was not an isolated occurrence. Documents relating to the war in France, Italy, and North Africa contain some reports on the deliberate killing of German prisoners of war, but there can be no comparison with the events on the Eastern Front."^[27]^{: 164–165}

In a November 1941 report, the Wehrmacht War Crimes Bureau accused the Red Army of employing "a terror policy... against defenseless German soldiers that have fallen into its hands and against members of the German medical corps. At the same time... it has made use of the following means of camouflage: in a Red Army order that bears the approval of the Council of People's Commissars, dated 1 July 1941, the norms of international law are made public, which the Red Army in the spirit of the Hague Regulations on Land Warfare are supposed to follow... This... Russian order probably had very little distribution, and surely it has not been followed at all. Otherwise the unspeakable crimes would not have occurred."^[27]^: 178

According to the depositions, Soviet massacres of German, Italian, Spanish, and other Axis POWs were often incited by unit commissars, who claimed to be acting under orders from Stalin and the Politburo. Other evidence cemented the War Crimes Bureau's belief that Stalin had given secret orders about the massacre of POWs.^[27]^{: 162–210} Unlike with the execution of Polish POWs at Katyn, however, no such directive attributed to Stalin or top Soviet officials, concerning Germans, have been found. However, despite the non-existence of such order, many lower ranking officers and soldiers, encouraged by brutal and simplistic propaganda, believed it exists, or that the execution of German POWs is unofficially expected or sanctioned. In the early years of the war, the justification for such actions was provided by the Stalin's speech of November 6 1941, in which Stalin said that "From now on our task, the task of the peoples of the U.S.S.R., the task of the fighters, commanders and the political workers of our Army and our Navy will be to exterminate every single German who has set his invading foot on the territory of our Fatherland. No mercy for the German invaders! Death to the German invaders!".^[28]^[29] Soon afterward, Soviet officials realized that such approach, leading to POW executions, was counterproductive, and reduced the chance of German soldiers surrendering; consequently, in February of 1942, Stalin, in another speech, explicitly encouraged taking prisoners.^[29]

In the context of German POWs, Grunewald in a monograph dedicated to the topic argued that "economic realities... not retribution, motivated [Soviet] policies and practices toward German POWs, noting that Grunewald also notes that Soviet treatment of German prisoners was not significantly motivated by retribution, despite the enormous scale of the German atrocities committed against Soviet prisoners of war.^[30]^: 3–4 Mark Edele noted that Soviet policy and actions towards German POWs in the early years of the war were inconsistent; and overall, "while Soviet war crimes cannot and should not be denied, they have more in common with prisoner executions in other times and places than with the Germans’ premeditated war of extermination" and "the murder and mutilation of prisoners by the Soviets was less common than [similar actions by the Germans]".^[29]

According to MacKenzie, many crimes committed by the Soviets against POWs were the result of intensive propaganda that portrayed Germans as not humans (here, mirroring similar German propaganda). He note that the situation of German and other Axis POWs improved in the later years of the war, as Soviets started to integrate them more efficiently (and purposively) into the economy of USSR as forced laborers. The conditions for those POWs, however, were very hash; deaths from starvation, disease or freezing conditions were common.^[31]

Soviet sources list the deaths of 381,000 of the 3,350,000 German Armed Forces taken prisoner in the war; some German estimates however are higher, suggesting a death toll of as high as one million (when accounting for German MIAs, which some scholars, like Rüdiger Overmans, believe to be undocumented POWs death).^[30]^: 3 Valerie Genevieve Hébert noted that "The general consensus regarding the fate of German prisoners of war under Soviet control is that of 3.15 million taken, 1.2 million died, mainly after January 1943".^[32]^: 261

The death rate of German soldiers held by Soviet Union has been estimated at 15% by Mark Edele,^[29] and at 35.8% by Niall Ferguson.^[33] An even higher estimate of death rate has been suggested for the Italian soldiers held by the Soviet Union: 79% (estimate by Thomas Schlemmer [de]).^[34]^: 153

Notable incidents

Massacre of Feodosia

Soviet soldiers rarely bothered to treat wounded German POWs. A particularly infamous example took place after the Crimean city of Feodosia was briefly recaptured by Soviet forces on December 29, 1942. 160 wounded soldiers had been left in military hospitals by the retreating Wehrmacht. After the Germans retook Feodosia, it was learned that every wounded soldier had been massacred by Red Army, Navy, and NKVD personnel. Some had been shot in their hospital beds, others repeatedly bludgeoned to death, still others were found to have been thrown from hospital windows before being repeatedly drenched with freezing water until they died of hypothermia.^[27]^{: 180–186}

Massacre of Grishchino

The Massacre of Grischino was committed by an armoured division of the Red Army in February 1943 (Soviet 4th Guards Tank Corps) in the eastern Ukrainian town of Krasnoarmeyskoye (also known as Grishchino). The Soviets took control of the location on the night of 10 and 11 February 1943, but were pushed back by the German 5th SS Panzer Division Wiking with the support of 333 Infantry Division and the 7th Panzer Division on 18 February 1943 .The Wehrmacht War Crimes Bureau announced that it had found the bodies of numerous POWs; many subject to gruesome torture: many of the bodies were horribly mutilated, ears and noses cut off and genital organs amputated and stuffed into their mouths. Breasts of some of the nurses were cut off, the women being brutally raped. In the cellar of the main train station around 120 Germans were herded into a large storage room and then mowed down with machine guns. Among the victims were 406 soldiers of the Wehrmacht, 58 members of the Organisation Todt (including two Danish nationals), 89 Italian soldiers, 9 Romanian soldiers, 4 Hungarian soldiers, 15 German civil officials, 7 German civilian workers and 8 Ukrainian volunteers.^[27]^{: 187–191}

Postwar

Some German prisoners were released soon after the war. Many others, however, remained in the GULAG long after the surrender of Nazi Germany; the last group of German POWs returned to Germany from USSR in 1956.^[30]^: 3

In addition to mistreatment of enemy POWs, contemporary Soviet leaders, including Stalin, considered Soviet soldiers who surrendered to be traitors, and "those who survived German captivity to 1945 were promptly sent to the Gulag".^[31]

Historiography

Research into Soviet crimes against POWs was hampered due to public condemnation of the Nazi regime, and the fact that discredited Nazi propaganda for many years made claims about related Soviet atrocities, which also led to the "propagandist contamination" of German records. Although such claims eventually became accepted in German and Western historiographies, in particular, as noted by Mark Edele, in the Soviet Union, "Any claim that the glorious Red Army might have committed war crimes was dismissed as slanderous enemy propaganda". Denial that such crimes occurred is still not uncommon in modern Russia, where the issue has remained politically controversial, and research on this topic in Russia is difficult (Edele noted that as of mid-2010s, the Central Archives of the Russian Ministry of Defence still "remains closed for this kind of research".^[29]

Dissonance with Soviet official statements

While the Soviet Union had not signed the 1929 Geneva Convention on Prisoners of War, Soviet officials claimed early in the war that they intend to respect the 1907 Hague Convention, ratified by the tsarist government; and official Soviet regulations on the treatment of POWs were inline with the Hague principles.^[29] However, several scholars noted that Soviet Union, while publicly declaring its support for humane treatment of PoWs, routinely ignored them, committing various atrocities. George Sanford wrote that Soviet public declarations and laws on concerning PoWs were "part of the Soviet 'big lie' for propaganda".^[35]^: 41 Likewise, Simon MacKenzie noted that "[Soviet] declared commitment to humanitarian principles [in the context of treatment of prisoners of war], however, was largely for foreign propaganda purposes" ^[31] Susan Grunewald likewise noted that Soviet officials "recognized that intentionally retributive treatment of German POWs would be an international relations disaster" and would clash with Soviet propaganda portraying USSR as a "peace loving country", particularly in the later years of the war and the early Cold War period.^[30]^: 3–4

References

^ Hill, Alexander (2014-07-03). "Voroshilov's 'Lightning' War–The Soviet Invasion of Poland, September 1939". The Journal of Slavic Military Studies. 27 (3): 404–419. doi:10.1080/13518046.2014.932628. ISSN 1351-8046.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f ^g ^h ⁱ ^j ^k Sanford, George (2005). Katyn and the Soviet Massacre of 1940: Truth, Justice and Memory. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-33873-8.
^ ^a ^b ^c Tuszynski, Marek; Denda, Dale F. (1999). "Soviet War Crimes Against Poland During the Second World War and Its Aftermath: A Review of the Factual Record and Outstanding Questions". The Polish Review. 44 (2): 183–216. ISSN 0032-2970. JSTOR 25779119.
^ ^a ^b Stańczyk, Tomasz (2010-06-04). "Wrzesień przed Katyniem i Wołyniem". Rzeczpospolita (in Polish). Retrieved 2024-10-20.
^ ^a ^b Jaczyński, Stanisław (2006). Zagłada oficerów Wojska Polskiego na Wschodzie: wrzesień 1939-maj 1940 (Wyd. 2, popr. i uzup ed.). Warszawa: Bellona Publishing House. ISBN 978-83-11-09194-8. OCLC 85852604.
^ (in Polish) Olszyna-Wilczyński Józef Konstanty Archived 2008-03-06 at the Wayback Machine, entry at Encyklopedia PWN. Retrieved 14 November 2006.
^ "Śledztwa - Białystok" (in Polish). Archived from the original on January 7, 2005. Retrieved January 7, 2005.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: unfit URL (link) Polish Institute of National Remembrance. 16.10.03. From Internet Archive.
^ "Investigation concerning the murder of approximately 300 civil and military inhabitants of Grodno in September 1939 by the officials of the Soviet state". Archived from the original on 2008-12-05. Retrieved 2007-09-18.
^ "Obrona Grodna | Muzeum II Wojny Światowej". muzeum1939.pl (in Polish). Retrieved 2024-10-20.
^ Poczobut, Andrzej (4 May 2021). "Białoruski historyk upublicznił nazwiska sowieckich katów obrońców Grodna z września 1939 roku". wyborcza.pl. Retrieved 2024-10-20.
^ Ocaleni z "nieludzkiej ziemi" (in Polish). Łódź: Instytut Pamięci Narodowej. 2012. p. 21. ISBN 978-83-63695-00-2.
^ Piotrowski, Tadeusz (1998). Poland's Holocaust: Ethnic Strife, Collaboration with Occupying Forces and Genocide in the Second Republic, 1918-1947. McFarland. p. 55. ISBN 978-0-7864-0371-4.
^ Zwolski, Marcin; Siemińska, Dominika (2018). "Ekshumacje ofiar totalitaryzmów II wojny światowej na Ukrainie, Białorusi oraz Litwie" (PDF). Poszukiwanie i identyfikacja ofiar zbrodni systemów totalitarnych : doświadczenia polskie w kontekście europejskim : studia i materiały. Oddział Instytutu Pamięci Narodowej w Białymstoku. pp. 147–170. ISBN 978-83-8098-447-9.
^ Ocaleni z "nieludzkiej ziemi" (in Polish). Łódź: Instytut Pamięci Narodowej. 2012. p. 21. ISBN 978-83-63695-00-2.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Nowak, Edmund (2020-06-01). "The vicissitudes of the Polish prisoners of war in the two totalitarian systems on the years 1939-1945 : similarities and differences". In Soleim, Marianne Neerland (ed.). Prisoners of War and Forced Labour: Histories of War and Occupation. Cambridge Scholars Publishing. ISBN 978-1-5275-5399-6.
^ ^a ^b Rieber, Alfred J. (2000). Forced migration in Central and Eastern Europe, 1939–1950. Psychology Press. pp. 31–33. ISBN 978-0714651323. Archived from the original on 6 December 2020. Retrieved 19 May 2011.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Kużniar-Plota, Małgorzata (30 November 2004). "Decision to commence investigation into Katyn Massacre". Departmental Commission for the Prosecution of Crimes against the Polish Nation. Archived from the original on 30 September 2012. Retrieved 4 August 2011.
^ Fischer, Benjamin B. (1999–2000). "The Katyn Controversy: Stalin's Killing Field". Studies in Intelligence (Winter). Archived from the original on 24 March 2010. Retrieved 3 August 2011.
^ Яжборовская, И. С.; Яблоков, А. Ю.; Парсаданова, B.C. (2001). "ПРИЛОЖЕНИЕ: Заключение комиссии экспертов Главной военной прокуратуры по уголовному делу № 159 о расстреле польских военнопленных из Козельского, Осташковского и Старобельского спецлагерей НКВД в апреле – мае 1940 г". Катынский синдром в советско-польских и российско-польских отношениях [The Katyn Syndrome in Soviet-Polish and Russian-Polish relations] (in Russian) (1st ed.). Росспэн. ISBN 978-5824310870. Archived from the original on 29 April 2010. Retrieved 9 November 2010.
^ Brown, Archie (2009). The Rise and Fall of Communism. HarperCollins. p. 140. ISBN 978-0061138799. Archived from the original on 18 June 2013. Retrieved 7 May 2011.
^ Szymczak, Robert (2008). "The Vindication of Memory: The Katyn Case in the West, Poland, and Russia, 1952-2008". The Polish Review. 53 (4): 419–443. ISSN 0032-2970. JSTOR 25779772.
^ Fredericks, Vanessa (2011-04-23), "The Katyn Massacre and the Ethics of War: Negotiating Justice and Law", Thinking About War and Peace: Past, Present, and Future, Brill, pp. 63–71, ISBN 978-1-84888-084-9, retrieved 2024-10-20
^ Weinberg, Gerhard (2005). A World at Arms. Cambridge University Press. p. 107. ISBN 978-0521618267.
^ Vieda Skultans (Vieda Skultāne) The Testimony of Lives: Narrative and Memory in Post-Soviet Latvia Published by Routledge, 217 pages 1998 ISBN 0-415-16289-0 ISBN 9780415162890
^ Archaeology of Terror by Dr. hist. Guntis Zemītis
^ Latvian:No NKVD līdz KGB. Politiskās prāvas Latvijā 1940–1986: Noziegumos pret padomju valsti apsūdzēto Latvijas iedzīvotāju rādītājs Archived 2007-02-27 at the Wayback Machine Latvijas Universitātes, Latvijas vēstures inst.; Red.: R. Vīksnes, K. Kanger; Sast.: Dz. Ērglis, R. Vīksne, A. Žvinklis, S. Boge.— Rīga, 1999.— XVIII, 975 lpp.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e Zayas, Alfred M. De (1989). The Wehrmacht War Crimes Bureau, 1939-1945. University of Nebraska Press. ISBN 978-0-8032-1680-8.
^ "Speech at Celebration Meeting of the Moscow Soviet of Working People's Deputies and Moscow Party and Public Organizations (1941)". www.marxists.org. Retrieved 2024-11-07.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f Edele, Mark (June 2016). "Take (No) Prisoners! The Red Army and German POWs, 1941–1943". The Journal of Modern History. 88 (2): 342–379. doi:10.1086/686155. ISSN 0022-2801.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Grunewald, Susan C. I. (2024-07-15). From Incarceration to Repatriation: German Prisoners of War in the Soviet Union. Cornell University Press. ISBN 978-1-5017-7604-5.
^ ^a ^b ^c MacKenzie, S. P. (September 1994). "The Treatment of Prisoners of War in World War II". The Journal of Modern History. 66 (3): 487–520. doi:10.1086/244883. ISSN 0022-2801.
^ Hébert, Valerie Geneviève (2021-02-12). Hitler's Generals on Trial: The Last War Crimes Tribunal at Nuremberg. University Press of Kansas. ISBN 978-0-7006-3267-1.
^ Ferguson, Niall (2004). "Prisoner Taking and Prisoner Killing in the Age of Total War: Towards a Political Economy of Military Defeat". War in History. 11 (2): 148–92. doi:10.1191/0968344504wh291oa. S2CID 159610355.
^ Schlemmer, Thomas, ed. (2009). Invasori, non vittime: la campagna italiana di Russia 1941-1943. Quadrante Laterza (1. ed.). Roma: GLF editori Laterza. ISBN 978-88-420-7981-1.
^ Sanford, George (2005). Katyn and the Soviet Massacre of 1940: Truth, Justice and Memory. Routledge. ISBN 978-0-415-33873-8.