Jump to content

Sigmund Mowinckel

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Sigmund Olaf Plytt Mowinckel
Born(1884-08-04)4 August 1884
Kjerringøy, Nordland, Norway
Died4 June 1965(1965-06-04) (aged 80)
Oslo
EducationUniversity of Oslo
TitleReverend Doctor

Sigmund Olaf Plytt Mowinckel (4 August 1884 – 4 June 1965) was a Norwegian professor, theologian and biblical scholar. He was noted for his research into the practice of religious worship in ancient Israel.[1]

Life

[edit]

Mowinckel was born at Kjerringøy in 1884[2] and was educated at the University of Oslo (1908; Th.D. 1916).[3] His early research interests were study of the Old Testament and Assyriology.[2] In the years 1911-13 he made study trips to Copenhagen, Marburg and Giessen.[2] At Giessen he came into contact with Hermann Gunkel and was inspired by Gunkel's understanding of the Old Testament as literature, as well as his traditio-historical method.[2]

In 1916 he published his doctoral thesis on the prophet Nehemiah, and a companion work on the prophet Ezra.[2] In the years 1921-24 he published Psalmenstudien, maybe his most influential work.[2] As an Old Testament scholar he was particularly interested in the Psalms and the ancient cult of Israel. [2]According to Clements,[4] "Mowinckel continually developed and revised his views, notably on Israelite kingship and Psalmody". In 1956 he published "He That Cometh: The Messiah Concept in the Old Testament and Later Judaism".[5][6] For most of his professional life Mowinckel was connected to the University of Oslo and continued to lecture there as an emeritus in the 1960's.[2] Among his students we find the norwegian biblical scholar Arvid Kapelrud.[2] His last book in english, "Religion and Cult", was published in 1981.[7]

Academic work and theories

[edit]

Mowinckels main contribution to biblical scholarship is his work on The Psalms of the Old Testament and his study of Messianic ideas in Judaism.

The Psalms

[edit]

From the 1920s, Mowinckel headed a school of thought concerning the Book of Psalms which sometimes clashed with the Form criticism conclusions of Hermann Gunkel and those who followed in Gunkel's footsteps. In broad terms, Gunkel strongly advocated a view of the Psalms which focused on the two notable names for God occurring therein: Yahweh (JHWH sometimes called tetragrammaton) and Elohim. The schools of Psalm writing springing therefrom were termed Yahwist and Elohist. Mowinckel's approach to the Psalms differed quite a bit from Gunkel's. Mowinckel explained the Psalms as wholly cultic, both in origin and in intention. He attempted to relate more than 40 psalms to a hypothetical New Year autumn festival,[8][9] the so-called "Enthronement Festival of Yahweh".[10] According to Mowinckel the Psalms had a practical usage in the context of the Temple service.[11] He also suggests that the authors of the Psalms were temple singers.[12] As for the Psalms that have no cultic context, Mowinckel identifies these as the "wisdom psalms".[12]

Messianic ideas

[edit]

In addition to his work on Psalms, his major monograph on the Old Testament roots of Messianism is of significance in scholarship until this day.[13] In his study of Messianism in ancient Israel, and the Ancient Near East, Mowinckel identified the concept of divine kingship.[14] He did however deny the title of Messiah to the reigning Hebrew kings, although they reflected the Messianic ideal.[15] The kings were associated with divinity, but Mowinckel does not support the view that they were an incarnation of the deity, or that they represented a suffering, dying and rising god.[15] The Israelites adapted some ideas on kingship from Canaanite sources, combined with traditions of old nomadic chieftainship and Yahwism.[16] According to Mowinckel the concept of Kingship is associated with the present, while the Messiah is a future being,[16] associated with eschatology.[17] The Hebrew royal line is therefore, in his view, not Messianic,[17] and there is no eschatology prior to the Babylonian exile.[17]

Mowinckel also considers the songs of the Suffering Servant in the Old Testament. Mowinckel accepts the common understanding of the servant songs, according to tradition, as signifying atonement and vicarious suffering. [17] He identifies the servant as a historical character from the circle surrounding Isaiah and Second Isaiah.[14] However, he does not rule out that the servant could be a future character.[17][14] He finds the servant free of kingly traits [15] and concludes that the songs were not originally meant to be Messianic. [16] The suffering servant is therefore, according to Mowinckel, something else than a Messiah, he is a «mediator of salvation»[17]

The Son of Man, on the other hand, is an eschatological figure,[17] influenced by Messianic ideas.[15] According to Ceroke[17] «The Son of Man is in Mowinckel’s treatment the culmination of messianism». However, Mowinckel disagrees with other scholars, such as Joachim Jeremias, that the Son of Man represents an atoning suffering and death.[17] Martin[16] notes that Mowinckels approach to the subject is historical, not theological or doctrinal. As a consequence of this Martin finds that Mowinckels handling of the subject is a bit incomplete in light of the entire message of Jesus and his (Jesus') use of the term Son of Man.

Mowinckel suggests that Jesus adapted both the concept of the Son of Man and the figure of the Servant, but in a paradoxical way.[16] The concept of the Messiah is modified in order to suit his ministry and his understanding of himself. He merges the redeeming element of the Son of Man with the idea of the suffering Servant. [16][17] According to Muilenburg[14] «Mowinckel believes that Jesus himself was the first to understand the real meaning of Isaiah 53 and to apply it to himself». Despite expressing criticism toward several aspects of Mowinckels work on this subject, several reviewers [15][16][17] found his treatment of Messianic ideas to be a solid contribution to Old Testament Scholarship.

Published works (early editions)

[edit]
  • Statholderen Nehemia (Kristiania: a. 1916)
  • Esra den skriftlærde (Kristiania: a. 1916)
  • Kongesalmerne i det Gamle Testamentet (Kristiania: (1916)
  • Der Knächt Jahves (1921)
  • Psalmenstudien I: 'Awan und die individuellen Klagepsalmen (Kristiania: SNVAO* 1921)
  • Psalmenstudien II: Das Thronbesteigungsfest Jahwäs und der Ursprung der Eschatologie (Kristiania: SNVAO* 1922)
  • Psalmenstudien III: Kultprophetie und kultprophetische Psalmen (Kristiania: SNVAO*, 1923)
  • Psalmenstudien IV: Die technischen Termini in den Psalmenuberschriften (Kristiania: SNVAO*, 1923)
  • Psalmenstudien V: Segen und Fluch in Israels Kult und Psalmdichtung (Kristiania: SNVAO*, 1924)
  • Psalmenstudien VI: Die Psalmdichter (Kristiania: SNVAO*, 1924)
  • Diktet om Ijob og hans tre venner (Kristiania: 1924)
  • Profeten Jesaja (Oslo: 1925)
  • Jesaja: Profetien fra Jesaja til Jeremia (Oslo: 1926)
  • Motiver og stilformer i profeten Jeremias diktning (1926)
  • Le Decalogue (Paris: 1927)
  • Det Gamle Testament som Guds Ord (Oslo: 1938)
  • Gamla testamental som Guds ord (Stockholm: 1938)
  • Die Erkentis Gottes bei den alttestamentlichen Propheten [translation: "The recognizable God in/within the Old Testament prophets" or perhaps "The recognition of God beside/by the Old Testament prophets"] Supplementary volume to Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift (Oslo: 1941).
  • Prophecy and Tradition (1946)
  • Han som kommer : Messiasforventningen i Det gamle testament og på Jesu tid (1951) (translated He That Cometh: The Messiah Concept in the Old Testament and Later Judaism, trans. G. W. Anderson [Oxford: B.Blackwell, 1956]
  • Offersang og sangoffer : salmediktningen i Bibelen [translated: "Song of sacrifice and Sacrifice of song" or "Offering song and Song offering": "Psalm Poetry in the Bible"] (Oslo: H. Aschehoug & Co, 1951).
  • Der achtundsechsigste Psalm [ANVAO**, II, 1953, I] (Oslo: 1953)
  • Religion och Kultus (1953).
  • Real and Apparent Tricola in Hebrew Psalm Poetry [ANVAO**, II, 1957] (Oslo: 1958)
  • The Spirit and the Word: Prophecy and Tradition in Ancient Israel. Edited by K. C. Hanson. Fortress Classics in Biblical Studies (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2002)

NOTE [*]: SNVAO signifies the Norwegian publisher/publications Skrifter utgitt av Det Norske Videnskaps-Akademi i Oslo, II. Hist.-Filos. Klasse

NOTE [**] ANVAO signifies the Norwegian publisher/publications Avhandliger utgitt av Det Norske Videnskaps-Akademi i Oslo. II. Hist. Filos. Klasse.

Articles by Mowinckel

[edit]
  • 'Om den jodiske menighets og provinsen Judeas organisasjon ca. 400 f. Kr.', Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift (Kristiania: 1915), pp. 123ff., 226ff.
  • 'Tronstigningssalmerne og Jahves tronstigningsfest', Norsk teologi til reformationsjubileet, specialhefte [i.e. special issue] to Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift (Kristiania: 1917), pp. 13ff.
  • 'Die vorderasiatischen Konigs- und Fursteninschriften' [translation: "The Near Eastern Royal and Princely Inscriptions"], Eucharisterion [Studien zur Religion und Literatur d. Alt und Neu Testaments, H. Gunkel zum 60] ["Studies in the Religion and Literature of the Old and New Testaments, H. Gunkel at 60" --- Gunkel's 60th birthday was in 1922] I, pp. 278ff., a book produced by Forschungen zur Religion und Literatur d. Alten und Neuen Testaments (FRLANT) Band (Vol.) 36 (Göttingen: 1923)
  • 'Det kultiske synspunkt som forskningsprinsipp i den gammelstestamentlige videnskap', Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift (Kristiania: 1924), pp. 1ff.
  • 'I porten' Studier tilegnede Frans Buhl (Copenhagen: 1925)
  • 'Drama, religionsgeschichtlisches' [translation: "Drama, history of religion", RGG2 [appeared in Religion in Geschichte und Gegenwart 2.Aufl.] (Tübingen: 1927-32)
  • 'Levi und Leviten' [translation: "Levi and Levites"], RGG2 [appeared in Religion in Geschichte und Gegenwart 2.Aufl.] (Tübingen: 1927-32)
  • 'Stilformer og motiver i profeten Jeremias dikning', Edda Vol. 36 (1926), pp. 276ff.
  • 'Salmeboken og gudstjenestesalmen', Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift (Oslo: 1927), pp. 153ff.
  • 'Die letzten Worte Davids' [translation: "The last words of David"], in II Samuel 23:1-7, Zeitschrift fur die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft' Band (Vol.) 45? (Giessen:1927), pp. 30ff.
  • 'A quelle moment le culte de Jahwe a Jerusalem est il officiellement devenu un culte sans images?' [translation: "At what moment did the cult of Jahweh of Jerusalem officially become a cult without images?"] Revue de l'Histoire et des Philosophies Religieuses Vol. 9 (Strasbourg: 1929), pp. 197ff.
  • The following sections/chapters in Det Gamle Testament, oversatt av S. Michelet, Sigmund Mowinckel og Nils Messel (also known simply as GTMMM) Volumes I - III (Oslo: 1929-following years):-: Sections 2. Mos. 18-34; 4. Mos. 20-25; 32-33; 5. Mosebok; Josvaboken; Samuelsboken; Kongeboken; Jesaja; Jeremia; Tolvprofetboken.
  • Book review of Eduard Konig's Das Buch Hiob in Deutsche Litz, 3. Folge, 1. Jahrg. 12, (1930) columns 529ff. [presumably this review relates to E Konig's Das Buch Hiob eingeleitet, ubersetzt und erklart (Gutersloh: Bertelsmann, 1927 or 1929)]
  • 'Die Komposition des Deuterojesajanischen Buches' [translation: "The Composition of the book of Deutero-Isaiah"], Zeitschrift fur die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft' Band (Vol.) 44 (Giessen: 1931)pp. 87ff., 242ff.
  • 'Die Chronologie der israelitischen und judaischen Konige' [translation: "The Chronology of the Kings of Israel and Judah"], Acta Orientalia Vol. 10 (Leiden: 1932) pp. 161ff.
  • 'Fiendene i de individuelle klagesalmer', Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift (Oslo: 1934), pp. 1ff.
  • 'The "Spirit" and the "Word" in the Pre-exilic Reforming Prophets', Journal of Biblical Literature Vol. 53 (1934) pp. 199–227.
  • '"Anden" og "Ordet" hos de foreksilske reformprofeter', Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift (Oslo: 1935), pp. 1ff.
  • 'Ekstatisk oplevelse og rasjonal bearbeidelse hos de gammeltestamentlige profeter', [translation: "Ecstatic experience and rational elaboration in Old Testament prophecy"] Theologisk Tidsskrift (known as "[D]TT") (Kobenhavn [Copenhagen]:1935), pp. 1ff.
  • 'Extatic Experience and Rational Elaboration in Old Testament Prophecy', Acta Orientalia Vol. 13 (Leiden: 1935), pp. 264–291.
  • 'Hat es ein israelitisches Nationalepos gegeben?' [translation: "Is there a given Israelite national epic?"], Zeitschrift fur die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft' Band (Vol.) 53 (Giessen: 1935) pp. 130ff.
  • 'Zur Geschichte der Dekalogue' [translation: "To a History of the Decalogue (Ten Commandments)"], Zeitschrift fur die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft' Band (Vol.) 55 (Giessen: 1937) pp. 218ff.
  • Book Review of Widengren's Accadian and Hebrew Psalms of Lamentation which appeared in Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift (Oslo: 1940), pp. 155. [G. Widengren's book itself was published at Stockholm, 1937].
  • 'Ras Shamra og det Gamle Testament', Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift Vol. xl, (Oslo: 1939), pp. 16ff.
  • 'Oppkomsten av profetlitteraturen', Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift (Oslo: 1942), pp. 65ff.
  • 'Kadesj, Sinai og Jahve', Norwegian Journal of Geography Vol. 9 (1942), pp. 21ff.
  • 'Nathanprofetien i 2. Sam. 7' [translation: "Nathan's prophecy in II Samuel 7"], Svensk exegetisk årsbok (known as SEÅ) (Uppsala: date ?), pp. 220ff.
  • 'Zum Problem der hebraischen Metrik' [translation: "Towards the Problem of the Hebrew Metric"], Bertholetfestschrift (Tübingen: 1950), pp. 379ff. [Bertholetfestschrift = Festschrift Alfred Bertholet zum 80. Geburtstag, herausgeg. von W. Baumgartner, O. Eissfeldt, K. Elliger, L. Rost>> translation: "Festschrift for Alfred Bertholet on his 80th Birthday--editors: W. Baumgartner, Otto Eissfeldt, K. Elliger and L. Rost"].
  • 'Den senjodiske salmediktning', Norsk Teologisk Tidsskrift (Oslo: 1950), pp. 1–54.
  • 'Zur hebraischen Metrik II' [translation: "Towards Hebrew Metric II"], Studia theologica cura ordinum theologorum Scandinavorum edita Vol. VII (1953), pp. 54ff.
  • 'Metrischer Aufbau und Textcritik, an Ps. 8 illustriert' [translation: "Metrical Construction and Textcriticism, illustrated on Psalm 8"], Studia Orientalia Johanno Pedersen Septuagenario...dicata [Studia Orientalia's volume celebrating the 70th birthday of Johannes Pedersen](Havniae [Copenhagen]: 1953), pp. 250ff.
  • 'Der metrische Aufbau von Jes. 62, 1 - 12 und die neuen sog. kurzverse' [translation: "The metrical construction of Isaiah 62: 1 - 12 and the new so-called ? shortverse"], Zeitschrift fur die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft' Band (Vol.) 65 (Giessen: 1953), pp. 167ff.
  • 'Zum Psalm des Habakuk' [translation: "Towards the Psalm of Habakkuk"], Theologische Zeitschrift Band (Vol.) 9 (Basel: 1953), pp. 1ff.
  • 'Psalm Criticism between 1900 and 1935 (Ugarit and Psalm Exegesis)', Vetus Testamentum Vol. 5 (Leiden: Brill, 1955) pp. 13ff.
  • 'Marginalien zur hebraischen Metrik', Zeitschrift fur die Alttestamentliche Wissenschaft' Band (Vol.) 67 (Giessen: 1956) pp. 97ff.
  • 'Zu Psalm 16, 3 - 4' [translation: "To/towards Psalm 16: 3 - 4"], Theologische Literaturzeitung (1957), columns 649ff.
  • 'Notes on the Psalms', Studia theologica cura ordinum theologorum Scandinavorum edita Vol. XIII (1959), pp. 134ff.
  • 'Drive and/or Ride in the O.T.', Vetus Testamentum Vol. 12 (Leiden: Brill, 1962) pp. 278–299ff.

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Sigmund Mowinckel (Augsburg Fortress)
  2. ^ a b c d e f g h i Sæbø, M. Crossing Borders: On Five Norwegian Bible Scholars, In Lemaire, A. & Sæbø, M.(Editors)(1998) Congress Volume Oslo 1998. Leiden: Brill[page needed]
  3. ^ Sigmund Mowinckel (Store norske leksikon)
  4. ^ Clements, R. E. (2008). "Review of Sigmund Mowinckel und seine Zeit: Leben und Werk eines norwegischen Alttestamentlers". Vetus Testamentum. 58 (2): 275–276. JSTOR 20504369.
  5. ^ Tomes, R. (1 January 2007). "SIGMUND MOWINCKEL, He That Cometh: The Messiah Concept in the Old Testament and Later Judaism". Journal of Semitic Studies. 52 (2): 429–430. doi:10.1093/jss/fgm034.
  6. ^ Rollston, Christopher A. (2009). "Review of He That Cometh: The Messiah Concept in the Old Testament and Later Judaism". Journal of Near Eastern Studies. 68 (1): 54–55. doi:10.1086/598075. JSTOR 10.1086/598075.
  7. ^ Stansell, Gary (2004). "Review of The Spirit and the Word: Prophecy and Tradition in Ancient Israel". Journal of Biblical Literature. 123 (1): 145–147. doi:10.2307/3268555. JSTOR 3268555.
  8. ^ Sigurd Hjelde: Sigmund Mowinckel, Teolog (Norsk biografisk leksikon)
  9. ^ Alan Cooper The Psalm of the Shofar Its Use in Liturgy and its Meaning in the Bible (Project Torah And Biblical Scholarship)
  10. ^ Dahood, M. (1964). "Review of The Psalms in Israel's Worship. Vol. I. Vol. II". Biblica. 45 (1): 109–111. JSTOR 42651128.
  11. ^ Moriarty, Frederick L. (1964). "Review of The Psalms in Israel's Worship. Vol. I: vol. II". Gregorianum. 45 (3): 551–553. JSTOR 23573410.
  12. ^ a b Murphy, Roland E. (1963). "Review of The Psalms in Israel's Worship. Vol. I and II". The Catholic Biblical Quarterly. 25 (4): 481–482. JSTOR 43711338.
  13. ^ He That Cometh: The Messiah Concept in the Old Testament and Later Judaism, trans. G. W. Anderson (Oxford: B.Blackwell, 1956 ISBN 978-0-8028-2850-7)[page needed]
  14. ^ a b c d Muilenburg, James (1957). "Review of He That Cometh". Journal of Biblical Literature. 76 (3): 243–246. doi:10.2307/3261576. JSTOR 3261576.
  15. ^ a b c d e Anderson, G. W. (1951). "Review of Han som kommer. Messiasforventningen i Det Gamle Testament og på Jesu tid". Vetus Testamentum. 1 (4): 311–313. doi:10.2307/1516312. JSTOR 1516312.
  16. ^ a b c d e f g Martin, M. (1959). "Review of He that Cometh". Biblica. 40 (4): 1029–1033. JSTOR 42640742.
  17. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k Ceroke, Christian P. (1957). "Review of He That Cometh". The Catholic Biblical Quarterly. 19 (2): 274–278. JSTOR 43710403.

Other sources

[edit]
  • Dahl, Nils A. (January 1988). "Sigmund mowinckel historian of religion and theologian". Scandinavian Journal of the Old Testament. 2 (2): 8–22. doi:10.1080/09018328808584897.
  • Hjelde, Sigurd (2006) Sigmund Mowinckel Und Seine Zeit: Leben Und Werk Eines Norwegischen Alttestamentlers (Mohr Siebeck Verlag) ISBN 9783161487347
  • Smend, Rudolf (December 1999). "Mowinckel und Deutschland". Studia Theologica - Nordic Journal of Theology. 53 (2): 79–96. doi:10.1080/00393389950136920.
[edit]
  • Hayes, John Haralson (1974) Old Testament Form Criticism (Trinity University Press) ISBN 978-0911536447
  • Koch, Klaus (1969). The Growth of the Biblical Tradition: The Form-Critical Method (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons) ISBN 0-684-14524-3
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sigmund_Mowinckel&oldid=1232022517"