Sexuality of Frederick the Great
It is almost certain that Prussian King Frederick the Great (1712–1786) was primarily homosexual, and that his sexual orientation was central to his life.[2][3][4][5] However, the nature of his actual relationships remains speculative.[6]
Though he had an arranged marriage, Frederick produced no children and was succeeded by his nephew. His favoured courtiers were exclusively male, and his art collection celebrated homoeroticism. Persistent rumours connecting the king with homosexual activity circulated around Europe during his lifetime, but there is less surviving definitive evidence of any sexual relationships of his, homosexual or otherwise. However, in July 1750, the Prussian king teasingly wrote to his gay secretary and reader, Claude Étienne Darget: "Mes hémorroïdes saluent affectueusement votre v[erge]" ('My hemorrhoids affectionately greet your cock'), which strongly suggests that he was sexually involved with men.[7][8]
Furthermore, at an advanced age, the king advised his nephew in a written document against passive anal intercourse, which from his own experience was "not very pleasant".[9] That he actually did desire men is also clear from statements by his famous contemporaries, Voltaire and Giacomo Casanova, who personally knew him and his sexual preferences. Significantly, Voltaire nicknamed Frederick "Luc". When read backwards, it means cul (the vulgar French term for 'anus' or 'butt').[10] According to Wolfgang Burgdorf, "Various foreign envoys [...] reported on Frederick's 'unnatural vice'. [...] None of them bothered with the idea of influencing the Prussian court's policy by launching a new mistress. Saxony and France, however, repeatedly managed to place good-looking young men near him. Sanssouci was a women-free zone during the Friderican era."[11] Frederick himself once shocked a dinner party with a misogynist rant against "ghastly women you smelled ten miles around."[10]
Frederick's sexuality was rejected by professional historians for centuries after his death, but was embraced by homosexual publications of Weimar Germany, which featured him on their covers and praised him for governing while homosexual.[12]
Possible homosexual relationships
[edit]As a young crown prince, Frederick confided to his mentor, Generalfeldmarschall Friedrich Wilhelm von Grumbkow, that he felt too little attracted to the female sex to be able to imagine entering into a marriage.[13] At age 16, Frederick seems to have embarked upon a youthful affair with Peter Karl Christoph von Keith, a 17-year-old page of his father. Rumors of the liaison spread in the court, and the "intimacy" between the two boys provoked the comments of Frederick's sister Wilhelmine who wrote, "Though I had noticed that he was on more familiar terms with this page than was proper in his position, I did not know how intimate the friendship was."[14] Rumors finally reached King Frederick William, who cultivated an ideal of ultramasculinity in his court, and derided his son's supposedly effeminate tendencies. As a result, Keith was dismissed from his service to the king and sent away to a regiment by the Dutch border, while Frederick was sent to the king's hunting lodge at Wusterhausen in order to "repent of his sin".[15]
King Frederick William may have thought that Frederick's relationship with Hans Hermann von Katte, another royal page who had succeeded Keith as Frederick's favorite, was also romantic, a suspicion which may have played a role in Katte's receiving a death sentence.[16] Frederick himself only escaped a death sentence thanks to Emperor Charles VI's intervention.[17] A contemporary courtier, Karl Ludwig von Pöllnitz, reports that Katte, eight years his senior, and Frederick treated each other “like a lover with his mistress.”[18] Princess Wilhelmine wrote about Katte: "He played the role of a free spirit and took his life to excess; Great ambition and arrogance went hand in hand with this vice. Such a favorite was far from dissuading my brother from his aberrations".[19]
While confined to Kustrin after the Katte affair, Frederick formed an intimate friendship with Michael Gabriel Fredersdorf, whom Frederick romantically corresponded with and demonstrated frequent concern for. Fredersdorf initially became Frederick's valet, and when Frederick became king he was provided with an estate and acted as factotum and, as some have said, as an unofficial prime minister.[20] In 1789, Frederick's garden inspector and Oberhofbaurat [head of the planning department and building control office] Heinrich Ludewig Manger described Fredersdorf as "the king's darling at the time".[21] Historian Eva Ziebura says: "The two of them probably had sex at the beginning".[22] Later they exchanged very intimate letters about their hemorrhoids, other ailments, potency issues, etc.[23] Another intimate confidante was his equerry: "No lover can be more agreeable and obliging than Frederick with Dietrich von Keyserling", said a councillor of war.[23] He was nicknamed “Caesarion” and was promoted from equerry to adjutant general. Another favorite was Lieutenant General Friedrich Rudolf von Rothenburg, who took part in the Round Table until his death in 1751 and regularly stayed in one of Sanssouci's guest rooms, which is still called the Rothenburg Room today. The king liked to take good-looking soldiers into his personal service. Numerous young pages also served at his court.
In 1746, Frederick wrote mocking letters to his rather openly gay brother, Prince Henry of Prussia, which were characterized by jealousy for the "handsome Marwitz",[24] a young royal page. One of Henry's favorites, the Queen's chamberlain, Ernst Ahasverus Heinrich von Lehndorff, also recalls this story in his memoirs.[25] The king wrote to his brother on March 3, 1746, from Potsdam: "Your little darling is doing very well and if he stays well behaved, you will see him again soon. At the moment he yearns for love and composes elegies in your honor full of hot kisses, which he intends to give you on your return. I advise you to conserve your strength so that you have enough to assert your love."[26] He also warned his brother about certain young men at court or among the officers he believed to suffer from gonorrhea.
Voltaire
[edit]Frederick invited the French philosopher Voltaire to live with him at Potsdam almost immediately after his accession to the throne. Voltaire, who was in a personal creative crisis, was happy to accept the invitation. He only lived in the City Palace for a short time before renting his own house, first in Potsdam and later in Berlin. Their literary correspondence and friendship, which spanned almost 50 years, had begun a few years earlier as a flirtation and maintained a mutual intellectual fascination.[28] Voltaire had just recently distributed Frederick's treatise Anti-Machiavel in Amsterdam to great popularity.[29] Although Voltaire was occasionally thought to have been involved in same-sex relations, especially as a young man,[30][31] it is highly doubtful whether the two had an intimate relationship. Occasionally to be read such claims were probably meant more polemically than seriously and are mainly due to the exuberant tones of their correspondence which were customary at the time.[32] It wasn't Voltaire's (not particularly attractive) appearance that attracted Frederick, but rather his spirit that outshone Europe, which the young crown prince had recognized early on and now wanted to use for his own glory.[33] Frederick wanted to adorn himself with one of the leading European intellectuals. He also appreciated the witty conversation in French and hoped the philosopher would not only enrich the royal academy but also the royal table (which always consisted only of men, just like his father's famous "tobacco club").
Frederick was a passionate supporter of the Enlightenment and Voltaire was its greatest spokesman. This included, for example, the abolition of criminal liability for homosexual acts. Frederick however did not abolish it, but unlike under his father,[34] no death sentence was carried out.[23] As early as 1725, Voltaire had brought about the release of Abbé Desfontaines, incarcerated for sodomy, from prison, an act the latter had repaid with ingratitude. Later, in his Dictionnaire philosophique (1752) Voltaire wrote an article about Love in the manner of Socrates, including a list of historical persons who were inclined towards homoerotic love. The final sentence reads: «Enfin je ne crois pas qu’il y ait jamais eu aucune nation policée qui ait fait des lois contre les mœurs» (After all, I don't think there was ever any civilized nation that enacted laws against mores).
However, Frederick found Voltaire difficult to live with in person. In addition, Frederick was often annoyed by Voltaire's many quarrels with his other friends. Voltaire's angry attack on Maupertuis, the President of Frederick's academy, in the form of a pamphlet, Le Diatribe du Docteur Akakia (The Diatribe of Doctor Akakia) provoked Frederick to burn the pamphlet publicly and put Voltaire under house arrest, after which Voltaire left Prussia. When Voltaire left, he took with him poems by Frederick mocking other rulers that could compromise Frederick and limit his political options. Frederick had his agents detain Voltaire in Frankfurt am Main on his way back to France in May 1753 and forced him to surrender the poems.[35] Voltaire later claimed that the envoys had also stolen much of his money and had behaved disrespectfully towards his niece who accompanied him. This episode, which was somewhat exaggeratedly described as a “lover's quarrel,”[36] cooled the friendship between Friedrich and Voltaire.
When in 1753, the anonymous writing “Vie privée du roi de Prusse” or “Idée de la personne, de la manière de vivre et de la cour du roi de Prusse Frederic II.” was published by - presumably - none other than Voltaire, with correspondingly delicate hints, Frederick wrote to his representative in London, Mitchell: “As to this libelous little book, of which you tell me that manuscripts are in circulation in England, I tell you not to bother with it, and neither should you reveal another word about it. […] Besides, I don’t care what obsessed people write about me as long as the well-being of my state doesn’t suffer.”[37]
In his memoirs of 1759,[38] Voltaire lashed out at Frederick with malice and perfidy in order to avenge his quarrels during his time in Potsdam and in particular his ignominious internment in Frankfurt in 1753. The pamphlet also contains plenty of mockery of the homosexuality of the king and many of his courtiers, along with all sorts of risqué details, like the king's eyes being drawn to the male dancers' legs in ballet, Fredersdorf serving the king "in more ways than one to encourage him", etc. Goethe, who read these memoirs not without pleasure, called them "the model of all scandalous writings".[39] In these Mémoires, he explicitly detailed the homosexuality of Frederick and his closest social circle.[40][41] He writes: "when His Majesty was dressed and booted, the Stoic gave some moments to the sect of Epicurus; he had two or three favorites come, either lieutenants of his regiment, or pages, or haidouks [Hungarian infantrymen], or young cadets. They took coffee. He to whom the handkerchief was thrown stayed another quarter of an hour in privacy."[42] A copy of the manuscript was stolen,[43] and after Voltaire's death, pirated excerpts from it were published in Amsterdam in 1784 as The Private Life of the King of Prussia.[44] Publicly, Frederick acted unconcerned about the revelations.[45] However, he had its publication suppressed in France,[44] and attempted to suppress it elsewhere as well.[46]
In 1757, on Voltaire's initiative, Frederick's sister Wilhelmine arranged for a resumption of correspondence between him and the king, who initially appeared brittle and had replies written by a secretary. But Voltaire's contact with the Prussian king seemed essential for his prestige in France, especially since the philosopher was still ignored at the court of Versailles. Gradually they exchanged polite letters again. Eventually both aired their mutual recriminations, and remained on friendly terms until Voltaire's death in 1778.[3] When Suzanne Necker raised funds for a statue of Voltaire in 1770, the king also donated to it. The famous statue of the naked philosopher by Jean-Baptiste Pigalle (1776) can now be seen in the Louvre.[47]
Frederick's writing and predilection for homoerotic artworks
[edit]In 1739, Frederick met the bisexual Venetian philosopher Francesco Algarotti, and they were both infatuated.[48] Frederick planned to make him a count. Challenged by Algarotti that northern Europeans lacked passion, Frederick penned for him an erotic poem, La Jouissance (ambiguously meaning "the pleasure" or "the orgasm"), which imagined what some have described as Algarotti in the throes of sexual intercourse with another partner, a female named Chloris.[49] Not all Frederick scholars have interpreted the poem in such a way; it has also been suggested as describing a liaison between Frederick and Algarotti,[49] especially in view of the fact that the latter was known as "Frederick's swan".[50][51] Similar poems were written by Frederick.[52] For instance, the fourth canto of his mock-heroic poem Le Palladion (1749) describes the homosexual adventures of his reader Claude Étienne Darget[53] and includes the following blasphemous lines: "The good Saint John, what do you think he did / To induce Jesus to sleep with him in his bed? / And don’t you feel that he knew his Ganymede."[54] In another verse he calls Julius Caesar the "wife of all Romans". However, none of these poems, including La Jouissance, unequivocally exposes Frederick as being involved in such affairs, though they do highlight his homoerotic artistic tendencies.[55]
Frederick also filled his palaces with erotic artworks that reflected his longing for homosexual relationships.[56] The palace gardens at Sanssouci include a Temple of Friendship (built as a memorial to his sister, Wilhelmine) celebrating the homoerotic attachments of Greek Antiquity, which is decorated with portraits of Orestes and Pylades, amongst others.[57] In the New Palace, a showcase palace also located on the grounds of Sanssouci, Frederick kept the fresco Ganymede Is Introduced to Olympus by Charles Vanloo: "the largest fresco in the largest room in his largest palace", in the words of a biographer.[58] In 1747, the king acquired the antique bronze statue of the nude Berlin Adorant, which he thought to represent Antinous, the supposed lover of the Roman emperor Hadrian.[59] The archaeologist Johann Joachim Winckelmann, a pioneering Hellenist and rather openly homosexual, visited Potsdam in 1752 and wrote: "I have seen Athens and Sparta in Potsdam and am filled with an adoring reverence towards the divine monarch", adding: "I have enjoyed lusts that I will never enjoy again".[23]
After his defeat at the Battle of Kolín, Frederick wrote in a letter: "La fortune m'a tourné le dos....[E]lle est femme, et je ne suis pas galant."[60] This has been translated as "Fortune has it in for me; she is a woman, and I am not that way inclined."[61] The original phrase "je ne suis pas galant" is somewhat ambiguous. While it would not be inaccurate to translate it as "I am not a lover/suitor (of women)", it could also be translated as the rather less suggestive, "I am not chivalrous".
The following explanation can be read on the SPSG website: “Love was also considered erotic, but in public and literary terms it appeared to be more enthusiastic, asexual, platonic. Sexuality, on the other hand, was practiced in the 18th century with a freedom that may surprise us today. The distinction between heterosexuality, homosexuality or bisexuality did not play the role that it should have played since the 19th century. Sexual contacts between older people and much younger people were common and corresponded to common behavior, at least in noble circles; promiscuity was the order of the day. The visual and performing arts of the time reflect this, but the traditional writings and even pornographic depictions leave nothing to be desired.” And further: “Frederick also liked to buy (paintings by) Pompeo Batoni (1708–1787). It is reported that his specially commissioned picture The Marriage of Cupid and Psyche from 1756 accompanied him throughout the entire Seven Years' War and was considered one of his favorite pictures. In any case, the pictures contain numerous of the cheerful so-called Mignons – sweethearts – who apparently matched the king's taste for young, pretty pages.”[62]
Possible heterosexual relationship
[edit]While there is no extensive documentation of Frederick having any intimate heterosexual relationships, it is speculated that he may have had a short relationship with Anna Karolina Orzelska, a countess five years his senior and the illegitimate daughter of King Augustus II the Strong of Poland and Saxony. The two first met in Dresden in February 1728 when Frederick was only sixteen and on a diplomatic visit with his father. Augustus allegedly attempted to divert Frederick's attentions away from his illegitimate daughter by offering him the nude opera singer called La Formera on a couch.[63] When the naked singer appeared after dinner, Frederick ignored her embarrassedly while his religious and prudish father threw a handkerchief over his son's head. The Prussian king rejected the flirtatious atmosphere at the Saxon court and would never have tolerated his son having a relationship with Augustus' bastard daughter. The two allegedly began a secret love affair, with Frederick dedicating several poems and music compositions to her. Some have claimed that Orzelska was Frederick's first and only mistress[64] - conjectures based largely on the wishful thinking of his sister Wilhelmine who didn't like her brother's same-sex liaisons with young pages.[65] It was probably a teenager's crush on a very unconventional young woman who was known for her tendency to drink, smoke tobacco, and have numerous affairs. Orzelska was also known for frequently dressing in men's clothing and military uniforms, for partaking in men's activities and for having an interest in dancing, which may have attracted young Frederick's attention. It has also been suggested that Orzelska was attempting to gather intelligence on Frederick and Prussia.[66] However, when King Augustus and the countess, who was now married and pregnant, paid a return visit to the Prussian court in 1731, Frederick was frustrated and turned to unspecified other forms of dissipation.[67] The alleged relationship between the crown prince and Orzelska was cited by some 19th century German historians as evidence against claims of Frederick's homosexuality.[68]
Contemporary opinion
[edit]"His father Frederick William called the heir to the throne a 'sodomite' and 'effeminate'", says biographer Wolfgang Burgdorf. The historian bundled the same-sex amours of gay Fritz in his Friedrich book.[69] Even during his lifetime, much of European society assumed Frederick was homosexual. According to Johann Georg Ritter von Zimmermann, the private physician of George III and later of Frederick himself, also a member of his academy, "Frederick lost a great deal of 'sensual pleasure,' says Mr. Bushing (i.e. Anton Friedrich Büsching), a Prussian ecclesiastic counsellor, 'by his aversion to women; but he indemnified himself by his intercourse with men, recollecting from the history of philosophy, that Socrates was reported to have been very fond of Alcibiades.' Not only Mr. Bushing, however, but also Voltaire, La Beaumelle, the Duke de Choiseul, innumerable Frenchmen and Germans, almost all the friends and enemies of Frederick, almost all the princes and great men of Europe, even his servants, – even the confidants and friends of his latter years, were of opinion that he had loved, as it is pretended, Socrates loved Alcibiades."[70]
In his undated poem, “Parallèle between Caesar and Frederick,” Denis Diderot wrote: “When I compare them [i.e. Caesar and Frederick] I see but one point in common, namely that they were both buggers. ... His Prussian Majesty never touched a woman, not even his own wife.”[71][72] Dealing with the "love" of the king, the Austrian writer Joseph Richter felt that Frederick had "lost all feeling for the fair sex" and "believed he could fill the empty moments no better than with Socratic love. Instead of suppressing his lust for a lecherous life, he just gave it another direction. What a woman could have done, a page now did."[73] In his Story of My Life, Giacomo Casanova noted that each member of First Potsdam Battalion "had a gold watch in the fob of his breeches. It was thus that the king rewarded the courage with which they had subjugated him, as Caesar once subjugated Nicomedes in Bithynia. No secret was made of it."[74] When Frederick was in Potsdam, he spent much of his time at Sanssouci with a circle that was exclusively male,[75] and during Frederick's lifetime the phrase les Potsdamistes was used throughout Europe to describe homosexual courtiers.[76]
When towards the end of the Seven Years' War Frederick published a malicious satire against the mistress of Louis XV, Madame de Pompadour, and against the French nation in general, the French minister Étienne de Choiseul wrote a reply which ended with the following verse: « Peux-tu condamner la tendresse, / Toi qui n'en as connu l'ivresse / Que dans les bras de tes tambours. » (Can you damn the tenderness [of the French king] / You who only knew love drunkenness / In the arms of your drummers.)[77]
William Hogarth's painting The Toilette may include a satirical depiction of Frederick as a flautist next to a mythological painting in which Zeus, in the form of an eagle, is abducting his male lover Ganymede[78][79] – thereby publicly outing the Prussian king as a homosexual as early as 1744.[80] Of course, word of his sometimes contemptuous treatment of his wife Elisabeth Christine had also got around at the European courts. In 1763, when Frederick, after the Seven Years' War, saw his wife for the first time in six years, he only told her: "Madame has become more stout" and then turned to his waiting sisters.[81] He himself never received his wife in Sanssouci; she had no access to his court there. Instead, she fulfilled royal representative duties in the Berlin Palace that the monarch avoided, such as receiving new envoys or distantly related foreign princes. However, she only took on the de facto role of first lady of the state after her mother-in-law's death in 1757.[82]
To muddy Frederick's homosexual reputation, Frederick's physician von Zimmermann claimed that Frederick had convinced himself that he was impotent[83] due to a minor deformity he had received during an operation to cure gonorrhea in 1733. According to Zimmermann, Frederick pretended to be homosexual in order to appear as still virile and capable of intercourse, albeit with men.[70] This story is doubted by biographer Wolfgang Burgdorf, who is of the opinion that "Frederick had a physical disgust of women" and therefore "was unable to sleep with them".[84][85] The surgeon Gottlieb Engel, who prepared Frederick's body for burial, indignantly contested Zimmerman's story, saying the king's genitalia were "complete and perfect as those of any healthy man". [86] In similar terms, the doctors who were involved in washing Frederick's corpse on 17 August 1786 reported that the recently deceased king showed no abnormalities whatsoever in the genitals. Ollenroth, Rosenmeyer and Liebert, the three surgeons of the 1st Life Guards Battalion, wrote that "the blessed king's external birth parts were healthy and not mutilated". "The two testicles were in their natural position without the slightest defect; the spermatic cord could be clearly felt up to the entrance of the abdominal ring without the least hardening or distention; the male member was of natural size; there was not the slightest bit in the soft parts of the pubic region characteristic of a scar or induration, or of any disease ever involving these parts."[87]
Legacy and historiography
[edit]Reinhard Alings, a curator of the Foundation for the Humboldt Forum in the Berlin Palace, writes on the SPSG[88] website: “The topic probably really outraged few of his contemporaries, although it was always good for one or two sharp remarks. The moralizing question of whether Frederick the Great was gay results from later times, first from the Frederick-Prussian historiography of the 19th century up to our days. Above all, the doubt as to whether this could even be true arises from later historiography. It can be assumed that it was only the vehement contradiction of the 19th and 20th centuries that gave lasting impetus to the question of Frederick's (homo-)sexuality. Til today. With the end of the Hohenzollern Monarchy in Germany and more critical historiography, there were fewer reasons to make the topic taboo.”[89]
Frederick's homosexuality was rejected by professional historians for centuries after his death. In 1921, doctor and amateur historian Gaston Vorberg wrote an essay to debunk ongoing rumors around Frederick's sexuality, asserting that he was heterosexual ("Gossip about Frederick II's sexual life").[90][91] For example, Voltaire's malices could be dismissed as obviously driven by vengeful motives without having to wonder if there might be any truth to them. Historian Johannes Kunisch (1937–2015) still insisted that there is "no serious evidence" of Frederick's homosexuality and that contemporary statements about this "facet" of Frederick's nature were "denunciatory". In his youth, for example, the crown prince would have had affairs with peasant 'nymphs', and as a young king he dated the ballet dancer Barbara Campanini. Finally, Kunisch wrote, it was also possible that Frederick only staged his homosexuality, for example to hide impotence.[92] This opinion has been described by others as "hair-raising psychologising, even pathologising ahistoricity".[93] It has also been argued that the king's interest in the ballet dancer Barbara Campanini, as well as in Anna Karolina Orzelska, can be explained by the phenomenon of the often female “gay icons” that is widespread among male homosexuals.[94] According to Frank-Lothar Kroll, Frederick's disposition was significantly less life-determining than that of his brother Henry. He believes that the king was more determined by male maxims than his brother was.[95] However, Henry proved very successful as a general; His luck in battle was less changeable than that of the king himself which Frederick expressly acknowledged.[96] In his later written admonitions to his nephew and successor, Frederick mockingly called the officers in Henry's regiments "a collection of pederasts".[97]
To others it seems that deliberate ignoring of abounding circumstantial evidence is rooted in conviction that a gay ruler would be a disgrace, as if Frederick's homosexuality would shrink his historic size.[10] The myth of one of the greatest war heroes in world history was not allowed to be psychologically deconstructed. It is such multicentennial historiography that today brings so much prominence, including a lexical special article, to a subject, that would play only one role among many in a biography about a contemporary.
In contrast, his homosexuality was embraced by the homosexual publications of Weimar Germany, which featured him on their covers and praised him for governing while homosexual. Thomas Mann had provided an early precursor to this point of view with his essay Frederick and the grand coalition, written in late 1914, at the start of World War I. He contrasted Frederick's soldierly, male drive and his literary, female connotations consisting of "decomposing" skepticism.[98] Vorberg's conclusions were sharply criticized by another amateur historian, Ferdinand Karsch, in the gay publication Die Freundschaft. In 1931, homosexual activist Richard Linsert published the book Intrigue and Love: On Politics and Sexual Life which spent nine pages discussing Frederick and his sexuality.[12] In 1937, the literary writer Jochen Klepper, who was persecuted by the Nazis and ultimately perished, published his successful novel The Father. Novel of the Soldier King,[99] in which he got to the bottom of the traumatic father-son relationship, although only hinting at a homosexual disposition in the son. He concluded that the father's values of discipline, order, and determination eventually prevailed over the son's effeminate tendencies. This was again compatible with the general historiography that Frederick, endowed with these paternal values, successfully used the powerful army his father had built up to transform a backward agricultural state on the periphery into a major European power.
Modern research is not typically concerned with proving Frederick II's homosexuality, as it became the accepted consensus among most historians. It frequently takes greater interest in the consequences of his disposition, and how they affected his reign as King of Prussia. Historian Wolfgang Burgdorf[100] suggests that Frederick's abuse and constant public humiliation by his father, Frederick William, for being too soft and effeminate stemmed from the latter's hatred for everything effeminate and his disappointment at the son's inability to father a successor. Burgdorf further suggests that Frederick William forcing his son to watch his lover's execution by sword, his subsequent intention − which was prevented only by the Emperor and the Prussian nobility − to also execute his son for attempted desertion, his subsequent suggestion that his son should commit suicide, and − after abandoning these bloody plans − the strict military and administrative training that he finally prescribed for his son, could explain Frederick II's "militaristic decisions" as King "as if the warlike royal hero wanted to prove to his dead father that he was a tough man."[10][101] Likewise, his lack of empathy could be explained by his own cruel experiences as a youth, because the conquest of Silesia cost the lives of tens of thousands of his soldiers and his country's citizens, which never affected Frederick in the least. Recent source research and historiography shows that the king absolutely wanted to go down in history as “the great” and reveal a person with great talents - and equally great weaknesses.[102]
References
[edit]- ^ Disputedly, this is the only portrait for which Frederick is said to have sat during his reign. According to Karin Schrader, Der Bildnismaler Johann Georg Ziesenis (1717–1776) (Münster 1995), pp. 101–119, it is not clear that Frederick sat for this portrait. In fact, Frederick had a large, hooked nose and considered himself as ugly as a scarecrow. Therefore, he refused to sit for official state portraits which show him either stoic or heroic while this overly handsome portrait shows him smiling and facing. Arthistoricum.net page of the University of Heidelberg
- ^ Blanning 2016, p. 193.
- ^ a b Henderson, Susan W. (1977). "Frederick the Great of Prussia: A Homophile Perspective". Gai Saber. 1 (1): 46–54.; also see: Johansson, Warren (2016). "Frederick II (The Great) of Prussia (1712–1786)". In Dynes, Wayne R. (ed.). Encyclopedia of Homosexuality. Vol. I. Oxfordshire, UK: Taylor & Francis. pp. 428–429.
- ^ Krause, Tilman (20 March 2019). "So Schwul War Deutschlands größter König" [Germany's Greatest King Was So Gay]. Welt (in German). Archived from the original on 17 November 2020.
- ^ Krysmanski, Bernd (2019), "Belege für die Homosexualität und die analerotischen Gelüste des Preußenkönigs," in Nur Hogarth zeigt den Alten Fritz wahrheitsgemäß mit krummem "Zinken" – die uns vertrauten Bilder von Pesne bis Menzel tun dies nicht (Heidelberg: arthistoricum.net). https://archiv.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/artdok/6399 ("Evidence for the Homosexuality and the Anal-Erotic Desires of the Prussian King," in Only Hogarth Depicts the Old Fritz Truthfully with a Crooked "Beak" – The Pictures Familiar to Us from Pesne to Menzel Don't Do This), p. 27: "Dass der Preußenkönig homosexuelle Neigungen hatte, war schon dem 18. Jahrhundert wohlbekannt." ("That the Prussian king had homosexual tendencies was well known as early as the 18th century.")
- ^ Blanning 2016, pp. 55–77; Clark 2006, pp. 186–189; Fraser 2000, pp. 39–42; MacDonogh 2000, pp. 106–107.
- ^ Œuvres de Frédéric le Grand, Tome XX, Correspondance Tome V: IV. Correspondance de Frédéric avec M. Darget (Mai 1749 - 6 Septembre 1771), no. 6.
- ^ Krysmanski, "Evidence for the homosexuality and the anal erotic desires of the Prussian king", p. 28. https://doi.org/10.11588/artdok.00008019
- ^ In his "Matinées" (a kind of guide written for his heir to the throne) to be found in the royal archives in Potsdam, the older monarch took a more sceptical view of his homosexual activities. Though on the one hand he admits that Amor knows no mercy and that it is useless to defy him, yet, on the other hand, he advises his nephew not to follow his example, because it could have serious consequences for him: "the commanders and officers would be more interested in pleasure than glory, and your army would end up in a collection of pederasts, like your Uncle Henry's regiment. From my personal experience I can assure you that that Greek pleasure has little appeal..." See Gaston Vorberg, "Der Klatsch über das Geschlechtsleben Friedrichs II." (Gossip about Frederick II's sexual life), in Abhandlungen aus dem Gebiete der Sexualforschung (Treatises from the field of sexual research), vol. III, no. 6 (1920-21), pp. 6-7.
- ^ a b c d Oliver Das Gupta, "Der schwule Fritz," Süddeutsche Zeitung, 23 January 2012.
- ^ Wolfgang Burgdorf, "Königliche Liebschaften: Friedrich der Große und seine Männer," in Norman Domeier and Christian Mühling (eds.), Homosexualität am Hof: Praktiken und Diskurse vom Mittelalter bis heute (Frankfurt am Main and New York: Campus), p. 133.
- ^ a b Beacock, Ian P. (23 May 2019). "Queer Ancestry as a Problem of Knowledge in Early 20th-Century Germany". German Historical Institute. doi:10.58079/12pxc. Retrieved 4 January 2022.
- ^ Reinhard Alings, "'Don't Ask, Don't Tell' - war Friedrich schwul?" in Friederisiko: Friedrich der Große: Die Ausstellung, edited by the Generaldirektion der Stiftung Preußische Schlösser und Gärten Berlin-Brandenburg (Munich, 2012), p. 238.
- ^ Wilhelmine of Prussia, Margravine of Brandenburg-Bayreuth (1888). Memoirs of Wilhelmine, Margravine of Baireuth. Translated by Princess Christian of Schleswig-Holstein. New York: Harper & Brothers. p. 83.
- ^ "Goldsmith, Margaret (1929). Frederick the Great. C. Boni. p. 50.
- ^ Mitford 1984, p. 61.
- ^ Reiners, Ludwig (1960). Frederick the Great: A Biography. New York: G. P. Putnam & Sons. OCLC 221946415., p. 41
- ^ Christopher Clark quotes this remark in his book Preußen. Aufstieg und Niedergang 1600–1947 (″Prussia. Rise and Decline 1600–1947″), publisher DVA, Stuttgart 2006, pages 135 and 800, as "credible".
- ^ Wilhelmine of Prussia, Margravine of Brandenburg-Bayreuth: Mémoires de Frédérique Sophie Wilhelmine, Margrave de Bayreuthe, soeur de Frédéric le Grand, depuis L’année 1709 jusqu’a 1742, écrit de sa main. (Mercure de France, Paris 1967), translated into German and edited by Günther Berger as: Memoiren einer preußischen Königstochter. Markgräfin Wilhelmine von Bayreuth (Memoirs of a Prussian king's daughter. Margravine Wilhelmine of Bayreuth), publisher Ellwanger, Bayreuth 2007, 3rd edition, 2018, pp. 93−94
- ^ Büstrin, Klaus (1 September 2012). ""Ich habe gemeinet, du häst mihr lieb": Friedrichs enge Beziehungen zu seinem Kammerdiener Fredersdorf" ["I thought you loved me": Frederick's Close Relationship with His Valet Fredersdorf]. Potsdamer Neueste Nachrichten (in German). Archived from the original on 3 August 2019.
- ^ Heinrich Ludewig Manger's Baugeschichte von Potsdam, besonders unter der Regierung König Friedrichs des Zweiten, vol. 1 (Berlin and Stettin: Nicolai, 1789–90), p. 34. Reporting the dismissal of Friedrich Wilhelm Diterich, the building inspector of Sanssouci, Manger suspects that Diterich "did not court the king's darling at the time (i.e. Fredersdorf) enough".
- ^ War Friedrich schwul oder nur not-homosexuell?, Die Welt, 23 January 2012. Eva Ziebura is a biographer of his brother Prince Henry: Eva Ziebura: Prinz Heinrich von Preußen. Biographie (in German), publisher; Aufbau-Taschenbuch-Verlag, Berlin, 496 pages, 2004, ISBN 3746617707
- ^ a b c d Oliver Das Gupta: Der schwule Fritz, in Süddeutsche Zeitung, 23 January 2012
- ^ Eva Ziebura, Prinz Heinrich von Preußen (Berlin: Stapp, 1999), pp. 44–48. The "handsome Marwitz" is presumably identical to the member of the von der Marwitz family mentioned on the Rheinsberg obelisk (without mentioning his first name) as "quartermaster in the king's army" with the life span 1724–1759.
- ^ Wieland Giebel (editor): Die Tagebücher des Grafen Lehndorff. Die geheimen Aufzeichnungen des Kammerherrn der Königin Elisabeth Christine (The diaries of Count Lehndorff. The Secret Notes of Queen Elisabeth Christine's Chamberlain), publisher: Story, Berlin 2007, ISBN 978-3929829525.
- ^ The letter of March 3, 1746 is cited by Eva Ziebura: Prinz Heinrich von Preußen. Biographie, p. 44
- ^ Abbott, J. S. C. (1870). "Frederick the Great". Harper's New Monthly Magazine. Vol. 40, no. 239. p. 680.
- ^ MacDonogh 2000, p. 117; Crompton 2009, p. 504; Mitford 1984, pp. 95–96.
- ^ MacDonogh 2000, p. 125.
- ^ See Louis Crompton, Homosexuality and Civilization (Harvard University Press, 2003), pp. 512–19.
- ^ Numa Praetorius, "Voltaire und die Homosexualität" (Voltaire and homosexuality), Der Kreis: Eine Monatsschrift, 11, nos. 7–9 (1943). [1] and [2] and [3]
- ^ Numa Praetorius: https://www.e-periodica.ch/cntmng?pid=kre-003%3A1943%3A11%3A%3A393
- ^ Frederick the Great and Voltaire, prussianhistory.com
- ^ Frederick William I had not only his son's favorite Katte executed, but also "trans-man" Catharina Margaretha Linck in 1723.
- ^ MacDonogh 2000, pp. 228–230.
- ^ MacDonogh 2000, p. 230.
- ^ Reinhard Alings: „DON’T ASK – DON’T TELL“ – WAR FRIEDRICH DER GROSSE SCHWUL? (Don't ask - don't tell - Was Frederick the Great gay?), blog on the SPSG website, June 29, 2022
- ^ Voltaire, Memoires pour servir à la vie de M. de Voltaire, écrits par lui-même, Paris 1759
- ^ Goethe, cited in the foreword to the German translation of Voltaire's memoirs: Voltaire über den König von Preußen, Memoiren (Voltaire on the King of Prussia, Memoirs), edited and translated by Anneliese Botond, publisher Insel Verlag, Frankfurt/M. 1981 (First edition 1967), p. 28
- ^ Tim Blanning, Frederick the Great: King of Prussia (Penguin edition, 2016), p. 446.
- ^ Krysmanski, "Evidence for the homosexuality and the anal erotic desires of the Prussian king", pp. 27–28. https://doi.org/10.11588/artdok.00008019
- ^ Cited in Louis Crompton, Homosexuality and Civilization (Cambridge, MA: Balknap Press of Harvard University Press, 2003), p. 516.
- ^ MacDonogh 2000, p. 341.
- ^ a b Languille, E. M. (2007). "Voltaire's satire on Frederick the Great: Candide, His Posthumous Mémoires, Scarmendado, and Les Questions Sur L'Encyclopédie". Romance Notes. 48 (1): 49–58. doi:10.1353/rmc.2007.0008. JSTOR 90011893. S2CID 162308699.
- ^ MacDonogh 2000, p. 382.
- ^ Voltaire (1784). Memoirs of the Life of Voltaire. London: G. Robinson. pp. i-ii.
- ^ Voltaire nu, Louvre Collections
- ^ MacDonogh 2000, p. 71; Mitford 1984, p. 80.
- ^ a b Hadley, Kathryn (2011). "Frederick the Great's Erotic Poem". History Today.
- ^ Wolfgang Nedobity, "Frederick's Swan: Francesco Algarotti and the Expression of Desire", SSRN, 2012. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2118506
- ^ On the relationship between the king and Algarotti, see also Ursula Pia Jauch, "Eros zwischen Herr und Knecht: Friedrich der Große und Francesco Algarotti im Land der Lust", in Bernd Sösemann (ed.): Friedrich der Große in Europa – gefeiert und umstritten (Stuttgart, 2012), pp. 59-70.
- ^ Clark 2006, p. 188.
- ^ Tim Blanning, Frederick the Great: King of Prussia (Penguin edition, 2016), pp. 183, 447–448 [ISBN missing]
- ^ Cited in Bernd Krysmanski, "Was Old Fritz really gay", in Das einzig authentische Porträt des Alten Fritz? Entdeckt in Hogarths 'Marriage A-la-Mode'. Is the only true likeness of Frederick the Great to be found in Hogarth's 'Marriage A-la-Mode'? (Dinslaken, 2015), p. 55.
- ^ Ashton, Bodie A. (1 May 2019). "Kingship, Sexuality and Courtly Masculinity: Frederick the Great and Prussia on the Cusp of Modernity" (PDF). ANU Historical Journal II. II (1). Canberra, Australian Capital Territory, Australia: Australian National University Press: 109–136. doi:10.22459/ANUHJII.2019.11. ISSN 2652-0281. Archived from the original (PDF) on 16 July 2020. Retrieved 3 July 2021.
- ^ Vogtherr, Christoph Martin (2001). "Absent Love in Pleasure Houses. Frederick II of Prussia as Art Collector and patron". Art History. 24 (2): 231–246. doi:10.1111/1467-8365.00262. ISSN 0141-6790. PMID 18751326.
- ^ Steakley, James D. (1988). "Sodomy in Enlightenment Prussia: From Execution to Suicide". Journal of Homosexuality. 16 (1–2): 163–175. doi:10.1300/J082v16n01_09. PMID 3069916.
- ^ Blanning 2016, p. 193.
- ^ See Thomas Fischbacher, Des Königs Knabe: Friedrich der Große und Antinous (Weimar: VDG, 2011).
- ^ "Frédéric à mylord Marischal, Après la bataille de Kolin, 18 juin 1757". Digitale Ausgabe der Universitätsbibliothek Trier (in French). Retrieved 8 June 2021.
- ^ Blanning 2016, p. 230.
- ^ Reinhard Alings: „DON’T ASK – DON’T TELL“ – WAR FRIEDRICH DER GROSSE SCHWUL? (Don't ask - don't tell - Was Frederick the Great gay?), blog on the SPSG website, June 29, 2022
- ^ Tim Blanning, Frederick the Great: King of Prussia (Penguin edition, 2016), p. 35.
- ^ Goeller, Tom (1 December 2011). Der alte Fritz: Mensch, Monarch, Mythos (in German). HOFFMANN UND CAMPE VERLAG GmbH. ISBN 978-3-455-85009-3.
- ^ See also Hans-Jürgen Bömelburg, Friedrich II. zwischen Deutschland und Polen: Ereignis- und Erinnerungsgeschichte (Stuttgart: Alfred Kröner Verlag, 2011), p. 11.
- ^ "::Countess Anna Orzelska::". 17 February 2012. Archived from the original on 17 February 2012. Retrieved 14 April 2023.
- ^ Blanning, Frederick the Great (Penguin edition, 2016), p. 35.
- ^ Schulthess, Robert (1850). Friedrich und Voltaire in ihrem persönlichen und litterarischen Wechselverhältnisse: eine litterar-historische Skizze (in German). F. Förstemann.
- ^ Wolfgang Burgdorf, Friedrich der Große: Ein biografisches Porträt, 2011 (Freiburg im Breisgau: Herder), pp. 76–103.
- ^ a b Zimmermann, Johann Georg (1792). "On Frederick's Supposed Grecian Taste in Love". Select Views of the Life, Reign, and Character of Frederick the Great, King of Prussia. Translated by Major Neuman. London: Hookham and Carpenter. pp. 45–67.
- ^ Louis Godbout, “Frederick the Great (1712-1786)”, glbtq, 2004, p. 3.
- ^ Morris Wachs, “Diderot’s Parallèle de César et de Frédéric,” in Otis Fellows and Diana Guiragossian (eds.), Diderot Studies, 14 (Geneva: Librairie Droz, 1971), pp. 259–265.
- ^ Joseph Richter, Lexikon aller Anstössigkeiten und Prahlereyen: welche in denen zu Berlin in funfzehn Bänden erschienenen sogenannten Schriften Friedrichs des Zweyten vorkommen (Leipzigermesse, 1789), pp. 103–104.
- ^ Jacques Casanova de Seingalt Vénitien, Histoire de ma vie, Édition intégrale, vol. 5 (Paris, 1961), p. 78.
- ^ Blanning 2016, p. 481.
- ^ Domeier, Norman (2014). "The Homosexual Scare and the Masculinization of German Politics before World War I". Central European History. 47 (4): 737–759. doi:10.1017/S0008938914001903. JSTOR 43965084. S2CID 146627960.
- ^ Numa Praetorius, "Voltaire und die Homosexualität", Der Kreis: Eine Monatsschrift, 11, nos. 7–9 (1943). [4], referring to a book by Dr. Paul D'Estrées (pseudonym of a well-known Parisian doctor): "Les Infames sous l'ancien régime", which had only appeared in 200 copies at the time and is kept in the Bibliothèque Nationale.
- ^ Bernd Krysmanski, "William Hogarth is the only artist who shows the gay Fritz truthfully with a brown complexion and an aquiline nose"", in Does Hogarth Depict Old Fritz Truthfully with a Crooked Beak? – The Pictures Familiar to Us from Pesne to Menzel Don’t Show This, ART-dok (University of Heidelberg: arthistoricum.net, 2022), 22–26. https://doi.org/10.11588/artdok.00008019
- ^ New, Melvyn (2019). "Das Einzig Authentische Porträt des Alten Fritz? Is the Only True Likeness of Frederick the Great to be Found in Hogarth's Marriage A-la-Mode? by Bernd Krysmanski (Review)". The Scriblerian and the Kit-Cats. 51 (2): 198. doi:10.1353/scb.2019.0084. S2CID 195475400 – via Project Muse.
- ^ MacDonogh, Giles (15 December 2015). "Hogarth's Portrait of Frederick the Great". Giles MacDonogh – Blog. Archived from the original on 9 February 2016.
- ^ This is reported in the diary of the Queen's Chamberlain Count Ernst Ahasverus Heinrich von Lehndorff, edited by Wieland Giebel: Die Tagebücher des Grafen Lehndorff. Die geheimen Aufzeichnungen des Kammerherrn der Königin Elisabeth Christine., p. 499. Publisher: Berlin Story Verlag, Berlin 2012, ISBN 978-3863680503
- ^ Alfred P. Hagemann: Queen Elisabeth Christine and her summer residence. In: Schönhausen - Rococo and Cold War. Jaron, 2009, ed.: General Directorate of the Prussian Palaces and Gardens Foundation Berlin-Brandenburg
- ^ Zimmermann, Johann Georg (1791). Doctor Zimmermann's Conversations with the Late King of Prussia, When He Attended Him in His Last Illness a Little Before His Death; to Which Are Added Several Curious Particulars and Anecdotes of That Extraordinary Prince. Translated by unknown. London: C. Forster. pp. 118–119.
- ^ Das Gupta, Oliver (23 January 2012). "Der Schwule Fritz" [The Gay Fritz]. Süddeutsche Zeitung (in German). Archived from the original on 17 February 2021.
- ^ Wolfgang Burgdorf, Friedrich der Große: Ein biografisches Porträt (Freiburg im Breisgau: Herder, 2011), pp. 102–103.
- ^ Asprey 1986, p. 40; Blanning 2016, p. 57.
- ^ Cited by Gaston Vorberg, "Der Klatsch über das Geschlechtsleben Friedrichs II.", in Abhandlungen aus dem Gebiete der Sexualforschung, vol. III, no. 6 (1920-21), p. 14.
- ^ The foundation SPSG today manages and administers most of Frederick's palaces including Sanssouci.
- ^ Reinhard Alings: „DON’T ASK – DON’T TELL“ – WAR FRIEDRICH DER GROSSE SCHWUL? (Don't ask - don't tell - Was Frederick the Great gay?), blog on the SPSG website, June 29, 2022
- ^ Gaston Vorberg, "Der Klatsch über das Geschlechtsleben Friedrichs II.", in Abhandlungen aus dem Gebiete der Sexualforschung, vol. III, no. 6 (1920-21), pp. 5-16.
- ^ Ian P. Beacock, "Queer Ancestry as a Problem of Knowledge in Early 20th-Century Germany", History of Knowledge, May 23, 2019.
- ^ Johannes Kunisch: Friedrich der Große. Der König und seine Zeit, publisher: Beck, Munich 2005, pp. 79–81.
- ^ Jakob Michelsen, "Die Verfolgung des Delikts Sodomie im 18. Jahrhundert in Brandenburg-Preußen," in Norbert Finzsch and Marcus Velke (eds.), Queer | Gender | Historiographie: Aktuelle Tendenzen und Projekte (Berlin: LIT Verlag, 2016), p. 241, note 63.
- ^ Krysmanski, "Evidence for the homosexuality and the anal erotic desires of the Prussian king," p. 28, note 83. https://doi.org/10.11588/artdok.00008019
- ^ Frank-Lothar Kroll: Die Hohenzollern, publisher: Beck, Munich, 2008, p. 56.
- ^ Eva Ziebura: Prinz Heinrich von Preußen. Biographie publisher Aufbau-Taschenbuch-Verlag, Berlin 2004, p. 157.
- ^ His "Matinées" (a kind of guide written for his heir to the throne) are in the royal archives in Potsdam, cited by Gaston Vorberg, "Der Klatsch über das Geschlechtsleben Friedrichs II.", in Abhandlungen aus dem Gebiete der Sexualforschung, vol. III, no. 6 (1920-21), pp. 6-7.
- ^ Thomas Mann had already started planning a novel about Frederick II in 1905/1906, which ultimately did not come to fruition. This “outline” was created in the second half of 1914 based, among other things, on the notes and excerpts already collected for this project. See: Friedrich und die große Koalition, Ein Abriß für den Tag und die Stunde, Fischer Verlag
- ^ Jochen Klepper: The Father. Novel of the Soldier King, in German: Der Vater. Roman des Soldatenkönigs. publisher: Deutsche Verlags-Anstalt, Stuttgart/Berlin 1937 (originally in 2 volumes). 74 editions published between 1937 and 2017 in German and English.
- ^ For biographical details, see German article Wolfgang Burgdorf
- ^ The source from which the newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung quotes, is: Wolfgang Burgdorf, “Königliche Liebschaften: Friedrich der Große und seine Männer,” (Royal love affairs: Frederick the Great and his men) in Norman Domeier and Christian Mühling (eds.), Homosexualität am Hof: Praktiken und Diskurse vom Mittelalter bis heute (Homosexuality at Court: Practices and Discourses from the Middle Ages to Today), Frankfurt am Main and New York, 2020: Campus, p. 133. [5]
- ^ Jürgen Luh: Der Große. Friedrich II. von Preußen. (The Great. Frederick II of Prussia.) publisher Siedler, Munich 2011
Sources
[edit]- Asprey, Robert B. (1986). Frederick the Great: The Magnificent Enigma. New York: Ticknor & Fields. ISBN 978-0-89919-352-6.
- Blanning, T. C. W. (2016). Frederick the Great: King of Prussia. Random House. ISBN 978-1-4000-6812-8.
- Clark, Christopher (2006). Iron Kingdom: The Rise and Downfall of Prussia 1600–1947. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press of Harvard University Press. ISBN 978-0-674-02385-7.
- Crompton (2009). Homosexuality and Civilization. Harvard University Press. ISBN 978-0-674-03006-0.
- Fraser, David (2000). Frederick the Great: King of Prussia. New York: Fromm International. ISBN 978-0-88064-261-3.
- MacDonogh, Giles (2000). Frederick the Great: A Life in Deed and Letters. Macmillan. ISBN 978-0-312-25318-9.
- Mitford, Nancy (1984) [1970]. Frederick the Great. New York: E. P. Dutton. ISBN 0-525-48147-8.
Further reading
[edit]- Alings, Reinhard (2012). “ ‘Don’t ask – don’t tell’ – War Friedrich schwul?” In Friederisiko: Friedrich der Große, exh. cat., Stiftung Preußische Schlösser und Gärten Berlin-Brandenburg, Neues Palais and Park Sanssouci, 28 April–28 October 2012 (Munich: Hirmer, 2012), "Die Ausstellung", pp. 238–247.
- Burgdorf, Wolfgang (2011). Friedrich der Große: Ein biografisches Porträt (Freiburg im Breisgau: Herder), 76–103.
- Burgdorf, Wolfgang (2020). "Königliche Liebschaften: Friedrich der Große und seine Männer", in Domeier, Norman / Mühling, Christian (eds.), Homosexualität am Hof: Praktiken und Diskurse vom Mittelalter bis heute (Frankfurt am Main and New York: Campus), pp. 133–150.
- Krysmanski, Bernd (2022). "Evidence for the homosexuality and the anal erotic desires of the Prussian king", in Does Hogarth Depict Old Fritz Truthfully with a Crooked Beak? – The Pictures Familiar to Us from Pesne to Menzel Don’t Show This, ART-dok (University of Heidelberg: arthistoricum.net), 24–30. doi:10.11588/artdok.00008019
- Shoobert, Jackson (2021). "Frederick the great's sexuality- New avenues of approach" (PDF). History in the Making. 8. Archived from the original (PDF) on 30 October 2021.