September 1276 papal election

Papal election
September 1276
Papal election; September 1276;
Dates and location
	Palazzo dei Papi di Viterbo
Key officials
Protopriest	Simone Paltanieri
Protodeacon	Riccardo Annibaldi
Elected pope
	João Pedro Julião; Name taken: John XXI
	← July, 1276 1277 →

The September 1276 papal election is the only papal election to be the third election held in the same year; after Pope Gregory X died, two successors died that year, requiring yet another election. The election was also the first non-conclave, since the establishment of the papal conclave after the papal election, 1268–1271.^[1]

Election of John XXI

Pope Adrian V died on August 18, 1276, at Viterbo after a pontificate of only 38 days without being consecrated. The only act of his pontificate was the suspension of the constitution Ubi periculum about the conclave.

The number of the cardinals present at Viterbo at the death of Adrian V is unclear, but, except for Simon de Brion, who acted as legate in France, at least cardinal Vicedomino de Vicedominis (and perhaps also Riccardo Annibaldi) was absent at Rome due to illness. The rest of the cardinals decided to await on his arrival.^[2] Vicedomino joined the electors at the beginning of September, and the electors finally started to proceed. However, the gravely ill Cardinal Vicedomino died on September 6.^[3]

The remaining 10 (nine?^[4]) electors continued to proceed. They were divided into two national parties: French and Italian.^[5] Neither of them had sufficient number of votes to elect his own candidate. On advice of Giovanni Gaetano Orsini the cardinals finally elected the only neutral cardinal, Portuguese Pedro Juliani, bishop of Frascati. The contemporary chronicles do not agree on the date of his election: dates between September 8 and September 17 are given.^[6] Most probable seems to be September 15.^[7] Due to errors in the numbering of the popes named John in the contemporary catalogs, the elect took the name John XXI, although there was no John XX. He was solemnly crowned by his grand elector Orsini on September 20.

Legend about Pope-elect Gregory XI

According to the later account created probably in the ecclesiastical circles of Piacenza and popularized by Franciscan historians, Cardinal Vicedomino de Vicedomini, bishop of Palestrina and (ostensibly) dean of the College of Cardinals, was elected pope on September 5 and took the name Gregory XI in honour of his uncle Gregory X, but he died within hours of his election, before it could be proclaimed.^[8]

This story, though repeated by some notable authors (incl. Lorenzo Cardella, Gaetano Moroni or more recently Francis Burkle-Young^[9]) has several weak points. The contemporary accounts know nothing about "pope-elect Gregory XI". His election has not been recorded by any chronicle, and also Pope John XXI in the bull in which he announced his election makes no reference to this fact.^[10] On the contrary, he explicitly calls Hadrian V his direct predecessor.^[11] Medieval necrology of the Cathedral of Piacenza recorded only: obiit Vicedominus quondam ep. Paenestrinus anno 1276 .., without any allusion to his election to the papacy.^[12] False or at least dubious are also other details of the story. Vicedomino ostensibly was elected under the influence of his relative, Cardinal-Bishop of Sabina Giovanni Visconti. No such cardinal existed at that time. The suburbicarian see of Sabina was occupied by Bertrand de Saint Martin, who is well attested in the curial documents until 1277.^[13] Also the statement, that Vicedomino was dean of the College (the first in the order of precedence) seems to be inaccurate – on the bulls of Gregory X which contain subscriptions of the cardinals he is always preceded by Pedro Juliani.^[14]

Together, all these facts indicate that the story about pope-elect Gregory XI is rather unlikely to be true.^[15] Perhaps this is a reminiscence of the candidature of Vicedomino in this election.^[16]

Cardinal electors

Elector	Nationality	Order and title	Elevated	Elevator	Notes
João Pedro Julião	Portuguese	Cardinal-Bishop of Frascati	June 3, 1273	Gregory X	Elected Pope John XXI
Bertrand de Saint-Martin O.S.B.	French	Cardinal-Bishop of Sabina	June 3, 1273	Gregory X
Simone Paltanieri	Monselice, near Padua	Cardinal-priest of Ss. Silvestro e Martino	December 17, 1261	Urban IV	Protopriest
Anchero Pantaleone	French	Cardinal-priest of S. Prassede	May 1262	Urban IV	Nephew of Urban IV
Guillaume de Bray	French	Cardinal-priest of S. Marco	May 1262	Urban IV
Riccardo Annibaldi	Roman	Cardinal-deacon of S. Angelo in Pescheria	1238	Gregory IX	Protodeacon, Archpriest of the patriarchal Vatican Basilica and protector of Augustinians
Giovanni Gaetano Orsini	Roman	Cardinal-deacon of S. Nicola in Carcere Tulliano	May 28, 1244	Innocent IV	Inquisitor General and protector of Franciscans; Future Pope Nicholas III
Giacomo Savelli	Roman	Cardinal-deacon of S. Maria in Cosmedin	December 17, 1261	Urban IV	Future Pope Honorius IV
Goffredo da Alatri	Alatri	Cardinal-deacon of S. Giorgio in Velabro	December 17, 1261	Urban IV
Matteo Rosso Orsini	Roman	Cardinal-deacon of S. Maria in Portico	May 1262	Urban IV	Nephew of Pope Nicholas III

Died during sede vacante

Elector	Nationality	Order and title	Elevated	Elevator	Notes
Vicedomino de Vicedominis	Piacenza	Cardinal-Bishop of Palestrina	June 3, 1273	Gregory X	nephew of Pope Gregory X; died on September 6, 1276

Absentee

Elector	Nationality	Order and Title	Elevated	Elevator	Notes
Simon de Brion	French	Cardinal-priest of S. Cecilia	December 17, 1261	Urban IV	Legate in the Kingdom of France; Future Pope Martin IV

Notes

^ Miranda, Salvador. "Papal elections and conclaves of the 13th Century (1216-1294): Election of August 19 - September 8, 1276 (John XXI)". The Cardinals of the Holy Roman Church. Florida International University. OCLC 53276621.
^ Stapper, p. 33
^ Stapper, pp. 33-34; cfr. Miranda, Salvator. 1998. "Election of August 19 - September 8, 1276: (John XXI)." (note 1)
^ It is not possible to ascertain whether Cardinal Annibaldi participated or not in the election. Eubel and Stapper do not count him, indicating that he had died earlier in that year. But the necrology of the church S. Spirito in Sassia in Rome registered his death under October 4, see Necrologi e libri affini della Provincia Romana, ed. Pietro Egidi (Roma : Forzani e c., tipografi del Senato, 1908–1914), I, p. 152.
^ Stapper, p. 35-36
^ Cfr. Stapper, p. 36-37; Dr. J.P. Adams Sede Vacante 1276
^ Eubel, p. 9; Stapper, p. 37
^ The story seems to be mentioned for the first time by 17th-century chronicler of the Order of Friars Minor Luke Wadding; it was later included by P. Campi in his Historia ecclesiastica di Piacenza (1659), then by Augustino Oldoini in 1677 edition of the work of Alphonsus Ciacconius Vitæ et res gestæ Pontificum Romanorum et S.R.E. Cardinalium, and later also by other authors; cfr. Dr J. P. Adams Sede Vacante 1276; and Stapper, p. 34 note 1.
^ F. Burkle-Young is an author of the notes to the papal elections and conclaves on the cardinals' site
^ Stapper, p. 34
^ "SEDE VACANTE". www.csun.edu. Retrieved 2020-02-13.
^ Stapper, p. 33 note 5.
^ Stapper, p. 34 and p. 35-36 note 3; cfr. Eubel, p. 9 note 3 and p. 38.
^ Cfr. the bulls published in Monumenta Boica, vol. 12, p. 138, and vol. 17 pp. 23-24.
^ According to J.P. Adams Sede Vacante 1276 this story is "undoubtedely a pious fiction". Similar conclusion also by Stapper, p. 34.
^ According to R.Sternfeld, Der Kardinal Johann Gaetan Orsini (Papst Nikolaus III.) 1244-1277, Berlin 1905, p. 252, Cardinal Vicedomino in summer of 1276 was counted among papabili.

Bibliography

Richard Stapper, Papst Johannes XXI, Kirchengeschichtliche Studien, Münster 1898.
Konrad Eubel, Hierarchia Catholica Medii Aevi, vol. I, edition altera, Münster 1913.

[miranda-1] Miranda, Salvador. "Papal elections and conclaves of the 13th Century (1216-1294): Election of August 19 - September 8, 1276 (John XXI)". The Cardinals of the Holy Roman Church. Florida International University. OCLC 53276621.

[2] Stapper, p. 33

[3] Stapper, pp. 33-34; cfr. Miranda, Salvator. 1998. "Election of August 19 - September 8, 1276: (John XXI)." (note 1)

[4] It is not possible to ascertain whether Cardinal Annibaldi participated or not in the election. Eubel and Stapper do not count him, indicating that he had died earlier in that year. But the necrology of the church S. Spirito in Sassia in Rome registered his death under October 4, see Necrologi e libri affini della Provincia Romana, ed. Pietro Egidi (Roma : Forzani e c., tipografi del Senato, 1908–1914), I, p. 152.

[5] Stapper, p. 35-36

[6] Cfr. Stapper, p. 36-37; Dr. J.P. Adams Sede Vacante 1276

[7] Eubel, p. 9; Stapper, p. 37

[8] The story seems to be mentioned for the first time by 17th-century chronicler of the Order of Friars Minor Luke Wadding; it was later included by P. Campi in his Historia ecclesiastica di Piacenza (1659), then by Augustino Oldoini in 1677 edition of the work of Alphonsus Ciacconius Vitæ et res gestæ Pontificum Romanorum et S.R.E. Cardinalium, and later also by other authors; cfr. Dr J. P. Adams Sede Vacante 1276; and Stapper, p. 34 note 1.

[9] F. Burkle-Young is an author of the notes to the papal elections and conclaves on the cardinals' site

[10] Stapper, p. 34

[11] "SEDE VACANTE". www.csun.edu. Retrieved 2020-02-13.

[12] Stapper, p. 33 note 5.

[13] Stapper, p. 34 and p. 35-36 note 3; cfr. Eubel, p. 9 note 3 and p. 38.

[14] Cfr. the bulls published in Monumenta Boica, vol. 12, p. 138, and vol. 17 pp. 23-24.

[15] According to J.P. Adams Sede Vacante 1276 this story is "undoubtedely a pious fiction". Similar conclusion also by Stapper, p. 34.

[16] According to R.Sternfeld, Der Kardinal Johann Gaetan Orsini (Papst Nikolaus III.) 1244-1277, Berlin 1905, p. 252, Cardinal Vicedomino in summer of 1276 was counted among papabili.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]

v t e Papal elections and conclaves
Papal selection before 1059 Papal conclave (1274–1276, 1294–present)
Elections and conclaves	1061 1073 1086 1088 1099 1118 1119 1124 1130 1143 1144 1145 1153 1154 1159 1181 1185 October 1187 December 1187 1191 1198 1216 1227 1241 1243 1254 1261 1264–1265 1268–1271 January 1276 July 1276 September 1276 1277 1280–1281 1285 1287–1288 1292–1294 1294 1303 1304–1305 1314–1316 1334 1342 1352 1362 1370 1378 1389 1404 1406 1417 1431 1447 1455 1458 1464 1471 1484 1492 September 1503 electors October 1503 electors 1513 1521–1522 1523 1534 1549–1550 April 1555 May 1555 1559 1565–1566 1572 1585 September 1590 October–December 1590 1591 1592 March–April 1605 electors May 1605 electors 1621 1623 1644 1655 1667 1669–1670 1676 1689 1691 1700 1721 1724 1730 1740 1758 1769 1774–1775 1799–1800 1823 1829 1830–1831 1846 1878 1903 1914 electors 1922 electors 1939 electors 1958 electors 1963 electors August 1978 electors October 1978 electors 2005 electors 2013 electors
Governing documents (selected)	Ubi periculum (1274) Aeterni Patris Filius (1621) Cum proxime (1922) Ingravescentem aetatem (1970) Romano Pontifici eligendo (1975) Universi Dominici gregis (1996) De aliquis mutationibus in normis de electione Romani Pontificis (2007) Normas nonnullas (2013)
Category