Jump to content

Sacrifice zone

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
A sacrifice zone where Iron hydroxide precipitate from coal mining has damaged a stream and surrounding area
A sacrifice zone where Iron hydroxide precipitate from coal mining has damaged a stream and surrounding area

A sacrifice zone or sacrifice area (often termed a national sacrifice zone or national sacrifice area) is a geographic area that has been permanently changed by heavy environmental alterations (often to a negative degree) or economic disinvestment, often through locally unwanted land use (LULU). Commentators including Chris Hedges, Joe Sacco, and Steve Lerner have argued that corporate business practices contribute to producing sacrifice zones.[1][2][3] A 2022 report by the United Nations highlighted that millions of people globally are in pollution sacrifice zones, particularly in zones used for heavy industry and mining.[4]

Definition

[edit]

A sacrifice zone or sacrifice area is a geographic area that has been permanently impaired by environmental damage or economic disinvestment.[5]

Another definition states that sacrifice zones are places damaged through locally unwanted land use causing "chemical pollution where residents live immediately adjacent to heavily polluted industries or military bases."[1]

For Ryan Juskus[6] sacrifice zones are "geographical areas that bore a disproportionate amount of industrial pollution, toxic chemical exposure, or other environmental harms associated with industry or national security" (p.11). Another important aspect of this definition is that the existence of Sacrifice Zones involves the presence of Abundance Zones.  In other words, the disproportionate environmental damage that some communities receive is directly related to maintaining privileges and lifestyles in other geographies. Another important aspect of sacrifice zones is that they are often located in low-income communities with a large presence of ethnic or religious minorities which benefits majority groups. [7]

Origin of the concept

[edit]

The concept of Sacrifice Zone has its origins in the field of livestock management, being used to refer to the spaces where farmers concentrated cattle waste in order to protect the remaining pasture land.[6] However, the concept would be appropriated by the American Indian Movement and some environmentalist struggles transforming it from a technical term used for land and animal management to a way of conceiving geographical spaces in which the destruction of natural resources is a problem.[6]

According to Helen Huntington Smith,[8] the term was first used in the U.S. discussing the long-term effects of strip-mining coal in the American West in the 1970s. The National Academy of Sciences/National Academy of Engineering Study Committee on the Potential for Rehabilitating Lands Surface Mined for Coal in the Western United States produced a 1973 report that introduced the term, finding:

In each zone the probability of rehabilitating an area depends upon the land use objectives, the characteristics of the site, the technology available, and the skill with which this technology is applied. At the extremes, if surface mined lands are declared national sacrifice areas, all ecological zones have a high probability of being successfully rehabilitated. If, however, complete restoration is the objective, rehabilitation in each zone has no probability of success.[9]

Similarly in 1975, Genevieve Atwood wrote in Scientific American:

Surface mining without reclamation removes the land forever from productive use; such land can best be classified as a national sacrifice area. With successful reclamation, however, surface mining can become just one of a series of land uses that merely interrupt a current use and then return the land to an equivalent potential productivity or an even higher one.[10]

Huntington Smith wrote in 1975, "The Panel that issued the cautious and scholarly National Academy of Sciences report unwittingly touched off a verbal bombshell" with the phrase National Sacrifice Area; "The words exploded in the Western press overnight. Seized upon by a people who felt themselves being served up as 'national sacrifices,' they became a watchword and a rallying cry."[8] The term sparked public debate, including among environmentalists and politicians such as future Colorado governor Richard Lamm.[11][12]

The term continued to be used in the context of strip mining until at least 1999: "West Virginia has become an environmental sacrifice zone".[13]

Cases

[edit]

Argentina

Further information: Flammable: Environmental Suffering in an Argentine Shantytown

Villa Inflamable neighborhood is located in the city of Dock Sud and is part of the Greater Buenos Aires Metropolitan Area.  The community is situated at the center of a petrochemical development area, where 44 hydrocarbon companies are currently operating. These same companies are mainly responsible for turning the Riachuelo-Matanza basin into one of the most polluted bodies of water in the world.[14]

Reports from Argentinian and foreign public agencies[15][16] have confirmed the presence of lead, chromium, benzene and other hazardous chemicals in the water supplies of the neighborhood, in amounts far in excess of what is allowed by international regulations. Journalistic[17] and academic research[16] has collected multiple testimonies of serious health diagnoses commonly associated with the presence of these contaminants.   Likewise the book Flammable: Environmental Suffering in an Argentine Shantytown explores the effects of toxicity in the daily lives of the residents of the Inflammable neighborhood, referring to multiple diagnoses of lead poisoning among the inhabitants of Inflammable, especially among children.[14]

Chile

[edit]
Further information: Pollution in Quintero and Puchuncaví

The Chilean port of Quintero and adjacent Puchuncaví have been pointed out as a sacrifice zone.[18] The zone hosts the coal-fired Ventanas Power Plant, an oil refinery, a cement storage, Fundición Ventanas, a copper foundry and refinery, a lubricant factory and a chemical terminal.[18] In total 15 polluting companies operate in the area.[19] In 2011, Escuela La Greda located in Puchuncaví, was engulfed in a chemical cloud from the Ventanas Industrial Complex. The sulfur cloud poisoned an estimated 33 children and 9 teachers, resulting in the relocation of the school. The old location of the school is now abandoned.[20] In August and September 2018 there was a public health crisis in Quintero and Puchuncaví, where over 300 people experienced illness from toxic substances in the air, coming from the polluting industries.[21]

Mexico

[edit]

The Endhó Dam, often referred to as the "largest septic tank in Latin America"[22][23] is a heavily polluted body of water that was built in the 1950s to supply irrigation water to the Mezquital Valley region of the State of Hidalgo and today receives about 70% of Mexico City's sewage effluent.[24] The river that feeds the dam is also a major repository for industrial waste from an oil refinery, two large cement factories, and several industrial parks in the region.  These sources of pollution have spread to nearby springs affecting people, animals and crops.[25] Journalist Carlos Carabaña[26] indicates that since 2007, the National Water Commission has issued reports to municipal and state authorities repeatedly informing them of the presence of high levels of heavy metals in the nearby wells, urging the authorities to take action because of the potential health risks posed by the dam. Other effects related to contamination from the dam include damage to crops in the communities neighboring the dam, poisoning of livestock, and stigmatization of agricultural products from the Mezquital Valley region.[22]

United States

[edit]
See also: Superfund

The US EPA affirmed in a 2004 report in response to the Office of Inspector General, that "the solution to unequal protection lies in the realm of environmental justice for all Americans. No community, rich or poor, black or white, should be allowed to become a 'sacrifice zone'."[27]: 28 

Commentators including Chris Hedges,[2] Joe Sacco, Robert Bullard[1] and Stephen Lerner have argued that corporate business practices contribute to producing sacrifice zones and that these zones most commonly exist in low-income and minority, usually African-American communities.[28] Sacrifice zones are a central topic for the graphic novel Days of Destruction, Days of Revolt, written by Hedges and illustrated by Sacco.[3]

In 2012, Hedges stated that examples of sacrifice zones included Pine Ridge, South Dakota and Camden, New Jersey[2] In 2017 a West Calumet public housing project in East Chicago, Indiana built at the former site of a lead smelter needed to be demolished and soil replaced to bring the area up to residential standards, displacing 1000 residents.[29] In 2014, Naomi Klein wrote that "running an economy on energy sources that release poisons as an unavoidable part of their extraction and refining has always required sacrifice zones."[30]

Venezuela

[edit]
Pollution at Maracaibo Lake

Lake Maracaibo in the state of Zulia is one of the most important bodies of water in the western region of Venezuela.  This lake was also the site of one of the worst environmental catastrophes in Venezuela's history: the Barroso II blowout in 1922; an oil well that began spewing huge quantities of oil for 9 days, spilling around 900,000 barrels in the area.[31] This oil disaster, paradoxically, became a milestone for the abundance of the oil industry in the country.

Erick Camargo indicates that oil spills generated by the lack of maintenance of the complex network of oil infrastructure continue to be a constant and are the main cause of contamination in the lake. However, he also indicates that the use of agrochemicals on nearby crops and the discharge of sewage worsen the situation.[32]

A 2022 scientific paper reveals the presence of multiple toxic elements in surface sediments in different parts of the lake.  This constitutes a high risk for the flora and fauna of the region, as well as for the health of the human communities living in the areas where the samples were taken.[33] Another study in 2007 revealed the presence of toxic metals in part of the subway aquifers connected to the lake basin; the samples taken had values well above the limits allowed for drinking water according to national and international regulations.[34]

Space industry

[edit]
Point Nemo is also known as “the oceanic pole of inaccessibility” for being the point in any ocean farthest from land. It serves as a "spacecraft cemetery" for space infrastructure and vessels.

The human-environment interactions that lie at the heart of environmental justice, including sacrifice zones, have been proposed to also include the environmental sacrifice of regions beyond Earth.[35] Klinger states that "the environmental geopolitics of Earth and outer space are inextricably linked by the spatial politics of privilege and sacrifice - among people, places and institutions".[35] Dunnett has called outer space the 'ultimate sacrifice zone' that exemplifies a colonially framed pursuit of infinite opportunities for accumulation, exploitation, and pollution. This manifests in both terrestrial and space-based sacrifice zones related to launch infrastructure, waste, and orbital debris.[36]

Point Nemo is an oceanic point of inaccessibility located inside the South Pacific Gyre. It is selected as the most remote location in the world and serves as a "spacecraft cemetery" for space infrastructure and vessels.[37] Since 1971, 273 spacecraft and satellites have been directed to Point Nemo; this number includes the Mir Space Station (142 tonnes) and will include the International Space Station (240 tonnes).

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c Bullard, Robert D. (June 2011). "Sacrifice Zones: The Front Lines of Toxic Chemical Exposure in the United States by Steve Lerner . Cambridge, MA:MIT Press, 2010. 346 pp., $29.95 ISBN: 978-0-262-01440-3". Environmental Health Perspectives. 119 (6): A266. doi:10.1289/ehp.119-a266. ISSN 0091-6765. PMC 3114843.
  2. ^ a b c Kane, Muriel (2012-07-20). "Chris Hedges: America's devastated 'sacrifice zones' are the future for all of us". www.rawstory.com. Retrieved 2019-09-16.
  3. ^ a b Neal Conan (2 August 2012). "Drive For Profit Wreaks 'Days Of Destruction'". NPR.org.
  4. ^ "Millions suffering in deadly pollution 'sacrifice zones', warns UN expert". the Guardian. 2022-03-10. Retrieved 2022-03-12.
  5. ^ "How are hazards / risks distributed among different groups?". Disaster STS Network. Retrieved 6 October 2021.
  6. ^ a b c Juskus, Ryan (March 2023). "Sacrifice Zones". Environmental Humanities. 15 (1): 3–24. doi:10.1215/22011919-10216129.
  7. ^ Lerner, S. (2012). Sacrifice zones: the front lines of toxic chemical exposure in the United States. Mit Press.
  8. ^ a b Huntington Smith, Helena (1975-02-16). "The Wringing of the West". The Washington Post. Washington, DC. p. 1–B4. ISSN 0190-8286. ProQuest 146405625.
  9. ^ National Research Council (U. S.) Study Committee on the Potential for Rehabilitating Lands Surface Mined for Coal in the Western United States (1974). Rehabilitation potential of western coal lands. Cambridge, MA: Ford Foundation Energy Policy Project / Ballinger Pub. Co. pp. 85–86. ISBN 978-0-88410-331-8.
  10. ^ Atwood, Genevieve (December 1975). "The Strip-Mining of Western Coal". Scientific American. 233 (6): 23–29. Bibcode:1975SciAm.233f..23A. doi:10.1038/scientificamerican1275-23.
  11. ^ "Lamm explained his view that Colorado must begin to control its own future, rather than succumbing to Washington's plea that the state should be "a national sacrifice area" to provide for the nation's energy needs." Griffith, Winthrop (1974-10-27). "An eco-freak for governor?". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2017-05-10.
  12. ^ Sterba, James P. (1974-09-26). "Worry Rises That Rockies Face Pollution and Crowds". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2017-05-10.
  13. ^ Fox, Julia (June 1999). "Mountaintop Removal in West Virginia". Organization & Environment. 12 (2): 163–183. doi:10.1177/1086026699122002. S2CID 110253546.
  14. ^ a b Auyero, J., & Swistun, D. A. (2009). Flammable: Environmental suffering in an Argentine shantytown. Oxford University Press.
  15. ^ United States Trade and Development Program (1997) Dock Sud Environmental Remediation and Pollution Abatement Project. Final Report. Volume 1. Executive Summary. https://ntrl.ntis.gov/NTRL/dashboard/searchResults/titleDetail/PB97160212.xhtml
  16. ^ a b Mozobancyk, Schelica; Pérez Sobrero, Javier A. (June 2016). "Percepción de la contaminación ambiental y los riesgos para la salud en la comunidad de 'Villa inflamable'". Anuario de Investigaciones. 23 (1): 207–216.
  17. ^ "Plagados de problemas de salud, vecinos de un río contaminado en Argentina tienen pocas alternativas". Global Press Journal. 2016-04-09. Retrieved 2024-03-27.
  18. ^ a b "¿Qué son las zonas de sacrificio de Chile?". El Diario (in Spanish). 2019-12-05. Retrieved 2022-12-09.
  19. ^ "Quintero y Puchuncaví: La zona de sacrificio". La Tercera (in Spanish). 25 August 2018.
  20. ^ "La olvidada escuela la Greda". 7 April 2019.
  21. ^ "Chile: Supreme Court Hears Massive Air Pollution Case". 11 April 2019.
  22. ^ a b Lopez Gomez, Paulina (July 4, 2022). "La fosa séptica más grande de América Latina está en México".
  23. ^ Fuente, Luis (July 3, 2022). "Esta es la fosa séptica más grande de Latinoamérica y está en Hidalgo".
  24. ^ Prieto-García, F.; Constantino, C. A. Lucho; Valardo, H. Poggi; Suárez, M. Alvarez; Esteban, E. Barrado (2007). "Caracterización fisicoquímica y extracción secuencial de metales y elementos trazas en suelos de la región Actopan-Ixmiquilpan del distrito de riego 03, Valle de Mezquital, Hidalgo, México". CIENCIA ergo-sum, Revista Científica Multidisciplinaria de Prospectiva. 14 (1): 69–80.
  25. ^ Muñoz E. A. (January 22, 2014) Presa Endhó, la región más contaminada. https://agua.org.mx/presa-endho-la-region-mas-contaminada/
  26. ^ Carabaña, C. (February 13, 2023) Los olvidados de Hidalgo. Cáncer, contaminación y aguas negras. N+ Focus. https://investigaciones.nmas.com.mx/los-olvidados-de-hidalgo/
  27. ^ US EPA (7 June 2004). "Agency Response to Recommendations Provided in the OIGEvaluation Report entitled, "EPA Needs to Consistently Implement the Intent of the Executive Order on Environmental Justice"" (PDF).
  28. ^ Jessica Roake. "Think Globally, Act Locally: Steve Lerner, 'Sacrifice Zones,' at Politics and Prose". Washington Post. Retrieved 2019-09-16.
  29. ^ Bamberger, Kaela (2017-07-11). "Not Your Sacrifice Zone: In Lead-Poisoned East Chicago, Residents Fight for Their Health and Homes". In These Times. ISSN 0160-5992. Retrieved 2019-09-16.
  30. ^ "From Rethinking Schools: Sacrifice Zones". Rethinking Schools Publishers. 2016. Retrieved 2019-09-16.
  31. ^ Clima, & Clima. (2022, 15 diciembre). 100 años de destrucción del Lago de Maracaibo. Desde la zona de sacrificio hasta al amor al lago | Clima21. Clima21 | Observatorio de Derechos Humanos Ambientales. https://clima21.net/noticias/100-anos-de-destruccion-del-lago-de-maracaibo-desde-la-zona-de-sacrificio-hasta-al-amor-al-lago/
  32. ^ Camargo, E. (2023, 21 marzo). El Lago de Maracaibo: un largo historial de contaminación. Observatorio de Ecología Política de Venezuela. https://ecopoliticavenezuela.org/2023/03/21/el-lago-de-maracaibo-un-largo-historial-de-contaminacion
  33. ^ Marín, Julio; Colina, Marinela; Ledo, Hilda; Gardiner, P.H.E. (20 August 2021). "Ecological risk by potentially toxic elements in surface sediments of the Lake Maracaibo (Venezuela)". Environmental Engineering Research. 27 (4): 210232–0. doi:10.4491/eer.2021.232.
  34. ^ Mesa, Johan; Bravo, Alfonso; Morales, José; Sánchez, Ligbel; Valle, Paola; Gutiérrez, Elizabeth (November 2007). "Contenido de metales trazas en aguas subterraneas de la region occidental del Lago de Maracaibo, Venezuela" [Content of trace metals in groundwater from western region of Maracaibo Lake, Venezuela]. Revista Tecnica (in Spanish). 30: 20–29. Gale A193835293.
  35. ^ a b Klinger, Julie Michelle (2021). "Environmental geopolitics and outer space" (PDF). Geopolitics. 26 (3): 666–703. doi:10.1080/14650045.2019.1590340. S2CID 150443847.
  36. ^ Dunnett, Oliver; Klinger, Julie; Maclaren, Andrew; Lane, Maria; Sage, Daniel (2019). "Geographies of Outer Space: Progress and New Opportunities". Progress in Human Geography. 43 (2): 314–366. doi:10.1177/0309132517747727. hdl:2164/11959. S2CID 149382358.
  37. ^ Fernandes, Joao (2021). "8 facts about Point Nemo". History of Yesterday. Retrieved 16 March 2022.

Further reading

[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Sacrifice_zone&oldid=1254261387"