Jump to content

S. S. Setlur

Add links
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Justice
S. S. Setlur
Setlur Śrinivāsiyengar
Image of Justice S. S. Setlur from 1909
Born(1862-07-21)21 July 1862
Died10 January 1930(1930-01-10) (aged 67)
Bangalore
EducationB.A. (1887), LL.B. (1891)
Alma mater Presidency College, Madras; Bombay University
Occupation(s)Lawyer and judge
Known forFirst president of Congress party in Mysore state (1921); association with Bal Gangadhar Tilak; works on Hindu inheritance law
WorksA Full and Authentic Report of the Trial of The Hon'ble Mr. Bal Gangadhar Tilak (1897); A Complete Collection of Hindu Law Books on Inheritance (1911); The Mitākshara, with Visvarūpa and Commentaries of Subodhini and Bālambhatti (1912)
MovementIndian independence movement
FatherSetlur Singiengar (Shingaiengar)
RelativesSargur Srihari (great grandson)

S. Srinivasiyengar Setlur (21 July 1862 – 10 January 1930), widely known as S. S. Setlur, was an Indian lawyer, judge, journalist, and freedom fighter. As a lawyer in Bombay (now Mumbai), Setlur was a close associate of Bal Gangadhar Tilak and served as the Bombay correspondent for The Hindu. He was later a justice of the Chief Court of Mysore (now the Karnataka High Court) and went on to found the Congress party in Mysore state, serving as its first president.

Setlur was also an expert on Hindu inheritance laws, preparing both a landmark compilation of ancient texts and a translation of the Mitākshara, an important text on inheritance, that are still in use today.

Background and education

[edit]

Setlur was a member of the Sri Vaishnava Brahmin community. His family came to princely Mysore and settled at Seringapatam (modern Srirangapatna) in the 18th century.[1] His father was Setlur Singiengar, who provided "highly approved services" to the British administration in various parts of the Madras Presidency before joining the Mysore government as the Marhamat (or Maramuth) Bakshi (Chief Engineer) of the state. Singiengar retired as Anche Bukshi or Postmaster-General in 1867, and his "extensive cosmpolitan charities" in Tirupati, North Arcot, and several parts of Mysore State had "rendered his name a household word in Mysore."[1][2]

Setlur studied at the Presidency College in Madras (now Chennai), graduating with a degree in arts (B.A.) in January 1887.[1] After taking a course in the B.Sc. class in the Science College, Poona, he eventually obtained his law degree (LL.B.) from Bombay University in 1890.[1][3]: 215  While studying law, in December 1889 he won Judge Spencer's prize and the Arnould Scholarship by placing first in the Presidency and first in Hindu law.[1][4][3]: 384, 439–40 

Career in Bombay

[edit]

Setlur spent a good portion of his life in Bombay (now Mumbai) and was a leading lawyer there.[5] In 1892, he was enrolled as an advocate in the Bombay and Madras High Courts.[1] He was a law professor for four years (1903-07) at the Government Law School where he lectured on Hindu law,[1][6][7] an examiner for High Court examinations, and an examiner in Kanarese (Kannada) for Bombay University where he was a fellow.[1][8][9] He was also active in local civic life, being a member of the Royal Asiatic Society,[1] serving as an honorary secretary of the local chess tournament,[10] judging an elocution contest (in Marathi),[11] and even signing a letter of protest against the resumption of animal sacrifices for the Dasara festival in Porbandar.[12] His friends and associates included N. C. Kelkar and Pherozeshah Mehta.[13]

Setlur was also an active journalist and writer. He was the Bombay correspondent for The Hindu (based in Madras) and edited English language columns for the Indu Prakash, an Anglo-Marathi journal published in Bombay.[2][1] He also sent letters to other publications.[14] He was a delegate to the seventh Bombay Provincial Conference held in November 1894,[15] and was later a delegate to the eleventh conference in 1901.[16]

Trial of Bal Gangadhar Tilak

[edit]

In September 1897, Bal Gangadhar Tilak was tried for sedition in the Bombay High Court. Setlur took an active interest in Tilak's defense,[17] and later published a complete report of the trial with a lengthy introduction that included some of his personal observations.[18]: vii–xvii  In Setlur's view, the prosecution of Tilak resulted from "panic among the European community" caused by the recent killings of two British officers in Poona by the Chapekar brothers; Setlur himself would later defend Balkrishna Hari Chapekar in his murder trial two years later.[19][20][18]: xi  The Tilak trial report was priced at 10 annas,[21] a low price intended to make it widely available to the Indian public, with profits designated for Tilak's defense fund.[18]: vi 

A London newspaper, the St. James's Gazette, was critical of Setlur's report, calling it "mischief which is allowed to run riot under the name of freedom of the Press." The Gazette added that "while purporting to be a 'report' of the trial, it is mainly a glorification of Tilak, and holds up the judgment of the court which tried him to native ridicule and contempt."[21] The Pioneer of Allahabad was also critical of Setlur, finding that he had committed "a great many popular errors" and concluding that the trial result was the product of "independent mature deliberation" about which "no one has any right to complain."[22][23]

While Setlur noted that he "did not know Mr. Tilak personally before the trial,"[18]: xvii  he would ultimately become a staunch follower of Tilak.[5] After the trial, Setlur served as one of his legal advisors and when Tilak quickly lost weight in prison, Setlur wrote to the Howard Association in London, eventually leading to some improvement in Tilak's conditions.[24]: 64  In 1915, a dying Gopal Krishna Gokhale, who had his differences with Tilak, would ask Setlur to seek a compromise with Tilak to achieve Congress party unity.[24]: 166–67 

Hindu inheritance law

[edit]

Setlur was a leading scholar of Hindu law relating to inheritances and contributed to the law journal of the Bombay Presidency.[1] In 1907, a response by Setlur to an article on the origin of the Bengal School of Hindu law was published by the Law Quarterly Review, one of London's leading law journals.[25][1] Setlur argued that the reason Bengal's inheritance laws differed from the Mitākshara school of the other Indian provinces was due to different historical circumstances, rather than different interpretations of the same original ancient Hindu texts.[citation needed]

In 1911, Setlur's A Complete Collection of Hindu Law Books on Inheritance was published. The treatise includes a nearly 30-page introduction by Setlur followed by English translations and analysis of all important texts recognized as authorities in different schools of Hindu law.[26] A review in the Madras Weekly Notes observed that this was the first volume to present most of the seventeen included texts in accurate English translations, and that it would enable lawyers to compare what different writers had to say on a given point.[27] Setlur's treatise was widely influential and was cited by the Supreme Court of India as recently as 1980.[28]

Setlur had a "keen interest in the advancement of Sanskrit knowledge" and was himself "a Sanskrit scholar of ability."[1] In 1912, he edited a comprehensive edition of the Mitākshara and related texts and commentaries in both Sanskrit and English.[29] Setlur's edition of the Mitākshara has had significant influence in the field to the present day.

Chief Court justice and freedom fighter

[edit]

Setlur eventually left Bombay for Bangalore. He became an acquaintance of Swami Vivekananda and shared his reflections in a letter to the Madras Mail upon the latter's passing in 1902.[30][31]

In 1908, the Dewan of Mysore, Sir V. P. Madhava Rao, appointed Setlur as one of three justices of the Mysore Chief Court,[5] and the appointment was "met with general satisfaction in the Province."[32] Upon taking his seat on 24 July 1908, Setlur expressed appreciation to the Mysore Bar, observing that "[m]ost of your members have been well known to me from my boyhood, and I am glad I have come back to my people...."[33] While the appointment was temporary to relieve a justice who had gone on leave,[34] he was reappointed for one year in November as the fourth judge.[35] Later, the British Resident in Mysore, Sir Stuart Fraser, objected to the appointment due to Setlur's links with Tilak, eventually leading Setlur to resign his judgeship.[5][36][37][38] Setlur would later visit London in 1915, leaving for his return journey to Bombay on 13 November on the P&O ship RMS Arabia.[39][40]

From 1914 to 1923, Setlur was a regular columnist for Annie Besant's newspaper, New India.[41] In February 1916, he attended Mahatma Gandhi's first public speech in India, on the occasion of laying the foundation stone for the Banares Hindu University. Gandhi did not finish the speech after being interrupted by Besant, who claimed she was protecting him from the authorities. In a letter to The Hindu, Setlur said that while Gandhi was not encouraging anarchists, he was instead "playing the role of an apologist for the Civilian Bureaucrat." Setlur went on to criticize much of the speech's substance and Gandhi's delivery.[42]: 21–22  In a public response to Besant, Gandhi called Setlur's criticism "in some respects totally unfair" and that Setlur had "endeavoured to tear me to pieces."[42]: 19  As part of a further reply to Gandhi, Besant herself re-published Setlur's letter.[42]: 20–21 

Setlur would go on to found the Congress party in princely Mysore in 1921 and serve as its first president.[5][43] When three freedom fighters were killed while picketing in Dharwad on 1 July 1921, Setlur served on a three-member inquiry committee appointed by the All India Congress Committee.[44][45]: 102  In February 1922, he and other Congress leaders were served with notices under Section 144 of the Criminal Procedure Code relating to unlawful assembly.[46] In December 2022, he called for an end to Congress' state-level work and resigned as the Mysore Congress Committee president, but his suggestions were not accepted by the committee.[47]

Setlur continued writing in his later years. In December 1923, the Bombay Chronicle published a lengthy essay in which he critiqued the new constitution of Mysore.[48] In 1927, Setlur led a group known as the "Sanatan Nationalists" with Hindu nationalist views.[49]

Setlur resided in the Siddikatte area of Bangalore (present day Gundopanth Street)[5] while continuing to own land elsewhere.[50] He died at his residence in Siddikatte on the morning of 10 January 1930 (possibly 9 January) after a five-month battle with stomach cancer, and was survived by his wife, six sons and three daughters.[51][52] A street in Bangalore's Richmond Town neighborhood may have been named after him or an ancestor.[43]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m The Cyclopedia of India, Vol. III. Calcutta: The Cyclopedia Publishing Coy. 1909. p. 276. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  2. ^ a b Rao, C. Hayavadana, ed. (1915). The Indian Biographical Dictionary. Madras: Pillar & Co. p. 389. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  3. ^ a b Bombay University Calendar for the Year 1902-1903. Bombay. 1902. Retrieved 8 June 2024.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  4. ^ "Bombay University Examination". Times of India. 6 December 1889. p. 4. Retrieved 9 June 2024. "The Arnold Scholarship and Judge Spencer Prize have been awarded to S. Shrinivasiengar Setlur."
  5. ^ a b c d e f Jayaram, A. (18 March 2001). "Giants from Karnataka who shaped the course of history". Bangalore: The Hindu. p. 5.
  6. ^ "Bombay "Government Gazette"". The Times of India. No. 283. Bombay. 27 November 1903. p. 6. Retrieved 20 June 2024. (noting appointment as Professor of Law in the Government Law School)
  7. ^ "The Bombay Services". The Bombay Gazette. No. 54271. 29 November 1907. p. 7. Retrieved 20 June 2024. (noting expiration of term as law professor)
  8. ^ "Election of Five Fellows of the University of Bombay". The Times of India. No. 205. Bombay. 27 August 1904. p. 5. Retrieved 20 June 2024.
  9. ^ "Bombay "Government Gazette"". The Times of India. No. 172. Bombay. 21 July 1905. p. 6. Retrieved 20 June 2024. (noting appointment as member of the Civil and Military Examination Committee for examining candidates in Kanarese)
  10. ^ "Untitled article". Indian Daily News. 25 May 1899. p. 14. Retrieved 2 June 2024. The article describes remarks Setlur delivered on the occasion of prizes being awarded in the chess tournament.
  11. ^ "The National Indian Association: An Elocution Gathering". Madras Weekly Mail. 18 January 1906. p. 75. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  12. ^ "Revival of Animal Sacrifice at Porbander". Homeward Mail from India, China, and the East. 27 October 1902. pp. 11–12. Retrieved 2 June 2024. The article notes that Setlur signed a petition to the ruler of Porbander appealing for the practice to stop.
  13. ^ Kelkar, N. C. (5 August 1945). "Pherozeshah Mehta As I Knew Him: The Last of the Political Barons". The Bombay Chronicle (Sunday / Weekly Edition). p. 9. Retrieved 19 June 2024. "The first time I talked with [Pherozeshah Mehta] was in 1899. It was in his well-known chamber, where I attended at his command, and was introduced to him ... by my friend, the late S. S. Setlur, then an Advocate in the Bombay High Court."
  14. ^ "Untitled article". The Indian Spectator. No. 7. Bombay. 18 February 1905. p. 148. Retrieved 2 June 2024. As the subject of sending young men to Europe, America, and Japan for technical training is receiving much attention both in British India and in Native States, Mr. S. S. Setlur draws our attention to an interview which Sister Nivedita had with Dr. Hanford Henderson of America when he was last year at Calcutta.
  15. ^ Report of Seventh Provincial Conference, Held at Bombay, on 2nd, 3rd, and 4th November 1894. Bombay: Printed at the "Times of India" Steam Press. 1895. pp. 100–101. Available online through the Asiatic Society of Mumbai's Granth Sanjeevani project. Setlur spoke in favor of a resolution setting the next conference location: "Being myself a Kanarese man, though not a citizen of Belgaum, I have a right to ask you to honour the Kanarese Districts by accepting this proposition, and on behalf of the people of the Karnataka country, I assure you, gentlemen, that you will have a right hearty welcome in Belgaum."
  16. ^ Report of the Eleventh Provincial Conference held at Bombay, on 14th & 15th September 1901. Bombay: Printed at the "Commercial Press". 1901. p. 103. Available online through the Asiatic Society of Mumbai's Granth Sanjeevani project.
  17. ^ Keer, Dhananjay (1959). Lokmanya Tilak: Father of Our Freedom Struggle. Bombay. pp. 131, 144–45. Retrieved 4 June 2024.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)
  18. ^ a b c d Setlur, S. S.; Deshpande, K. G., eds. (1897). A Full and Authentic Report of the Trial of The Hon'ble Mr. Bal Gangadhar Tilak. Bombay: Education Society's Press, Byculla. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  19. ^ "The Jubilee Murders: Yesterday's Proceedings". The Bombay Gazette. No. 51559. 8 March 1899. p. 5. Retrieved 19 June 2024. (noting Setlur's appearance for the defense and cross-examination of witnesses)
  20. ^ "The Jubilee Murders. The Verdict. The Three Accused Found Guilty". The Bombay Gazette. No. 51560. 9 March 1899. p. 5. Retrieved 20 June 2024. (noting Setlur's closing argument of nearly two hours)
  21. ^ a b "Notes". St. James's Gazette. London. 11 November 1897. p. 3. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  22. ^ "Untitled article". The Pioneer. No. 11433. Allahabad. 13 November 1897. p. 1. Retrieved 19 June 2024.
  23. ^ "The Tilak Case". Madras Weekly Mail. 18 November 1897. p. 460. Retrieved 2 June 2024. (reprinting 13 Nov. 1897 article from The Pioneer)
  24. ^ a b Jog, N. G. (1962). Builders of Modern India: Lokmanya Bal Gangadhar Tilak (PDF). Publications Division, Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, Government of India. Retrieved 3 June 2024.
  25. ^ Setlur, S. S. (April 1907). "Origin and Development of the Bengal School of Hindu Law". Law Quarterly Review. 23 (2). London: 202–219. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  26. ^ Setlur, S. S. (1911). A Complete Collection of Hindu Law Books on Inheritance. Madras: V. Kalyanaram Iyer & Co. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  27. ^ "Hindu Law Books on Inheritance: A Translation" (PDF). Madras Weekly Notes: 11. 20 August 1911. Retrieved 2 June 2024. See also "Hindu Law Books on Inheritance". Calcutta Law Journal. XIV (11). Calcutta: 65. 1 December 1911. Retrieved 9 June 2024. The Calcutta law journal was more critical, saying that "[t]here is no indication given of the persons responsible for the translations. That they have not been made first-hand by the same person is manifest."
  28. ^ Shyam Sunder Prasad Singh & Ors. vs. State of Bihar & Ors., 1981 AIR 178 (22 July 1980), https://main.sci.gov.in/jonew/judis/4501.pdf
  29. ^ Setlur, S. S., ed. (1912). The Mitākshara, with Visvarūpa and Commentaries of Subodhini and Bālambhatti (Vol. 1) (in Sanskrit). Madras: Bramhavadin Press. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  30. ^ "The Late Swami Vivekananda". Madras Weekly Mail. 17 July 1902. p. 20. Retrieved 2 June 2024. The news article includes an excerpt of a letter from Setlur that describes Vivekananda's visits to Bangalore, Mysore, and Madras.
  31. ^ "A Svami's ideas". The Indian Spectator. Bombay. 18 February 1911. pp. 121–22. Retrieved 2 June 2024. Mr. Setlur mentioned that the Svami wished to found a ladies' Matha or Vihara at Poona, but he did not live to see the idea concretised.
  32. ^ "The Mysore Chief Court". Madras Weekly Mail. 23 July 1908. p. 89. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  33. ^ "The Chief Court". Madras Weekly Mail. 30 July 1908. p. 138. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  34. ^ "The Chief Court". Madras Weekly Mail. 30 July 1908. p. 117. Retrieved 2 June 2024. Mr. S. Setlur, the newly appointed acting Third Judge of the Mysore Chief Court ... took his seat on the Bench to-day, relieving Mr. Justice P.S. Krishna Rao, who proceeds on leave. There is every prospect of Mr. Setlur's appointment being made a permanent one before the end of the year, as certain changes among high officials of the service are impending.
  35. ^ "Official". Madras Weekly Mail. 26 November 1908. p. 575. Retrieved 2 June 2024. "Bangalore, 19th Nov. -- The Government of H. H. the Maharajah of Mysore have appointed Mr. S. Setlur to be a fourth Judge of the Mysore Chief Court for one year, with effect from the date of Mr. Justice Nanjundiah's return from leave.
  36. ^ "Judge Setlur Retires". The Bombay Gazette. No. 54861. 25 October 1909. p. 6. Retrieved 20 June 2024. ("Mr. S. S. Setlur ... intends retiring and starting practice at Madras.")
  37. ^ "The appointment of Mr. Setlur, B.A., LL.B., as a Puisne Judge of the Chief Court of Mysore". Selections from the native newspapers published in the United Provinces of Agra & Oudh (47): 881. 20 November 1909. Retrieved 10 June 2024. The online source is likely from the India Office Reports on native newspapers. It mentions three local news stories: 49. Advocate (Lucknow), 7 November 1909, referring to an article in The Hindu and suggesting that "this action was probably due to the fact that a letter written to one of the nationalist leaders in Calcutta fell into the hands of the police." 50. Musafir (Agra), 15 November 1909. 51. Leader (Allahabad), 18 November 1909.
  38. ^ "Comments on the alleged advice given by the Government of India to Mysore State against the appointment of Mr. Setlur as a Judge of the Chief Court". Report on Native Papers published in the Bombay Presidency (48): 32. 27 November 1909. Retrieved 10 June 2024. The report quotes the Phoenix, 20 November 1909, which in turn references The Hindu. The Phoenix article cites as reasons Setlur's editing of the Tilak trial transcript, and also "it is rumoured that the Bombay Political Department had in possession a letter written by Mr. Setlur to Mr. Tilak expressing sympathy with his propaganda."
  39. ^ "The London Indian Association". India. 12 November 1915. p. 215. Retrieved 2 June 2024. The London Indian Association was "At Home" ... to meet Dr. Jivraj N. Mehta on the eve of his departure for India. *** [A]mong those present were ... Mr. S. S. Setlur....
  40. ^ "Mail Passengers: Outward Bound". Civil & Military Gazette. Lahore. 8 December 1915. p. 11. Retrieved 2 June 2024. The article provides a list of passengers leaving London for Bombay on 13 November on the P&O ship Arabia that includes "Setlur, Mr. S S."
  41. ^ V Geetha; S V Rajadurai (15 July 1995). "One Hundred Years of Brahminitude: Arrival of Annie Besant". Economic and Political Weekly. 30 (28): 1769. Retrieved 10 June 2024.
  42. ^ a b c Phatak, N. R., ed. (1965). Source Material for a History of the Freedom Movement in India, Vol. 3 (Part I). Mumbai: Government of Maharashtra. Retrieved 4 June 2024.
  43. ^ a b Prasad, Srinivasa (9 February 2001). "Becker's girlfriend has roots in south India". Times of India. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  44. ^ Shrinidhi, R (14 August 2021). "Centenary of Dharwad's mini Jallianwala Bagh". Deccan Herald. Retrieved 9 June 2024.
  45. ^ The Indian National Congress: Being a collection of the resolutions of the Congress and of the All India Congress Committee and of the Working Committee of the Congress from September 1920 to December 1923. Allahabad: Allahabad Law Journal Press. 1924. Retrieved 10 June 2024.
  46. ^ "Notices Served on Agitators". Civil & Military Gazette. Lahore. 24 February 1922. p. 7. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  47. ^ "Congress Work in Indian States". Civil & Military Gazette. Lahore. 6 December 1922. p. 8. Retrieved 2 June 2024.
  48. ^ Setlur, S. S. (20 December 1923). "Mysore Reforms: The Constitutional Aspect". The Bombay Chronicle. p. 10. Retrieved 17 June 2024.
  49. ^ "Brahmins' Greetings". Civil & Military Gazette. Lahore. 19 December 1927. p. 11. Retrieved 2 June 2024. Mr. S. S. Setlur, leader of the 'Sanatan Nationalists' in a special telegram to the Afghan Consul, Bombay, extending a cordial welcome to His Majesty the King of Afghanistan says: 'Pray convey the heartiest greetings of the Brahmana Aryas of Southern India to His Majesty, Arya's Ruler of the most sacred Vedic North-Western Province of Gandhara, the ancient Hindu name for the geopgrahical unit of Afghanistan.
  50. ^ "The North Arcot District Conference". Madras Weekly Mail. 30 April 1908. p. 487. Retrieved 2 June 2024. Mr. S. S. Setlur, an Advocate of the Bombay High Court, who owns lands in the North Arcot District, [was] among those present.
  51. ^ "Mr. S. S. Setlur Dead". The Bombay Chronicle. 11 January 1930. p. 7. Retrieved 17 June 2024. "Bangalore, Jan. 10. Mr. S. S. Setlur ailing of cancer in the stomach for the last five months expired this morning at 6-35 in his family residence at Siddikata, Bangalore City." (italics added)
  52. ^ "Late Mr. Setlur". The Bombay Chronicle. 20 January 1930. p. 11. Retrieved 17 June 2024. "Bangalore, Jan. 10. It is with regret I have to report the death of the late Mr. S. S. Setlur, a prominent advocate yesterday at his residence. *** He leaves behind him, his young wife six sons and three daughters...." (italics added)
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=S._S._Setlur&oldid=1230634863"