Ross v Henderson

Ross v Henderson
Court	Privy Council
Full case name	Ewen Neil Ross v John Samuel Lester Henderson
Decided	15 November 1977
Citation	[1977] 2 NZLR 458
Transcript	Privy Council ruling
Court membership
Judges sitting	Lord Simon of Glaisdale, Lord Salmon, Lord Russell of Killowen, Lord Keith of Kinkel, Sir Garfield Barwick

Ross v Henderson [1977] 2 NZLR 458 is a cited case in New Zealand regarding illegal contracts that were later upheld that the Illegal Contracts Act 1970 had the power to validate (i.e. make legal) despite the fact that another legal enactment "deemed to be unlawful and shall have no effect".

Background

In 1971, Ross entered into an agreement to a 5-year lease his 345-acre dairy farm to Henderson, with an option to purchase the farm for $65,000.

As leases of 3 years or more are legally required to be registered with the Land Transfer Office, Henderson duly registered the lease, which included the option to purchase.

Unfortunately, the LTO standard declaration form, required under the law, was not designed for such a transaction, and later resulted in Henderson to of breached the law by not registering his purchase, making the sale illegal and of no effect.

In this background, in 1974 Ross's solicitor wrote to Henderson informing him that the sale of the farm had now come to an end.

Henderson filed in court for relief under the Illegal Contracts Act by having the sale agreement validated.

Held

The Privy Council ruled that as the law did not specifically rule out validation, then validation was possible, and given that the law was enacted to prevent undue aggregation of land, and that this was not an issue here, the court upheld the out of Appeals earlier decision to validate the sale agreement.

Footnote: This case is often cited along with the earlier Court of Appeal case of Harding v Coburn [1976] 2 NZLR 577.