Jump to content

Robert Whitney Imbrie

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Robert Whitney Imbrie
Robert Imbrie at Yale in 1906
Personal details
Born(1883-04-23)April 23, 1883
Washington, D.C.
DiedJuly 18, 1924(1924-07-18) (aged 41)
OccupationForeign service officer

Robert Whitney Imbrie (1883–1924) was the first United States Foreign Service officer to be killed. He was murdered in Tehran, Persia (now Iran) while serving on temporary assignment.[1][2]

Early years

[edit]

Imbrie was born in Washington, D.C., on April 23, 1883. He was the only surviving child of Jeremiah and Leila (Whitney) Imbrie. His mother died when he was seven; his father when he was thirteen. Imbrie then came under the care of his maternal aunt and her husband, Mary O. and Charles Fishbaugh.[3]

Imbrie attended Friends Select School, Central High School, George Washington University, (A.B. 1902; LL.B. 1905) and Yale Law School (LL.M. 1906).[4] The topic of his master’s thesis was admiralty law. In 1907 he was appointed attorney-in-charge of the Seaman’s Branch of the Legal Aid Society in New York City. [5] In 1908, Imbrie opened a law practice in Baltimore with Howard McCormick, who later served as a long-time professor of English at the United States Naval Academy.[6]

Imbrie traveled extensively between 1906 and 1915, visiting the southwest U.S., Canada, Europe, and Gabon, West Africa. His guide to Africa was Richard Lynch Garner, who had been assigned by William Temple Hornaday, the director of the New York Zoological Society, to bring back a live gorilla, which he did.[7]

Military and diplomatic service

[edit]

World War I

[edit]
His memoir—Behind the Wheel of a War Ambulance by Robert Imbrie, New York: Robert M. McBride & Co.,1918.

In late 1915 Imbrie enrolled as a volunteer driver in the American Ambulance Field Service, which was part of the Automobile Section of the French Army.[8] He served in France from December 1915 until October, 1916, when he transferred to the Army of the Orient in Macedonia. He served there until April 1917, when the United States entered the war.

Imbrie received the following medals for his wartime service—the Croix de Guerre, the White Rose Croix de Guerre, the Ambulance Medal, the Field Service Medal, and the Medal of Recognition for serving six months or more at the front.[9] He was one of the longest-serving volunteer ambulance drivers in the war, seventeen months.

Russia

[edit]

Because of his age and a recent bout with typhus, Imbrie could not enlist in the U.S. military; instead he joined the U.S. Consular Service and was sent to Petrograd. He arrived in November, 1917, in the midst of the Russian Revolution.[10]

With the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk about to be signed, ending the war between Germany and Russia, the American legation moved north in late February, 1918. In April Ambassador David Francis sent Imbrie back to Petrograd, where he stayed for five months as the primary and at times the sole U.S. representative in the city.[11] On August 30, Imbrie learned of his imminent arrest. With the help of the Norwegian embassy, he secured false papers and transportation out of the country.

Finland

[edit]

In early 1919, Imbrie, then based in Viborg, Finland, began tracking the movement of the northern division of the White Army as it prepared to seize Petrograd and Moscow from the Bolshevik Red Army.[12] In addition, Imbrie worked to provide food relief to thousands of Russian émigrés.[13] After the fall of the White Army in the north, he left Finland in June 1920. By then he had been tried in absentia by the Bolsheviks and sentenced to death.[14]

Turkey

[edit]

Imbrie was next posted to Crimea, where the southern division of the White Army was active; however, when he arrived in Turkey in December, 1920, he found it, too, had collapsed. Instead, he was assigned to Constantinople under Admiral Mark Bristol, who headed the U.S. military and diplomatic missions in Turkey.[15] After traveling extensively throughout the region doing reconnaissance, Imbrie left Turkey in July, 1921.

Returning to Turkey in March, 1922, Imbrie became the only U.S. official observer in Angora (Ankara), the seat of the new government of modern Turkey. There he met Katherine Helene Gillespie (1883–1968), an American relief worker caring for Armenian and Greek orphans of genocide and war. They married on December 26, 1922.[16] Imbrie continued his reconnaissance work, befriended Mustapha Kemal, the new president of Turkey, and tracked American commercial interests in the area. In 1923, after Imbrie learned that a $40,000 bounty had been placed on his head, he and Katherine returned to the United States.[17] On the way they stopped in Switzerland so Imbrie could brief the U.S. representative at the Lausanne Peace Conference regarding oil concessions in Turkey.[18]

Fateful service in Persia

[edit]

Posting to Tehran

[edit]

Imbrie’s next post was to Tabriz, Persia (Iran); however, before assuming that duty, he was temporarily reassigned to Tehran when Consul Bernard Gotlieb went on leave.[19] Imbrie immediately immersed himself in this new post as Persia struggled with both internal strife, involving politics and religion, and external pressures, including oil interests and foreign entanglements.[20]

Murder

[edit]

In early 1924, there had been several outbreaks of anti-Baháʼí violence in Tehran. On the morning of 18 July, Imbrie went to visit a well in the city's bazaar where it was alleged a man had lost his sight because of a sacrilege but had had it restored when he repented. Imbrie took a camera with him as he often did, his hobby being travel-writing and photography. Accompanying him was Melvin Seymour, an American roustabout, who was serving house arrest at the consulate.[1]

The Imbrie grave marker at Arlington National Cemetery. Photo by Jane Nelson.

Upon their arriving at the well, someone yelled that they were Bahai; another accused them of having poisoned the well. A crowd quickly gathered and chased Imbrie and Seymour, who managed to escape in their carriage. The mob caught up with them, however, when the carriage was blocked by a motorbike near the Cossack battery. There they were pulled from the carriage and beaten by the crowd. The police eventually intervened and took Imbrie and Seymour to the police hospital. Shortly afterwards, the mob broke into the hospital and again assaulted Imbrie. He died at 3:00 p.m.[21]

Immediately, suspicion that Imbrie's murder was politically motivated fell on Reza Khan. Some of the attackers were members of a regiment of the Persian Cossack Brigade.[22] Khan had led this brigade first as its commander and then, after the coup, as the Commander-in-Chief of the Army.[23]

Imbrie's body was shipped home aboard the USS Trenton (CL-11), the first U.S. warship to enter the Persian Gulf,[24][25] Among the notables attending his funeral services in Washington, D.C., was President Calvin Coolidge.[26] Imbrie and his wife Katherine are buried at Arlington National Cemetery in Virginia.[27]

Hours after Imbrie's death, Reza Khan, then prime minister as well as minister of war, declared martial law [28] and used the murder as an excuse to consolidate his power. According to Major Sherman Miles, a United States Army General Staff officer sent to Tehran to investigate, the murder was deliberate. Miles concluded that the anti-Bahai rioting in Tehran was intended by the Iranian government to end in the death of a foreigner. Reza Khan wanted a foreigner to die "so that he could declare martial law and check the power of the Mullahs."[1]

Aftermath

[edit]

The U.S. State Department and especially the consulate in Tehran worked to bring the guilty parties to justice. However, when three people were executed (two teenagers and an army private), U.S. officials believed that justice had failed.[29] Meanwhile Imbrie's widow sought what she considered adequate indemnity for her husband's death, a legal battle that lasted for over 25 years. In 1950 the $70,000 indemnity that Persia had paid the United States was folded into a fund to educate foreign students.[30]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ a b c Michael P. Zirinsky (August 1986). "Blood, Power, and Hypocrisy: The Murder of Robert Imbrie and American Relations with Pahlavi Iran, 1924". International Journal of Middle East Studies. 18 (3): 275–292. doi:10.1017/S0020743800030488. JSTOR 163379. S2CID 145403501.
  2. ^ Stowell, Ellery C. (1924). "The Imbrie Incident". American Journal of International Law. 18 (4): 768–774. doi:10.2307/2188849. ISSN 0002-9300. JSTOR 2188849.
  3. ^ Boyd Vincent Imbrie, Mary E. Philbrook, and Addison Murray Imbrie, Genealogy of the Imbrie Family of Western Pennsylvania: Descendants of James Imbrie, Pioneer Settler and his Wife Euphemia Smart, Pittsburgh, PA: D.H. Lucas Co., 1953.
  4. ^ Robert Imbrie, Application for Appointment to the United States Consulate, Imbrie Personnel File, August 14, 1917.
  5. ^ .Smithsonian Museum Acquisition #98,532, received from Katherine Imbrie, 1927.
  6. ^ Yale University Obituary Record of Graduates Deceased During the Year Ending July 1, 1925, Bulletin of Yale University Twenty-First Series, #22, August, 1925, 1555–1556
  7. ^ Jeremy Rich, Missing Links: The African and American Worlds of R. L. Garner, Primate Collector. Series: Race in the Atlantic World, 1700-1900, Athens, GA: University of Georgia Press, 2012.
  8. ^ Robert Imbrie, Behind the Wheel of an Ambulance, New York: Robert M. McBride & Cp., 1918.
  9. ^ Field Service Bulletin, September 1, 1917, #9 notes Imbrie’s receiving the Croix de Guerre. For a list of Imbrie’s wartime awards, see “State Department Begins Inquiry,” The New York Times, July 20, 1924, 1
  10. ^ Imbrie, "Report on the Petrograd Consulate, April 5 to September 1, 1918," RG 59 123.813/7 ½
  11. ^ Imbrie, "Report on the Petrograd Consulate, April 5 to September 1, 1918," RG 59 123.813/7 ½.
  12. ^ Imbrie to the Secretary of State, “Establishment of Consular Office at Viborg, Finland,” March 21, 1919, 125.972/1.
  13. ^ Imbrie report of March 4, 1919 included in 861.00/4020, March 11, 1919 from Acting Secretary of State Polk to the Commission to negotiate Peace regarding the proposal of Dr. Fridtjof Nansen for Relief of Russia under Supervision of Northern Neutrals. FRUS/Russia/1919, 98.
  14. ^ John W. Davis (London) to the Secretary of State. March 1, 1921. Enclosure: “Confidential Memorandum on British Counter-Revolutionary Activities in Russia” by Z. M. Kennedy submitted February 21, 1921. RG 165, Entry A1 65, MIS Correspondence, Folder 9771-245, Box 2192.
  15. ^ Charles Allen to Secretary of State, December 6, 1920, Box 1448, 123 Im ¼.
  16. ^ "Wedded in Constantinople: Miss Gillespie Relief Worker, Bride of Robert Imbrie of Baltimore," New York Times, December 31, 1922, 2.
  17. ^ Blake to Carr, June 23, 1923, 123 Im 1/82.
  18. ^ Secretary of State to Turkey (Bristol), May 22, 1923, Im 1/61
  19. ^ Imbrie in U.S., January 21, 1924, 123 Im 1/75.
  20. ^ Imbrie Report, RG 59, 891.6363-SO/370, June 11, 1924.
  21. ^ Susan M. Stein (2020). On Distant Service: The Life of the First U.S. Foreign Service Officer to be Assassinated. University of Nebraska Press. p. 188ff. ISBN 9781640121942.
  22. ^ Kornfeld to Secretary of State, July 27, 1924, post mortem enclosure.
  23. ^ Cyrus Ghani; Sīrūs Ghanī (2001). Iran and the Rise of the Reza Shah: From Qajar Collapse to Pahlavi Power. I.B.Tauris. p. 147. ISBN 978-1-86064-629-4.
  24. ^ Fuller dispatch 51 August 30, 1924, 123 Im 1/279.
  25. ^ R. K. Cravens, Adjutant General's Office, War Department to Division of Near Eastern Affairs, September 25, 1924, 123 Im 1/268.
  26. ^ "Coolidge Attends Imbrie's Funeral," New York Times, September 30, 1924, 12.
  27. ^ Burial Detail: Imbrie, Robert W (Section 4, Grave 2903) – ANC Explorer
  28. ^ Imperial Legation of Persia, Washington D.C. to Grew, Acting Secretary of State. July 21, 1924. Enclosure, 123 Im 1/97.
  29. ^ Sherman Miles report, 123 Im1/290, August 31, 1924, Murray telegram 645, 123 Im 1/229, August 31, 1924; Murray telegram 118, 123 Im 1/249, September 13, 1924; Murray to Secretary of State, dispatch 645, 123 Im 1/313, September 16, 1924.
  30. ^ 96 Cong. Rec. 15080 1950, 15080—15088. H. R. 5731 and an identical bill, S. 2342.

Further reading

[edit]
  • Susan M. Stein (2020). On Distant Service: The Life of the First U.S. Foreign Service Officer to be Assassinated. Lincoln, NE: Potomac Books, an imprint of The University of Nebraska Press, ISBN 978-1640121942, OCLC 1120149518.
[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Robert_Whitney_Imbrie&oldid=1247301936"