Qualitative economics

Qualitative economics is the representation and analysis of information about the direction of change (+, -, or 0) in some economic variable(s) as related to change of some other economic variable(s). For the non-zero case, what makes the change qualitative is that its direction but not its magnitude is specified.

Typical exercises of qualitative economics include comparative-static changes studied in microeconomics or macroeconomics and comparative equilibrium-growth states in a macroeconomic growth model. A simple example illustrating qualitative change is from macroeconomics. Let:

GDP = nominal gross domestic product, a measure of national income

M = money supply

T = total taxes.

Monetary theory hypothesizes a positive relationship between GDP the dependent variable and M the independent variable. Equivalent ways to represent such a qualitative relationship between them are as a signed functional relationship and as a signed derivative:

$GDP=f({\overset {+}{M}})\quad \!$ or $\quad {\frac {df(M)}{dM}}>0.$

where the '+' indexes a positive relationship of GDP to M, that is, as M increases, GDP increases as a result.

Another model of GDP hypothesizes that GDP has a negative relationship to T. This can be represented similarly to the above, with a theoretically appropriate sign change as indicated:

$GDP=f({\overset {-}{T}})\quad \!$ or $\quad {\frac {df(T)}{dT}}<0.$

That is, as T increases, GDP decreases as a result. A combined model uses both M and T as independent variables. The hypothesized relationships can be equivalently represented as signed functional relationships and signed partial derivatives (suitable for more than one independent variable):

$GDP=f({\overset {+}{M}},{\overset {-}{T}})\,\!\quad$ or $\quad {\frac {\partial f(M,T)}{\partial M}}>0,\quad$ ${\frac {\partial f(M,T)}{\partial T}}<0.$

Qualitative hypotheses occur in earliest history of formal economics but only as to formal economic models from the late 1930s with Hicks's model of general equilibrium in a competitive economy. A classic exposition of qualitative economics is Samuelson, 1947. There Samuelson identifies qualitative restrictions and the hypotheses of maximization and stability of equilibrium as the three fundamental sources of meaningful theorems — hypotheses about empirical data that could conceivably be refuted by empirical data.

References

• J. R. Hicks, 1939. Value and Capital. Oxford.
• Kelvin Lancaster, 1962. "The Scope of Qualitative Economics," Review of Economic Studies, 29(2), p p. 99-123.
  • W.M. Gorman, 1964. "More Scope for Qualitative Economics," Review of Economic Studies, 31(1) p p. 65-68.
• James Quirk, 1987. "qualitative economics," The New Palgrave: A Dictionary of Economics, v. 4, pp. 1–3.
• _____ and Richard Ruppert, 1965. "Qualitative Economics and the Stability of Equilibrium," Review of Economic Studies, 32(4), p p. 311-326.
• Paul A. Samuelson, 1947. Foundations of Economic Analysis, Harvard University Press. ISBN 0-674-31301-1