Pseudodon shell DUB1006-fL
.jpg)
The Pseudodon shell DUB1006-fL or Pseudodon DUB1006-fL (540,000-430,000 BP) is a fossil freshwater shell of Pseudodon vondembuschianus trinilensis found at Trinil, Java, Indonesia. The shell has a zigzag engraving supposedly made by Homo erectus, which could be the oldest known anthropogenic engraving in the world.[1]
Description
[edit]The shell is a part of an assemblage of fossil freshwater mussel shells, excavated by the Dutch paleoanthropologist and geologist Eugène Dubois in 1890s from the Pleistocene layer at the Trinil site, Java, Indonesia. The assemblage, including the shell DUB1006-fL, is now at the Naturalis Biodiversity Center, Leiden, Netherlands.
Geometric engravings on the shell DUB1006-fL were discovered by a biologist Josephine Joordens (then at Leiden University) and her colleagues in 2014. Their analysis suggests that the engravings are made by Homo erectus between 540,000 and 430,000 BP. The engravings were probably made on a fresh shell specimen using a shark tooth. It is also suggested that all grooves were made by a single individual in a single session with the same tool.[1]
Interpretation
[edit]Joordens et al. do not give a direct interpretation of the engravings, but suggest that "engraving abstract patterns was in the realm of Asian Homo erectus cognition and neuromotor control."[1] In her interview, Joordens says that since the intentions of the individual who made the engravings are not known, it is not possible to classify these engravings as art.[2] "It could have been to impress his girlfriend, or to doodle a bit, or to mark the shell as his own property," says Joordens.[2]
Controversy
[edit]The main discussion happens around the question of whether the engraving on the shell can be considered as art (which would make it the earliest known artistic expression of hominids in the world). Commentators of the original study by Joordens et al.[1] suggest their opinions, but do not study the engravings explicitly. Some commentators, similarly to the authors of the study, give a neutral description of the engravings, calling them a "doodle"[2] or "decorative marks".[3] Some other commentators suggest explicitly that these engravings are art.[4][5][6]
Tsion Avital, a philosopher of art and culture, makes a distinction between art and design and suggests that the engraving on Pseudodon DUB1006-fL cannot be seen as the former, but can well be the latter. He contests the description of the engraving by Joordens et al. who called it an "abstract pattern", saying that the terms "abstract" and "pattern" "hint obliquely at the possibility that these engravings possess some symbolic significance." "These engravings are in no sense abstract but rather are completely concrete marks," says Avital.[7]
The Indonesian government has requested the return of the complete Dubois collection (circa 40.000 fossils), because they regard it as goods that were looted by the Dutch during the colonial occupation.[8]
See also
[edit]- Homo erectus
- Java Man
- Venus of Tan-Tan
- Venus of Berekhat Ram
- Prehistoric art
- Art of the Middle Paleolithic
References
[edit]- ^ a b c d Joordens, Josephine C. A.; d’Errico, Francesco; Wesselingh, Frank P.; Munro, Stephen; de Vos, John; Wallinga, Jakob; Ankjærgaard, Christina; Reimann, Tony; Wijbrans, Jan R.; Kuiper, Klaudia F.; Mücher, Herman J. (2015). "Homo erectus at Trinil on Java used shells for tool production and engraving". Nature. 518 (7538): 228–231. Bibcode:2015Natur.518..228J. doi:10.1038/nature13962. ISSN 1476-4687. PMID 25470048. S2CID 4461751.
- ^ a b c Callaway, Ewen (2014-12-03). "Homo erectus made world's oldest doodle 500,000 years ago". Nature News. doi:10.1038/nature.2014.16477. S2CID 164153158.
- ^ Thompson, Helen (2014-12-03). "Zigzags on a Shell From Java Are the Oldest Human Engravings". Smithsonian Magazine. Retrieved 2021-04-18.
- ^ Brahic, Catherine (2014-12-03). "Shell 'art' made 300,000 years before humans evolved". New Scientist. Retrieved 2021-04-18.
- ^ Geggel, Laura 03 (2014-12-03). "540,000-Year-Old Shell Carvings May Be Human Ancestor's Oldest Art". livescience.com. Retrieved 2021-04-18.
{{cite news}}: CS1 maint: numeric names: authors list (link) - ^ Keim, Brandon (2014-12-04). "World's Oldest Art Identified in Half-Million-Year-Old Zigzag". Adventure. Retrieved 2021-04-18.
- ^ Avital, Tsion (2017). The Confusion between Art and Design: Brain-tools versus Body-tools (PDF). Vernon Press.
- ^ "Indonesië vraagt topkunst en natuurhistorische vondsten terug". nos.nl (in Dutch). 2022-10-18. Retrieved 2023-07-06.