Members of the teams are traditionally known as Blues, or Oxford specific as Dark Blue. The original conditions are:
No player eligible who has been a member of his University for more than four years, or who has not been in residence during the term in which the match takes place. Instituted in 1878. Played generally at Hurlingham, in June. (Modern Polo, 1896[2])
No player eligible who has been a member of his University for more than four years, or who has not been in residence during the term in which the match takes place. The Cup shall be held by the winning University in each year until May 1st in the succeeding year, when it shall be returned to The Hurlingham Club. Play – 6 periods.
(The Polo Yearbook 1939[3])
Teams are selected from students of all colleges within the university. Women began participating in 1962, a notable development in the history of the event. An official rules change in 1963 followed, allowing mixed-gender teams which is still a rare opportunity amongst the Blues Sports of both universities. The first female captaincy was in 1966. However, only four out of 125 Varsity teams have been captained by a woman yet (1966, 1994, 2019, 2024).
In the following table, team members are listed from left to right in their respective positions (1 to 4) including their college affiliation, possible captaincy, and polo handicaps, which ranges from -2 to +10.
1 John Blundell Leigh, Christ Church; 2 James Henry Stock, Christ Church, Captain; 3 John Grant Lawson, Christ Church; 4 Henry Arthur Hallam Farnaby Lennard, Christ Church; 5 John Ernest Stock, Christ Church, Goalkeeper
1 John Blundell Leigh, Christ Church, Captain; 2 Walter MacMurrough Kavanagh, Christ Church; 3 John Grant Lawson, Christ Church; 4 James Henry Stock, Christ Church; 5 Martin Thomas Kennard, Christ Church
1 Henry Berkeley Portman, 3rd Viscount Portman, non-coll.; 2 Douglas Haig, Brasenose; 3 John Cator of Woodbastwick Hall, Christ Church; 4 Charles Edward Nicholas Charrington, Christ Church; 5 J. Goslyn
1 Henry Berkeley Portman, 3rd Viscount Portman, non-coll.; 2 Douglas Haig, Brasenose; 3 John Cator of Woodbastwick Hall, Christ Church ; 4 Charles Edward Nicholas Charrington, Christ Church; 5 J. Goslyn
1 Richard Lawson, Christ Church; 2 Lord William August Cavendish Bentinck, 6th Duke of Portland, Christ Church; 3 Piers Alexander Hamilton Edgcumbe Viscount Valletort, Christ Church; 4 James Lionel Dugdale, Christ Church
1 Keppel Pulteney, Christ Church, Captain; 2 Arthur Dugdale, Christ Church (+2); 3 Roger William Giffard Tyringham, Christ Church; 4 George Saville Clayton, University College
1 Penn Curzon Sherbrooke, Christ Church; 2 Godfrey Nigel Everard Baring, Hertford; 3 Arthur Dugdale, Christ Church, Captain (+2); 4 Frederick Charles Graham Menzies, Christ Church
1 George Henry Clifford, New College; 2 Godfrey Nigel Everard Baring, Hertford, Captain; 3 Arthur Dugdale, Christ Church (+2); 4 Frederick Charles Graham Menzies, Christ Church
1 Neil Primrose, New College; 2 Ralph Albert Brassey, New College; 3 Weetman Harold Pearson, 2nd Viscount Cowdray, Christ Church; 4 Leonard H. Hardy, New College, Captain
1 Neil Primrose, New College; 2 Francis Vernon Willey, Baron Barnby, Magdalen; 3 Weetman Harold Pearson, 2nd Viscount Cowdray, Christ Church, Captain; 4 Ralph Albert Brassey, New College
1 Julian Walter Winans, Worcester; 2 Paul Winans, Exeter; 3 Frederick Cripps, 3rd Baron Parmoor, New College; 4 Francis Vernon Willey, Baron Barnby, Magdalen, Captain
1 George Bampfylde, New College (+1); 2 Hubert Sydney Loder, Magdalen (+3); 3 Captain James Joseph Pearce, Worcester (+5); 4 Robert Spear Hudson, Viscount Hudson, Magdalen, Captain (+4)
1 Geoffrey William Martin Lees, Christ Church; 2 Albany "Barney" Kennett Charlesworth, Christ Church (+1); 3 Rothesay Stuart Wortley, Balliol (0); 4 Edward Frederick Lawson, 4th Baron Burnham, Balliol (+1)
1 Charles Wilfrid Bennett, Trinity; 2 Edwin Vickerman Rutherford, Trinity; 3 Hugh Alastair Hamilton Fraser, Magdalen; 4 George Sheavyn Sale, New College; spare Allen Bathurst, Lord Apsley, Christ Church
1 Reginald Alfred Carr-White, St Catherine's, Captain; 2 Walter Morley Sale, New College; 3 Ralph John Hines, Christ Church; 4 James Townsend Pearce, Christ Church
1 Thomas Martin Hilder, Oriel; 2 Sir Ian Walker Bart, Christ Church; 3 Reginald Alfred Carr-White, St Catherine's; 4 Walter Morley Sale, New College, Captain
1 Edward Fitzhardinge Peyton Gage, Christ Church (+1); 2 Hugh Sidebottom, Christ Church; 3 E. Dugdale, Christ Church; 4 John Mortimer Schiff, New College
1 R. J. Holland (+1); 2 Edward Fitzhardinge Peyton Gage, Christ Church, Captain (+1); 3 John Mortimer Schiff, New College (+1); 4 H. Bradley-Martin, Christ Church (+2)
1 Oliver Sanderson Poole, Christ Church; 2 John "Weetman" Pearson, 3rd Viscount Cowdray, Christ Church, Captain (+1); 3 John Lakin, New College (+1); 4 Robert Vickris Taylor, Magdalen (0)
1 Oliver Sanderson Poole, Christ Church; 2 Lt. L. H. Rodgers, Christ Church (+3); 3 John "Weetman" Pearson, Christ Church, Captain (+1); 4 John Lakin, New College (+1)
1 Peter Murray Kemp-Gee, Oriel (0); 2 Arthur Maitland Budgett, Christ Church (+1); 3 Richard Alan Budgett, Christ Church, Captain; 4 Denis Frederick Little, New College (+1)
1 Denis Frederick Little, New College (+1); 2 Peter Murray Kemp-Gee, Oriel (0); 3 Arthur Maitland Budgett, Christ Church, Captain (+1); 4 Devereux Milburn Jr., Lincoln (0)
1 John Errol Mansfield, Christ Church (0); 2 John David Summers, Christ Church (0); 3 Arthur Maitland Budgett, Christ Church, Captain (+1); 4 Peter Murray Kemp-Gee, Oriel (+1)
1 John Errol Mansfield, Christ Church (0); 2 John Jacob ("Jackie") Astor, New College; 3 John David Summers, Christ Church (0); 4 Nicholas Hyde Villiers, New College
1 Timothy Wentworth Beaumont, Baron Beaumont of Whitley, Christ Church (-2); 2 Robert Hamilton Bishop, Corpus Christi; 3 C. A. Broadie; 4 Dan Lockwood McGurk, Christ Church
1 Giles Eden Fitzherbert, Christ Church; 2 Walter Murray Butcher, Worcester; 3 John Richard Wilson, New College, Captain; 4 Francis Paul Bowyer Nichols, Balliol
1 Sir Robert Noel Hutchings, Trinity; 2 Charles Arthur Russell Lockhart, Worcester (0); 3 Peter Robin Wilson, Trinity, Captain; 4 William Oliver Lane Fox-Pitt, Trinity
1 Sir Robert Noel Hutchings, Trinity; 2 Charles Arthur Russell Lockhart, Worcester (0); 3 Peter Robin Wilson, Trinity, Captain; 4 William Oliver Lane Fox-Pitt, Trinity
1 Robert Hernando Franco, Trinity (-2); 2 Charles Arthur Russell Lockhart, Worcester (0); 3 Anthony Hugh Burns De Bono, Christ Church (1); 4 Anthony Aufrere Wallace-Turner, Trinity (-2)
1 Hugh Charles Vivian Smith, 4th Baron Bicester, Worcester; 2 Peter Palumbo, Worcester; 3 Dr Anthony Hugh Burns De Bono, Christ Church (1); 4 Edward Stephen Cazalet, Christ Church
1 Claire Lucas, Somerville, first female Captain of OUPC (0); 2 Justin J. Cartwright, Trinity; 3 Simon Tomlinson, University College; 4 Julian Arthur Eeley, Wadham
1 Justin J. Cartwright, Trinity; 2 Simon Tomlinson, University College, Captain; 3 Julian Arthur Eeley, Wadham; 4 Christopher Philip Mackenzie (Chris) Ashton, Trinity
1 John Pirie Moir, Oriel; 2 Christopher Philip Mackenzie (Chris) Ashton, Trinity; 3 Julian Arthur Eeley, Wadham, Captain; 4 Anthony Clive Jellicoe Preston, University College (0)
1 Robert M. Lindemann, Christ Church (-2); 2. Christopher Andrew Joll, Mansfield (0); 3 Redmond Watt, Christ Church (2); 4 Chandos Alaric Graham Gore Langton, St Catherine's, Captain (0)
1 William Jeffery Reeve, Exeter (-2); 2 Robert Mark Howes, Hertford (-2); 3 Chris Elston, Worcester, Captain (1); 4 John H. Bodkin, St Edmund Hall (-1)
1 Alannah Weston, Merton (0); 2 Jacqui Broughton, St Edmund Hall, Discretionary Full Blue (0); 3 Paul Lalor, Jesus (1); 4 James (Jim) Tuttle, Wolfson, Captain (0)
1 Alastair Vere Nicoll, St Hugh's (-2); 2 Jacqui Broughton, St Edmund Hall, Discretionary Full Blue, Captain (0); 3 Andrew Dechet, Jesus (0); 4 Cameron Walton Masters, St Peter's (3)
1 Alastair Vere Nicholl, St Hugh's (-1); 2 Andrew Dechet, Jesus (0); Cameron Walton Masters, St. Peter's, Captain (3); Jacqui Broughton, St Edmund Hall (0)
1 Edward Upton, Magdalen (-1); 2 Francois Perrodo, St Peter's, Captain (1); 3 Alastair Lamb, Corpus Christi (0); 4 Reda Hasse (Rida) Said, Pembroke (-1)
1 Hugo Guy Sylvester Grimston, Worcester (-1); 2 Edward Upton, Magdalen (-1); 3 Francois Perrodo, St Peter's, Captain (1); 4 Alastair Lamb, Corpus Christi, (0)
1 Pablo Goetz, Green College (-2); Quintin Fraser (-2); 2 Jonathan Randall, Worcester, Captain (-1); 3 Matthew Penley, University College (-1); 4 Hugo Guy Sylvester Grimston, Worcester (-1)
1 Harry Townsend, St Catherine's (0); 2 Matthew Penley, University, Captain (-1); 3 Jose (Pepe) Penafiel, St Benet's (2); 4 Philippa Grace, Saïd Business School (1)
1 Alex Gleeson, LMH (0), 1 Jamie Dundas, Greyfriars (1); 2 John Harris, St Peter's (2); 3 Jose (Pepe) Penafiel, St Benet's (2); 4 Harry Townsend, St Catherine's, Captain (0)
1 Charlie James Hitchman, Magdalen (0); 2 Louis Maddison, St Hugh's, Captain (0); 3 Vere Harmsworth, St Peter's (0); 4 George Pearson, Christ Church, MVP (2)
1 Heather Winsor, Brasenose (-1); 2 Ben Evans, Corpus Christi (-2); 3 Christiaan de Koning, Christ Church (-2); 4 Louis Maddison, St Hugh's, MVP, Captain (0)
1 James Thomas Coates, St Hugh's/ Freddie Schrager, Worcester (-1); 2 Christiaan de Koning, Christ Church (-2); 3 Tamara Gibbons, St Edmund Hall, MVP, Captain (1); 4 Charlie James Hitchman, Magdalen, BPP (0)