At New Release Tuesday, Mark Ryan rated the album a perfect five stars, stating that "This album is perplexing, there will be people that love it and people that don't care for it."[1] In addition, Ryan wrote that "At first listen Misfits 2 is light and flaky like a Tenderflake pie crust... but upon listening closer it is deep and rich like a chocolate bobka."[1]
For the Billboard charting week of May 17, 2014, Misfits 2 ranked No. 59 on the Billboard 200 albums chart, and it reached Nos. 6 and 3 on the Christian Albums and Gospel Albums charts, respectively. It also was the No. 10 on the Rap Albums chart that same week and No. 14 on the Independent Albums chart. The album has 10,000 copies in the US as of March 2015.[2]
