Marvin's Legal Bibliography
Legal Bibliography is a book by John Gage Marvin, and was hist best-known work. It is a bibliography of law. It was the first publication of its kind to originate from the United States of America.[1] Marvin was then a librarian at Harvard University and would later serve as the first California State Superintendent of Public Instruction.
This work was preceded by an 1843 edition of a work on international law by Sir James Mackintosh, with reading list, and an 1846 Catalogue of the Harvard Law Library including recent accessions. The Bibliography is in alphabetical by author, with a topical index, and includes evaluative comments on the works, drawing on numerous sources. Despite the impression given by its short title, the Bibliography was an attempt to integrate other legal works into the Anglo-American tradition.[2]
In 1857, the Upper Canada Law Journal and Lower Courts Gazette said "Mr. Marvin's, Legal Bibliography, is by far the completest work of its kind we have had".[3]
Harvard University Library Notes said that this book was, "for many years" after its first publication, "the best American work of its kind".[4]
In the Proceedings of the First Annual Meeting of the Virginia State Bar Association, this book was described as "good in its day, but now more than 40 years old".[5]
In 1914, Percy Winfield said that this book was a "valuable" guide "to the materials of English law",[6] that it appeared to be little known in England, that the critical notes were appended to certain classics and reporters and were necessarily brief, especially in relation to the Year Books, that the book was an index of authors rather than topics, and that a new edition was needed.[7]
In 1988, Bookman's Yearbook said that the fact that this book was still in use indicated "the sorry state" that legal bibliography was in, the book being "like a third class Lowndes or Brunet".[8]
Criticisms
[edit]The Harvard Law Review said, in relation to Year-Book bibliography, that Marvin's Legal Bibliography discloses little that is valuable and its accuracy does not stand the test of verification.[9]
In his preface, Marvin says that upon reviewing this volume, he discovered that some titles were omitted, and that some dates were erroneous.[10]
References
[edit]- Marvin, J G. Legal Bibliography, or a thesaurus of American, English, Irish and Scotch law books:together with some continental treatises. T & J W Johnson. 1847. Digitised copy from Google Books.
- ^ British and Irish Association of Law Librarians. The Law Librarian. 1981. Volume 9.
- ^ Michael H. Hoeflich, Annals of Legal Bibliography: J. G. Marvin, Law Library Journal (2004) vol. 96; PDF Archived 2012-05-23 at the Wayback Machine.
- ^ The Upper Canada Law Journal and Lower Courts Gazette. 1857. Volume 3. Page 5, col 2. Digitised copy from Google Books.
- ^ Harvard University Library Notes. Harvard University Press. 1941. Issue 4. Page 106.
- ^ The Virginia State Bar Association. Proceedings of the First Annual Meeting. Richmond Press. 1889. Page 57.
- ^ Winfield, Percy H. "Some Bibliographical Difficulties of English Law" (1914) 30 LQR 190.
- ^ 30 LQR 190 at 198
- ^ Bookman's Yearbook. Bookman's Weekly. 1988. Page 10.
- ^ Harvard Law Review. 1900. Volume 14. Page 558.
- ^ Marvin, J G. Legal Bibliography. 1847. p vii.
Further reading
[edit]- The Western Law Journal. Desilver and Burr. 1848. Volume 5. Pages 140 and 475 to 476. Digitised copy from Google Books.
External links
[edit]
Works related to Marvin's Legal Bibliography at Wikisource
