Kobayashi red yeast rice scandal
 | |
| Date | March 22, 2024 – ongoing |
|---|---|
| Location | Japan, Taiwan |
| Type | Cholesterol-lowering medication and food products |
| Cause | Puberulic acid contamination |
| Deaths | Up to 80 |
| Non-fatal injuries | 500+, 94,000+ consultations |
The Kobayashi red yeast rice scandal (Japanese: 紅麹サプリ事件) is an ongoing widespread supplement contamination that was first noted on 22 March 2024, resulting in numerous health problems to people taking the supplements in Japan and Taiwan. Up to 80 people died after taking the supplements, with at least 500 more hospitalized.[1][2][3] Kobayashi Pharmaceutical officially discontinued production of beni koji products on 8 August 2024.[4]
Incident
[edit]On 22 March 2024, authorities reported that five people had died after consuming three products produced by Kobayashi Pharmaceutical, including "Red Koji Cholesterol Help".[5] More than 240 people were hospitalized due to taking the supplement, and a total of 94,000 consultations were made, leading to a mandated recall as they were suspected of containing toxic and harmful substances.[3][6][7] Kobayashi Pharmaceutical red yeast rice supplements were also supplied to other companies and used in confectionery, bread, sake, miso, and several other products, expanding the distribution of contaminated red yeast rice. The damage spread to Taiwan where Kobayashi Pharmaceutical red yeast rice was sold. Six cases of acute kidney failure and other health problems were reported, prompting a recall of the ingredients and products using them from about 100 companies.[8] Taiwanese companies recalled 154 products linked to the contaminated red yeast rice supplements.[9]
On 28 June 2024, the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare announced that 76 new deaths suspected to be related to taking the supplement had been discovered.[10][11] As of 28 June 2024, Kobayashi Pharmaceutical had received 170 inquiries from about the deaths of family members, of which 76 were from people who had taken the product and died, and another three were from doctors positing no causal relationship between taking the supplement and deaths.[12] On 2 July, the city of Osaka requested the government of Mie Prefecture to investigate a case relating to the death to provide further information on the contamination and its spread.[13]
Health issues
[edit]According to Dr. Ryuta Fujimura of the Department of Nephrology at the Higashiosaka Municipal Medical Center, who examined the hospitalized patients, the symptoms common to the victims were severe damage to the renal tubules which became crusted, chronic fatigue, loss of appetite, vomiting, and frequent urination, as well as an extreme deterioration in kidney test results, which were consistent with Fanconi syndrome.[14]
Good Manufacture Practice (GMP) certification requires an external inspection every year. Kobayashi Pharmaceutical did not have GMP certification, and had no opportunity to have a third party check it. Under the guidelines for voluntary recalls, Kobayashi Pharmaceutical had a policy of not recalling products until a causal relationship could be established to some extent, possibly resulting in further widespread health issues.[3]
Of the 76 deaths where a causal relationship is suspected, in addition to kidney-related diseases, Kobayashi Pharmaceutical claimed that some were due to other diseases (cancer, cerebral infarction, pneumonia, aortic dissection, etc.) requiring further inquiry.[12] On 30 June 2024, The Japanese Society of Nephrology announced that approximately 85% of over 100 patients reported have not returned to normal kidney function over a month after ceasing the supplement.[15]
Causes
[edit]As of June 2024, the precise cause has not been determined, but it has been discovered that the batches manufactured between June and August 2023 and in which the health damage was confirmed contained puberulic acid and two unknown compounds with a basic structure similar to that of lovastatin (monacolin K), which was an active ingredient in the supplement.[16] Animal experiments confirmed that puverulic acid causes kidney damage.[12]
Due to prior research indicating the risk of causing kidney disfunction, in Switzerland, sales of red yeast rice are illegal, France, and the European Union have expressed safety concerns, Germany issued a warning not to consume it, and Taiwan recommends that people with chronic diseases seek professional medical advice before taking it.[17]
The mold used to make red yeast rice is called "koji mold", with there being several types of koji mold. The type most commonly used in Japan is Aspergillus oryzae, which is classified as part of the Aspergillus genus. It is used in sake, soy sauce, miso, mirin, amazake, and other products, with no reported health problems. In contrast, red koji mold is a species classified as Monascus, and is used in Chinese and Taiwanese fermented bean curd. Some red koji molds produce a mycotoxin called citrinin, which is known to cause kidney disease, but the product uses red koji mold that does not have the gene to synthesize citrinin, and in fact no citrinin was detected. On March 29, the possibility that the "unknown substance" was puverulic acid was first postulated.[18]
The Japanese Society of Nephrology conducted a survey of doctors and reported that as of 4 April, 95 people who had taken "Red Koji Cholesterol Help" and other products reported health problems, with the majority of patients showing symptoms that appeared to be Fanconi syndrome, with about three-quarters of patients reporting that their symptoms improved once they stopped taking the supplement.[19]
Puberulic acid was detected in the blue mold from the Osaka and Wakayama factories, which was produced by modifying monacolin K. An inspection by Osaka City officials indicated that the cultivation period in the factory was 50 days, three times longer than usual, in order to increase the concentration.[3] Additionally, earlier reports stated in April 2023 that there were hygiene issues with raw material production, which included picking up and reusing ingredients that had spilled on the floor.[20]
Puberulic acid
[edit]
The red yeast rice that caused the health problems was made at a factory in Osaka. The unknown substance found in the product was found to be puverulic acid, derived from blue mold, but there have only been six research papers on puverulic acid, and research into it has been very limited. According to a company that produces red yeast rice, red koji mold is very delicate compared to other fungi and is easily infested with bacteria, so thorough hygiene management is important. It was also revealed that Kobayashi Pharmaceutical had a unique manufacturing method that included culturing it for more than three times the normal period to increase the concentration of its ingredients. Professor Shinjiro Tachibana of the University of the Ryukyus pointed out that if the product is cultivated for a long time, it becomes difficult to control the temperature and moisture because additional work is required, such as adding water. The increased maintenance increases the risk of contamination. Professor Toshiro Watanabe of Sonoda Women's University pointed out that there is a risk of water entering through cracks in the tanks, a problem typical of aging factories. The presence of blue mold can be noticed in the early stages when the product is not red, but it is highly likely that it will not be noticed after red koji has developed. On April 19, several other substances not supposed to be found in the product were also found in addition to puverulic acid.[3]
On 28 May, the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare reported on a study by the National Institute of Health Sciences and the Osaka Institute of Health and Safety, administering puberulic acid or red yeast rice supplements to rats caused renal tubular necrosis, although a certain causal link could not be established.[21][22]
List of major recalled products
[edit]| Company | Merchandise | Recall date |
|---|---|---|
| Kobayashi Pharmaceutical | "Red Koji Cholesterol Help"
"Naishi Help + Cholesterol" "Nattokinase Smooth Grain GOLD" |
March 22, 2024 |
| ZERO PLUS | "Rich cheese rice crackers that help lower bad cholesterol" | March 22, 2024 |
| Marine Food | "Tofu" | March 22, 2024 |
| Bread Kawabata | "Bread of Life (Red Koji Bread)" | March 22, 2024 |
| Kanaya Hotel Bakery | "Kanaya Hotel Bakery Brand"
"Strawberry Bread" "Strawberry Roll" "Spring Anpan" |
March 22, 2024 |
| Tokura Shoji | "Red koji powder 1P-D・K"
"Red koji powder 3P-D1" |
March 22, 2024 |
| Takara Shuzo | "Shochikubai Shirakabegura "Mio" PREMIUM <ROSE> 750ml"
"Shochikubai Shirakabegura "Mio" PREMIUM <ROSE> 300ml" |
March 23, 2024 |
| Ministop | "Direct-fire grilled spicy beef offal" | April 2, 2024 |
| QVC Japan | "Revisio Sakura Yanagida Yeast Plus" | April 4, 2024 |
| Social Welfare Corporation Kyoto Ikusei no Kai | "Baked goods: Four Seasons" | April 4, 2024 |
| Toms | "Super Mineko" | April 10, 2024 |
| Nissin Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd. | "Triple Mega Support PREMIUM" | April 15, 2024 |
| フレンド | "Red yeast rice" | April 16, 2024 |
Reactions
[edit]Kobayashi Pharmaceutical began airing an apology commercial on April 6, 2024, showing an apology displayed in black text on a white background, stating:[24]
"Kobayashi Pharmaceutical offers an apology and request. We deeply apologize for the inconvenience caused by our red koji products."
"Currently, there have been reports of health problems with Red Koji Cholesterol Help and other products, and we are conducting a recall of the products. We ask that you do not consume any products you have in your hands and cooperate with the recall."
"Please check our website for health consultations, etc."
In addition, the company posted an apology regarding refunds on its official website.[25]
On 23 July, Kobayashi Pharmaceutical Chair Kazumasa Kobayashi and his son Akihiro Kobayashi, the President resigned from their posts. The company reported 279 deaths, 2,274 hospital visits with 461 required hospitalization from the effects of its beni kōji red yeast rice supplements. The firm continues probe into 80 deaths.[26]
See also
[edit]References
[edit]- ^ "小林製薬「紅麹サプリ」入院患者 腎疾患以外も含めると500人に". テレ朝news (in Japanese). Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "Japan's Kobayashi Pharma reveals 76 more deaths possibly linked to supplement". Nikkei Asia. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ a b c d e “『独自の製造工程』に潜むリスク】小林製薬「紅麹」サプリ 3倍の培養期間で異物の混入・発生のリスク高 タンクが老朽化していた可能性も". KTV NEWS (April 22, 2024). Accessed July 2, 2024.
- ^ Inoue, Yukana (8 August 2024). "Kobayashi Pharma to withdraw from beni kōji product segment". Japan Times. Retrieved 8 August 2024.
- ^ "紅麹コレステヘルプ - 製品情報 - 小林製薬株式会社". 小林製薬株式会社 -あったらいいなをカタチにする- (in Japanese). Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "小林製薬の紅麹サプリ、入院114人 通院は希望含め680人 死者5人". 毎日新聞 (in Japanese). Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "（社説）紅麹サプリ 責任の重大さ自覚せよ：朝日新聞デジタル". 朝日新聞デジタル (in Japanese). 2024-03-29. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ 日本放送協会 (2024-03-31). ""小林製薬の紅麹製品摂取後に体調不良6人に" 台湾メディア". NHKニュース. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "Japan's Kobayashi Pharmaceutical now probing 80 deaths over possible link to benikoji red yeast supplement - CBS News". CBS. 2024-06-28. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ 日本放送協会 (2024-06-28). "紅麹問題 小林製薬 "死亡"76件の因果関係調査 厚労省に報告". NHKニュース. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ 社会部, 時事通信 (2024-06-28). "新たに７６人死亡疑い 小林製薬「紅麹」サプリ―因果関係調査へ・厚労省：時事ドットコム". 時事ドットコム (in Japanese). Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ a b c "紅麹関連製品による被害の発生状況について | ニュースリリース | 小林製薬株式会社". 小林製薬株式会社 -あったらいいなをカタチにする- (in Japanese). 2024-06-28. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ 日本放送協会. "小林製薬の紅麹問題 大阪市から三重県に１件調査依頼｜NHK 三重県のニュース". NHK NEWS WEB. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ 日本放送協会 (2024-04-03). "紅麹問題 診察した医師 "患者はファンコニー症候群"". NHKニュース. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ 日本放送協会 (2024-06-30). "小林製薬 紅麹問題 患者の約85％が腎臓の機能1か月以上戻らず". NHKニュース. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "紅麹：有用成分モナコリンKの吸収性の検証 | 小林製薬 中央研究所". research.kobayashi.co.jp. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "紅麹を由来とするサプリメントに注意（欧州で注意喚起） | 食品安全委員会 - 食の安全、を科学する". fsc.go.jp. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "専門家が指摘｢紅麹問題｣で表出する"重要な視点"". 東洋経済オンライン (in Japanese). 2024-03-28. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "紅麹成分含むサプリ 大半が「ファンコニー症候群」日本腎臓学会調査 4分の3ほどはサプリの服用の中止で症状が改善 | TBS NEWS DIG (1ページ)". TBS NEWS DIG (in Japanese). 2024-04-09. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "床にこぼれた材料で紅麴原料を生産 小林製薬、昨年6月に自主回収：朝日新聞デジタル". 朝日新聞デジタル (in Japanese). 2024-04-12. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "プベルル酸が腎臓尿細管「壊死」引き起こすと確認 紅麴問題で厚労省：朝日新聞デジタル". 朝日新聞デジタル (in Japanese). 2024-05-28. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "「紅麹」健康被害問題、原料から検出の「プベルル酸」が腎障害引き起こすことを確認…厚労省". 読売新聞オンライン (in Japanese). 2024-05-28. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "リコール情報サイトトップページ｜消費者庁". recall.caa.go.jp. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "小林製薬「紅麹」お詫びCM開始 「あっ」なく深刻ナレーションに反響【4・3までの公表事例数】". ORICON NEWS. 2024-04-07. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ "Kobayashi Pharma looking into 76 more deaths linked to supplements". Kyodo News+. 28 June 2024. Retrieved 2024-07-02.
- ^ Da Silva, João (July 23, 2024). "Japan drugmaker bosses quit as firm probes deaths". BBC News. Retrieved July 25, 2024.
