John Brown's Provisional Constitution

Hundreds of copies of a provisional constitution were found among John Brown's papers after his 1859 raid on Harper's Ferry, Virginia. It called for a new state in the Appalachian Mountains, a sort of West Virginia, populated by volunteer freedom fighters and escaped slaves from plantations, which were at lower altitudes. It was introduced into evidence at his trial as evidence of sedition.

John Brown also wrote, at about the same time, a little-known Declaration of Liberty, inspired by the U.S. Declaration of Independence.^[1]^{: 162–163}

Creation of the constitution

The Provisional Constitution and Ordinances for the People of the United States was written by Brown while a guest in Frederick Douglass's house in Rochester, New York, in February, 1858.^[2] He later described it as "of my own contriving and getting up".^[3] This constitution was adopted at a convention Brown held in Chatham, Ontario, Canada, on May 8–10, 1858.^[4]^[5]^{: 258–261}

Although this document was dismissed by contemporaries as evidence of Brown's madness, David Reynolds points out that at the time, the U.S. Constitution itself was "a highly contested text". It was rejected by the abolitionists Wm. Lloyd Garrison and Wendell Phillips, who called it "a covenant with death and an agreement from hell" because it indirectly sanctioned slavery,^[6]^{: 249–250} as the Dred Scott decision had just confirmed.

Projected use of the Constitution

Just what the provisional constitution was intended for is not completely clear. It was not distributed in Harpers Ferry. There is no record of any comments by Brown on how and when it was to be distributed and used. "John Brown never...communicated his whole plan, even to his immediate followers. ...With characteristic reticence Brown revealed his whole plan to no one, and many of those close to him received quite different impressions, or rather read their own ideas into Brown's careful speech."^[5]^: 262 Brown's planned raid on Harpers Ferry was laid out at the Chatham Convention, held in Chatham, Ontario, Canada, in 1858.^[7] The convention of mostly black delegates also adopted the measures of Brown's Provisional Constitution.

Printed certificates named the following as officers under the Provisional Constitution:

John Brown, Commander in Chief
John Henry Kagi, Secretary of War
George B. Gill, Secretary of the Treasury (reproduced at right)
Jeremiah G. Anderson, named Captain, October 1, 1859^[8]
William H. Leeman, named Captain, October 15, 1859 (reproduced at right)

It was not the constitution of a projected new state, for that it was made up of the mountainous regions of the mid-Atlantic states, that would join or seek to join the Union. He also denied, during his trial, the intent of revolting against the United States, of creating a new country. Sometimes he seems to want the same United States—he does describe it in the constitution's title as "for the people of the United States"—but with a better and anti-slavery constitution. This proposed one was only "provisional", which implies some sort of procedure to create a new, permanent constitution.

Under Brown's provisional constitution, there would be a unicameral legislature of no less than 5 nor more than 10 members, all chosen at large. There would be no senate.

Brown did not see setting up another government with a different constitution to be a revolt against the United States.

The Provisional Constitution was cited during the trial as evidence of his intent to commit treason.

Not one of the copies was ever distributed; even nearby enslaved persons did not receive copies. The reason for this has never been explained. Although it was reprinted, always with scorn, in the press, Brown was not asked about it by any of the many visitors he saw during the month (November 2–December 2, 1859) between being sentenced to death (in Virginia v. John Brown) and his execution.

Much of the Constitution was reprinted in many newspapers, such as the Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, shortly after his arrest.^[9]

In the pockets of William H. Leeman, one of the rebels killed at Harpers Ferry, was found a commission as captain "in the army established under the provisional constitution". It was signed by John Brown, Commander in Chief, at the "War Department, near Harpers Ferry", dated October 15. The commission was a preprinted form, with Leeman's name filled in by hand.^[10]

References

^ Tsai, Robert L. (January 2010). "John Brown's Constitution". Boston College Law Review. 51 (1): 151–207. Archived from the original on May 25, 2021. Retrieved March 20, 2021.
^ DeCaro, Louis A (2002). "Fire from the midst of you" : A Religious Life of John Brown. New York: New York University Press. p. 244. ISBN 9780814719220.
^ "John Brown's Interview in the Charlestown (or Charles Town) Prison". October 18, 1859. Archived from the original on June 16, 2019. Retrieved September 10, 2020.
^ Anderson, Osborne P. (1861). A Voice from Harpers Ferry; with incidents prior and subsequent to its capture by Capt. Brown and his men. Boston: The author. Archived from the original on 2015-10-31. Retrieved 2020-09-11.
^ ^a ^b Du Bois, W. E. Burghardt (1909). John Brown. (For the article on this biography, see John Brown (biography)). Philadelphia: George W. Jacobs.
^ Reynolds, David S. (2006). John Brown, abolitionist : the man who killed slavery, sparked the Civil War, and seeded civil rights. New York: Vintage Books. ISBN 0375726152.
^ "John Brown's Convention 1858". Historical Marker Database. Archived from the original on September 25, 2015. Retrieved September 23, 2022.
^ Brown, John (October 1, 1859), (Title unknown), Clipping from unidentified newspaper., archived from the original on July 20, 2021, retrieved September 12, 2020
^ "Further from Harper's Ferry!". Wheeling Daily Intelligencer. October 20, 1869. p. 3. Archived from the original on August 29, 2020. Retrieved August 18, 2020.
^ Our own reporter (19 October 1859). "The late rebellion". The Daily Exchange (Baltimore, Maryland). p. 1. Archived from the original on 1 September 2020. Retrieved 18 August 2020.

v t e John Brown's raid on Harpers Ferry
John Brown's raiders	Osborne Perry Anderson John Brown body Oliver Brown Owen Brown (son) Watson Brown John Anthony Copeland Jr. Barclay Coppock Edwin Coppock Shields Green Albert Hazlett John Henry Kagi Lewis Sheridan Leary Francis Jackson Meriam Dangerfield Newby Aaron Dwight Stevens
Secret Six	Thomas Wentworth Higginson Samuel Gridley Howe Theodore Parker Franklin Benjamin Sanborn Gerrit Smith George Luther Stearns
Other individuals	John Wilkes Booth Mary Ann Day Brown (wife) Owen Brown (father) John Brown, Jr. James Buchanan Samuel Chilton John E.P. Daingerfield Israel Greene George Henry Hoyt Andrew Hunter Stonewall Jackson Robert E. Lee James M. Mason Richard Parker Wendell Phillips Richard Realf James Redpath George Sennott Heyward Shepherd Lysander Spooner George H. Steuart J. E. B. Stuart Lewis Washington Walt Whitman Henry A. Wise
Locations	Allstadt House and Ordinary B & O Railroad Potomac River Crossing Beall-Air Charles Town, West Virginia Gibson-Todd House Harpers Ferry Armory Harpers Ferry, West Virginia Historic District John Brown's Fort Kennedy Farm Sandy Hook, Maryland Winchester, Virginia
Afterwards	Battle Hymn of the Republic Burning of Winchester Medical College Harpers Ferry National Historical Park Heyward Shepherd monument John Brown (biography) John Brown Farm State Historic Site John Brown Farm, Tannery & Museum John Brown House (Akron, Ohio) John Brown Museum (Osawatomie, Kansas) John Brown's body John Brown's Body (poem) John Brown's Body (song) John Brown's last speech John Brown's Provisional Constitution The Last Days of John Brown The Last Moments of John Brown A Plea for Captain John Brown Remarks After the Hanging of John Brown Tragic Prelude Virginia v. John Brown
Related	Abolitionism in the United States La Amistad Battle of Black Jack Battle of the Spurs James Madison Bell Bleeding Kansas Cloudsplitter John Stuart Curry George DeBaptiste Frederick Douglass Ralph Waldo Emerson Fire on the Mountain Wm. Lloyd Garrison The Good Lord Bird (book, miniseries) Haitian Revolution Victor Hugo Elijah P. Lovejoy Marching Song (play) James Montgomery Origins of the American Civil War Battle of Osawatomie Quindaro Townsite Allan Pinkerton Pottawatomie massacre Santa Fe Trail (film) Seven Angry Men Storer College Henry David Thoreau Harriet Tubman Nat Turner Denmark Vesey Wakarusa War Walt Whitman Winchester and Potomac Railroad

Creation of the constitution

Projected use of the Constitution

References

Further reading