Ralph Bristout of XXL said "Despite the notable joints, I'm Up is flooded with featured guests, whom often outshine the rapper ("Don't Make No Sense" next to Fabolous and 8Ball; "Scarface" alongside Scarface). Though they don't necessarily hurt the project— adding a mélange of different styles and various temperaments—the supporting cast makes the tape seem more like a compilation project than a solo."[1] Slava Kuperstein of HipHopDX said "Whatever criticisms fans may offer of Gucci Mane, the man works the mixtape scene hard. A cursory look at Wikipedia reveals that I'm Up is Gucci's 27th mixtape; not only that, but it's the second of this year. Sure, it's easier to have such prolific output when your subject matter is so narrow you could thread a needle with it, but Gucci delivers what the people want from him: a handful of hard-hitting beats, a few quotables, and some memorable guest spots."[2]
Music videos has been released for songs such as "Super Cocky",[3] "Kansas" featuring Jim Jones,[4] "Wish You Would" featuring Verse Simmonds,[5] "Brought Out Them Racks" featuring Big Sean,[6] "Plain Jane (Remix)" featuring Rocko and T.I.,[7] and "Too Sexy" featuring Jeremih.[8]