Gold Rush: Maybe One Day received three positive reviews from music critics. At AllMusic, Andy Kellman rated the album four stars, writing, "Murray offers his strongest and most focused solo set yet."[1] Dwayne Lacy of New Release Tuesday rated the album four-and-a-half stars, writing that "Dre keeps it real and relevant" with this release full of "masterful production and heavy lyrical content".[3] At Christian Music Zine, Anthony Peronto rated the album a perfect five stars, saying, "With no filler tracks, generic trap beats, or any hype songs made for workout sessions this isn't an album for the casual listen" because "Dre Murray has made one of the best albums of the year and it's a mature work that deserves attention."[2]