File talk:SnowballGeography.gif

This orphaned talk page, subpage, image page, or similar is not eligible for speedy deletion under CSD G8 as it has been asserted to be useful to Wikipedia.
If you believe it should be deleted, please nominate it on Wikipedia:Miscellany for deletion.

Fair use rationale

The fair use rationale has come under fire on the file page on the grounds that the file can reasonably be replaced.

However, Hyde et al.'s image is scientifically accurate. Its copyright licensing does not permit the construction of a derivative work. A non-derivative replacement that involved original modifications would by definition involve a deviation from the factual data used to generate Hyde et al.'s image, and thus be inappropriate for use in the article.

Martin (Smith609 – Talk) 16:53, 15 April 2010 (UTC)[reply]

Scientific data isn't copyrightable.^{[citation needed]} If it's possible to generate this map on the basis of Hyde et al.'s data, then a free version of this map could be created, without deviating from their data, without being a derived work, and without being OR. +An gr 17:05, 15 April 2010 (UTC)[reply]

Scientific data isn't copyrightable, but Hyde et al.'s map is. So a "free" version of this file cannot reasonably be replaced. --Philcha (talk) 17:55, 15 April 2010 (UTC)[reply]

This map is copyrighted. A different map could be generated from the same data set and licensed freely. +An gr 19:00, 15 April 2010 (UTC)[reply]

A table could be generated from the same data set and, if it uses the same conventions and layout, would be copyrighted. The principle works for a map. So a FUR is appropiate. --Philcha (talk) 21:02, 15 April 2010 (UTC)[reply]

Is the data used to generate this map publically available? If so, where? If not, then it is impossible to reproduce the map. Martin (Smith609 – Talk) 21:33, 15 April 2010 (UTC)[reply]