Draft talk:How to Succeed in Witchcraft (Aislinn Brophy)
Draft Article
[edit]This is a great start to your article & I know you'll be expanding on it once you have the book in hand again. See also the Book Reviews I shared with you via email. I'm concerned that Wikipedia Editors may not recognize GoodReads as a reliable source, so those other resources will really allow you to expand the contribution. 8/10 Christacraven (talk) 18:17, 14 October 2024 (UTC)
Peer review
[edit]The lead covers a lot of the topic, is extremely informative and well written.
the overall content is up to date and relevant to the content as well as being detailed on the characters. I think that each character could possibly be its own section if they have a big story/are main characters. You could possibly also include detail on the authors reasoning behind character choices, you can find information through interviews. Another section you can add is themes of the book and about the style of the book.
overall your tone is neutral and informative. You are following the guidelines for a new article, except Im not sure if some of your sources will be taken in as reliable.
I really love your organization and links you’ve put in your article. Sunflowerlvr1 (talk) 07:14, 21 October 2024 (UTC)