Coup of Hongxi
A coup of Hongxi (Chinese: 弘晳逆案) was an unsuccessful coup d'etat organised by Hongxi, Prince Li of the First Rank and the eldest surviving son of deposed crown prince Yunreng[1] and other co-conspirators, most of whom were sons of the imperial princes who did not participate in the succession brawl between Yinzhen, Yunzhi, Yunsi and their supporters.
The background
[edit]Yunreng's tenure as a crown prince
[edit]Yunreng was instated as the crown prince in 1675, having barely been one year old.[2] Yunreng married lady Guwalgiya (daughter of Shi Wenbing), lady Ligiya, Lady Lingiya, Lady Tanggiya and Lady Fangiya in 1695, with lady Gūwalgiya being instated as crown princess.[3] As Yunreng was instated as a crown prince, his children would be adopted into the imperial palace.
When Kangxi Emperor went on military campaign against Galdan Khan in 1696, Yunreng became a regent. At that time, he showed immoral behaviour, yet remained in the favour.[4] In 1703, Yunreng was implicated in the Songgotu's case of attempt to murder the Kangxi Emperor and stripped of his title.
In 1708, Yunzhi and Yunsi were stripped of their titles.[5] The members of the "Party of the Crown Prince" and Tong Guowei (Kangxi Emperor's maternal uncle) encouraged the emperor to reinstate Yunreng as the crown prince.[6] However, Yunreng was convicted of attempts to seize the throne for himself and deposed in 1712.[4] Yunreng died in 1725 and was posthumously honoured as Prince Limi of the First Rank.[7]
The controversy with heir apparent
[edit]The Qianlong Emperor ascended to the throne in 1735. In 1738, Qianlong Emperor's second son, Yonglian, died of smallpox. Qianlong Emperor decreed that the heir apparent to the throne would be the eldest son born to highest ranking consort. Qianlong Emperor's younger brother, Hongyan, was adopted into Prince Guo peerage.[8] According to the last will of the Kangxi Emperor, the fourth prince Yinzhen would ascend to the throne, while Hongxi would receive a title of the first ranking prince. The group of imperial princes supporting the Party of Crown Prince perverted the meaning of the imperial last will, changing the personal name of the Yongzheng Emperor into the name of deposed crown prince (Kangxi Emperor mentioned that Yinzhen's second surviving son, Hongli, should be instated as a crown prince). In 1739, that same group formed a fraction aimed at ousting Qianlong Emperor from power and settling their leader as a new emperor.
Participants
[edit]The list of participants included 5 princes of the 'hong' generation (Hongxi, Hongsheng, Hongpu, Hongchang, Hongjiao) and Yunlu. As Yunqi and Yunxiang died before 1739, Yunlu was implicated in the case. Yunli and the family members of the conspirators had nothing in common with the case,[9] except of Hongwei, the younger half-brother of the initiator.[10]
Hongxi
[edit]Hongxi (理親王 弘晳; 25 August 1694 – 26 October 1742) was the eldest surviving son of the deposed crown prince. Although Hongxi was born to secondary crown princess, lady Ligiya,[11] he was seen as a potential candidate to succeed his father. Hongxi was deeply favoured by the Kangxi Emperor since young as he was adopted into the imperial palace and raised as if he was an imperial son.[12]
When Yunreng was deposed for immorality, Kangxi Emperor mentioned that Hongxi has more virtue than his father and wouldn't replicate the latter's misconducts. Choson Korean ambassadors also described him as a virtuous and kind in 1714.[13] According to the last will of the Kangxi Emperor written down by Maci, Hongxi would be granted a title of the Prince of the First Rank, while Yinzhen would ascend to the throne.
Hongxi inherited the Prince Li peerage as the second-ranking prince in 1722. In 1723, Yongzheng Emperor ordered to convert the Villa of the Zheng Family with surrounding barracks into the princely manor. When Hongxi paid his respects together with princess consort, Prince Yu of the First Rank Baotai, Prince Zhuang of the First Rank Yunlu, Prince Heng of the First Rank Yunqi, Minister of the Imperial Household Laibao (of the Hitara clan) and other ministers reported on a personnel of the newly built Prince Li manor.[14] In 1728, Hongxi was promoted to Prince of the First Rank.[15] In 1731, he was present at the funeral of Empress Xiaojingxian.[16] In 1735, when Yongzheng Emperor felt gravely ill in the Old Summer Palace, Hongli was made crown prince and ordered to proclaim the emperor's last will.[17] After the funeral ceremony, at that Hongxi and his paternal uncle Yunyi presided, Hongli ascended to the throne as the Qianlong Emperor.[18]
Hongsheng
[edit]Hongsheng (弘升;1696-1754) was the son of Yunqi, Prince Heng. In 1719, Hongsheng was granted a title of hereditary prince Heng of the First Rank (世子). Hongsheng received an appointment in the imperial stables and supervised the affairs of the Bordered White Banner.[19] In 1727, Hongsheng was stripped of his title because of mistrust. In 1735, Hongsheng was appointed as a commander of Artillery.[20]
Hongpu
[edit]Hongpu (弘普) was the second son of Yunlu, Prince Zhuangke of the First Rank born to secondary princess consort, lady Li. In 1736, Hongpu was granted a title of prince of the fourth rank.[21]
Hongjiao
[edit]Hongjiao (寧良郡王 弘晈; 17 June 1713 – 9 September 1764) was the fourth son of Yinxiang, Prince Yi of the First Rank born to primary princess consort Yixian. In 1730, Hongjiao was granted a title of Prince Ning of the Second Rank. Hongjiao was one of the candidates to inherit the iron-cap Prince Yi of the First Rank peerage. As Hongjiao was given a new princely title, Hongxiao, the seventh son of Yinxiang, inherited the title.[22]
Hongchang
[edit]Hongchang (貝勒 弘昌; 14 December 1706 – 3 June 1771) was the eldest son of Yinxiang, born to secondary princess consort Yixian, lady Gūwalgiya. Hongchang received the title of the prince of the fourth rank in 1723 and was promoted to the prince of the third rank in 1725. As the eldest son, Hongchang could inherit the Prince Yi peerage, but was found unsuitable because of his mental abilities.[23] Hongchang shared a close relationship with Hongsheng, a son of Prince Heng of the First Rank Yunqi.[24]
Yunlu
[edit]Yunlu (允禄; 28 July 1695 – 20 March 1767) was Kangxi Emperor's 16th surviving son by Consort Shunyimi, lady Wang. In 1723, Yunlu was adopted into the Prince Zhuang peerage as Boguoduo died without a male heir.[25] Yunlu was not involved in the succession brawl among the sons of the Kangxi Emperor, like Yuntao, Yunxu, Yunli, Yunqi, Yunyou and other princes who haven't come of age.[26] Due to little difference in age with Hongxi, Yunlu would normally belong to the "hong" generation.[27]
The plan of the coup
[edit]In 1739, Hongxi, Hongsheng, Hongchang and Hongjiao met at the Prince Zhuang manor and formed there a faction. Yunlu hesitated to agree with the postulate to oust Qianlong Emperor from power because he wielded an immense authority among the clansmen. However, as Yunlu said, the faction members could have been unable to commit that kind of revolution. Instead of Yunlu, Hongpu joined the fraction.[26] Hongxi was chosen as the most suitable candidate as the son of deposed crown prince by the claim that Kangxi Emperor had high hopes for him.[27]
The rebels planned to accomplish their coup d'etat during the 1739 imperial hunt at the Mulan hunting grounds. Hongxi appeared in the hunt in neapolitan yellow palanquin, which led the rebels to believe that he is the emperor. The rebels said that Dzungar Khanate could not have dared to defeat Beijing and attempted to proclaim him as an emperor.[28]
Hongchang ordered Hongxi to return to the capital so as to prepare for the coronation. Hongpu dispatched a messenger to report an urgent matter to the emperor, but was arrested at the Copper Wall by imperial guards.[29] During the arrest, only Hongchang pleaded his innocence.[30] The plan of the faction failed at that moment.
Trial and the punishments
[edit]The rebelliants were temporarily enclosed in the Imperial Clan Court, where the trial was held. One of the persons interrogating rebelliants was Ba'ertu, Prince Kang of the First Rank,[Note 1] who had been entrusted with the affairs of the imperial clan court.[31] Another interrogator was Fupeng, Prince Ping of the Second Rank.[Note 2] The proper decree was drafted by Ba'ertu and Zhang Tingyu, one of the most prominent officials of the Qianlong era.[32]
Punishments of Hongxi
[edit]- Deprivation of the title of Prince of the First Rank
- Banishment from the imperial clan
- Renaming as "Sishiliu" (四十六[Note 3])
- Imprisonment at the Eastern Garden near Jingshan park
- Removal from the imperial genealogy[33]
The punishments received by Hongxi were comparable to the punishments received by Yunsi or Yuntang. Hongxi's daughters and consorts were spared from punishments.
Punishments of Hongsheng
[edit]Hongsheng was co-organisator of the rebellion. As he was once stripped of his title, he received following punishment:
- Perpetual imprisonment[34]
Punishment of Hongchang
[edit]- Deprivation of the title of Prince of the Third Rank[35]
Punishment of Hongpu
[edit]- Demotion to the grace defender duke[36]
Punishment of Hongjiao
[edit]Hongjiao did not play major role in the clique.
- Deprivation of salary[34]
Punishment of Yunlu
[edit]Yunlu disagreed with postulates of rebels. Nevertheless, his son was included in the list of fractionists.
- Dismission from the official position.[35]
The fate of the rebels
[edit]Hongxi died in captivity in 1742, having been 49 years old. Hongxi's title was passed to Hongwei, who was posthumously honoured as Prince Like of the Second Rank.[37]
Hongchang never recovered his beile title and died on 3 June 1771.[38]
Hongjiao held several appointments until 1759, when he was stripped of his position in the Ministry of Revenue due to several delicts.[39] His relatives were not implicated in the case. Most of his time Hongjiao dedicated to poetry.
Hongsheng died in 1754 and was posthumously honoured as Prince Gongke of the Third Rank (恭恪贝勒, meaning "reverent and respectful").[40]
Hongpu was designated as a right vice director of the Imperial Clan Court in 1740. Hongpu died in 1743 and was posthumously honoured as Hereditary Prince Gongqin (恭勤世子, "gongqin" meaning "respectful and diligent").
Yunlu supervised a court of imperial music and completely lost trust of the Qianlong Emperor. In 1759-1766, Yunlu compiled the "Illustrated Precedents for the Ritual Paraphernalia of the imperial Court", a holistic publication concerning items necessary for the ceremonies of the imperial court in 18 volumes.[41] Yunlu died in 1768 and his title was passed to Yongchang, Hongpu's son.[42]
Revival
[edit]In 1778, Qianlong Emperor restored the original names of Yunsi, Yuntang and Hongxi and allowed their descendants to be recorded in the imperial genealogy. However, the emperor did not revoke the decrees depriving those princes of their titles. In 1783, when the imperial chronicles were commissioned, the historians were ordered to emphasise the role of the emperor in quelling the rebellion and to mention that "Hongxi and others wanted to usurp the throne".[43]
References
[edit]Sources
[edit]- ^ "详细资料介绍_爱新觉罗宗谱网". www.axjlzp.com. Retrieved 2021-02-12.
- ^ 《聖祖仁皇帝實錄 卷之五十八 》/ "Veritable records of the Sagacious Ancestor, Emperor Ren". Vol. 58.
- ^ 《宮中檔康熙朝奏摺》.
- ^ a b 《聖祖仁皇帝實錄》.
- ^ "Veritable records of the Sagacious Ancestor, Emperor Ren". Vol. 235.
- ^ 《明清檔案》. Vol. 39. p. 176.
- ^ Feng, Qili. 《重訪清代王爺墳》/ "Revisiting the tombs of the QIng dynasty imperial princes". Beijing: Yanshan Press.
- ^ Ting, Lina (2013). 河北易縣嶺東村果恭郡王弘瞻園寢寶頂主人考. 中國河北省石家莊市/Shijiazhuang city, Hebei prefecture, China: 文物春秋.
- ^ Zhou, Ruchang (2009). "Between Noble and Humble: Cao Xueqin and the Dream of the Red Chamber". Peter Lang. p. 143.
- ^ 皇朝文獻通考/ "Comprehensive research of the imperial dynasty". Vol. 140.
- ^ "详细资料介绍_爱新觉罗宗谱网". www.axjlzp.com. Retrieved 2021-02-13.
- ^ 《聖祖仁皇帝御製文集》.
- ^ 《朝鲜王朝李朝实录》/"Chronicles of the Li dynasty of the Choson Kingdom".
- ^ 《雍正朝滿文硃批奏摺全譯347頁》. p. 347.
- ^ 《清世宗憲皇帝實錄》/ "The Chronicles of the Perpetual Ancestor, Emperor Xian".
- ^ 《清世宗憲皇帝實錄》/ "The Chronicles of the Perpetual Ancestor, Emperor Xian". Vol. 111.
- ^ 《雍正朝起居注册》/ "Documents of the Yongzheng era".
- ^ 《高宗純皇帝實錄》.
- ^ Tong, Jiajiang. "A revision of the "Draft History of Qing" ". p. 436.
- ^ 清代全史/"Complete History of Qing Dynasty". Vol. 4. 1991. p. 89.
- ^ 清高宗乾隆. 2013.
- ^ Tian, Shuhe (2018). 北京市區主要街道景觀導覽. 崧博出版事業有限公司.
- ^ Wang, Shuqing; Wan, Yi; Liu, Lu (1990). 清代宫廷史. Liaoning Public Press. p. 235.
- ^ Feng, Jingzhi (2003). The art of weaving in the Qing. Chunfeng Cultural Press. p. 624.
- ^ 梅卅人物传. 1990. p. 22.
- ^ a b Hua, Bin (2018). 大清高宗純皇帝乾隆. 千華駐科技出版有限公司.
- ^ a b 世界伟人传记丛书（上）（套装共8册）/ "The most powerful of the World". 青苹果数据中心. 2015.
- ^ Hui/惠, Huanzhang/焕章 (2004). 汉光武帝刘秀百谜/中国帝王百谜系列/ "Enigma of the Emperor Guang of Han Liu Xiubai/100 Secrets of the Chinese Emperors". Shaanxi: 陕西旅游出版社. p. 30.
- ^ Gao, Yang (2001). 三春爭及初春景/Fight in the spring scenery. 生活・讀書・新知三联书店. p. 686.
- ^ Gao, Yang (2001). "Fight in the spring scenery"/三春爭及初春景. Vol. 3. 生活・讀書・新知三联书店. p. 677.
- ^ Dong (董), Yiqiu (一秋) (2003). 10 great writers of China. Cao Xueqin / 中国十大文豪曹雪芹. Beijing Book Co. Inc.
- ^ Feng, Jingzhi (2003). "A weaving art of Great Qing". 春风文艺出版社. p. 1020.
- ^ 《高宗純皇帝實錄》. Vol. 106.
- ^ a b "Qianlong Reign|The Palace Museum". en.dpm.org.cn. Retrieved 2021-02-13.
- ^ a b Chen (陈), Jiexian (捷先) (2010). "Real Qianlong". 遠流出版. p. 62.
- ^ Feng, Jingzhi. The art of weaving in the Qing. Chunfeng Cultural Press. p. 1065.
- ^ "详细资料介绍_爱新觉罗宗谱网". www.axjlzp.com. Retrieved 2021-02-13.
- ^ "详细资料介绍_爱新觉罗宗谱网". www.axjlzp.com. Retrieved 2021-02-13.
- ^ "A decree dismissing Prince Ning of the Second Rank Hongjiao from his duties in the Ministry of Revenue".
- ^ "详细资料介绍_爱新觉罗宗谱网". www.axjlzp.com. Retrieved 2021-02-13.
- ^ "《皇朝礼器图式》 - 故宫博物院". www.dpm.org.cn. Retrieved 2021-02-13.
- ^ Zhao, Erxun (1928). 《清史稿 卷一百六十四 表四》/"Draft History of Qing". Vol. 164, table 4.
- ^ 《高宗純皇帝實錄》. Vol. 1048.