Complemented group

In mathematics, in the realm of group theory, the term complemented group is used in two distinct, but similar ways.

In (Hall 1937), a complemented group is one in which every subgroup has a group-theoretic complement. Such groups are called completely factorizable groups in the Russian literature, following (Baeva 1953) and (Černikov 1953).

The following are equivalent for any finite group G:

• G is complemented
• G is a subgroup of a direct product of groups of square-free order (a special type of Z-group)
• G is a supersolvable group with elementary abelian Sylow subgroups (a special type of A-group), (Hall 1937, Theorem 1 and 2).

Later, in (Zacher 1953), a group is said to be complemented if the lattice of subgroups is a complemented lattice, that is, if for every subgroup H there is a subgroup K such that H ∩ K = 1 and ⟨H, K ⟩ is the whole group. Hall's definition required in addition that H and K permute, that is, that HK = { hk : h in H, k in K } form a subgroup. Such groups are also called K-groups in the Italian and lattice theoretic literature, such as (Schmidt 1994, pp. 114–121, Chapter 3.1). The Frattini subgroup of a K-group is trivial; if a group has a core-free maximal subgroup that is a K-group, then it itself is a K-group; hence subgroups of K-groups need not be K-groups, but quotient groups and direct products of K-groups are K-groups, (Schmidt 1994, pp. 115–116). In (Costantini & Zacher 2004) it is shown that every finite simple group is a complemented group. Note that in the classification of finite simple groups, K-group is more used to mean a group whose proper subgroups only have composition factors amongst the known finite simple groups.

An example of a group that is not complemented (in either sense) is the cyclic group of order p², where p is a prime number. This group only has one nontrivial subgroup H, the cyclic group of order p, so there can be no other subgroup L to be the complement of H.

References

• Baeva, N. V. (1953), "Completely factorizable groups", Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR, New Series, 92: 877–880, MR 0059275
• Černikov, S. N. (1953), "Groups with systems of complementary subgroups", Doklady Akademii Nauk SSSR, New Series, 92: 891–894, MR 0059276
• Costantini, Mauro; Zacher, Giovanni (2004), "The finite simple groups have complemented subgroup lattices", Pacific Journal of Mathematics, 213 (2): 245–251, doi:10.2140/pjm.2004.213.245, hdl:11577/1341437, ISSN 0030-8730, MR 2036918
• Hall, Philip (1937), "Complemented groups", J. London Math. Soc., 12 (3): 201–204, doi:10.1112/jlms/s1-12.2.201, Zbl 0016.39301
• Schmidt, Roland (1994), Subgroup Lattices of Groups, Expositions in Math, vol. 14, Walter de Gruyter, ISBN 978-3-11-011213-9, MR 1292462
• Zacher, Giovanni (1953), "Caratterizzazione dei gruppi risolubili d'ordine finito complementati", Rendiconti del Seminario Matematico della Università di Padova, 22: 113–122, ISSN 0041-8994, MR 0057878