C Case
| C Case | |
|---|---|
| Court | High Court (Ireland) |
| Full case name | A and B, Applicants, v. Eastern Health Board, District Judge Mary Fahy and C, Respondents and The Attorney General, Notice Party |
| Started | 28 November 1997 |
| Decided | 25 November 1997 |
| Citation | [1998] 1 IR 464; [1998] 1 ILRM 460 |
| Court membership | |
| Judge sitting | Hugh Geoghegan |
| Keywords | |
| |
A and B v Eastern Health Board, commonly known as the C Case, was a legal case in Ireland on whether a thirteen-year-old girl (known as C), who had become pregnant as a result of rape and was suicidal, could be permitted to travel abroad to obtain an abortion. She was in the care of the Eastern Health Board (EHB), an organ of the Irish state, and the abortion was resisted by her parents, the applicants in the case. Abortion law in Ireland at the time of the case made abortion inaccessible within Ireland; however, in the X Case (1992), the Supreme Court had ruled that abortion was permissible under the Constitution where there was a threat to a woman's life, including a risk of suicide.
Facts
[edit]Ms C was brutally raped by an adult male (Simon McGinley) on 27 August 1997, and became pregnant as a result. She is a member of the travelling community and one of a family of twelve. The perpetrator was also of the travelling community and a long-standing friend of the family. The evidence before the District Court indicated that she lived in particularly squalid conditions which were quite unlike the conditions in which most Travellers lived. The court believed that the girl was very severely traumatised by the rape. The girl was in the care of the Eastern Health Board (EHB) under the Child Care Act 1991. She had become suicidal and the EHB made a court application to bring her to the UK for an abortion.[1]
Law
[edit]Abortion was illegal in Ireland at the time of the case. It was prohibited under sections 58 and 59 of the Offences against the Person Act 1861, and Article 40.3.3° of the Constitution of Ireland protected the right to life of the unborn. The substantive clause was added by the Eighth Amendment of the Constitution in 1983. A further clause was added by the Thirteenth Amendment in 1992 in response to the X Case, protecting the freedom to travel to another state to obtain an abortion.
Court case
[edit]On 21 November 1997, the District Court made an order that C could leave the state.[1] The parents challenged this order in the High Court. Judge Hugh Geoghegan upheld the original order, allowing the EHB to bring her to the UK for an abortion.[1][2] The court relied on the judgment in the X Case and on the Thirteenth Amendment.
Aftermath
[edit]Ms C had an abortion in the UK in December 1997, accompanied by two officers from the Garda Síochána and her EHB guardian.[3] Her parents were opposed to the abortion, and communicated regularly with Youth Defence.[3]
On 18 December 1998, Simon McGinley was sentenced to 12 years imprisonment after pleading guilty to the rape of thirteen-year-old Ms. C, with Judge John Quirke suspending the final four years on condition that McGinley undergo sex offenders therapy in prison.[4]
Reaction
[edit]The Roman Catholic Archbishop of Dublin, Desmond Connell, strongly criticised the ruling;[5][6][7] however, he declined to fund a Supreme Court challenge.[8]
I have many concerns about the decision... I have deep reservations about the re-affirmation by the courts of the notion that there are circumstances where abortion is medically justifiable. The testimony in the X Case, relating to suicidal tendencies, was already controversial.
— Desmond Connell, "Archbishop's deep sadness at 'amazing' court decision". Irish Independent. 29 November 1997. p. 13.
Archbishop Connell claimed that abortion caused mental health problems:
at a psychiatric level, abortion would appear to cause more problems than it solves, even were we to judge the issue on its medical implications alone. One this last point, it is clear from the significant risk of psychological problems following abortion, particularly among those who have abortions in their teens or who are ambivalent and/or unsupported, that this unhappy child would be better served if she received the highest degree of medical and psychological support along with the continuation of her pregnancy.
— Desmond Connell, "Archbishop's deep sadness at 'amazing' court decision". Irish Independent. 29 November 1997. p. 13.
Youth Defence picketed the home of EHB Chair Róisín Shortall because she did not stop the case.[9]
The Pro Life Campaign criticised the EHB, and called for a full inquiry.[10]
Legacy
[edit]The woman at the centre of the case has occasionally spoken about her experiences, but not revealed her identity. She found the abortion traumatic, and did not understand what was going on at the time. She did not know that she would be getting an abortion, and thought that the hospital was going to deliver her baby. She eventually named and sought a death certificate for the aborted child. She has expressed that she wishes the child would have been put up for adoption. She made numerous attempts on her own life following the procedure, but eventually gave birth to a son who helps keep her mentally stable.[11][12][13]
It has been living with me, still to this day it’s living with me. There is still stuff to this day with nightmares, I can’t sleep and I’m on medication. I’m still living in fear, fear all the time. No one understands how you feel, how a rape victim feels after being raped. It never goes away no matter how people say it does. It lives with you constantly. Fears and everything that goes with, the nightmares, the whole lot
— C
Post Trial Developments
[edit]Simon McGinley was released from Arbour Hill Prison in November 2003.[14] In 2009, McGinley was sentenced to 21 years in prison after being found guilty of the rape of an 86-year-old woman in Monaghan the previous year.[15] McGinley was again released from Arbour Hill prison in September 2022 and thereafter moved to the Dundalk area,[16] with the conditions of his release resulting in him being banned from engaging in door-to-door sales and from cold calling to stranger's houses.[17]
McGinley was remanded in custody to Cloverhill Prison in August 2023 after alleged breaches of the conditions of his release, relating to him cold calling to a house regarding the sale of a car and intimidating a teenage girl who lived there. McGinley was also accused of breaching the conditions of the Sex Offenders Act in February 2023 at an address in Skerries, where he was caught power washing the driveway of an elderly lady.[17] In January 2024, McGinley pleaded guilty to breaching the conditions of his release and had the 15-month suspended sentence imposed from his 2009 rape conviction activated by Dundalk Circuit Court.[citation needed]
The 2018 abortion referendum, held in May 2018, approved an amendment replacing the wording of Article 40.3.3° with a permissive clause allowing legislation by the Oireachtas. Legislation regulating abortion, the Health (Regulation of Termination of Pregnancy) Act 2018, was enacted in December 2018. Abortion services began on 1 January 2019.
See also
[edit]References
[edit]- ^ a b c "A. and B. v. Eastern Health Board [1997] IEHC 176; [1998] 1 IR 464; [1998] 1 ILRM 460 (28 November, 1997)".
- ^ "After the C Case". The Irish Times. 29 November 1997. p. 17.
- ^ a b Newman, Christine (4 December 1997). "13-year-old rape victim had abortion in England yesterday". The Irish Times. p. 4. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
- ^ Mac Ruairi, Tomas (18 December 1998). "Judge jails C case rapist for 'dreadful evil act'". Irish Independent. p. 7. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
- ^ "Connell criticises court's decision". The Irish Times. 29 November 1997. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
- ^ Connell, Desmond (29 November 1997). "Archbishop's deep sadness at 'amazing' court decision". Irish Independent. p. 13.
- ^ O'Regan, Eilish; Maddock, John; Glennon, Chris (29 November 1997). "Church alarm at girl's abortion freedom". Irish Independent. p. 1.
- ^ McKenna, Gene; O'Toole, Bernie (1 December 1997). "Archbishop rejects plea to fund abortion challenge". Irish Independent. p. 1.
- ^ Coulter, Carol (5 December 1997). "Youth Defence plans more protests". The Irish Times. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
- ^ Kennedy, Geraldine (18 December 1997). "Pro-Life Campaign wants inquiry on health board's handling of C case". The Irish Times. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
- ^ O'Doherty, Gemma (5 May 2013). "C-Case mum: I grieve for my lost baby every day". Irish Independent. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
- ^ "C-CASE GIRL SPEAKS OUT". Life Institute. Archived from the original on 17 August 2016. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
- ^ "'Still to this day it's living with me ... I'm still living in fear, fear all the time'". The Irish Times. 18 July 2009. p. 9. Retrieved 2 August 2016.
- ^ "'C Case' rapist jailed for 21 years". Irish Examiner. 15 July 2009.
- ^ Holland, Kitty (18 July 2009). "21-year sentence 'was a bit of relief". The Irish Times. p. 9. Retrieved 19 August 2009.
- ^ "Notorious double rapist Simon McGinley back on road in battered jeep after prison release". Sunday World. 15 November 2022.
- ^ a b "Double rapist Simon McGinley has charge struck out after witness fails to show up in court". Sunday World. 5 January 2024.
