Alfred Hitchcock Presents season 1

Alfred Hitchcock Presents aired 39 episodes during its first season from 1955 to 1956.

Episodes

No. in series	No. in season	Title	Directed by	Written by	Stars	Original air date
1	1	"Revenge"	Alfred Hitchcock	Story by : Samuel Blas Teleplay by : Francis Cockrell	Ralph Meeker as Carl Spann, Vera Miles as Elsa Spann	October 2, 1955 (1955-10-02)
Carl Spann (Meeker) wakes up early for his first day at a new job and makes his wife Elsa (Miles) breakfast. Carl briefly speaks with neighbor Mrs. Fergusen (Bavier) before driving to work, and Mrs. Fergusen offers to take Elsa to market, as Elsa has nothing to do in their new location by the sea, having been given advice by doctors to take a break after having a nervous breakdown. While Carl is at work, Elsa is apparently attacked and left traumatized by an intruder, claiming to be a salesman, in their trailer park home, as Carl comes home to a burning cake and Elsa in a state of shock. After reporting it to police officers (Willis and Daheim), two lieutenants (Teal and Lytton) take over handling the case. After talking to Elsa's doctor (Gallaudet), Carl decides to take Elsa on a vacation. Later, while driving in town, Elsa points out a man in a gray suit (Montgomery) as her attacker. Seeking revenge, an enraged Carl follows the man and kills him in his hotel room with a wrench, and a maid (O'Malley) quickly finds the body. However, a little later Elsa, still mentally disturbed, identifies another man as her attacker, leading Carl to realize, too late, that he might have killed an innocent man, just as the police close in on them. Elsa is taken away to a mental hospital while Carl is tried, convicted, and sentenced to prison for taking the law into his own hands. Supporting cast: Frances Bavier as Mrs. Fergusen, John Gallaudet as Doctor, Ray Teal as Police Lieutenant, Herbert Lytton as Police Lieutenant, Ray Montgomery as Man in Gray Suit, Norman Willis as Cop, John Daheim (credited as John Day) as Cop, Lillian O'Malley as Hotel Maid
2	2	"Premonition"	Robert Stevens	Harold Swanton	John Forsythe as Kim Stanger, Warren Stevens as Perry Stanger, Cloris Leachman as Susan Stanger	October 9, 1955 (1955-10-09)
Kim Stanger (Forsythe) returns home to the U.S. after four years in Rome and Paris, hoping to reunite with his estranged father, Greg, who has not answered any of his letters. After being dropped off by local cabbie Mason (Brinegar), he runs into old acquaintance Douglas Irwin (MacReady), his sister-in-law's father, who is quite surprised to see him and tries to get Kim to call his family first. Upon returning home, he learns that his father died four years ago (1950) of a heart attack on the tennis court, a fact that his brother Perry (Stevens) and sister-in-law Susan (Leachman) did not tell him. Kim suspects foul play, as Perry inherited everything in the will and Kim finds a hunting license dated after Greg supposedly died in that October, so he inquires with Irwin, who says that Perry just got the date wrong. Kim then goes to see a cemetery official, Gerald Eaton (Helton), whom he pressures to let him see the body, Eaton admitting that there is no body in the coffin. Next, Kim sees the coroner, Isaiah Dobbs (Tyler), who claims ignorance because the former coroner retired, stating that three men (Greg, Irwin, and Greg's son) went hunting, and only two returned alive. Kim eventually learns from Susan that he is the one who killed his father, and the family staged the incident and bribed people to make it look like an accident. He has been in an Arizona mental hospital for four years and his memories of Paris are just a delusion. Supporting cast: George MacReady as Douglas Irwin, Percy Helton as Gerald Eaton, Paul Brinegar as Mason, Harry Tyler as Isaiah Dobbs
3	3	"Triggers in Leash"	Don Medford	Story by : Allen Vaughn Elston Teleplay by : Dick Carr	Ellen Corby as Old Maggie Ryan, Gene Barry as Del Delaney, Darren McGavin as Red Hillman	October 16, 1955 (1955-10-16)
Old Maggie Ryan (Corby) promises to fix a wonderful meal to Ben Morgan (MacGregor) if he will get to work during a very rainy day. Cowboy Dell Delaney (Barry) arrives shortly afterward, desiring a warm respite from the storm, and proceeds to scare the life out of Ben by drawing his gun on him when Ben brings in some firewood. Another cowboy, Red Hillman (McGavin), soon shows up at Old Maggie's roadhouse, and the two cowboys threaten a shoot-out over a poker game and intoxication from the night before. Maggie, widow to a renowned gunfighter, does her best to negotiate a peace, threatening to tell the sheriff that whoever shoots first is a murderer, and she eventually convinces them to only shoot each other when the clock strikes. All she requests is to hold the giant cross that her husband gave her on their wedding day, which sits next to the clock on the shelf. When the clock mysteriously stops, the men take it to be a sign from God and leave peacefully. The light-hearted ending is enhanced by an explanation from Ben of why the clock stops, as it is the cross that keeps the shelf level, enabling the clock to function properly. Supporting cast: Casey MacGregor as Ben Morgan
4	4	"Don't Come Back Alive"	Robert Stevenson	Robert Dennis	Sidney Blackmer as Frank Partridge	October 23, 1955 (1955-10-23)
Financially strapped couple Frank (Blackmer) and Mildred Partridge (Gregg) scheme to have Mildred "disappear" for seven years and be declared legally dead in order to collect Mildred's $25,000 life insurance policy. Frank got a sales job, but it won't start until next month, and bills are due. They rush to take Mildred to the bus station to "disappear", as Mildred's sister Lucy (Tedrow) will soon stop by to pick up Mildred. Insurance investigator Mr. Kettle (Emhardt) suspects that Frank killed Mildred, and his constant hounding of Frank means that the couple must not be in contact with each other. They have to carefully meet at the local library and avoid being seen by the librarian (Holland), and Frank suggests that Mildred go to San Francisco. Two days before the seven years is up, Frank is visited by Mildred, who has moved on with her life. She wants a divorce and an end to the scheme, and she is willing to pay off Frank for $1500. In a rage, Frank bludgeons her to death and buries her in his garden. On the seventh anniversary, as Frank is going to court, Kettle returns to congratulate Frank for "winning" and offers to help him with his garden. Supporting cast: Virginia Gregg as Mildred Partridge, Robert Emhardt as Mr. Kettle, Irene Tedrow as Lucy, Edna Holland as Librarian
5	5	"Into Thin Air" "The Vanishing Lady"	Don Medford	Marian Cockrell	Pat Hitchcock as Diana Winthrop	October 30, 1955 (1955-10-30)
Paris, 1899. British Mrs. Winthrop (Forbes) and her daughter Diana (Hitchcock) are on their way home from India via France, and check into a Paris hotel when finally given a room by the clerk (Marsac). Mrs. Winthrop falls suddenly ill while the bellhop (d'Arno), porter (Camlin), and maid (Gaylor) check them in their room, and the hotel doctor (Mylong) sends Diana to his home for medicine from his wife (Codee). When Diana returns, the front-desk clerk and other hotel employees profess to have no recollection of her, nor is there any record that the Winthrops were ever there. Diana goes to the embassy and speaks with the ambassador, Sir Everett (Napier), but her story is believed only by Basil Farnham (Toone). Basil sends an administrator, Maris (Hadlow), to check on the basic details given by Diana and Basil examines the "medicine" only to find it is actually Vittel water, which Diana had to wait two hours to receive. The doctor's wife even claimed to have no telephone, but Diana heard it ring upon leaving. Diana and Basil go back to the hotel and demand to see the room, which is very different from Diana's precise description, but Diana decides to stay there after seeing a painter in the lobby. She asks to see the room in question and rips off the new wallpaper, proving that there is a conspiracy at hand. The cover-up is revealed by Sir Everett to have been set in place by the French government, because Mrs. Winthrop, who is now dead, had the bubonic plague. Based on the Legend of the Vanishing Lady. Supporting cast: Mary Forbes as Mrs. Herbert Winthrop, Alan Napier as Sir Everett, Geoffrey Toone as Basil Farnham, Michael Hadlow as Maris, Maurice Marsac as Hotel Clerk, John Mylong as the Hotel Doctor, Ann Codee as Doctor's Wife, Albert d'Arno as Bellhop, Peter Camlin as Porter, Gerry Gaylor as Maid, Jack Chefe as Detective
6	6	"Salvage"	Justus Addiss	Story by : Fred Freiberger Teleplay by : Fred Freiberger & Dick Carr	Gene Barry as Dan Varrel, Nancy Gates as Lois Williams	November 6, 1955 (1955-11-06)
Lois Williams (Gates) goes to a high-class bar and fends off a drunk (Montgomery) in order to get the bartender (Wayne) to find Lou Henry (Bryar), as she expects recently released convict Dan Varrel (Barry) to kill her as revenge for her causing his brother Ritchie's death by giving police robbery evidence and Ritchie's location. Then she goes to see her ex-boyfriend Tim Grady (Adams) and confesses her fear, which he rejects as hysterics, though he offers to pay her way back home to Springfield, Massachusetts. When Dan visits her apartment later, he is surprised when Lois refuses to put up a fight and shows no fear, as she believes that she has nothing to live for and no one to turn to. When he says that he would be doing her a favor by killing her, he seemingly has a change of heart and offers her a business deal to help him look legitimate to the police. Lois sets up a boutique, hiring Mary (Cooper), Hilda (Angold), and a model (Christine). To help fund the shop, Dan visits Lou for a loan of $5000. There, he receives a lot of criticism from fellow criminal Shorty (Cook Jr.) for working with Lois. After months of hard work, the dress shop is launched successfully, and Lois and Dan celebrate with a big party with numerous guests (Farnum, Brooks). Dan also convinces money-hungry Tim to reconcile with her under the belief that she is now wealthy, and Tim proposes. Lois, now happy and full of life, expresses her gratitude, but Dan reveals that he did all of it so that Lois would not want to die. Now he can kill her with satisfaction, which he does by shooting her to death the moment he's done talking. Supporting cast: Peter Adams as Tim Grady, Paul Bryar as Lou Henry, Elisha Cook Jr. as Shorty, Maxine Cooper as Mary, Edit Angold as Hilda, Virginia Christine as Model, Billy Wayne as Bartender, Ralph Montgomery as Drunk, Franklyn Farnum as Party Guest (uncredited), Ralph Brooks as Party Guest (uncredited)
7	7	"Breakdown"	Alfred Hitchcock	Story by : Louis Pollock Teleplay by : Francis Cockrell & Louis Pollock	Joseph Cotten as William Callew	November 13, 1955 (1955-11-13)
Cynical movie producer William Callew (Cotten) dictates a letter to his secretary while relaxing in the sun with friend Ed Johnson (Bailey). Callew fires a long-time employee, Hubka (Stanley), over the phone and scoffs at his crying. Later while driving on a rural detour, Callew gets into a car accident and is completely paralyzed (other than being able to move his left pinky finger) after crashing into a prison guard (Weldon) and multiple vehicles. He is robbed by escaped convicts (Spelling, Emanuel, one other) who ignore him and leave him for dead. Two more convicts (Edwards and Ragan) come by shortly afterward and take his clothes. Finally, the sheriff (Chandler) arrives after catching a prisoner. At the morgue, worker Lloyd (Alper) and the ambulance driver (Newton) discuss the escape, and the coroner (Landers) and his assistant (Peters) order William to be left for the night. Just when Callew is about to be declared legally dead, he saves himself at the last minute by getting the attention of Dr. Harner (Shannon) and his friend Chessy (Press) with his tears. Supporting cast: Raymond Bailey as Ed Johnson, Forrest Stanley as Hubka, Harry Shannon as Dr. Harner, Murray Alper as Lloyd, Marvin Press as Chessy, Lane Chandler as Sheriff, James Edwards as Convict, Aaron Spelling as Road Worker Convict, Harry Landers as Coroner, Jimmy Weldon as Guard, Mike Ragan as Escaped Convict, Elzie Emanuel as Black Escaped Convict, Ralph Peters as the Coroner's Assistant, Richard Newton as Ambulance Driver Note: The actress who played Callew's secretary is uncredited and currently unknown.
8	8	"Our Cook's a Treasure"	Robert Stevens	Story by : Dorothy L. Sayers Teleplay by : Robert C. Dennis	Everett Sloane as Ralph Montgomery, Beulah Bondi as Mrs. Sutton	November 20, 1955 (1955-11-20)
With a serial-murderer maid called Mrs. Andrews on the loose in the city, Ralph Montgomery (Sloane) becomes suspicious of his and his actress wife Ethel (Ward)'s housemaid, Mrs. Sutton (Bondi). Ralph talks about major news with co-worker Earl Kramer (Reid) while walking to work. When Ralph gets violent cramps at work while dictating a letter to his secretary (Singleton), his co-worker George Brooks (Gordon) suggests that he go see a doctor. He becomes even more concerned while playing cards with friends Earl, George, and Dr. Pritchard (King). When he finds a can of arsenic in his garage, he decides to have his home cocoa analyzed by a chemist (Soulé), and it turns out to contain arsenic. Ralph initially blames Mrs. Sutton, and fires her, before he learns that the serial murderer has been caught. However, Mrs. Sutton confesses to him her unhappiness at having had to lie for Ethel, who is having an affair with her co-star. Ethel, unaware of what Ralph has learned, offers him a cup of cocoa that she made for him. Supporting cast: Janet Ward as Ethel Montgomery, Elliott Reid as Earl Kramer, Gavin Gordon as George Brooks, Walter Woolf King as Dr. Pritchard, Doris Singleton as Secretary, Olan Soulé as Chemist
9	9	"The Long Shot"	Robert Stevenson	Harold Swanton	Peter Lawford as Charles 'Charlie' Ffolliot Raymond, John Williams as Walker Hendricks/English Jim	November 27, 1955 (1955-11-27)
Heavily indebted Charlie Raymond (Lawford) narrates his previous week's happenings, beginning with his gambling losses at the races. The bartender (Graham) takes a phone call for him, covering him as he owes $4200 to his bookie. He answers a newspaper ad placed by Walker Hendricks (Williams), who wants an English companion for his road trip to San Francisco who can talk in-depth of London. After starting out, Charlie is confronted by bookie Tommy Dewitt (Cantor), who tells him that he must proceed to Florida for a sure thing. Charlie steals Hendricks' money while he is away. He also learns, from a letter written by attorney Matthew Kelson (Warwick), that Walker is on his way to claim an inheritance of $200,000 from a family that he has never met. When they reach Salt Lake City, Charlie tests his ability to assume Hendricks' identity by visiting Hendricks' aunt Margaret Stoddard (Hoffman), at which he is successful. Charlie kills Walker by driving over him in the Nevada desert at night and takes his identity to present himself at lawyer Kelson's office. The secretary (Christine) keeps him company until Kelson calls him in, and he is met by Police Sergeant Mack (Gerstle), who informs him that the real Walker Hendricks was killed much earlier in New York City and thrown in the river. The man whom Charlie killed was "English Jim", another con man who had also been after the inheritance. Supporting cast: Charlie Cantor as Tommy DeWitt, Gertrude Hoffman as Margaret Stoddard, Robert Warwick as Matthew Kelson, Frank Gerstle as Police Sergeant Mack, Virginia Christine as Secretary, Tim Graham as Bartender Previously an episode of Suspense (broadcast 31 January 1946).
10	10	"The Case of Mr. Pelham"	Alfred Hitchcock	Story by : Anthony Armstrong Teleplay by : Francis Cockrell	Tom Ewell as Albert Pelham (both real and fake)	December 4, 1955 (1955-12-04)
Albert Pelham (Ewell) is a successful businessman who stops by his club, talking with the bartender (Willis) until distant acquaintance Dr. Harley (Bailey) stops in. Pelham tells Harley he has a paranoid suspicion that he has a double who is slowly taking over his life and is even better at it. In a flashback, Pelham was eating lunch with Detroit client Mr. Hartley when a friend, Tom Mason (Smith), entered, being somewhat upset of being ignored by Pelham two days before, when Pelham was actually in Philadelphia. An attendant, Harry (Arvan), confirms to him that either he, or an exact twin, played pool that night, when he did not. Pelham believes that the situation must be a joke being played on him by friends Tom, Vincent (Compton), and the staff of the club. Even one of Pelham's secretaries, Miss Clement (Stewart), notices that he is off while delivering to him dictated letters which he knows he did not dictate. Neither she nor the other secretary (Brewster) notice a difference in the details of the work being completed by Pelham. With the support of Harley, Pelham varies his schedule and buys a one-of-a-kind necktie from a salesman (Collier) in the hopes of catching his double off-guard. Upon returning to work, Miss Clement brings him documents containing his new signature, which he just started using. Pelham calls home and the double answers, troubling him greatly. When he returns home, his double is there, and they are seen together by Pelham's manservant Peterson (Watson), who has been constantly confused throughout the time period by the seemingly consistent inconsistency of Pelham. The impassive double points out that Pelham is the imposter by showing that he is wearing an unusual tie, and when Peterson believes him and thinks that Pelham is the impostor, Pelham has a mental breakdown. The impostor Pelham takes over Pelham's life, while the real Pelham is taken away to a lunatic asylum. Supporting cast: Raymond Bailey as Dr. Harley, Justice Watson as Henry Peterson, Kirby Smith as Tom Mason, Kay Stewart as Miss Clement, John Compton as Vincent, Jan Arvan as Harry the Club Attendant, Diane Brewster as Secretary, Norman Willis as Bartender, Tim Graham as Lawyer, Richard Collier as Tie Salesman
11	11	"Guilty Witness"	Robert Stevens	Story by : Morris Hershman Teleplay by : Robert C. Dennis	Judith Evelyn as Amelia Verber, Kathleen Maguire as Dorothy Crane, Joseph Mantell as Stanley Crane	December 11, 1955 (1955-12-11)
Stanley (Mantell) and Dorothy (Maguire) Crane live in the apartment below volatile couple Amelia (Evelyn) and Ben (Kemmer) Verber, and they often hear them fighting. While serving Mrs. Glavetsky (Wendorff) and Mrs. Santini (Narciso) in his shop, Ben notices bruises on Dorothy when she stops in. Following a particularly loud fight after Ben gets a phone call from a woman, Ben mysteriously vanishes, and Dorothy pushes Stanley to find out more. A man shows up at the Crane's apartment, claiming to be from the board of health. He reveals himself to Stanley as Sergeant Halloran (Simon) and says that he is investigating the disappearance of Ben. Despite his skepticism, Stanley helps Sergeant Halloran's investigation, and they break into the Verber's apartment. Dorothy is passionately insistent to Stanley that Amelia killed Ben. Sergeant Halloran and Stanley eventually discover that Amelia killed Ben and hid his body in the basement in the baby carriage. Amelia reveals the reason the fight got so out of hand was because the woman Ben was about to leave Amelia for — was Dorothy. Supporting cast: Robert Simon as Sergeant Halloran, Ed Kemmer as Ben Verber, Laiola Wendorff as Mrs. Glavetsky, Grazia Narciso as Mrs. Santini
12	12	"Santa Claus and the Tenth Avenue Kid"	Don Weis	Story by : Margaret Cousins Teleplay by : Marian Cockrell	Barry Fitzgerald as Harold "Stretch" Sears	December 18, 1955 (1955-12-18)
At a parole office, Doris (Harford) is being supervised by parole officer Clementine Webster (Gregg) when disgruntled ex-con Harold "Stretch" Sears (Fitzgerald) is brought in by Mr. Chambers (Space). Sears is hired by store manager Mr. Shaw (Watson) as a department store Santa for $10 per day plus lunch thanks to Miss Webster. Sears loathes the job, as he dislikes the children (Gibson, Hunley, Blankley, Bernard, Winkelman), but his attention is caught by a cynical poor boy (Clark) who wants an expensive toy plane currently being played with by a highly engaged man (Willis) and the boy believes that Santa is unable to give it to him. Sears is so unimpressed by the store that he doesn't even try to take anything past security (McVey), and he acts rather rudely to Miss Webster when she drives him home. Sears steals the toy to give it to the cynical boy for Christmas, as he sees himself in the child. Sears is caught by the police after leaving the boy's apartment home, but Webster understands Sears' intent and has the charges dropped by paying for the gift, despite the hesitancy of the police sergeant (Reynolds). Supporting cast: Virginia Gregg as Clementine Webster, Bobby Clark as 10th Avenue Kid, Arthur Space as Mr. Chambers the Parole Officer, Betty Harford as Doris, Justice Watson as Mr. Shaw (the Store Manager), Tyler McVey as Security Guard, Norman Willis as Man with Toy Plane, Alan Reynolds as Police Sergeant, Mimi Gibson as First Girl in line to see Santa, Gary Hunley as Boy, Anthony Blankley as Boy, Butch Bernard as Boy, Wendy Winkleman as Girl, Noel Green, Harrison Lewis
13	13	"The Cheney Vase"	Robert Stevens	Robert Blees	Patricia Collinge as Martha Cheney, Darren McGavin as Lyle Endicott	December 25, 1955 (1955-12-25)
Lyle Endicott (McGavin) exchanges barbs with his now former boss, Herbert Koether (Macready), on the day of his firing and seeks consoling from his girlfriend Pamela Waring (Jones). Lyle worms his way into the good graces of Martha Cheney (Collinge), a rich, invalid woman with a penchant for sculpture. Lyle hopes to obtain her Cheney vase, which will fetch a high price on the market, with a buyer offering $45,000 for it. Lyle gets Pamela to forge a letter from Koether pushing for him to work for Martha. Lyle methodically cuts Martha off from the world in the hopes that she will die, even seeking to separate her from maid Bella (Card) by framing Bella for breaking items. He hires a new maid, Ruby Boyenton (Lee), to take the place of Bella, whom he fired, all the while telling Martha that Bella quit. Lyle cuts off the telephone, so Martha futilely begs the conniving Ruby to help her, as she fears Lyle's intentions. Lyle even begins to lie to Pamela, telling her the vase is in a safety deposit box in order to cut her out while he plans to flee abroad to Frankfurt. When Pamela warns Koether and the authorities about his plan, Lyle rushes to Martha's gallery to take the vase, but discovers that Martha has been working on dozens of copies of the vase, and now he is unable to identify the correct one. Supporting cast: Carolyn Jones as Pamela Waring, George Macready as Herbert Koether, Ruta Lee as Ruby Boyenton, Kathryn Card as Bella
14	14	"A Bullet for Baldwin"	Justus Addiss	Story by : Joseph Ruscoll Teleplay by : Eustace and Francis Cockrell	John Qualen as Mr. Benjamin Stepp	January 1, 1956 (1956-01-01)
San Francisco, 1909. When middle-aged Mr. Stepp (Qualen) is suddenly fired from an investment banking company after 21 years of loyal service, he shoots his boss Nathaniel Baldwin (Cabot) and calmly leaves, telling the janitor (Adamson) not to bother Baldwin. Stepp's landlady (Lawson) remarks to him her concern for his tired appearance, but he reassures her all is well. On Monday morning, Stepp is awakened by his landlady about Baldwin's secretary Abigail Wilson (Clarke) is calling him, and Wilson tells him to report to the office immediately, as the office believes him to be late for work. Stepp is surprised when Baldwin is at work the next day as though nothing happened. Baldwin's partner, Walter King (Reed), convinces Stepp that he hallucinated the Saturday night shooting, and King tells Stepp to hire an assistant considering his extensive workload. King, however, has actually hired a look-alike actor named Davidson for $2000 to take Baldwin's place in order to close an important deal. King even tells Davidson that Baldwin had a stroke, which is the reasoning for his hire, although he admits to having an affair with Baldwin's wife. When Davidson figures out Baldwin has been killed, King admits to Stepps' action. King and Davidson agree to stage Baldwin's "death" later, and in order to close all possible leaks, King forces Stepp to retire. King tells Stepp that Stepp himself made up the issue with the new assistant and raise in pay. In retaliation, Stepp shoots and kills King, and then calmly leaves, believing this to be just another hallucination. Supporting cast: Sebastian Cabot as Nathaniel Baldwin/Davidson, Philip Reed as Walter King, Cheryll Clarke as Miss Abigail Wilson the Secretary, Don McArt as Albert, Robert Patten (credited as Bob Patten) as Detective, Ruth Lee as Neighbor, Arthur Gilmour as Neighbor, Kate Drain Lawson as Landlady, James Adamson as Janitor, David Dwight as Fireman Note: The actress who played Mrs. Baldwin is uncredited and currently unknown. The actors at the financial meeting are uncredited and currently unknown. Don McArt, Robert Patten, Ruth Lee, Arthur Gilmore, and David Dwight do not appear in the episode, though they are all credited, suggesting potential deleted scenes. Bill Erwin may have played an uncredited role as a fireman in deleted scenes as well.
15	15	"The Big Switch"	Don Weis	Story by : Cornell Woolrich Teleplay by : Richard Carr	George Mathews as Sam Dunleavy, Beverly Michaels as Goldie	January 8, 1956 (1956-01-08)
Chicago, 1920. Gangster Sam Dunleavy (Mathews), fresh from killing a couple of gangsters in Miami, is visited by Police Lieutenant Al Hawkshaw (Downing), who presses him to leave Chicago. Sam wants to murder his ex-girlfriend, Goldie (Michaels), as she has started a relationship with Morgan (Dana). Sam visits his favorite bar, surprising bartender friend Ed (Edwards), before seeing close friend Barney (Stone). Sam has Barney arrange for him the perfect alibi for $2500. Barney has it staged as though he and Sam are playing a game of poker in Barney's backroom, with waiter Tony (Whiting) to witness the two in the backroom playing cards. Sam sneaks out successfully through the fake phonebooth, but he finds himself unable to kill Goldie when she claims that she has a baby (named Dunleavy) and is married to Morgan. "Baby", however, is actually a revolver Morgan uses for robberies. When Sam returns to Barney's backroom, Barney accidentally shoots himself while cleaning one of his guns, and Sam is arrested for murder by Hawkshaw. Supporting cast: George E. Stone as Barney, Joe Downing (credited as Joseph Downing) as Lieutenant Al Hawkshaw, James Edwards as Ed, Napoleon Whiting as Tony, Mark Dana as Morgan
16	16	"You Got to Have Luck"	Robert Stevens	Story by : S. R. Ross Teleplay by : Eustace & Francis Cockrell	John Cassavetes as Sam Cobbett, Marisa Pavan as Mary Schaffner	January 15, 1956 (1956-01-15)
Sam Cobbett (Cassavetes) has just broken out of prison while serving four consecutive 99-year sentences by hiding in a laundry basket. Warden Jacobs (Teal) and his secretary (Dawson) work to fend off the media and begin a pursuit via helicopter. The pilot (Clark) and co-pilot (Patten) fly over a local community looking for any clues. Meanwhile, David (Johnson) and Mary Schaffner (Pavan) discuss a grocery list before David goes to work. Cobbett enters the Schaffner house while David is away and makes Mary cook for him, pretend that everything is okay over the phone when her mother calls, and curtly dismiss her neighbors Maude (Janiss) and Susie Martin (Winkleman) when they come by. Cobbett believes that he can take his time, so he shaves, showers, and changes clothes. However, a prison guard (Pullen) and the warden suddenly arrive to arrest him. They were tipped off by Mary's mother — Mary is deaf and should not have answered the phone or been able to hear her mother's questions. Supporting cast: Lamont Johnson as David Schaffner, Ray Teal as Warden Jacobs, Vivi Janiss as Maude Martin, Robert Patten (credited as Bob Patten) as Willis the Co-Pilot, Wendy Winkleman as Susie Martin, Hal K. Dawson as Secretary, Steven Clark as Pilot, Bill Pullen as Prison Guard
17	17	"The Older Sister"	Robert Stevens	Story by : Lillian de la Torre Teleplay by : Robert C. Dennis	Joan Lorring as Emma Borden, Carmen Mathews as Lizzie Borden, Polly Rowles as Nell Cutts	January 22, 1956 (1956-01-22)
Based on the Lizzie Borden murders and set one year after Lizzie was acquitted for the murder of her parents. A little girl (Winkleman) walks by the Borden house singing about the murders. Emma Borden (Lorring) and friend Margaret (Hitchcock) talk about Lizzie's mental state and their desire to leave the house. Ambitious Sacramento reporter Nell Cutts (Rowles) barges into the home of the Borden sisters, Lizzie (Mathews) and Emma, in the hopes of an exclusive interview, and she pesters Emma with constant questions, even recreating the events of the murder. Lizzie finally comes downstairs with her cat (Orangey) to confront the reporter and throw her out. Cutts' aggressive questioning causes Emma distress, but it turns out that Emma killed their father and stepmother, and Lizzie was merely trying to protect her. Lizzie tells Emma of how she saw her after the murders holding the axe and wearing a blood-stained apron, and Emma admits why she killed the two people. Emma suddenly suffers a delusion that the parents are upstairs and feels an imminent need to kil them again. When Lizzie tries to stop her, she threatens Lizzie with the axe. Just then, Cutts returns and stumbles upon the axe, demanding a statement. Emma immediately leaves, speaking shortly to neighbor Grace (Stewart) before heading to the train station. To force the reporter out, Lizzie falsely confesses and threatens Nell with the axe, finally understanding Emma's ability to reach the breaking point. Supporting cast: Pat Hitchcock as Margaret, Kay Stewart as Grace, Wendy Winkleman as Child, Orangey as Cat (uncredited)
18	18	"Shopping for Death"	Robert Stevens	Ray Bradbury	Jo Van Fleet as Mrs. Shrike	January 29, 1956 (1956-01-29)
Clarence Fox (Harris) and Elmer Shore (Qualen) are retired insurance agents who travel to see various accidents and determine the causes by interviewing witnesses (Morgan, Montgomery). They hope to use their years of experience to save people that they believe will die soon, especially potential murders occurring when the temperature hits 92 degrees Fahrenheit. Clarence has his sights on the aptly named Mrs. Shrike (Fleet), a boorish alcoholic whom he believes has a death wish, who yells at her nosy neighbors (Knight, Wendorff) and rudely orders around children and her agitated butcher (Ansara). She irritates basically everyone with whom she comes into contact. They try to advise her to change her life and fix her house, but this just causes her to laugh at them and lash out, leading Clarence to almost strike her with his cane and admit to Elmer that he failed to see her as a lost soul. As the pair leave, they see Mrs. Shrike's husband Albert (Ross) return home with a meat hook, and she is killed soon afterward. Supporting cast: Robert Harris as Clarence Fox, John Qualen as Elmer Shore, Mike Ross as Albert Shrike, Michael Ansara as Butcher
19	19	"The Derelicts"	Robert Stevens	Story by : Terence Maples Teleplay by : Robert C. Dennis	Robert Newton as Peter J. Goodfellow	February 5, 1956 (1956-02-05)
Husband Ralph (Reed) and wife Herta Cowell (Knudsen) argue over the price of an expensive black mink stow. Businessman Ralph receives a call from his partner, millionaire Alfred Sloane (Delevanti), who wants to meet and discuss repayment of an IOU for $10,000 (and half the profits) for funding his invention. While meeting in a park that night, Ralph claims he doesn't have the money, and when Sloane threatens to involve lawyers, Ralph strangles his silent partner to avoid paying what he owes. The murder is witnessed by vagrant Peter J. Goodfellow (Newton), who picks up Sloane's cigarette case with the IOU inside, and he uses it to blackmail Ralph. Goodfellow and his fellow vagrant friend Fenton Shanks (Silver) move into the Cowell home, much to the disgust of Herta. After months of Goodfellow and Fenton living with them and pawning almost everything in the Cowell home, as well as draining Ralph's bank account, Ralph confesses to Herta when she threatens to leave. After searching every night throughout the home, Ralph is eventually able to find the IOU and burn it. Goodfellow and Fenton leave, but soon afterward Police Detective Sergeant James Monroney (Foulk) arrives with a pawn ticket signed by Fenton for Sloane's cigarette case in Ralph's name, thusly tying Ralph to the Sloane murder. Supporting cast: Philip Reed as Ralph Cowell, Peggy Knudsen as Herta Cowell, Cyril Delevanti as Alfred J. Sloane, Johnny Silver as Fenton Shanks, Robert Foulk as Police Detective Sergeant James Monroney
20	20	"And So Died Riabouchinska"	Robert Stevenson	Story by : Ray Bradbury Teleplay by : Mel Dinelli	Claude Rains as John Fabian, Charles Bronson as Detective Krovitch	February 12, 1956 (1956-02-12)
Macey (Adrian) and Dan Silver (Tyler) make a bet while backstage in a theatre when an errant coin toss leads to the discovery of the dead body of juggler Luke Ockham. Detective Krovitch (Bronson) investigates the murder by questioning John Fabian (Rains) and his wife Alice (Carleton). His suspicions fall on John Fabian, a ventriloquist with a fixation on his female dummy, Riabouchinska (voice of Gregg). Riabouchinska, seemingly acting independent of Fabian's control, insists on telling Krovitch the truth about Alice and lover Mel Douglas (Gilmore), which angers Alice greatly, as she despises Riabouchinska. A stagehand (Haade) gives Krovitch some background information during Fabian's show, and Krovitch finds a picture of the real Riabouchinska, a woman named Ilyana who mysteriously disappeared while serving as an assistant to Fabian. Fabian admits to having a tempestuous relationship with her before her disappearance, and it is she who served as the model for the dummy. Krovitch interviews booking agent Zander (Cantor) about Ockham's whereabouts. When Krovitch confronts Fabian, Riabouchinska tells Krovitch that Fabian killed Ockham because Ockham threatened to expose Fabian and Riabouchinska's love affair to the world unless he received $1000. Fabian confesses and Riabouchinska declares she can no longer love Fabian. She stops moving and Fabian is arrested by Krovitch. Supporting cast: Claire Carleton as Alice Fabian, Lowell Gilmore as Mel Douglas, Charlie Cantor as Zander, Iris Adrian as Macey, Harry Tyler as Dan Silver, Bill Haade as Stagehand, Virginia Gregg as the voice of Riabouchinska
21	21	"Safe Conduct"	Justus Addiss	Andrew Solt	Claire Trevor as Mary Prescott, Jacques Bergerac as Jan Gubak	February 19, 1956 (1956-02-19)
American journalist Mary Prescott (Trevor) is traveling on a train out of the Iron Curtain when her passport and documents are reviewed by the train conductor (Banner) and an officer (Van Eyck). She is befriended by local celebrity Jan Gubak (Bergerac), the captain of the national soccer team. Jan describes his on-field successes with the help of the conductor and an enthusiastic waiter (Manza) when Mary is suddenly approached by Professor Klopka (Klemperer), who states that his country has a secret serum to offer society. While talking privately, Mary agrees to carry a luxury watch for Gubak, but during the customs inspection Jan turns her in to Customs Officer Trevitch (Shayne) for smuggling luxury items. Mary is arrested, and Professor Klopka, who is actually Captain Kriza, attempts to interrogate her for evidence. However, she is released soon afterward when the watch is discovered to be fake and Kriza believes the entire event to be an attempt to raise outrage internationally. Mary is soon visited by Jan on the train to Munich, and she learns that he is part of the underground resistance. The charade was to create a distraction that enabled Gubak to smuggle sensitive microfilm out of the country containing information written by an imprisoned and tortured bishop. Gubak gives Mary the microfilm and urges her to write the truth about his country. Supporting cast: Werner Klemperer as Professor Klopka / Captain Kriza, John Banner as Train Conductor, Peter Van Eyck as Officer, Konstantin Shayne as Customs Officer Trevitch, Ralph Manza as Waiter, Charlie Hall as Man with Pool Cue (uncredited)
22	22	"Place of Shadows"	Robert Stevens	Robert C. Dennis	Everett Sloane as Father Vincente	February 26, 1956 (1956-02-26)
A man named Floyd Unser gets travel information from the ticket agent (Tyler) about a vehicle coming to pick him up. He is soon met by Brother Gerard (McClory), who takes him to a local monastery where he meets with Father Vincente (Sloane) about seeing a man named Dave Rocco. Father Vincente reveals that he knows the man is actually Ray Clements (Damon), whom Rocco stole money from and cost him his job, his father, and his girl. Clements wants to get revenge on Rocco, who is taking sanctuary there. Father Vincente gives Clements all the money he is owed ($13,000) and both he and Brother Gerard advise Clements to choose forgiveness, and Clements is forced to leave when he declines. Clements almost shoots a man after following Brother Charles (Glass) to a visitor's room, not realizing the man is someone else, but luckily he is stopped by Father Vincente. Clements later kills Rocco's partner, the actual Floyd Unser (Downing), in self-defense at the train station and takes sanctuary at the same monastery, as he was shot by Unser. Police officers (Akins, Mitchell) visit the monastery and ask Father Vincente questions about Clements' location. He tells Father Vincente that he no longer wants revenge, but Rocco died just before Clements' arrival. Supporting cast: Mark Damon as Ray Clements, Joe Downing (credited as Joseph Downing) as Floyd Unser, Sean McClory as Brother Gerard, Everett Glass as Brother Charles, Steve Mitchell as Joey the Cop, Claude Akins as Cop, Harry Tyler as Train Ticket Agent
23	23	"Back for Christmas"	Alfred Hitchcock	Story by : John Collier Teleplay by : Francis Cockrell	John Williams as Herbert Carpenter	March 4, 1956 (1956-03-04)
Englishman Herbert Carpenter (Williams) is digging a hole in his basement under the guise of building a wine cellar. He and his loving but pesky wife Hermione (Elsom) are planning a long holiday in California, which he desires to be permanent. Their servant Elsie (Glessing) is preparing the house for their extended absence. They hold one last party with friends, such as Major (Gould-Porter) and Mrs. Sinclair (Kemble-Cooper), Mr. and Mrs. Hewitt (Hamer and Tedrow), and others. They discuss jet flight, which the Carpenters fear, versus driving, their preferred mode of travel. On the day of their departure, and after doting good-byes from their friends, Herbert bludgeons his wife to death, as planned, and buries her body in the basement. He is almost caught in the act by a surprise visit from friends Mr. and Mrs. Wallingford (Muir and Warren), but he hides until they leave. He then goes off alone on his road trip to Northridge, California and a new job there, where he gloats in his freedom from marriage and forges a fake letter from Hermione to their friends. Soon after arriving at his new swanky "digs", Herbert receives the mail from his new employer Mr. Hall (Ford) while waiting for his new maid (Harris). Among the letters to his wife from their friends back home is a bill from a contractor for work that Hermione had secretly arranged for – excavating the wine cellar as a present for Herbert... meaning that his crime will soon be discovered. Supporting cast: Isabel Elsom as Hermione Carpenter, Arthur Gould-Porter (credited as A.E. Gould-Porter) as Major Sinclair , Lily Kemble-Cooper as Mrs. Sinclair, Gavin Muir as Mr. Wallingford, Katherine Warren as Mrs. Freda Wallingford, Gerald Hamer as Mr. Hewitt, Irene Tedrow as Mrs. Hewitt, Mollie Glessing as Elsie the Servant, Ross Ford as Mr. Hall, Theresa Harris as the California Maid
24	24	"The Perfect Murder"	Robert Stevens	Story by : Stacey Aumonier Teleplay by : Victor Wolfson	Hurd Hatfield as Paul Tallendier, Mildred Natwick as Aunt Rosalie Tallendier	March 11, 1956 (1956-03-11)
France. Henri Tallendier narrates how his brother Paul Tallendier (Hatfield) and he plotted to kill their Aunt Rosalie (Natwick) to inherit her fortune after a lawyer (Helton) reveals the contents of a deceased uncle's estate. Henri is a hardworking father of four while Paul is a dissolute hedonist. Rosalie pledges to leave her wealth to the local convent, aware that Paul and Henri want her gone, and Paul feigns fainting from anemia, with servant Ernestine (Hurlbut) instructed to care for him. Paul begins to live with Aunt Rosalie and her fast-talking parrot, who dislikes him but appreciates his capacity to play dominoes, and Ernestine is overjoyed with Paul's presence. Dr. Poncet (Kingsford) happily tells Aunt Rosalie that she has the pulse of a twenty-year-old, to the disgust of Paul. Henri begins breaking in to steal items for pawning and is confronted by Paul. After discussing their situations, Paul has Henri grind glass into fine powder while his wife Marie (Summers) is away, while Paul himself gets drunk rejoicing with a waiter (Chefe). Paul adds it to the egg mixture that is supposed to make a soufflé for Rosalie's dinner, but that night Rosalie drunkenly insists on eating fish, and the next morning Paul dies when he eats an omelette made out of the lethal egg mixture. Aunt Rosalie tells Henri, that as her sole remaining family member he will be her heir. Supporting cast: Philip Coolidge as Henri Tallendier, Hope Summers as Marie Tallendier, Walter Kingsford as Dr. Poncet, Gladys Hurlbut as Ernestine, Percy Helton as Lawyer, Jack Chefe as Waiter
25	25	"There Was an Old Woman"	Robert Stevenson	Story by : Jerry Hackady & Harold Hackady Teleplay by : Marian Cockrell	Estelle Winwood as Monica Laughton	March 18, 1956 (1956-03-18)
Couple Frank (Bronson) and Lorna (Crane) Bramwell, desperate for money, go to the mansion of eccentric Monica Laughton (Winwood) to rob her when they learn from Theodore (Greer), the milkman, and Arthur (Treacy), the local deli manager, that Laughton is all alone after her relative Oscar died. They present themselves as relatives and are warmly welcomed by Laughton, who introduces them to ghost relatives that she believes are present for the funeral. Their robbery plan goes awry because Laughton proves wholly crazy and completely unresponsive to their threats to her. She only shows fear when they threaten her imaginary guests. The Bramwells become tired and frustrated, because they cannot find any money and there seems to be no food in the house. In desperation, they eat a batch of freshly made muffins, not knowing that they are filled with rat poison. Laughton's fortune turns out to be inside a handbag that she carries everywhere with her, which is revealed when she pays Theodore the milkman with a $1000 bill. Supporting cast: Charles Bronson as Frank Bramwell, Norma Crane as Lorna Bramwell, Dabbs Greer as Theodore the Milkman, Emerson Treacy as Arthur the Deli Manager
26	26	"Whodunit"	Francis Cockrell	Story by : C. B. Gilford Teleplay by : Francis Cockrell & Marian Cockrell	John Williams as Alexander Penn Arlington	March 25, 1956 (1956-03-25)
Dead mystery writer Alexander Penn Arlington (Williams) is distraught when he arrives in Heaven not knowing who killed him with a letter opener. The author of 75 novels, he demands to know the answer. His recording angel, Wilfred (Napier), returns Alexander to Earth to repeat his last day to investigate, and he is awakened by his butler, Horace (Robles). Alexander's fired assistant Talbot (Coolidge), money-owing nephew Vincent (Slack), openly unfaithful wife Carol (Blake), and his wife's lover Wally Benson (Paris) all have motives. In his study, he tells them all that one of them is planning his death for midnight and asks them all questions. Benson turns off the light and Alexander is killed in the dark without seeing who did it. Returning to Heaven, Wilfred points out that the killer must have trusted the person who turned off the light, so Alexander deduces that it must have been Carol. Supporting cast: Amanda Blake as Carol Arlington, Jerry Paris as Wally Benson, Philip Coolidge as Talbot, Alan Napier as Wilfred – The Recording Angel, Bill Slack as Vincent, Ruta Lee as Angel, and Rudy Robles as Horace the Butler.
27	27	"Help Wanted"	James Neilson	Teleplay by : Robert C. Dennis Based upon the Mary Orr and Reginald Denham adaptation of a story by : Stanley Ellin	John Qualen as Mr. Crabtree, Lorne Greene as Mr. X	April 1, 1956 (1956-04-01)
Elderly Mr. Crabtree (Qualen) worries about his wife Laura (Kennedy), who desperately needs an operation. Despite having attacked his former employer when being fired for being too old, he receives a visit from Miss Brown (Swanson) confirming his new employment filing reports regarding corporate notices for a generous $100 per week salary. One day, he is ordered by his new boss, the emotionless Mr. X (Greene), to kill a man who will enter his office on a certain day in exchange for keeping his job and one year's worth of salary to cover the operation as Mr. X admits to burning all of Crabtree's reports. The man in question is his wife's first husband, who is blackmailing Mr. X to keep his wife's secret of being a bigamist. Crabtree is to hand the man an envelope, secretly containing a suicide note instead of money, and then push the man out the window. Crabtree decides at the last moment not to do the task, but when a man (Harmon) enters his office at the expected time, Crabtree is so upset at the thought of losing his wife and job that he ends up killing him anyway, and Mr. X calls him to report mailing him his salary, as he witnessed the act. Police Detective Gryar (Baer) and another officer (Brinegar) question Crabtree briefly but leave without suspicion. Shortly afterward another man, the correct target (Atterbury), arrives at Crabtree's office, but Crabtree has already received his payment for the murder and simply walks out. Supporting cast: Madge Kennedy as Mrs. Laura Crabtree, Parley Baer as Police Detective Gryar, Ruth Swanson as Miss Brown, John Harmon as Donations Collector, Malcolm Atterbury as the Blackmailer, Paul Brinegar as Police Officer Interesting note: Lorne Greene, John Qualen, and Madge Kennedy all died in 1987, with Greene dying on September 11, the day before Qualen's death (September 12).
28	28	"Portrait of Jocelyn"	Robert Stevens	Story by : Edgar Marvin Teleplay by : Harold Swanton	Philip Abbott as Mark Halliday, Nancy Gates as Debbie Halliday, John Baragrey as Arthur Clymer / Detective Arbison	April 8, 1956 (1956-04-08)
Married couple Mark (Abbott) and Debbie (Gates)'s first anniversary is ruined when a portrait they commissioned is revealed to be of Mark's first wife, Jocelyn, who has been missing for five years. The art dealer (Soule) tells them to talk to Jeff Harrison (Bailey), Mark's former brother-in-law, if they have an issue. Jeff tells Mark that he received a letter from Jocelyn from Switzerland two years prior, after she supposedly disappeared. Debbie jealously believes that Mark stills loves Jocelyn and urges him to find the truth. With the help of Jeff and a real estate agent (Tyler) who rents Mark his former cottage home, Mark tracks down the painter, Arthur Clymer (Baragrey), who claims to have been married to Jocelyn and killed her in a jealous rage. Mark attacks Clymer because he (Clymer) described how Mark, in fact, actually killed Jocelyn five years ago at the same cottage in which Mark is staying. Clymer is actually a police officer and worked together with Jeff to get a confession out of Mark. Supporting cast: Raymond Bailey as Jeff Harrison, Olan Soule as Art Dealer, Harry Tyler as Real Estate Agent
29	29	"The Orderly World of Mr. Appleby"	James Neilson	Story by : Stanley Ellin Teleplay by : Victor Wolfson & Robert C. Dennis	Robert H. Harris as Laurence Appleby, Meg Mundy as Martha Sturgis-Appleby	April 15, 1956 (1956-04-15)
Antiques dealer Laurence Appleby (Harris) is desperate for money as he is being threatened with a lawsuit by a Turkish national, Mr. Desar (Ansara), over a $12,000 debt. He becomes utterly distraught when wealthy Martha Sturgis (Mundy) breaks an $11,000 camel statuette, although he is somewhat relieved when she writes him a check for the full balance. Appleby kills his argumentative wife Lena (Larabee) by deliberately causing her to fall and hit her head in order to get her inheritance. Since he still has debts, he woos and marries wealthy heiress Sturgis. When Martha refuses to give him money for another $7000 in debt to Desar over Hittite curios, he tries to kill her while servant Ella (Glessing) is away, but Martha is prepared for him. Martha and her lawyer Sidney Gainsborough (Clarke) have evidence that Appleby killed his first wife. If anything happens to Martha, Gainsborough will go to the police. Appleby is about to comply with Martha's demands to give up his shop and stay at home with her, but she accidentally falls and dies the same way as Lena. Supporting cast: Gage Clarke (credited as Gage Clark) as Sidney Gainsborough, Louise Larabee as Lena Appleby, Michael Ansara as Mr. Desar, Edna Holland as Mrs. Murchie, Helen Spring as Mrs. Grant, Mollie Glessing as Ella Note: Edna Holland and Helen Spring are credited but do not appear in the episode; this suggests deleted scenes feature the pair.
30	30	"Never Again"	Robert Stevens	Story by : Adela Rogers St. Johns Teleplay by : Gwen Bagni, Irwin Gielgud and Stirling Silliphant	Phyllis Thaxter as Karen Stewart, Louise Allbritton (credited as Louise Albritton) as Renee Marlow, Warren Stevens as Jeff Simmons	April 22, 1956 (1956-04-22)
Karen Stewart (Thaxter), a recovering alcoholic, wakes up hung over and with no memory of the night before. She slowly recalls speaking with friend Margaret (Banks) before attending a party with her fiancé, Jeff Simmons (Stevens). Karen, jealous and insecure, started drinking again with a Mr. Marlow (Mullaney) when she concludes (from drunken rambling via Marlow) that Jeff's business associate (and Marlow's sister) Renee (Allbritton) is trying to seduce Jeff, even though Renee and the bartender (Ramstead) try to serve her ginger ale. Others, such as Mr. Sterling (Curry), constantly try to hand her alcohol, not knowing her addiction. Her last memory is of breaking a glass in her hand and Jeff trying to help her. Karen then learns from the nurse (Veazie) that she is in jail for killing Jeff with that broken glass. Supporting cast: Jack Mullaney as Mr. Marlow, Joan Banks as Margaret, Mason Curry as Mr. Sterling, Jack Ramstead as Bob the Bartender, Jack Mulhall as Party Guest, Karine Nordman as Tipsy Woman, Carol Veazie as Nurse, Marion Gray as Party Guest, Franklyn Farnum as Party Guest (uncredited), Jack Deery as Bar Patron (uncredited), Herschel Graham as Party Guest (uncredited), Don Ames as Party Guest (uncredited) Interesting Note: Both Phyllis Thaxter and Warren Stevens were born in November 1919 and died in 2012, with both passing at the age of 92.
31	31	"The Gentleman from America"	Robert Stevens	Story by : Michael Arlen Teleplay by : Francis Cockrell	Biff McGuire as Howard Latimer	April 29, 1956 (1956-04-29)
London, May 1940. Sir Stephen Hurstwood (Clanton) and friend Derek (Irving) discuss their betting engagements while American oilman Howard Latimer (McGuire) celebrates a big victory. Hurstwood offers a bet of £1,000 (British pounds) if Latimer can stay the entire night in the supposedly haunted Cromwell room of the Hurstwood mansion. Latimer is given a gun, one candle, one match, and a book that describes the mysterious beheading of Julia Hurstwood in the room. He takes one practice shot to confirm that the pistol is loaded. He reads about and envisions Julia (Chaney) and Geraldine Hurstwood (Torgeson), the individuals serving as the basis of the ghost story. That night Latimer sees a ghostly headless figure, fires the weapon numerous times, and collapses in fright. In October 1945, Latimer suddenly shows up at the Hurstwood mansion and is met by the butler Hanson (Snowden) before meeting Hurstwood and Derek, who admit to putting blanks in the gun and state that the ghost is a trick set up by Hurstwood for money, which causes Latimer to attack Hurstwood. Two sanitarium officials, Calendar (Dodsworth) and an attendant (Alderson), suddenly arrive to subdue Latimer, and Calendar tells Hurstwood and Derek of Latimer's insanity and the need to solve the murder of Julia. Supporting cast: Ralph Clanton as Sir Stephen Hurstwood, Eric Snowden (credited as Eric Snowdon) as Hanson, John Dodsworth as Calender, John Irving as Derek, Sonia Torgeson as Geraldine, Jan Chaney as Julia, John Alderson as Attendant, Geoffrey Steele as Man, Sam Harris as Club Patron (uncredited), Herschel Graham as Club Patron (uncredited)
32	32	"The Baby Sitter"	Robert Stevens	Story by : Emily Neff Teleplay by : Sarett Rudley	Thelma Ritter as Lottie Slocum	May 6, 1956 (1956-05-06)
Lottie Slocum (Ritter) is the last person to have seen Clara Nash (Mathews) before she was strangled to death, so she is interviewed by a police detective sergeant (Teal) and is supported by her daughter Janie (Welles). As the detective sergeant leaves, nosy Blanche Armsteader (Wickes) arrives to gossip. Lottie, who used to be the Nashes' babysitter, believes that Clara had it coming because she treated her husband Mr. Nash (Newton) badly, and she notes her distrust of Clara's boyfriend Mr. DeMario (Ansara). Lottie flashes back to the last fight between the husband and wife, one in which Lottie actually intervened by arguing with an angry Clara. After Janie leaves, Lottie is visited by DeMario, who warns her not to make things up about him to the police. The detective stops by to confirm Lottie's story about DeMario, as he has no alibi, and Lottie tearfully states that he left at 1:45. Lottie has feelings for Mr. Nash and hopes to please him by keeping his secret from the police — that he was at home the night that Clara died — so she writes him a note outlining what she knows about that night. He stops by while she is writing the note, supposedly to talk, but he burns the note and kills her instead. Supporting cast: Mary Wickes as Blanche Armsteader, Carole Mathews as Clara Nash, Rebecca Welles (credited as Reba Tassell) as Janie Slocum, Theodore Newton as Mr. Nash, Michael Ansara as Mr. DeMario, Ray Teal as a Police Detective Sergeant
33	33	"The Belfry"	Herschel Daugherty	Story by : Allan Vaughan Elston Teleplay by : Robert C. Dennis	Jack Mullaney as Clint Ringle, Pat Hitchcock as Ellie Marsh	May 13, 1956 (1956-05-13)
Clint Ringle (Mullaney) wants to marry schoolteacher Ellie Marsh (Hitchcock), but when she refuses him, he kills her fiancé Walt Norton (Compton) with an axe and flees, as the act was seen by student Albert Grinstead (Saber). Clint is hunted by the townsfolk (Moody, Ehrhardt) and the sheriff (Greer), so he hides in the belfry of Ellie's school, planning to kill her when he gets the chance, and he even leaves a threatening note for her on the school chalkboard. The next day, Ellie blames students Albert and Luke (Lee), but a schoolgirl (Hartnagel) says that it was there when the children arrived. Clint stays in the belfry for a few days and feels smug when everyone assumes that he is long gone, although he is almost caught by Albert retrieving a ball. When Ellie's fiancé is buried after the local preacher (Hayward) conducts his funeral, local man Elmer (Leavitt) rings the bell, causing Clint to shout in surprise and reveal his whereabouts. Supporting cast: John Compton as Walt Norton, Norman Leavitt as Elmer, David Saber as Albert Grinstead, Rudy Lee as Luke, Dabbs Greer as the Sheriff, Jim Hayward as Preacher, Ralph Moody as Local Citizen, Horst Ehrhardt as Local Citizen, Kathleen Hartnagel as Schoolgirl
34	34	"The Hidden Thing"	Robert Stevens	Story by : A. J. Russell Teleplay by : James Cavanagh	Biff McGuire as Dana Edwards, Robert H. Harris as John Hurley	May 20, 1956 (1956-05-20)
Dana Edwards (McGuire)'s fiancée Laura (Ames) is killed in a hit-and-run in front of Dana and others (Collier), and he is unable to remember any details of the car involved for Police Inspector Shea (Newton). His mother (Warren) consoles him as best she can, helping him try to recover, when a man suddenly arrives. The stranger, John Hurley (Harris), is a former teacher who lost his son in a similar way, and he claims to know how to give Dana Total recall. After many sessions, Dana is successfully able to remember the license plate of the car and tells Shea. He is then surprised to learn from Shea that John Hurley is crazy and not a memory expert at all, nor did he ever have a son. Supporting cast: Rachel Ames (credited as Judith Ames) as Laura, Theodore Newton as Inspector Shea, Katherine Warren as Mother Edwards, Richard Collier as The Counterman
35	35	"The Legacy"	James Neilson	Story by : Gina Kaus Teleplay by : Gina Kaus & Andrew Solt	Leora Dana as Irene Cole, Jacques Bergerac as Prince Burhan	May 27, 1956 (1956-05-27)
Palm Beach, Florida. English author Randolph Burnside (Clanton) runs into wealthy Cecilia Smithson (Markey), Colonel Blair (Kingsford), and Irene Cole (Dana) upon returning to his former home, where he is welcomed by the cafe host (Anders). Donna Dew (Arlen) begs Burnside to write a script for her. Wealthy but plain housewife Irene, wife of oil millionaire Howard Cole (Hewitt) and herself a bottlecap heiress, is pursued by playboy Prince Burhan (Bergerac), who ignores other beauties (Dixon) for her and threatens to kill himself if he can't have Irene. However, she refuses to leave her neglectful husband (Hewitt) for him and consistently seeks advise and consoling from Burnside, who is writing a book about Burhan. When Burhan dies, Irene and her husband assume that he killed himself over his love for Irene. Sometime later, Burnside learns from the cafe host that Burhan's death was an accident, as his mechanic had disconnected his brakes, and that he had pursued Irene for her money. Burnside decides to keep this a secret when he sees that Irene, believing a man killed himself over his love for her, has a newfound confidence that has greatly improved her marriage and her spark for life. Supporting cast: Enid Markey as Cecilia Smithson, Alan Hewitt as Howard Cole, Walter Kingsford as Colonel Blair, Ralph Clanton as Randolph Burnside, Roxanne Arlen as Donna Dew, Rudolph Anders as Cafe Host, Joan Dixon as Jealous Girl, Bess Flowers as Club Patron (uncredited), Florence Wix as Club Patron (uncredited), Charles Cirillo as Porter (uncredited), Sam Harris as Club Patron (uncredited), Herschel Graham as Club Patron (uncredited), Don Ames as Club Patron (uncredited), Harry Denny as Club Patron (uncredited), Joe Gilbert as Club Patron (uncredited), Robert Locke Lorraine as Club Patron (uncredited), Paul Power as Club Patron (uncredited)
36	36	"Mink"	Robert Stevenson	Irwin Gielgud & Gwen Bagni	Ruth Hussey as Paula Hudson	June 3, 1956 (1956-06-03)
Mild-mannered Paula Hudson (Hussey), supported by her friend Lois (Bromley), seeks to have a mink stole coat valued by fur shop owner Leslie Ronalds (Eustrel) and a furrier assistant (Burns), but she is apprehended by a policewoman, Sergeant Bradford (Janiss), for possessing stolen property belonging to Mrs. Wilson (Jackson). Paula attempts to prove that she bought it to Police Sergeant Delaney (Hayworth) for $400 cash the previous Monday, but to her distress the people she bought it from deny ever having sold it to her. The seller, Dolores Dawn (Paul), denies ever having met her, and her hairdresser Lucille (Borg) denies having given any information regarding the coat, although Lucille calls Dolores just after the police leave to discuss the matter. Paula is eventually approached by the man, Charlie Harper (McCallion), who stole the coat, and he offers to buy it back from her for $600, as he admits to facing 10 years in prison if caught. When she declines, he steals it back in order to end the police investigation, but he ends up being arrested. Supporting cast: Eugenia Paul as Dolores Dawn, Anthony Eustrel as Leslie Ronalds, Vinton Hayworth as Sergeant Delaney, Vivi Janiss as Sergeant Bradford, Sheila Bromley as Lois, Veda Ann Borg as Lucille, Mary Jackson as Mrs. J. Wilson, James McCallion as Charlie Harper, Paul E. Burns as Furrier Assistant
37	37	"Decoy"	Arnold Laven	Story by : Richard George Pedicini Teleplay by : Bernard C. Schoenfeld	Robert Horton as Gil Larkin, Cara Williams as Mona Cameron	June 10, 1956 (1956-06-10)
Piano player Gil Larkin (Horton) is upset when he learns that the woman he loves, singer Mona Cameron (Williams), is being abused by her husband Ben (McDearmon), an agent. Gil confronts Ben in his office after the secretary (Laven) leaves, but someone knocks Gil unconscious and shoots Ben, placing the gun in Gil's hand and listening to the scene over the phone. Gil remembers the name Ritchie being said by Ben and realizes his predicament as a patsy, or decoy. After investigating a note on Ben's desk, Gil goes to see Mona, hiding himself from the theater doorman (Tyler), when he runs into Mr. and Mrs. Sasikawa (Mita and Yamaji), who report not having spoken with Ben over the phone. Gil speaks with disc jockey Dave Packard (Mullaney) about Ben's death after Dave deals with autograph seekers (Gorshin), but Dave is clueless. Gil is briefly apprehended by Lieutenant Brandt (Coolidge), as he admits that his fingerprints are on the gun. After he is released, he goes to Mona and realizes when he hears the record that was playing over the phone during the murder that she set him up so she could be with her lover, Ritchie (Lewis). Mona and Ritchie are arrested, while Gil takes his musical arrangements. Supporting cast: Jack Mullaney as Dave Packard, Philip Coolidge as Lieutenant Brandt, Harry Lewis as Ritchie, David Orrick McDearmon (credited as David Orrick) as Ben Cameron, Mary Jean Yamaji as Mrs. Sasikawa, Edo Mita as Mr. Sasikawa, Frank Gorshin as Autograph Seeker, Harry Tyler as Theater Doorman, Wallace Earl Laven (credited as Eileen Harley) as Secretary
38	38	"The Creeper"	Herschel Daugherty	Story by : Joseph Ruscoll Teleplay by : James Cavanagh	Constance Ford as Ellen Grant, Steve Brodie as Steve Grant, Harry Townes as Ed	June 17, 1956 (1956-06-17)
Martha Stone (Shaw) and George the janitor (Helton) discuss the extreme heat and a murderer killing local women. The murderer has killed two blonde women while they are alone at night. Ellen Grant (Ford) is terrified and wants extra locks on the apartment door, but her husband Steve (Brodie) is dismissive of her concerns as he is angry that he did not get a pay raise at work. Ellen wants Steve to request to work the day shift until the murderer is caught. Steve goes to have a beer before work and runs into friend Ed (Townes), who stops by the Grant's apartment and offers to stay with old acquaintance Ellen. The two discuss why Ellen turned down Ed romantically and Ed's continuing grudge regarding Ellen. While Steve is at work, Ellen is scared and suspicious of various people that she meets, such as the local shoemaker (Linder) and even George, but she turns down Martha's offer to stay with her that night. Martha even accuses Ellen of having an affair with Ed. She is only relieved when the locksmith arrives to fix a lock and chain on her door, but the locksmith turns out to be the murderer, and he strangles Ellen as a terrified Steve listens to the commotion over the phone. Supporting cast: Reta Shaw as Martha Stone, Percy Helton as George the Janitor, Alfred Linder as Shoemaker
39	39	"Momentum"	Robert Stevens	Story by : Cornell Woolrich Teleplay by : Francis Cockrell	Skip Homeier as Richard Paine, Joanne Woodward as Beth Paine	June 24, 1956 (1956-06-24)
Richard Paine (Homeier) narrates his hatred of the rat race of life. He and his wife Beth (Woodward) are about to be kicked out of their home, and both are angry that he worked on half pay to help his job and his boss, A.T. Burroughs (Christy) has yet to repay him the $450 owed. Richard tries to borrow the money from bartender Charlie (Newell) while having a drink with others (Cook), but Charlie lost his money at the racetrack. Richard goes to Burroughs' home and steals the money that Burroughs owes him, but in the process, he accidentally kills him when Burroughs interrupts him and a struggle ensues. Richard tells Beth that he got the money from Charlie. Just then, the janitor Martin (Kreig) arrives to show the apartment to a prospective renter (Tyler). Richard becomes paranoid that he is being watched and sought after by the police, and he follows an innocent man (Lehman) seeking his wife (Knox) at a bus stop. He then overreacts and is shot when a finance company agent (Hunter) comes to collect his debt. He flees just as the police (Dillaway) arrive. Beth becomes paranoid herself, believing a man (Tesler) reading a newspaper is monitoring her. He takes a cab ride to meet Beth at the bus station, and the cab driver (Ragan) shows concern and offers to get him help, though a radio announcer (Frees) giving a news flash about Richard's doings brings fear to the cabbie. Richard forces the cabbie to pull over, and he knocks him out after a passing motorist (Gilbert) stops to offer help. While injured and possibly dying, Richard discovers that Beth met Burroughs the night before and received the owed money, commenting about the rat race before passing out. Supporting cast: Ken Christy as A.T. Burroughs, William Newell (credited as Billy Newell) as Charlie, Frank Kreig (credited as Frank Krieg) as Martin the Janitor, Henry Hunter as Finance Company Agent, Don Dillaway as Policeman, Mike Ragan as Cab Driver, Harry Tyler as Apartment Hunter, Jack Tesler as Newspaper Man, Joe Gilbert (credited as Joseph Gilbert) as Passing Motorist, Dorothy Crehan as Woman, Patricia Knox as Woman at Bus Stop, John Lehman (credited as John Lehmann) as Man at Bus Stop, Myron Cook as Man in Bar, Paul Frees as Radio Announcer (uncredited)