This article is about the Division I-AA (now FCS) championship game. For the Division I-A (now FBS) champions, see 1991 NCAA Division I-A football season.
The participants of the Championship Game were the finalists of the 1991 I-AA Playoffs, which began with a 16-team bracket.[4] The location of the final, the Georgia Southern Eagles' Paulson Stadium, had been predetermined via a three-year agreement the university reached with the NCAA in February 1989.[5]
Youngstown State finished their regular season with an 8–3 record.[6] Unseeded in the tournament and ranked 13th in the final NCAA I-AA in-house poll,[7] the Penguins defeated Villanova, top-seed Nevada, and Samford to reach the final. This was the first appearance for Youngstown State in a Division I-AA championship game.
Marshall also finished their regular season with an 8–3 record (5–2 in conference).[8] Unseeded and ranked eighth in the final NCAA I-AA in-house poll,[7] the Thundering Herd defeated Western Illinois, third-seed Northern Iowa, and second-seed Eastern Kentucky to reach the final. This was the second appearance for Marshall in a Division I-AA championship game, having lost in 1987.
After a low-scoring first half, Youngstown State held a 3–0 lead at halftime. Marshall then scored all of their points in the third quarter, taking a 17–6 lead. Youngstown State rallied for three touchdowns in the fourth quarter, and a 25–17 win.[9]