1884 Andalusian earthquake

1884 Andalusian earthquake
	Enrique Simonet Terremoto en Málaga (1885)
UTC time	1884-12-25 21:08
Local time	21:08
Magnitude	6.7±0.2 Mw
Depth	12,300 metres (40,400 ft)
Epicenter	36°58′N 4°04′W / 36.96°N 4.07°W
Max. intensity	MMI IX (Violent)
Aftershocks	1 year
Casualties	1,200 dead ; 3,000+ Injured

The 1884 Andalusian earthquake (Spanish: Terremoto de Andalucía de 1884) occurred on 25 December 1884 at 9:08 p.m in the south of Spain, and had an estimated magnitude of 6.7 M_w. It shook a poor region where many of the houses were built without foundations, with lime or mud mortar, and with weak joints. More than 10,000 buildings were badly damaged, of which 4,399 were completely destroyed. There were over 1,200 deaths and 1,500 serious injuries, however, many people were in the streets celebrating Christmas hence casualties were not higher. The heavy snow that followed the earthquake caused further suffering and deaths. Help was slow to arrive at first, but as the news spread food and blankets arrived, then tents, and then donations from around the world helped with reconstruction.

Background

The Bética region in the south and southeast of Spain experiences seismic activity caused by the collision of the African plate and the Eurasian plate. Within this region, Granada is a zone of moderate seismic activity by world standards, but is a dangerous seismic zone under the Spanish building code. Most earthquakes are of magnitude less than 5.5, but large earthquakes with magnitude greater than 6.5 do occur occasionally. Many of the earthquakes are shallow, at depths of less than 40 kilometres (25 mi), but there are a significant number with hypocenters at depths from 40 to 150 kilometres (25 to 93 mi). Some rare events have been detected at depths of around 630 kilometres (390 mi).^[2]

The slippage rate in the Ventas de Zafarraya fault is about 3.5 centimetres (1.4 in) per century. At least two other earthquakes of magnitude 6.5 have occurred along this fault in the last 10,000 years.^[3] There are records of earthquakes with epicenters in the region in 1431, 1504, 1518, 1522, 1531, 1645, 1674, 1680, 1748, 1804 and 1829.^[4] Historical records show that destructive earthquakes in the Málaga/Granada region occur every 200 years or so.^[1]

Destructive earthquakes in the Depression of Granada occurred on 24 April and 27 June 1431 and on 27 October 1806 with epicenters in Santa Elvira near Granada.^[5] There were destructive shocks in the Province of Almería in 1804, 1860 and 1863, and in the Region of Murcia in 1828–29 and 1864. A few very weak tremors were felt a day or two before the 25 December 1884 earthquake. Minor shocks were noted at Colmenar and Zafarraya during the night of 24–25 December, and later on 25 December small movements were felt in Málaga and Periana.^[6]

Earthquake

The clock at the Real Instituto y Observatorio de la Armada stopped at 9:08 p.m. GMT, or 9:18 p.m. Paris time on 25 December 1884.^[7] Magnetographs at Lisbon, Parc de Saint-Maur near Paris, Greenwich and Wilhelmshaven recorded disturbances at 9:09, 9:14, 9:15 and 9:29 respectively.^[8] Two observatories near Rome detected slight tremors at or just after 10:00 p.m.^[9]

The earthquake caused damage in a zone 200 by 80 kilometres (124 by 50 mi) in the provinces of Granada and Malaga.^[5] It was felt as far away as Madrid and Valencia.^[10] Later, the French commission estimated that 154,000 square miles (400,000 km²) were disturbed by the earthquake, and the Italian commission put the area at 174,000 square miles (450,000 km²). Even the larger estimate must be too small, since the shock was sufficient to ring bells and stop clocks in Madrid.^[9] The fracture zone was 17 to 20 kilometres (11 to 12 mi) long, which indicates a moment magnitude of about 6.5 to 6.9. The epicenter was between 36°58′N 3°59′W / 36.96°N 3.98°W / 36.96; -3.98 and 36°58′N 4°10′W / 36.96°N 4.16°W / 36.96; -4.16. This is between Arenas del Rey and Ventas de Zafarraya.^[7] It is on the northern side of the Sierra de Tejeda, nearest to Ventas de Zafarraya.^[11]

The shaking was generally thought to have lasted for 15 to 20 seconds, with a noise "like cannon shots" in Arenas del Rey and Jayena, or like loud thunder in Ventas de Zafarraya, Alhama de Granada, Alcaucín, Canillas de Aceituno and Colmenar. In Ventas de Zafarraya and Alhama almost vertical longitudinal waves were followed one or two seconds later by transverse waves.^[3] This indicates a depth of focus that was probably less than 15–20 kilometres (9.3–12.4 mi).^[12]

Aftershocks were felt during the night that followed, with one at 2:30 causing the collapse of some of the buildings damaged by the main earthquake. That night aftershocks were also felt in Jayena, Alcaucin, Ventas de Huelma, Motril, Cacín, Dúrcal, and further away in Vélez-Málaga. There were almost daily aftershocks until May, causing further damage in the epicentral area. Significant shocks were felt on 30 December 1884 and in 1885 on 3/5/21 January, 19/27 February, 25 March, 11 April and 13 October.^[7]

A visible crack over 7 kilometres (4.3 mi) long ran in a roughly east–west direction along the northern margin of the Sierra Tejeda and past Ventas de Zafarraya. Displacements along the crack were 1.2 to 1.5 metres (3 ft 11 in to 4 ft 11 in) horizontally and 1.2 metres (3 ft 11 in) vertically.^[13] The earthquake produced soil liquefaction, landslides, cracks in the ground, subsidence, changes to the flow from springs, and the release of gases.^[14] The three commissions that investigated the earthquake described phenomena associated with soil liquefaction at seven separate sites. Dynamic penetration tests have proved that liquefaction occurred at five of these sites.^[15]

Damage

The earthquake damaged 106 communities, of which 39 suffered severe damage.^[5] The villages of Arenas del Rey, Ventas de Zafarraya and Alhama de Granada were almost completely destroyed.^[10] 10,715 buildings were badly damaged, of which 4,399 were completely destroyed.^[1] More than 20,000 houses were affected.^[5]

The most common types of building in the region were poorly built, with lime or mud mortar and without foundations, and proved very vulnerable, particularly when built on soft terrain which amplified the shocks.^[16] There was less damage to houses built on old limestone or crystalline rocks, greater damage to houses built on soft sedimentary rocks and greatest damage to those built on alluvial soil.^[14] A horseshoe-shaped landslide in Güevéjar was about 2 kilometres (1.2 mi) long, with cracks 1 to 4 metres (3 ft 3 in to 13 ft 1 in) wide and over 6 metres (20 ft) deep. The village had to be rebuilt in a different place nearby.^[14]

There were over 1,200 deaths and 1,500 serious injuries.^[5]^[a] The quake occurred around 9 p.m. on Christmas night, so many people were on the streets celebrating the holiday, which reduced the number of victims.^[5] Other factors that may have reduced the number of casualties compared to other earthquakes of similar magnitude were that few people lived very close to the epicenter, and the most destructive vibrations were near the end of the shock, giving people time to escape.^[18]

Church of Zafarraya after the earthquake
Alhama de Granada
Church in Arenas del Rey
Jayena

Aftermath

The villages that were most affected were poor and isolated, and the earthquake was followed by unusually heavy snowfall.^[10] The disaster left over 15,000 people without homes, another 25,000 were forced to leave their homes by the ruinous conditions, and others left for fear of further collapses. They had to live in the fields, mostly without shelter, and suffered from the cold and snow.^[19] Aftershocks, some quite strong, followed in the next few days. Many of those who remained in their homes kept their doors open despite the intense cold.^[20] The first priority was to rescue people buried in the rubble and care for the wounded, and this was done by the local people in the first few days.^[19]

The newspaper El Defensor de Granada published the first news of the disaster on 26 December 1884, but the full extent was not really known until the next day. The editor called for the central and local governments to act, called for national press coverage, and opened a relief fund. He made a series of visits to distribute grants and funds in the affected villages in January, February and March.^[21] The civil and military heads of Granada delayed sending relief until ordered by the central government, and no aid arrived in Alhama until 4 January 1885.^[19] King Alfonso XII of Spain (1857–1885) visited 25 villages in the region between 10 and 20 January 1885, riding on horseback in severe weather. He died later that year.^[22]

The governors of Granada and Malaga obtained lists of victims, survivors and aid requirements and set up local organizations to distribute aid, usually consisting of the mayor, priest, doctor and leading citizens in each community. Emergency hospitals were set up in Arenas del Rey, Alhama and Padul.^[21] Wooden sheds were thrown up for temporary shelter, with 698 sheds built in total in Granada.^[23] At a national and international level the first reaction was disbelief, but this was quickly followed by a surge of support for the victims. A national subscription organized by the Spanish government reached 6.5 million pesetas. Newspapers and other organizations collected donations, and aid came from Mexico, Uruguay, Cuba and elsewhere.^[21]

Reconstruction

Large donations came from subscription funds and private individuals in Argentina, Britain, Germany and France, and from the Vatican. In Spain, Barcelona alone collected 157,925 pesetas for relief.^[24] The Catalan poet Jacint Verdaguer published a book of poems Caritat (Charity) to raise funds for reconstruction.^[17] People around the world sent donations to help recovery that totaled 10 million pesetas, and in 1885 the Comisaría Regia was established to distribute the funds to those in need. Cónchar received 31,870 pesetas and Dúrcal received 13,062 pesetas. These were not among the worst affected communities.^[20] Ventas de Zafarraya was rebuilt almost entirely with money from Cuba, at that time a colony of Spain, and the village became known as "New Havana".^[25]

In February 1885 the Ministry of the Interior called for designs by Spanish architects for new houses for the poor, which had to cost no more than 1,500 pesetas and be as strong as possible against future earthquakes. The ministry chose five designs by the architect Mariano Belmás Estrada (1850–1916). They used similar construction techniques and were between 40 and 150 square metres (430 and 1,610 sq ft) in area.^[26] Other architects such as Francisco Jareño y Alarcón and Juan Monserrat Vergés cast doubts on whether the Belmás designs would be adequate for the harsh climate of the region.^[27]

Belmás was replaced in January 1886 by José Marín-Baldo y Cachia (1826–1891).^[28] The houses that were built had solid foundations, strong frameworks, reinforced corners and other features designed to reduce risk of collapse.^[29] The villages were moved to new sites nearby on stable ground with slopes less than 5%. To ensure access after a future earthquake, reduce the risk of falling facades and provide open places for camps the new village layouts had houses grouped in blocks, streets over 10 metres (33 ft) wide and large squares.^[30] 12,345 people received assistance in reconstruction or repairs, which were undertaken from July 1885 to June 1887.^[26]

Investigations and theories

On 7 January 1884 the Spanish government appointed a commission to study the earthquake led by the mining engineer Manuel Fernández de Castro y Suero (1825–1895).^[31] They visited the region at once, circulated a 33-question survey, and on 12 March 1885 issued a report based in part on the survey results. They located the focus as 4 kilometres (2.5 mi) deep under the villages of Periana and Guarro.^[32] The preliminary report devoted seven pages to current theories of earthquake causes, volcanic and non-volcanic, including the internal heat of the earth, high pressure vapors and dissolution of rocks by underground waters. A further seven pages described the orography and hydrography of the provinces of Granada and Malaga, followed by twenty-one pages on geology that described rock formations and the location and direction of the main fault line.^[33]

The Spanish Commission estimated that 17,178 buildings were damaged, of which 4,899 were totally destroyed. 745 people had died and 1,485 had been wounded.^[33] They concluded that the earthquake was caused by the pressure of water vapor in deep underground strata, from water that had penetrated the permeable rocks above.^[34] The commission noted that atmospheric pressure had dropped markedly before the earthquake.^[35]

The French Academy of Sciences sent another commission headed by Ferdinand André Fouqué (1828–1904), an academy member, which prepared a long report with a map.^[32]^[b] The French commission said the atmospheric conditions were irrelevant and the earthquake was related to the region's geology.^[35]

The Italian Government and the Accademia dei Lincei sent the seismologists Torquato Taramelli (1845–1922) and Giuseppe Mercalli (1850–1912), who also provided a long report on the area's geology with a map of the intensity of the shaking.^[32] Mercalli thought the earthquake was produced by the build-up of pressure in magma in a region where the crust was too strong to allow a volcanic eruption.^[37] The Italian team, with access to more information than the Spanish and French commissions, estimated there were 750 deaths and 1,554 severely wounded. After careful enquiries, El Defensor de Granada estimated that 828 died and 1,164 were wounded in Granada alone.^[38] The pioneering geologist José Macpherson y Hemas (1839–1902) explained the earthquake as having been caused by movement along the faults that bound the Tejeda / Almijara massif to the north and south. He thought the movement was due to contraction of the earth. Others thought the cause might have been the collapse of underground cavities.^[39]

In historical times the only earthquake in Spain that was larger than the 1884 earthquake was that of 1954, which also had an epicenter in Granada, although the destruction in 1954 was not as great.^[40]

Notes

^ Another source says 745 died and 1475 were wounded.^[1] All figures must be treated with caution due to poor data collection at the time.^[17]
^ Fouqué later wrote a popular textbook on earthquakes that included short accounts of the Ilopango earthquake and Japanese earthquakes of 1854, the Ischia earthquake of 1883, the Granadan earthquake of 1884 and the French Riviera earthquake of 1887.^[36]

Citations

^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Udias & Muñoz 1979, p. 291.
^ Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 11.
^ ^a ^b Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 17.
^ Vidal Sánchez 2011, pp. 11–12.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d ^e ^f Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 13.
^ Davison 1905, PT62.
^ ^a ^b ^c Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 15.
^ Davison 1905, PT67.
^ ^a ^b Davison 1905, PT66.
^ ^a ^b ^c Udías 2013, p. 191.
^ Udías 2013, p. 194.
^ Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 18.
^ Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 16.
^ ^a ^b ^c Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 21.
^ Arango et al. 1995, p. 1.
^ Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 23.
^ ^a ^b Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 40.
^ Davison 1905, PT64.
^ ^a ^b ^c Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 30.
^ ^a ^b Terremoto de Granada, Año 1884.
^ ^a ^b ^c Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 31.
^ Udías 2013, p. 191–192.
^ Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 34.
^ Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 32.
^ Ventas de Zafarraya Historia.
^ ^a ^b Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 35.
^ Burgos Núñez, Olmo García & Sáenz Pérez 2018, p. 8.
^ Burgos Núñez, Olmo García & Sáenz Pérez 2018, p. 10.
^ Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 37.
^ Vidal Sánchez 2011, p. 36.
^ Udías 2013, p. 192.
^ ^a ^b ^c Udías 2013, p. 193.
^ ^a ^b Preliminary Report of the Commission... 1885, p. 393.
^ Preliminary Report of the Commission... 1885, p. 394.
^ ^a ^b Udías 2013, p. 195.
^ Davison 1927, p. 158.
^ Udías 2013, pp. 195–196.
^ Davison 1905, PT63.
^ Udías 2013, p. 196.
^ Anduaga Egaña 2009, p. 39.

Sources

Anduaga Egaña, Aitor (2009), Geofísica, economía y sociedad en la España contemporánea (in Spanish), Editorial CSIC – CSIC Press, ISBN 978-84-00-08906-1, retrieved 21 August 2019
Arango, José R.; Blazquez, Rafael; Chacon, José; López Casado, Carlos (July 1995), "Soil liquefaction potential induced by the andalusian earthquake of 25 December 1884", Natural Hazards, 12 (1): 1–17, Bibcode:1995NatHa..12....1A, doi:10.1007/BF00605278, S2CID 128943821
Burgos Núñez, Antonio; Olmo García, Juan Carlos; Sáenz Pérez, María Paz (25 October 2018), "Las Viviendas Del Terremoto De Andalucía De 1884" (PDF), Biblio3W, XXIII (1.252), Universitat de Barcelona, ISSN 1138-9796, retrieved 2019-08-24
Davison, Charles (1905), "A Study of Recent Earthquakes", Nature, 71 (1849), Read Books Limited: 532–533, Bibcode:1905Natur..71..532., doi:10.1038/071532b0, hdl:2027/uc2.ark:/13960/t2c82665v, ISBN 978-1-4733-8266-4, S2CID 4048841, retrieved 21 August 2019
Davison, Charles (1927), The Founders of Seismology, Cambridge University Press, ISBN 978-1-107-69149-0, retrieved 21 August 2019
"Preliminary Report of the Commission Appointed to Report on the Spanish Earthquakes", Science, 6 (143), American Association for the Advancement of Science: 393–394, 30 October 1885, Bibcode:1885Sci.....6R.393., doi:10.1126/science.ns-6.143S.393-a, JSTOR 1761923, PMID 17820268
"Terremoto de Granada, Año 1884", Conchar.com (in Spanish), retrieved 2019-08-19
Udías, Agustín (2013), "Development Of Seismology In Spain In The Context Of The Three Large Earthquakes Of 1755, 1884 And 1954", Earth Sciences History, 32 (2), History of Earth Sciences Society: 186–203, Bibcode:2013ESHis..32..186U, doi:10.17704/eshi.32.2.f1168212m214l532, JSTOR 24140011
Udias, A.; Muñoz, D. (20 March 1979), "The Andalusian earthquake of 25 December 1884", Tectonophysics, 53 (3–4): 291–299, Bibcode:1979Tectp..53..291U, doi:10.1016/0040-1951(79)90074-X
"Ventas de Zafarraya Historia", Andalucia.org (in Spanish), Consejería de Turismo y Deporte de la Junta de Andalucia, retrieved 2019-08-19
Vidal Sánchez, Francisco (2011), "Terremoto de Alhama de Granada de 1884 y su impacto", Anuari Verdaguer (in Spanish) (19), retrieved 2019-08-20

v t e Earthquakes in the 1800s
1800s	1802 Vrancea 1803 Garhwal 1804 Kisakata 1804 Almería 1805 Molise
1810s	1810 Crete 1810 North Korea 1811–1812 New Madrid 1812 Caracas 1812 San Juan Capistrano 1812 Ventura 1815 Pinglu 1815 Bali 1816 North Atlantic 1816 Guatemala 1817 Santiago del Estero 1819 Copiapó 1819 Rann of Kutch
1820s	1822 Costa Rica 1822 Aleppo 1825 Blida 1828 Sanjō 1829 Torrevieja
1830s	1830 Cixian 1833 Bihar–Nepal 1833 Kunming 1833 Sumatra 1833 Shōnai 1834 Jerusalem 1834 Java 1835 Concepción 1837 Galilee 1837 Valdivia 1838 Vrancea 1838 San Andreas 1839 Ava
1840s	1840 Ahora 1841 Kamchatka 1841 Caída da Praia 1842 Cap-Haïtien 1843 Nias 1843 Guadeloupe 1843 Wanganui 1844 Salta 1847 Zenkoji 1848 Marlborough
1850s	1850 Xichang 1851 Vulture 1852 Banda Sea 1852 Acapulco 1853 Shiraz 1854 Iga–Ueno 1854 Tōkai 1854 Nankai 1855 Wairarapa 1855 Bursa 1855 Edo 1856 Djijelli 1856 Heraklion 1857 Fort Tejon 1857 Basilicata 1858 Hietsu 1859 Erzurum 1859 Shamakhi
1860s	1861 Sumatra 1861 Mendoza 1861 Mendoza 1863 Jujuy 1863 Hawke's Bay 1863 Manila 1865 Memphis 1866 Bingöl 1867 Manhattan 1867 Java 1867 Virgin Islands 1867 Keelung 1868 Hawaii 1868 Arica 1868 Ecuador 1868 Hayward 1869 Christchurch 1869 Cachar
1870s	1870 Batang 1870 Charlevoix 1871 Lānaʻi 1871 Orán 1871–72 Quchan 1872 Hamada 1872 Owens Valley 1872 Amik 1872 North Cascades 1873 Alpago 1875 Cúcuta 1877 Iquique 1879 Bozqush 1879 Surigao 1879 Gansu
1880s	1880 Southern Luzon 1880 Zagreb 1881 Chios 1881 Nicobar Islands 1882 Panama 1883 Casamicciola 1883 Çeşme 1884 Colchester 1884 Andalusian 1885 Belovodoskoe 1886 Peloponnese 1886 Charleston 1887 Sonora 1887 Verny 1888 Ritter Island 1888 Río de la Plata 1888 North Canterbury 1889 Chilik 1889 Kumamoto
1890s	1891 Port Waikato 1891 Mino–Owari 1892 Laguna Salada 1892 Catamarca 1892 Vacaville–Winters 1893 Malatya 1893 Quchan 1894 Vlorë 1894 Atalanti 1894 Tokyo 1894 Istanbul 1894 Shōnai 1894 San Juan 1895 Quchan 1895 Ljubljana 1895 Balkan 1895 Charleston 1896 Sanriku 1896 Rikuu Assam 1897 Mindanao 1898 Balıkesir 1898 Mare Island 1898 Trilj 1899 Yakutat Bay 1899 Aydın–Denizli 1899 Ceram 1899 San Jacinto