User talk:Mshep
ORRIEL SMITH
[edit]I've had to delete the article you created. You are welcome to do it again, but PLEASE dont write it all in caps again? Also, please be advised that Some of the people, places or things you have written about in the article ORRIEL SMITH may not be sufficiently well-known to merit articles of their own. The Wikipedia community welcomes newcomers, and encourages them to become Wikipedians. On Wikipedia, all users are entitled to a user page in which they can describe themselves, and this article's content may be incorporated into that page. However, to merit inclusion in the encyclopedia proper, a subject must be notable. We encourage you to write or improve articles on notable subjects. -- - Glen 08:32, 19 September 2006 (UTC)
Welcome to Wikipedia!
[edit]Morning Mike, small world (Im also an Aucklander - Takapuna to be precise :) ) You are dead right, notability is entirely subjective; however we do have some guidelines (have a read of the policy at WP:N)
I took a look at the website yesterday as it happens, and my first impressions were that she is on the fringe. When articles are written that are clearly not notable (and we get hundreds per day) they are deleted almost immediately via our Speedy deletion criteria - now in my opinion she is not speediable - which means that when you submit the article, if some editors feel it is not notable enough then it will most likely be nominated for deletion. Now this is a 5 day process where users express there opinions and then deletion (or not) is decided upon based on consensus.
So, what I suggest you do is rewrite the article at Orriel Smith, and do your best to ensure it fits our neutral point of view and copyright policies (don't copy it from her website for example). This will give the best chances of retaining the article.
I know it sounds complicated (and writing your first article is a challenge - most Wikipedians find their first attempts deleted) but its not that difficult trust me (Ive clocked up 10,000 edits here!) The only other tip I have is take a look at the formatting or similar articles, especially things like Wikilinks, and things like the External links sections (you'll find all of this info at WP:MOS).
And good luck! And please message me if I can assist in anyway (there's only a couple of administrators from NZ so we were lucky to meet!) - I'll leave a few more tips below, thanks again! - Glen 19:45, 19 September 2006 (UTC)
Welcome!
[edit]
Welcome to Wikipedia! I hope you enjoy the encyclopaedia and want to stay. Before getting too in-depth, you may want to read about the simplified ruleset. If you need help on how to title new articles check out the naming conventions, and for help on formatting the pages visit the manual of style. If you need help look at Wikipedia:Help and the FAQ; plus, if you can't find your answer there, check the Village Pump (for Wikipedia related questions) or the Reference Desk (for general questions). There's still more help at the Tutorial and Policy Library. Also, don't forget to visit the Community Portal. And if you have any more questions after that, feel free to post them on my user talk page.
Additional tips
[edit]Here are some extra tips to help you get around in Wikipedia:
- If you want to play around with your new Wiki skills the Sandbox is for you.
- You can sign your name using four tildes (~~~~).
- You may want to add yourself to the new user log.
- If you ever think a page or image should be deleted, please list it at the articles for deletion page. There is also a requests for undeletion page if you want to retrieve something that you think should not have been deleted.
- If you're still entirely confused, or would like to get a better grasp of your wikipedia skills, and you have an IRC client (or don't mind getting one), check out the Bootcamp. It's not what it sounds like, but it is fun and can help you with your editing skills.
Current open tasks
[edit]You can help improve the articles listed below! This list updates frequently, so check back here for more tasks to try. (See Wikipedia:Maintenance or the Task Center for further information.)
Help counter systemic bias by creating new articles on important women.
Help improve popular pages, especially those of low quality.
Orriel Smith
[edit]I got your message but I can't find the article you speak of. It is not at Orriel Smith Operatic Parodist nor Orriel Smith (and it hasn't been deleted from those locations). Any ideas? Glen 01:37, 2 February 2007 (UTC)
- Hmmm... okay. The draft you've given me really needs some work. First of all, what really strikes me is a lot of it breaches our neutral point of view policy. Example - look for the parts in italics:
- The difference between "naive" parodists like Florence Foster Jenkins (who for all her seeming naivety well knew what she was on about) is that Orriel Smith can not only sing but can hit high E's and F's which have reviewers drooling
- In fact, even talking about the difference between her and others is showing a point of view (who says they're different - they may sound the same to me) - see what I mean? If you have an opinion like that in there, it should be the opinion of a reviewer (and the review should be linked to).
- Also, Im not really sure that her notability is shown. Perhaps if you could link to these reviews it would help. Hope this helps you for now Glen 20:19, 2 February 2007 (UTC)