Wikipedia:Requests for arbitration/Tango/Evidence/by Risker
Temporary page - All data are here; a wikitable will be prepared to make it more readable.
Risker (talk) 22:27, 23 April 2008 (UTC)
Block 1
[edit]Date/Time of block: 13:14, 12 April 2008 [1]
Article(s) involved: User talk page of User:MONGO. At 10:38 on 10 April, MONGO reverted a post by User:Thomas Basboll with edit summary "revert SPA trolling"[2], subsequently reverted posts by User:Tango at 0400 on 12 April 2008 with an edit summary "get lost...if you support conspiracy theorist misusing this website, then you should be deadminned"[3]
User(s) blocked: MONGO
Reason(s) for block: "Incivility following warninging (sic) under http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Requests_for_arbitration/September_11_conspiracy_theories#Discretionary_sanctions"
Warning(s) given: On MONGO's page - 14:59, 10 April 2008[4], addition of link to Arbcom ruling 15:06, 10 April 2008[5]; ANI warning at 14:57 on 10 April[6]
Noticeboard info: ANI thread from 10 April 2008[7], includes warning to MONGO; announcement of block, extensive discussion, announcement of civility parole, etc. on ANI[8]
Subsequent actions by Tango: See AN/I discussion
Subsequent actions by other admin(s): See AN/I discussion
Additional Notes:
| Date/Time of block: | Article(s) involved: | User(s) blocked: | Reason(s) for block: | Warning(s) given: | Noticeboard info: | Subsequent actions by Tango | Subsequent actions by other admin(s): | Additional Notes: |
| 13:14, 12 April 2008 [9] | User talk page of User:MONGO. | MONGO |
"Incivility following warninging (sic) under [10]" |
On MONGO's page - 14:59, 10 April 2008[11], addition of link to Arbcom ruling 15:06, 10 April 2008[12]; ANI warning at 14:57 on 10 April[13] | ANI thread from 10 April 2008[14], includes warning to MONGO; announcement of block, extensive discussion, announcement of civility parole, etc. on ANI [15] |
See AN/I discussion | See AN/I discussion | |
| Synopsis: At 10:38 on 10 April, MONGO reverted a post by User:Thomas Basboll with edit summary "revert SPA trolling"[16], subsequently reverted posts by User:Tango at 0400 on 12 April 2008 with an edit summary "get lost...if you support conspiracy theorist misusing this website, then you should be deadminned"[17] | ||||||||
Block 2
[edit]Date/Time of block: 23:21 on 21 March 2008
Article(s) involved: List of countries and outlying territories by total area
User(s) blocked: User:Tubesship[18] [19], User:70.49.152.70[20] [21]
Reason(s) for block: WP:3RR violation on List of countries and outlying territories by total area
Warning(s) given: None by User:Tango. Message on talk page of IP from User Tubesship at 23:05, 21 March 2008 requesting end to edit war[22]
Noticeboard info: From ANI-User:Tubesship requests help with anonymous IP on the article at 22:49, 21 March 2008; some discussion of dispute resolution occurs after both parties blocked for 3RR [23]
Subsequent actions by Tango: Extended conversation with User:Tubesship on user talk page[24]. Discussion of the 3RR rule, explanation of why IP's edit was not considered vandalism, Tubesship's request that autoblock be lifted as others use the same proxy, no offer to lift block once new user understood rule.
Subsequent actions by other admin(s): None
Additional Notes: (1) The edit war had started several hours earlier at 01:42 with edits by another IP, which were reverted by User:Polaron and User:Parsecboy; it could be considered a slow edit war, with 2 IPs and 3 registered regular editors. (2) User:Tubesship registered his account on 26 February 2008. Editing was in articles relating to Kosovo, a few miscellaneous articles, and a discussion with an experienced user with respect to image copyright ("Please help a greenhorn understand the difference between public domain and wiki commons").
Block 3
[edit]Date/Time of block: 17:35, 30 January 2008
Article(s) involved: Pure Reason Revolution Edit war over whether or not the references given supported the statements in the article. No talk page discussion. The edit war appears to have been the result of recent changes patrol, based on the contribution histories of the other editors involved. Blocked user reverted by four other editors, including Tango. [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36](Reversion by Tango)
User(s) blocked: User:Justpassinby[37], [38]
Reason(s) for block: Vandalism
Warning(s) given: 29 January (for different edits to article): Level 1[39], level 2[40]; 30 January: level 3[41], level 4[42]
Noticeboard info: None identified. Block appears to have occurred during RC patrolling
Subsequent actions by Tango: None identified
Subsequent actions by other admin(s): None identified
Additional Notes: 1) Blocked user appears to be a single purpose account, editing solely on this and one other related article, plus various user and project pages related to these articles. Prior to 29 January, he had only 16 edits since registration in March 2007. Signed his edits on the article. Consider possibility he was a member of, or related to, the subject band. 2) Blocked user has subsequently been blocked indefinitely by User:Jpgordon[43]. 3) The blocked account was correct, in that the reference sources did not support the content in the article. It appears the RC patrollers never actually checked the edits for correctness. 4)Blocked user had also edited the article the day before, and had communicated with editor reverting him on the second editor's talk page[44], at which point the second editor stopped reverting.
Block 4
[edit]Date/Time of block: 20:14, 1 September 2007
Article(s) involved: Subregion
User(s) blocked: User:67.71.251.74[45], [46], User:AlexCovarrubias [47], [48]. IP blocked 24 hours. AlexCovarrubias blocked one month.
Reason(s) for block: Three-revert rule violation: 3RR on Subregion
Warning(s) given: None on either user's talk page. None on talk page of article.
Noticeboard info: 3RR[49]; no discussions identified on ANI or AN.
Subsequent actions by Tango: User:AlexCovarrubias, posting as an anonymous IP, requests Tango to reconsider block length on 2 September on Tango's talk page. [50]. Tango deletes messsage[51]. Tango unblocks user then reblocks for 2 months[52].
Subsequent actions by other admin(s): RFCU report by User:Picaroon[53]. Unblock by Picaroon[54] on 19 September, identifying AlexCovarrubias agreed to limit himself to 1 revert per day.
Additional Notes: 1) AlexCovarrubias had a history of 3RR violations at the time of Tango's block, and his previous block for 3RR was for one month. The initial block was consistent with usual practice. 2) The block message left on the blocked user's talk page did not contain a link to the "unblock" template. 3)Additional exchanges on this case appear to have taken place via email with one or more administrators.
Block 5
[edit]Date/Time of block: 18:08, 27 August 2007
Article(s) involved: Stargate Atlantis
User(s) blocked: User:Andromeda[55] [56], User:88wolfmaster[57] [58]
Reason(s) for block: Edit warring on Stargate Atlantis
Warning(s) given: To User:Andromeda 15 Aug [59] to use edit summaries on Stargate Atlantis; 20 Aug[60], 3RR warning.
Noticeboard info: None identified.
Subsequent actions by Tango: Prior to blocks, protected page on 22 Aug[61]. Tango subsequently attempted to mediate on article's talk page, 2-3 Sep; one of the editors involved has not edited the article since (no suggestion Tango had anything to do with that).
Subsequent actions by other admin(s): None identified
Additional Notes: 1) Two editors with different visions of what the article should be, one more recalcitrant than the other. Slow edit war over several weeks, with other users identifying that one user's various attempts at consensus were preferred over the other's. Page history[62], talk page history[63]. 2) Neither editor had made any edits on the page for over 36 hours when they were blocked. 3) Tango is very involved in articles related to this subject, and mentioned his work in this topic during his RfA.
Block 6
[edit]Date/Time of block: 20:29, 22 August 2007
Article(s) involved: Mulatto
User(s) blocked: User:ArabicX[64], [65]; User:Deadriene16[66], [67]
Reason(s) for block: Three-revert rule violation: edit warring on Mulatto
Warning(s) given: None on user talk pages.
Noticeboard info: 3RR noticeboard[68], Arabic X reporting Deadriene.
Subsequent actions by Tango: None identified. Note that block notices did not include the unblock template.
Subsequent actions by other admin(s): None identified
Additional Notes: 1) User:Deadriene16 has subsequently changed names to User:Poison the Well. 2) This is an edit war where one user (Arabic X) was making genuine improvements to the article, only to be constantly reverted by Deadriene to include an obviously inappropriate image. Arabic X had attempted to start a talk page conversation[69] and had reported to 3RR before violating the rule himself, made only 3 reverts. (Note: Description of incident is changed since short version).
Block 7
[edit]Date/Time of block: 16:29-16:31, 26 July 2007
Article(s) involved: Atanas Badev
User(s) blocked: User:Laveol[70] (3 hours, no userpage notice); User:Strich3d[71] [72] (1 week, length not identified on block message); User:Mr. Neutron[73] [74] (48 hours, length not identified on block message); User:Amacos[75] [76] (3 hours, length not identified on block message)
Reason(s) for block: Edit warring on Atanas Badev
Warning(s) given: None on any of the talk pages or on the article talk page.
Noticeboard info: None identified.
Subsequent actions by Tango: Tango did follow up with User:Amacos in August, when Amacos was complaining of the block and making sockpuppet allegations against some of the other edit warriors.[77] [78]
Subsequent actions by other admin(s): None identified
Additional Notes: 1) User:Mr. Neutron has changed username to User:ForeignerFromTheEast.
Block 8
[edit]Date/Time of block: 21:38, 22 February 2007
Article(s) involved: Cult apologist
User(s) blocked: User:Smeelgova[79] (3 hours)
Reason(s) for block: 3RR on Cult apologist
Warning(s) given: Unable to verify.
Noticeboard info: None identified.
Subsequent actions by Tango: Unable to verify.
Subsequent actions by other admin(s): Unable to verify
Additional Notes: 1) Userpages for User:Smeelgova have been deleted, so unavailable for review except to administrators. 2) Smeelgova (also known as User:Smee and probably more names), was known to have a history of 3RR and other blocks. Block history for Smeelgova[80], block history for Smee[81]
Block 9
[edit]Date/Time of block: 13:37, 16 December 2006
Article(s) involved: Goa Inquisition
User(s) blocked: User:Rumpelstiltskin223[82] [83] (3 hour block); User:Xandar[84] [85] (3 hour block)
Reason(s) for block: Violating 3RR on Goa Inquisition
Warning(s) given: By Rumplestiltskin223 to Xandar - NPA[86], vandalism[87]
Noticeboard info: ANI thread relating to blocks and protection[88] ; per ANI thread, this case had been reported to AIV (page history not checked)
Subsequent actions by Tango: Protected Goa Inquisition at 15:34 (nearly 2 hours after blocks)[89]
Subsequent actions by other admin(s): None identified
Additional Notes: 1) After blocking these two users, Tango himself edit-warred on the page[90] [91] [92] [93] [94] before protecting the page[95] 2) Messages on Tango's talk page pertaining to edits[96] [97]
Block 10
[edit]Date/Time of block: 12:48, 20 November 2006
Article(s) involved: User talk:Fys
User(s) blocked: User:Fys[98] (extension to 24 hours of initial 3 hour block by User:William M. Connolley[99])
Reason(s) for block: expiry time of 24 hours (repeating requesting unblock without a good reason)
Warning(s) given: N/A - user already blocked
Noticeboard info: Discussion on Tango's user talk page[100]; ANI thread[101]
Subsequent actions by Tango: Protected and subsequently unprotected User talk:Fys [102]
Subsequent actions by other admin(s): Unblock by User:Mackensen[103]
Additional Notes: