Jump to content

Panorama (British TV programme)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from The Window on the World)

Panorama
Also known asWindow on the World
The Window on the World
A Window on the World
Opening themeFrancis Lai's Aujourd'hui C'est Toi
Country of originUnited Kingdom
Original languageEnglish
No. of episodes1,233[1]
Production
Running time30–60 minutes
Production companyBBC Factual
Original release
NetworkBBC One
Release11 November 1953 (1953-11-11) –
present

Panorama is a British current affairs documentary programme broadcast on the BBC. First broadcast in 1953, it is the world's longest-running television news magazine programme.[2]

Panorama has been presented by many well-known BBC presenters, including Richard Dimbleby, Robin Day, David Dimbleby and Jeremy Vine. As of 2022, it broadcasts in peak time on BBC One, without a regular presenter. The programme also airs worldwide through the international feed of the BBC News channel in many countries, and domestically via the UK feed.

History

[edit]

Panorama was launched on 11 November 1953 by the BBC; it emphasises investigative journalism. Daily Mail reporter Pat Murphy was the original presenter,[3] who only lasted one episode after accidentally broadcasting a technical mishap. Max Robertson then took over for a year. The programme originally had a magazine format and included art features.

In September 1955, when Richard Dimbleby took over as presenter, it got the subtitle Window on the World.[4][5][6] He presented the show until his death in 1965.

His son, David Dimbleby, later presented the programme on 11 November 1974—the 21st anniversary of the show. Other past presenters include: Sir Robin Day, Sir Ludovic Kennedy, Sir Charles Wheeler and Jeremy Vine. On 13 December 2010, it was announced that the programme would be relaunched during the new year with no regular presenter.

International versions

[edit]

Panorama set an example for the German magazine series of the same name, which is produced by Norddeutscher Rundfunk, and broadcast by Das Erste. Panorama started there in 1961 and is one of the leading political magazine shows.

Theme music

[edit]

The original theme music was an excerpt from Pelléas et Mélisande by Sibelius, which was followed a few years later by a composition by Robert Farnon entitled "Openings & Endings".[7] From 1968, an extract from Rachmaninov's Symphony No.1 in D Minor, 4th Movement was used, followed in 1971 by an adaptation of Francis Lai's Aujourd'hui C'est Toi ("Today It's You"). The latest version was arranged in 2023 by Bojan Andic.

Team

[edit]

Editors

[edit]

Presenters

[edit]

Investigators

[edit]

Notable programmes

[edit]

Mescaline

[edit]

In 1955, Panorama filmed Christopher Mayhew taking mescaline under medical supervision.[9][10] The resulting programme was never broadcast, though the footage and transcripts were later released.[11]

Spaghetti tree

[edit]

Panorama broadcast a famous hoax film about the harvesting of the spaghetti crop on April Fool's Day, 1957.[12]

Salvador Dalí

[edit]

Broadcast on 4 May 1955, Malcolm Muggeridge talked with Salvador Dalí, the Spanish surrealist artist.[13]

Maggie's Militant Tendency

[edit]

In January 1984, Panorama broadcast an episode which claimed that three Conservative MPs (Neil Hamilton, Harvey Proctor and Gerald Howarth) had links to far-right organisations both in Britain and on the Continent.[14]

The programme was based on an internal Conservative Party report compiled by Phil Pedley, Chairman of the Young Conservatives. Panorama confirmed its status with a senior Conservative Party vice chairman. The report was formally presented to the Party in the week before the programme was aired. During the making of the programme, attempts to contact some of the named MPs for comment were unsuccessful. (Hamilton's wife Christine later described how "Neil and I had devised a method for making sure that Panorama personnel would not be in a position to say that Neil had refused to speak".)[15] The programme was vetted prior to transmission by the BBC's lawyers, by the Head of Currents Affairs Television, and by the Chief Assistant to the Director General, Margaret Douglas.

Two of the MPs named in the programme (Hamilton and Howarth) sued the BBC and the programme-makers. The Director-General, Alasdair Milne, reviewed the BBC's own legal advice, and that of his Chief Assistant, and declared the programme to be "rock solid". The Board of Governors (Chairman Stuart Young) also gave their backing for the programme to be defended in court. Stuart Young died in August 1986, two months before the libel case against Panorama came to trial. A new chairman, Marmaduke Hussey, had been appointed but had not formally arrived at the BBC when the trial opened on 13 October 1986. Hussey nevertheless spoke with the BBC's barrister, Charles Grey. Hussey says in his memoirs that "Grey thought it unlikely the BBC would win". Sir Charles Grey disputes this statement, saying that "my junior and I both thought the case was winnable".[15] The first four days of the trial were given over to opening statements from Hamilton and Howarth and their lawyers, which received wide press coverage. On the evening of the fourth day the BBC's Assistant DG Alan Protheroe informed the BBC's legal team and the named defendants that the Governors now wished to settle the case immediately. This prevented the BBC's defence from being put to the court, or known to the public.[16]

Hamilton and Howarth were each awarded £25,000 in damages. Costs amounted to £240,000. They dropped their case against Phil Pedley.

There was controversy over the editing of the programme: it juxtaposed shots of Howarth wearing a train driver's uniform at a steam railway enthusiasts' rally with the claim that he had attended a fascist meeting in Italy, suggesting that the uniform he was wearing was a fascist one.[17]

Diana, Princess of Wales interview

[edit]
Main article: An Interview with HRH The Princess of Wales

Arguably the best known Panorama programme of all was the 1995 interview of Diana, Princess of Wales by Martin Bashir, which occurred after her separation from Charles, Prince of Wales, when she openly discussed the rumours about her personal life. The programme's filming and planning was subject to extreme secrecy, with Richard James Ayre, the Controller of Editorial Policy, authorising a series of clandestine meetings between Bashir and Diana.[18]

It became known a quarter century later that Bashir had used journalistically unethical practices in gaining the interview. In late 2020, the BBC director general Tim Davie apologised to Earl Spencer, brother of the princess, for the use of highly dubious methods.[19] The Earl, who introduced Bashir to his sister, rejected the apology and demanded an inquiry.[20] Former Justice of the Supreme Court John Dyson, Lord Dyson conducted an independent inquiry into the issue.[21][22] Dyson's inquiry found Bashir guilty of deceit and breaching BBC editorial conduct to obtain the interview.[23][24]

Omagh bombing

[edit]

One of the most controversial broadcasts of recent time was the "Who bombed Omagh?" programme, which named those suspected of involvement in the Omagh bombing. Deputy Assistant Commissioner Alan Fry of Scotland Yard's anti-terrorist unit SO13 said that the Real IRA attack on the BBC Television Centre could have been a revenge attack for the broadcast.[25]

Scientology

[edit]

In 1987, the Panorama programme Scientology: The Road to Total Freedom? for the first time exposed on broadcast television the secret upper-level doctrines of the Church of Scientology, and featured an animated retelling of the Xenu incident of Scientology doctrine.[26]

On 14 May 2007, an episode titled Scientology and Me was broadcast. The journalist John Sweeney presented the edition, showing how the Church reacted to his journalistic investigations, including its reaction when he stated to members that some people describe the organisation as a "cult". At one point during an interview, the presenter lost his temper with the Church's international spokesman; an edited portion of this incident was released subsequently by the Church on YouTube and DVD in an attempt to publicise it and raise controversy. However, the 2007 Scientology episode was Panorama's greatest audience since it moved to Monday evening.[27][28]

A follow-up programme, The Secrets of Scientology, was broadcast on 28 September 2010, presenting proof that the Church had harassed Sweeney during the making of the earlier documentary, with the specific intention of making him react in the way he eventually did. The episode also included numerous interviews with former high-ranking members of the organisation who had been subject to harassment.[29]

Panorama and Seroxat

[edit]

Since 2002, Panorama has made four programmes about the anti-depressant Seroxat (paroxetine / Paxil): "The Secrets of Seroxat" (2002);[30] "Seroxat: Emails from the Edge" (2003);[31] "Taken on Trust" (2004)[32] and "Secrets of the Drug Trials" (2007).[33]

"The Secrets of Seroxat" elicited a record response from the public as 65,000 people telephoned the BBC helpline and 1,300 people emailed Panorama directly.[34]

The major mental health charity Mind collaborated with Panorama in a survey of those who emailed the programme. Anonymous findings from the 239 responses were sent to the Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA).[34]

The second Panorama programme on Seroxat, "Emails from the Edge", included a report of the survey to which the 239 people responded. It showed widespread experiences of suicidal feelings and other severe reactions, very bad withdrawal symptoms and lack of warnings from doctors. After the broadcast users/survivors and Mind protested outside the offices of the MHRA.[34]

On 29 January 2007, the fourth documentary of the series about the drug Seroxat was broadcast. It focused on three GlaxoSmithKline paediatric clinical trials on depressed children and adolescents. Data from the trials show that Seroxat could not be proven to work for teenagers. Not only that, one clinical trial indicated that they were six times more likely to become suicidal after taking it. In the programme, Panorama revealed the secret trail of internal emails which show how GlaxoSmithKline manipulated the results of the trials for its own commercial gain. Access to the documents has been gained as GlaxoSmithKline fights a fraud trial in the US.

Some of these previously secret Glaxo documents featured in the programme were leaked into the internet after the programme's broadcast.[35]

Undercover: Football's Dirty Secrets

[edit]
Main article: 2006 English football corruption investigation

On 19 September 2006 Panorama showed a documentary called "Undercover: Football's Dirty Secrets", which alleged payments in English football contrary to the rules of the Football Association, involving:

  • That Bolton Wanderers manager Sam Allardyce, and his agent son Craig were implicated for taking "bungs" (a bribe or kickback) from agents for signing certain players. Two agents, Teni Yerima and Peter Harrison, were secretly filmed, each claiming separately that they had paid Allardyce through his son. Allardyce denies ever taking, or asking for, a bung.[36] The programme was aired on the same night that Bolton beat Walsall 3–1 in the Carling Cup, so Allardyce missed the original showing.
  • Portsmouth manager Harry Redknapp is secretly filmed discussing the possibility of buying the Blackburn Rovers captain Andy Todd with agent Peter Harrison, which is against Football Association rules.
  • Then Portsmouth first-team coach Kevin Bond, who was first team coach of Newcastle United at the time of broadcast, is secretly recorded admitting he would consider discussing receiving payments from a proposed new agency involving agent Peter Harrison. Consequently, Bond was relieved of his duties at Newcastle.
  • Chelsea director of youth football Frank Arnesen is secretly filmed making an illegal approach or "tapping up" Middlesbrough's England youth star 15-year-old Nathan Porritt. Arnesen offers a fee of £150,000 spread over three years as an incentive to relocate. Both of these allegations are against FA rules.
  • Agent Peter Harrison told the undercover reporter that, to secure transfer deals with Bolton, he bribed Sam Allardyce by offering to pay his son Craig. Harrison is a FIFA-listed agent who is based in the north-east of England.
  • That three different Bolton transfer signings involved secret payments from agents to Craig Allardyce, some when he was contractually banned from doing any Bolton deals. Panorama alleged Bolton's transfer signings of defender Tal Ben Haim, midfielder Hidetoshi Nakata and goalkeeper Ali Al-Habsi involved secret payments from agents to Craig Allardyce. Allardyce's son quit the agency business in summer 2006, and has admitted in newspaper interviews that his working as an agent might have cost his father the chance of becoming England manager.

The Football Association has asked for any evidence as it tries to rid such action from football.

Sex Crimes and the Vatican

[edit]
Main article: Sex Crimes and the Vatican

On 1 October 2006 Panorama broadcast an episode on Crimen Sollicitationis, a church "instruction" approved by Pope John XXIII in 1962, which establishes a procedure for dealing with child sex abuse scandals within the Catholic Church. It was enforced for 20 years by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger before he became the Pope. It instructs bishops on how to deal with allegations of child abuse against priests. Critics claim the document has been used to evade prosecution for sex crimes.

Daylight Robbery

[edit]
Further information: Iraq War misappropriations

Panorama investigated claims that as much as $23 billion (£11.75 billion) may have been lost, stolen or not properly accounted for in Iraq.[37]

The United States Department of Justice has imposed gagging orders that prevent discussion of the allegations.[38] US and other media have reported little on this issue.[39]

Death in the Med

[edit]

In a programme broadcast in 2010, Jane Corbin investigated what really happened on the ship MV Mavi Marmara, when Israeli commandos seized the ship as part of the blockade of Gaza.

Abbas Al Lawati, a reporter for Gulf News, who was on the Mavi Marmara during the Gaza flotilla raid, criticised Panorama's reporting of the raid in the documentary, "Death in the Med", stating that it was either a result of "weak journalism" or "deep bias".[40] Nobel Peace Laureate Mairead Maguire, who had also participated in the Free Gaza flotilla, has also accused the programme of a "lack of truth" and "bias" in a letter to the BBC, describing its effects on the families of those who died as a "grave injustice".[41]

"The BBC Trust has ruled that a Panorama documentary about the Israeli boarding of the Mavi Marmara was "accurate and impartial" overall..."[42]

FIFA's Dirty Secrets

[edit]
Main article: FIFA's Dirty Secrets

On 29 November 2010, three days before voting for the 2018 FIFA World Cup, Panorama broadcast an investigation into bribes by senior FIFA officials.[43]

Undercover Care: The Abuse Exposed

[edit]
Main article: Winterbourne View hospital abuse

On 31 May 2011 Panorama aired an investigation into physical and psychological abuse suffered by people with learning disabilities and challenging behaviour at Winterbourne View private hospital in Bristol. It showed a number of patients being repeatedly punched, kicked, slapped, pinned down and given cold punishment showers – then left outside in near-zero degree temperatures.[44]

Local social services and the national regulator had received various warnings but the mistreatment continued. One senior nurse three times contacted the national regulator saying he wanted to talk about "abuse" – but heard nothing back.[45] The hospital was shut down.[46]

On 21 June 2011, 86 people and organisations wrote to the Prime Minister, David Cameron about the revelations, "We are aware of the various actions currently being taken within and outside government – such as the DH review and CQC internal enquiry. We hope to make submissions to those both individually and collectively. However, on their own these will not be enough and a clear programme is needed to achieve change."[47]

The prime minister responded saying he was "appalled" at the "catalogue of abuses" Panorama had revealed.[48]

In June 2011 the Association of Supported Living[30] issued a press statement, which was followed up in writing to every member of parliament in the United Kingdom, calling for community-based assisted living services to replace institutional services for people with learning disabilities.

The national regulator, the CQC did a nationwide check on facilities owned by the same company – as a result, three more institutions have been closed.[49]

The CQC also inspected 132 similar institutions and a Serious Case Review was commissioned – some of the roughly ten local and national enquiries were carried out to examine what went wrong, including one by NHS Southwest which was one of the first to be published and list many of the others.[50][51]

The head of the Care Quality Commission resigned ahead of a critical government report, a report in which Winterbourne View was cited.[52]

Eleven people plead guilty to criminal offences of neglect or abuse as a result of evidence from Undercover Care and six of them were jailed.[53][54] Immediately after the eleventh person pleaded guilty, the Serious Case Review was published, revealing hundreds of previous incidents at the hospital and missed warnings.[55][56]

Mencap published a report warning that similar abuse could be going on elsewhere and calling for the closure of all large institutions far from people's families.[57]

The film has also won a number of awards including the RTS Scoop of the year and a BAFTA.[58]

The Daily Telegraph said, "It is impossible to read the details of what went on at Winterbourne View, a care home for the severely disabled in Gloucestershire, without feeling repelled. In the wake of an exposé from the BBC’s Panorama, 11 members of staff were convicted of almost 40 charges of neglect and ill-treatment of those in their care."[59][60][61]

Euro 2012: Stadiums of Hate

[edit]
Police in Warsaw on 12 June 2012

On 28 May 2012 Panorama examined the issues of racism, antisemitism and football hooliganism which it stated were prevalent among Polish and Ukrainian fans.[62] The programme, titled "Euro 2012: Stadiums of Hate", included recent footage of fans chanting various antisemitic slogans and displays of white power symbols and banners. The documentary recorded antisemitism and monkey noise taunts of black players in Poland.[62] In Ukraine, the documentary recorded Nazi salutes and FC Metalist Kharkiv fans violently assaulting a group of Asian students at the Metalist Oblast Sports Complex, one of the stadiums hosting matches in Ukraine.[63][64] Panorama filmed former England defender Sol Campbell watching these clips, and then asked him whether he would recommend families go to the Championship. He responded: "Stay at home, watch it on TV. Don't even risk it… because you could end up coming back in a coffin."[65]

The report was then followed up by most of the British media, which published a large number of articles accusing Poles and Ukrainians of racism.[66]

The documentary was criticised as sensationalist, unbalanced and unethical. Jonathan Ornstein, Director of the Jewish Community Center[67] in Kraków, Poland, and who was interviewed for the film said: "I am furious at the way the BBC has exploited me as a source. The organization used me and others to manipulate the serious subject of anti-Semitism for its own sensationalist agenda... the BBC knowingly cheated its own audience – the British people – by concocting a false horror story about Poland. In doing so, the BBC has spread fear, ignorance, prejudice and hatred. I am profoundly disturbed by this unethical form of journalism."[68] The BBC rejected Ornstein's criticism, however, saying: "The context of the programme was made clear to Mr Ornstein both before and during the interview which he kindly agreed to do with the programme makers. Panorama disagrees in the strongest terms that his interview was misrepresented." The BBC reproduced the text of Ornstein's interview, including those parts which were not broadcast, and also pointed out that Ornstein "contacted the programme makers two days after it was broadcast in the UK on 28 May and immediately thereafter running on YouTube. He made none of the comments featured in his statement of Wednesday 6 June. We note that his statement was made following the programme's broadcast on Tuesday 5th June on Polish TV."[69]

Another source used in the film, anti-racism campaigner Jacek Purski said: "The material prepared by the BBC is one-sided. It does not show the whole story of Polish preparations for the Euros. It does not show the Championship ran a lot of activities aimed at combating racism in the "Respect Diversity" campaign. For us the Euro is not only about matches. The event has become an opportunity to fight effectively against racism and promote multiculturalism. There is no country in Europe free from racism. These are the facts."[70]

Black Polish MP John Godson said: "The documentary was biased, one-sided and rather sensational. I have received information that there were also interviews that were omitted by the BBC—for example, interview with the Polish police."[71]

A reporter from Gazeta Wyborcza, Poland's most popular left-wing newspaper, questioned Panorama's practices and said: "I am becoming more and more surprised with what the BBC says. So far it has denied two situations I witnessed. I would not be surprised if the BBC prepared a statement saying that the Panorama crew has never been to Poland."[71]

Ukrainian foreign ministry spokesman Oleh Voloshyn responded that the allegations were an "invented and mythical problem",[72] and that "Nazi symbols can be seen at ... any match in England".[73] Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk stated: "Nobody who comes to Poland will be in any danger because of his race. This is not our custom, as is not pointing out similar incidents in other countries."[74]

The Guardian reported: "Other sources have come forward to say that an interview with a Jewish Israeli player was also cut from the programme because he failed to confirm Panorama's "anti-semitism" thesis. The BBC interviewed midfielder Aviram Baruchian, who plays for the Polish team Polonia Warsaw. One source who was present said the Panorama journalists had complained afterwards that the interview was "useless". Panorama strongly denies this. It says the interview was not used because Baruchian had only played in the Polish league since January.[75]

Panorama responded to the criticism, saying:

England Fans, the official England Supporters' Club, travelling to Euro 2012 called the programme unhelpful and some Poles in the UK have expressed concern that they have been labelled as racist. But amid all of these accusations against Panorama and the BBC, there is a real fear that the key issue has been missed – the overt and frightening racist and anti-Semitic abuse and violence of the kind broadcast by Panorama is both wrong and deeply upsetting to those on its receiving end. That was the point of the programme. We set out to highlight a wrong. Were the beatings that the students from India sustained in Ukraine's Metalist stadium somehow "exaggerated"? Was the fact that they said the police were of "no use" as they walked off bruised and alone into the Ukrainian night somehow "made up"? Were the monkey chants hurled at the black players we filmed in Poland somehow "sensationalised"?

— [76]

British columnist Edward Lucas wrote: "Either the allegations against the BBC are a tissue of lies (and those who make them will be exposed), or the programme-makers have a lot of explaining to do. ...it rightly decried the use of "Jew" as an insult, but never mentioned that just the same – deplorable – language is used by rival fans against Ajax in the Netherlands or Tottenham Hotspur in Britain. It said ethnic minorities were "all but invisible" – but did not mention that Poland has two black members of parliament (Britain elected its first only in 1987). Poland certainly has its problems – but the highly questionable assumptions behind eastern 'backwardness' and Western 'progress' went blithely unexamined.

"It would be easy to scent a kind of 'orientalism' here: the belief that 'ex-communist' is synonymous with 'poor', 'nasty' and 'ignorant'. The muddy wastelands of the east are great places to make shocking documentaries. Best of all, because nobody there knows English, you can say pretty much what you like and get away with it. Not any more."[77]

Brendan O'Neill wrote in The Daily Telegraph that England fans had staged "a protest against BBC Panorama's hysterical depiction of Ukraine as a hotbed of racism and anti-Semitism, which they have discovered during their stay in that country to be untrue. ...it was the respectable Beeb, echoed by broadsheets, which painted an entire nation "over there" as backward and prejudiced, while it has fallen to everyday fans to poke holes in this xenophobic mythmaking and to point out that there is actually nothing scary about modern Ukraine and its inhabitants. England fans have proven themselves way more racially enlightened than the aloof suits in the current-affairs department of the BBC."[78]

England football coach Roy Hodgson said the racism allegations were "the biggest negativity in England... As a result, I think we've lost a lot of fans who didn't come because of a lot of horror stories about how life would be in the Ukraine and Poland." Hodgson added that he had nothing but positive impressions of Poland and Ukraine.[79]

According to the Dutch daily de Telegraaf, during an open training session in Kraków, Dutch black players were allegedly subjected to monkey noises and jeers, an incident that the Holland captain Mark van Bommel described as a "real disgrace". UEFA acknowledged that there had been "isolated incidents of racist chanting".[80] However, other Dutch media, including the prestigious daily de Volkskrant, have reported that the allegations of monkey chants were made up. According to the newspaper, the coach of the Dutch team has made several statements to the BBC that he had not heard the supposed chanting, nor did the rest of the team. According to de Volksrant, the story was sensationalised by de Telegraaf.[81]

Jessica Elgot wrote an article in The Jewish Chronicle headlined "I went all the way to 'racist' Kiev and all I got was love", reporting how "By-and-large, no one understood why we were going. Friends raised their eyebrows in horror, before inquiring if we had seen "that Panorama programme". My grandmother politely inquired why we wanted to go to "that shmatte place". As I left for the airport, I got a sweet good-bye text from my house-mate. "Have a lovely trip. Please don't get Jew-bashed."[82]

The Daily Mirror commented: "The biggest plus of Euro 2012 must be the scaremongering presented by BBC's Panorama of violence and terrible racism in Poland and Ukraine largely proved to be just that. If you do not believe me, then take the word of Gary Lineker who did not mind taking a swipe at his BBC bosses to point out how friendly and accommodating the locals have been. Ahead of Spain’s semi with Portugal, Lineker tweeted: 'Donetsk is a lovely town with friendly folk. Pre-tournament scaremongering way off the mark.'"[83]

Tim Black, senior writer at Spiked, speculated that "What seemed to drive 'Stadiums of Hate' was not an intention to deceive, exactly. It was something else: an overriding willingness to believe the worst about people from 'over there'. The East European 'they' are not like 'us', the programme seemed to be saying: they are less developed, less socially advanced; they need our moral lessons, our anti-racist schooling. Amid the apparent social backwardness of Poland and Ukraine, the multicultural, cosmopolitan superiority of Western Europe can shine through. And we in Britain can bask in its glow."[84]

The deputy mayor of Kraków, referring to the incidents of racism and anti-Semitism broadcast by Panorama, said: "We believe that, step by step, the clubs will also take more responsibility for this kind of activity at stadiums". Adam Bulandra, project coordinator of the Interkulturalni Foundation and co-author of Kraków's new anti-racist strategy said: "The local community does not react properly to this problem, it does not actively oppose the incidents that happen, that's why they are so visible, and we want to change this situation." A spokesperson for Poland's Ombudsman for Citizens' Rights, noted that while there may seem to be only a small number of racist incidents in Poland, that 80 per cent of racist crimes go unreported in the country.[85]

In 2014, Jewish News and other news organizations reported that during the making of the documentary, host Chris Rogers had been filmed giving a Nazi salute while marching in front of the crew. Rogers was reprimanded by the BBC, apologized and had not been re-hired by the Panorama program for two years after the incident.[86]

The Mind Reader: Unlocking My Voice

[edit]

This Panorama Special broadcast on 13 November 2012 showed the pioneering work being done by scientists to help patients who have suffered severe brain injuries. The film told the stories of a group of patients and their families, and showed the revolutionary efforts made to help them communicate with the outside world. The film included the story of Scott Routley, a Canadian man in a persistent vegetative state for more than a decade who was able to tell doctors he is not in any pain.[87]

North Korea Undercover

[edit]

North Korea Undercover was filmed in North Korea in late March 2013 by a 3-person team that accompanied a group of students from the London School of Economics. The trip was organised through the Grimshaw Club – an international relations club affiliated with LSE – by Tomiko Sweeney, the wife of John Sweeney. The North Koreans, who require permission for entry by journalists, and who have jailed journalists who have attempted unauthorised entry, were not informed of the BBC team and failed to recognize John Sweeney, calling him "professor." The degree to which the students were informed led to a difference of opinion between the institutions later, with the BBC maintaining that less than full disclosure was a measure taken to protect the students in the event of discovery.[88] Sweeney and his wife were accompanied by a BBC cameraman.[89]

Subsequently, however, a public statement signed by six of the 10 LSE student participants on the trip said that "We feel that we have now been put in more risk than was originally the case, as a result of the LSE's decision to go public with their story".[90] They also indicated that they had no objection to the broadcast of the BBC Panorama documentary and that they were satisfied with how the BBC handled the trip.

According to Gianluca Spezza, an informed critic and one of the directors of NK News, the documentary was of low quality, comparable to many of the videos frequently taken by tourists and posted to YouTube. In addition, according to Spezza, the undercover filming had a detrimental effect on responsible efforts to engage in legitimate cultural exchange and development of mutual understanding.[91]

Contaminated Blood: The Search for the Truth

[edit]

Originally broadcast on 10 May 2017, the 1-hour special episode Contaminated Blood: The Search for the Truth examined some of the events surrounding the contaminated blood scandal of the 1970s and 1980s, whereby haemophiliacs were infected with Hepatitis C and HIV via Factor VIII medicine products.[92]

The programme featured former Health Ministers Andy Burnham and David Owen, both were critical of successive governments roles in the scandal, with the former suggesting it was "criminal". Professor John Cash (former Director of the Scottish National Blood Transfusion Service) told the programme that the truth about the scandal in England and Wales "[had] not yet been told".

One of the victims' sons, Jason Evans, told the programme he was taking legal action, which was subsequently billed by the press as a "landmark legal case", calling for a public inquiry into records and documents of the scandal, with allegations that some records could have been destroyed at the time.[93] The case, entitled Jason Evans & Others V Secretary of State for Health, is ongoing as of February 2022; an inquiry into the scandal, also ongoing as of February 2022, was announced by then-Prime Minister Theresa May shortly after the programme aired.

Is Labour Anti-Semitic?

[edit]

The hour-long episode Is Labour Anti-Semitic? premiered on 10 July 2019 and explored allegations of antisemitism in the UK Labour Party.[94] During the programme, eight former members of Labour party staff said that senior Labour figures had intervened to downgrade punishments handed out to members over antisemitism.[94] The Labour Party criticised the programme prior to broadcast[94] and issued the following statement afterwards:

"The Panorama programme was not a fair or balanced investigation. It was a seriously inaccurate, politically one-sided polemic, which breached basic journalistic standards, invented quotes and edited emails to change their meaning. It was an overtly biased intervention by the BBC in party political controversy. An honest investigation into antisemitism in Labour and wider society is in the public interest. The Panorama team instead pre-determined an answer to the question posed by the programme's title."[95]

The programme was presented by John Ware and produced by Neil Grant, both of whom also worked on a 2015 Panorama programme, Labour's Earthquake. Grant, who had been a teacher at JFS[96] and London Labour Party activist,[96] also produced a 2016 Dispatches programme, Battle for the Labour Party. Both programmes were strongly criticised by supporters of party leader Jeremy Corbyn.[97] Ken Loach called it "probably the most disgusting programme I've ever seen on the BBC. Disgusting because it raised the horror of racism against Jews in the most atrocious propagandistic way, with crude journalism ... and it bought the propaganda from people who were intent on destroying Corbyn."[98]

The Labour Party submitted a formal complaint about the programme to the BBC, which received around 1,600 complaints in total.[99] The BBC's Executive Complaints Unit rejected these complaints.[100] Over 20 complaints of bias were taken to Ofcom, who ruled that the programme had been "duly impartial" and had given appropriate weight to Labour's position.[101]

After the episode aired, a party spokesman accused staff featured in the documentary of being "disaffected former officials... who have always opposed Jeremy Corbyn's leadership, worked to actively undermine it, and have both personal and political axes to grind."[102] Labour Party staff represented by the GMB Union voted 124–4 to demand the party apologise to the former staff[103] and John Cryer, Chair of the Parliamentary Labour Party, said that attacking former Labour staff who appeared on the documentary was "a gross misjudgment".[102] Five of the staff featured announced their intention to sue the Party, claiming that Labour's response breached its commitment to protect the rights of whistleblowers and 'defamed' them.[104]

In July 2020, the Labour Party, now under the leadership of Keir Starmer, retracted in full the allegations it had made about both John Ware and the participants in the Panorama documentary, which it conceded were false, issued a formal apology, and agreed to pay damages and costs, estimated to be around £600,000.[105]

Has the government failed the NHS?

[edit]

Broadcast on 27 April 2020, the episode Has the government failed the NHS?, presented by reporter Richard Bilton, investigated the UK Government's alleged failure to stockpile critical equipment such as personal protective equipment (PPE), and the impact this had on the management of COVID-19 within the NHS during the pandemic's early months.[106][107] The investigation also examined the reversal of the designation of COVID-19 as a "High consequence infectious disease" (HCID) and the simultaneous downgrading of PPE guidance. It was argued that the decision-making was fuelled, in part, by the lack of suitable equipment in the stockpile.[108]

Among the interviewees was public health expert John Ashton, who described the findings as "breathtaking" and said "The consequence of not planning; not ordering kit; not having stockpiles is that we are sending into the front line doctors, nurses, other health workers and social care workers without the equipment to keep them safe".[citation needed]

The Missing Princess

[edit]

In February 2021, BBC Panorama released a full-fledged investigative documentary, The Missing Princess, about the daughter of Dubai ruler Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, Princess Latifa, who attempted to flee her home country in 2018. However, she was captured and brought back to Dubai from international waters. In 2019, a family court in the UK ruled that Sheikh Mohammed had ordered the abduction of Princess Latifa, who was publicly seen only once since, in December 2018 during the visit of former United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights, Mary Robinson.[109][110]

The Missing Princess was released in 2021, after BBC Panorama received a video message secretly recorded by Latifa bint Mohammed Al Maktoum from her bathroom in 2018. The messages were sent by Princess Latifa's friends, who were not able to get in touch with her for a long time. The Princess accused her father, Sheikh Mohammed, of holding her "hostage". She also gave details of her abduction, where she was drugged and brought back by Emirati soldiers on a boat and then a private jet. Saying that she feared for her life, Latifa complained about being tired in the solitary confinement without any medical and legal assistance.[110][111]

Release of the documentary prompted the United Nations to intervene in the matter, where the organization questioned the United Arab Emirates about Princess Latifa and asked for a proof that she is alive.[112]

Programme influenced by security services

[edit]

In December 2011, it was revealed that former BBC Director General Sir Ian Trethowan had met in 1981 with the chiefs of MI5 and the Secret Intelligence Service about an episode of Panorama dealing with the security services.[113] He showed a video recording of the original programme to Bernard Sheldon, legal adviser to MI5,[113] who suggested cuts to the programme. Trethowan asked the head of BBC News to reduce the programme to half its length, including the cuts suggested by MI5.[113]

Scheduling

[edit]

The scheduling of Panorama has, since the 1980s, often been a subject of media debate and controversy, due to the duties of the BBC to provide both, on the one hand, entertaining programming that appeals to a mass audience, and on the other serious journalism that might have a narrower audience. In February 1985, with the programme being watched by an average audience of just 3.5 million viewers, Controller of BBC One Michael Grade moved the programme from its traditional prime time 8.10 pm slot on Monday evenings back to 9.30 pm, after the Nine O'Clock News.[114] Despite many protests about this move in the media,[114] Panorama remained in this slot until 1997, although two of Grade's successors, Alan Yentob and Michael Jackson, were known to be unhappy about running 70 continuous minutes of news from 9 pm.[114] In May 1997 the Acting Controller of BBC One, Mark Thompson, did move Panorama back half an hour to 10 pm, to make way for the sitcom Birds of a Feather, which opened the BBC to criticism that it was sidelining serious content in favour of lighter programming.[114]

In 2000, the programme was moved again, with the 10 pm timeslot no longer available due to the transferring of the BBC News from 9 pm to the later slot. Panorama was moved to Sunday nights, after the news, usually shown at around 10.15 pm – labelled by some critics as a "graveyard slot".[115] The number of editions made per year was also reduced, which attracted press criticism for the BBC in general and its Director-General Greg Dyke in particular, as Dyke was the driving force behind the schedule changes.[116][117] The incoming Controller of BBC One, Lorraine Heggessey, defended the move, claiming that the programme's audience would have "dwindled" had it remained on Monday nights.[115]

In January 2007 Heggessey's successor, Peter Fincham, moved Panorama back from Sunday nights to a prime time Monday evening slot at 8.30 pm, reduced to half an hour. This decision was at least partly in response to a demand from the Board of Governors of the BBC for the channel to show more current affairs programming during prime time.[118]

Legacy

[edit]

A series of Panorama transcripts, dating between 1958 and 1961, are housed at the British Library. The papers can be accessed through the British Library catalogue.[119]

See also

[edit]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ "Collections Search - Panorama". British Film Institute.
  2. ^ "Panorama returns to peak time on BBC ONE". BBC.
  3. ^ BBC Radio 2, Steve Wright in the Afternoon 15 January 2006, Jeremy Vine interview
  4. ^ "Panorama - Window on the World". BBC Programme Index. 19 September 1955. Retrieved 4 July 2023.
  5. ^ McQueen, David (4 January 2011). "A Very Conscientious Brand: A Case Study of the BBC's Current Affairs Series Panorama". Core. Journal of Brand Management. 18 (9). Bournemouth University Research Online: Macmillan Publishers: 4–5. doi:10.1057/bm.2011.5. S2CID 167900487. Retrieved 4 July 2023.
  6. ^ Paxman, Jeremy (29 October 2003). "Windows on the World". BBC News - Panorama. Retrieved 4 July 2023.
  7. '^ Panoramas theme tune BBC website 10 Dec 2008
  8. ^ "Inside the secret world of trading nudes". BBC News. 22 August 2022. Retrieved 10 October 2022.
  9. ^ Sharan, A.K. (2000). Encyclopaedia of Abnormal Psychology. New Delhi: Anmol. p. 315. ISBN 81-261-0475-9.
  10. ^ Hartocollis, Peter (1983). Time and Timelessness: A Psychoanalytic Exploration of the Varieties of Temporal Experience. International Universities Press. p. 131. ISBN 978-0-8236-6545-7.
  11. ^ Stafford, Peter (1992). Psychedelics Encyclopedia. Berkeley, CA: Ronin. pp. 147–148. ISBN 0-914171-51-8.
  12. ^ Falk, Quentin; Falk, Ben (2005). "Television's Strangest Moments". London: Robson Books. pp. 20–21. ISBN 1-86105-874-8.
  13. ^ "BBC One - Panorama, Salvador Dali". BBC.
  14. ^ Charles Moore, Margaret Thatcher, Volume Two: Everything She Wants (London: Allen Lane, 2015), p. 532.
  15. ^ a b Richard Lindley 'Panorama' Politico's 2002 p.254.
  16. ^ Richard Lindley 'Panorama' Politico's 2002 p.255.
  17. ^ Charles Moore, Margaret Thatcher, Volume Two: Everything She Wants (London: Allen Lane, 2015), p. 533.
  18. ^ "50 Facts about Panorama". BBC News. 29 October 2003.
  19. ^ Urwin, Rosamund (1 November 2020). "BBC says sorry to Diana's brother Earl Spencer for interview 'deceit'". The Sunday Times. Retrieved 12 November 2020. (subscription required)
  20. ^ Waterson, Jim (4 November 2020). "Diana's brother demands inquiry over 'deceit' that led to BBC interview". The Guardian. Retrieved 7 November 2020.
  21. ^ Waterson, Jim (19 November 2020). "Prince William welcomes BBC's investigation into Diana interview". The Guardian. Retrieved 19 November 2020.
  22. ^ "BBC announces investigation into 1995 Diana interview". RTE. AFP. 18 November 2020. Retrieved 18 November 2020.
  23. ^ Mendick, Robert; Yorke, Harry; Ward, Victoria (19 May 2021). "Princess Diana interview probe to find BBC's Martin Bashir guilty of deceit". The Telegraph. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022. Retrieved 19 May 2021.
  24. ^ Booth, William (20 May 2021). "BBC reporter used 'deceitful behaviour' to secure 1995 Princess Diana interview, investigation concludes". The Washington Post. Retrieved 20 May 2021. The former judge found that Bashir carried out a sophisticated ruse and lied to his bosses about it, and that the BBC, having been alerted to his behavior, mostly papered over it and sought to evade scrutiny on the topic.
  25. ^ Steele, John; Millward, David (5 March 2001). "Real IRA blamed for BBC bombing". The Daily Telegraph. UK. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022. Retrieved 3 October 2010.
  26. ^ "Scientology – The Road to Total Freedom?". Panorama. 27 April 1987.
  27. ^ Oatts, Joanne (15 May 2007). "Journalist's Panorama (Gibraltar) outburst brings in 4.4m". Digital Spy. Retrieved 15 May 2007.
  28. ^ Plunkett, John (15 May 2007). "Panorama rant boosts ratings". The Guardian. UK.
  29. ^ John Sweeney revisits the Church of Scientology BBC News, 26 September 2010
  30. ^ "The secrets of seroxat". BBC News. 10 October 2002.
  31. ^ "Seroxat: Emails from the edge". BBC News. 28 April 2003.
  32. ^ "Taken on trust". BBC News. 21 September 2004.
  33. ^ "Secrets of the drug trials". BBC News. 29 January 2007.
  34. ^ a b c "Campaigning on Seroxat and other SSRI antidepressants – a chronology". www.mind.org.uk. Archived from the original on 3 November 2005.
  35. ^ "Want to see some of the documents that Glaxo don't want you to see?". Seroxat Secrets. 29 January 2007.
  36. ^ "Agents claim manager was bribed". BBC News. 19 September 2006.
  37. ^ "Daylight Robbery". BBC News. 9 June 2008.
  38. ^ "BBC uncovers lost Iraq billions". BBC News. 10 June 2008.
  39. ^ The BBC Uncovers Lost Iraq Billions – Called ‘The Largest War Profiteering in History’[permanent dead link‍] Disinformation, 11 June 2008
  40. ^ "Bad journalism at best". Gulf News. 25 August 2010. Retrieved 31 August 2010.
  41. ^ "BBC failed responsibility to tell truth about Gaza Flotilla attack". Muslim News.
  42. ^ Conlan, Tara (19 April 2011). "BBC film on Gaza aid flotilla praised by trust despite breaching guidelines". The Guardian. London.
  43. ^ "Fifa chief Issa Hayatou denies bribery claims". BBC News. December 2010.
  44. ^ "BBC One - Panorama, Undercover Care: The Abuse Exposed". BBC.
  45. ^ "Winterbourne View 'failed to protect people'". BBC News. 18 July 2011.
  46. ^ "Winterbourne View 'abuse' hospital closes on Friday". BBC News. 24 June 2011.
  47. ^ "Experts available for comment". Dimensions.
  48. ^ "Prime Minister Response". NDTi.
  49. ^ "Third Castlebeck Closes, CQC". CQC. Archived from the original on 27 October 2011. Retrieved 13 August 2012.
  50. ^ "NHS Southwest Report" (PDF). NHS. Archived from the original (PDF) on 15 September 2012. Retrieved 13 August 2012.
  51. ^ "Other Home Close". BBC News. 28 September 2011.
  52. ^ Campbell, Denis (23 February 2012). "Cynthia Bower Resigns". The Guardian. London.
  53. ^ "Eleventh Guilty Plea". Avon and Somerset Police. Archived from the original on 11 June 2015. Retrieved 13 August 2012.
  54. ^ "Winterbourne View: Care workers jailed for abuse". BBC News. 26 October 2012.
  55. ^ "Serious Case Review". South Gloucestershire Council. Archived from the original on 10 August 2012. Retrieved 13 August 2012.
  56. ^ "Serious Case Review". Bristol Post. Archived from the original on 31 October 2012. Retrieved 13 August 2012.
  57. ^ "Mencap Report". Mencap.
  58. ^ "BAFTA Win". BBC News. 28 May 2012.
  59. ^ "Telegraph Leader". The Daily Telegraph. 7 August 2012. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022.
  60. ^ "Responses to Winterbourne View, a page of information from BILD, the British Institute of Learning Disabilities". BILD.
  61. ^ "LD Coalition Campaign". Learning Disability Coalition.
  62. ^ a b "Sol Campbell warns fans to stay away from Euro 2012". BBC News. 28 May 2012.
  63. ^ "Asian fans racially abused in Euro 2012 stadium". BBC News. 28 May 2012.
  64. ^ "Steer clear of Euro 2012, warns former England defenders Sol Campbell". The Independent. 28 May 2012. Archived from the original on 24 May 2022.
  65. ^ "Sol Campbell warns fans to stay away from Euro 2012". BBC News. 28 May 2012.
  66. ^ "Euro 2012: are Ukrainians still Untermenschen? | Brendan O'Neill | spiked". Spiked-online.com.
  67. ^ "JCC – Strona główna". Jcckrakow.org.
  68. ^ Eastern approaches Ex-communist Europe (6 June 2012). "An ugly spectre: Euro 2012 is overshadowed by accusations of racism and anti-Semitism". The Economist. Retrieved 14 November 2012.
  69. ^ "The BBC's statement on its Panorama programme Euro 2012". The Economist. London. 7 June 2012. Retrieved 29 April 2014.
  70. ^ "Wszyscy jesteśmy odpowiedzialni za pseudokibiców". Krakow Gazeta.
  71. ^ a b Eastern approaches Ex-communist Europe (13 June 2012). "Poland and the BBC: Stitch up unstitched—updated (again)". The Economist. Retrieved 14 November 2012.
  72. ^ "Ukraine says UK press racism allegations "invented"". Reuters. 29 May 2012. Archived from the original on 9 January 2016.
  73. ^ "Euro 2012: Ukraine hits back after Sol Campbell warns fans". BBC Sport.
  74. ^ "'Unfair' say organisers". Hindustan Times. 29 May 2012. Archived from the original on 1 December 2012. Retrieved 14 June 2012.
  75. ^ Luke Harding in Kiev and Kamil Tchorek in Warsaw (13 June 2012). "Ukraine attacks BBC Panorama documentary as 'provocation'". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 14 November 2012.
  76. ^ "The Editors: 'Stadiums of Hate': Legitimate and fair". BBC.
  77. ^ "European Voice". European Voice.
  78. ^ O'Neill, Brendan (20 June 2012). "England's football fans have proven that they are far more racially enlightened than the BBC". The Daily Telegraph. London. Archived from the original on 23 June 2012. Retrieved 14 November 2012.
  79. ^ "Hodgson: Ukraine 'Horror Stories' Deterred Fans | RIA Novosti". En.ria.ru. 20 June 2012. Retrieved 14 November 2012.
  80. ^ "Euro 2012: Uefa acknowledge 'isolated' racist chants directed at black Holland players during training session". The Daily Telegraph. Archived from the original on 18 October 2017.
  81. ^ "Holenderskie media: Opowieści o małpich odgłosach są wyssane z palca" [The stories about monkey chants are pulled out of thin air]. TOK FM. 14 June 2012.
  82. ^ "I went all the way to 'racist' Kiev and all I got was love". The Jewish Chronicle. 21 June 2012. Retrieved 14 November 2012.
  83. ^ "Matt Law's Euro 2012 diary: My highs and lows of the tournament in Poland and Ukraine – Matt Law". Daily Mirror. 30 June 2012. Retrieved 14 November 2012.
  84. ^ "Euro 2012: where are these stadiums of hate?". www.spiked-online.com. Retrieved 4 December 2017.
  85. ^ "Clubs must do more to stop racism at stadiums, says Krakow deputy mayor – Thenews.pl :: News from Poland". Thenews.pl.
  86. ^ "Panorama presenter apologises for Hitler salute". Jewish News. London.
  87. ^ "Vegetative patient Scott Routley says 'I'm not in pain'". BBC News. 9 November 2012.
  88. ^ Ravi Somaiya (14 April 2013). "BBC Tactics in Covering North Korea Are Faulted". The New York Times. Retrieved 15 April 2013.
  89. ^ Josh Halliday; Tara Conlan (15 April 2013). "LSE students contradict BBC claims over North Korea trip: Some say they only became aware of presence of Panorama journalists when they arrived in the capital, Pyongyang". The Guardian. London. Retrieved 16 April 2013.
  90. ^ Josh Halliday. "Students say LSE has placed them at 'more risk' from North Korea". The Guardian. Retrieved 22 October 2013.
  91. ^ Gianluca Spezza (17 April 2013). "Undercover in North Korea: Making It Harder For Serious Researchers To Do Their Job". NK News. Retrieved 18 April 2013.
  92. ^ "Contaminated Blood: The Search for the Truth, Panorama – BBC One". BBC. Retrieved 4 December 2017.
  93. ^ "Tainted blood scandal victim's son to sue amid cover-up allegations". The Independent. 10 May 2017. Archived from the original on 24 May 2022.
  94. ^ a b c Kentish, Benjamin (10 July 2019). "Jeremy Corbyn's team repeatedly intervened in antisemitism cases, claim Labour whistleblowers". The Independent. Archived from the original on 24 May 2022. Retrieved 11 July 2019.
  95. ^ Schofield, Kevin (11 July 2019). "Labour goes to war with BBC over Panorama probe into anti-semitism in party". PoliticsHome.com. Retrieved 11 July 2019.
  96. ^ a b "Winning a Bafta is just as tough as teaching at JFS says award-winning filmmaker". Jewish Chronicle.
  97. ^ "Dispatches Momentum Channel 4 Documentary Slammed Over Claims Of Production Company's 'Bias'". Huffington Post. 19 September 2016.
  98. ^ Chakrabortty, Aditya (10 October 2019). "Ken Loach: 'The airwaves should be full of outrage'". The Guardian. Retrieved 12 October 2019.
  99. ^ "Labour submits complaint to BBC over Panorama expose". Jewish News. 26 July 2019. Retrieved 23 May 2020.
  100. ^ Waterson, Jim (31 October 2019). "BBC to dismiss Labour complaint over Panorama antisemitism episode". The Guardian. Retrieved 23 May 2020.
  101. ^ "Ofcom FOI Response on Panorama's 'Is Labour Anti-Semitic?'" (PDF). Ofcom. Retrieved 23 May 2020.
  102. ^ a b Rowena Mason and Jessica Elgot, "Corbyn under fire from staff and Labour peers over antisemitism", The Guardian, 15 July 2019, accessed 21 July 2019)
  103. ^ Woodcock, Andrew (18 July 2019). "Labour staff members vote overwhelmingly to condemn party's response to Panorama documentary on antisemitism". The Independent. Archived from the original on 24 May 2022. Retrieved 21 July 2019.
  104. ^ Tominey, Camilla (22 September 2019). "Former Labour employees set to sue party for libel over anti-Semitism". The Telegraph. Archived from the original on 12 January 2022. Retrieved 23 May 2020.
  105. ^ "Labour pays out six-figure sum and apologises in antisemitism row". The Guardian. 22 July 2020.
  106. ^ Morrison, Sean (28 April 2020). "Key PPE items 'not in pandemic stockpile when coronavirus hit UK'". www.standard.co.uk.
  107. ^ "BBC One - Panorama, Has the Government Failed the NHS?". BBC.
  108. ^ "Coronavirus: UK failed to stockpile crucial PPE". BBC News. 28 April 2020.
  109. ^ "Princess Latifa timeline: The failed escapes of Sheikh Mohammed's daughters". BBC News. 16 February 2021. Retrieved 16 February 2021.
  110. ^ a b "Panorama: The Missing Princess". BBC. Retrieved 16 February 2021.
  111. ^ "Princess Latifa: 'Hostage' ordeal of Dubai ruler's daughter revealed". BBC News. 16 February 2021. Retrieved 16 February 2021.
  112. ^ "Princess Latifa: UN asks for proof that Dubai ruler's daughter is alive". BBC News. 19 February 2021. Retrieved 19 February 2021.
  113. ^ a b c Corera, Gordon (30 December 2011). "Secret service pressed BBC to censor Panorama – papers". BBC News.
  114. ^ a b c d Culf, Andrew (8 May 1997). "Birds of a Feather puts Panorama to flight as Sharon and Tracey displace BBC flagship". The Guardian. UK.
  115. ^ a b Wells, Matt (17 October 2000). "1 m viewers lost as BBC shifts Panorama to Sunday 'graveyard' slot". The Guardian. UK. Retrieved 20 January 2007.
  116. ^ Elstein, David (22 May 2000). "A shameful decision". The Guardian. UK. Retrieved 21 January 2007.
  117. ^ Aaronovitch, David (16 May 2000). "You cannot be serious!". The Independent. UK.
  118. ^ Sherwin, Adam (19 June 2006). "Panorama to take on ITV soap". The Times. UK. Retrieved 19 January 2007.[dead link‍]
  119. ^ Panorama Transcripts, archives and manuscripts catalogue, the British Library. Retrieved 15 May 2020

Bibliography

[edit]
  • Richard Lindley (2002), Panorama: Fifty Years of Pride and Paranoia, Politico's, ISBN 1-902301-80-3
[edit]
"Scientology and Me"
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Panorama_(British_TV_programme)&oldid=1248012708"