| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Watchmen characters' and their Charlton equivalents |
5 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Watchmen characters' and their Charlton equivalents
|
| Merging 'Chronology of the Watchmen' |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Merging 'Chronology of the Watchmen'
|
| False document setting |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#False document setting
|
| Keene Act |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Keene Act
|
| Rumours |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Rumours
|
| Cleanup - what remain to be done |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Cleanup - what remain to be done
|
| Is "right-wing" quite the correct term for Rorshach? |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Is "right-wing" quite the correct term for Rorshach?
|
| A Substantial Edit |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#A Substantial Edit
|
| Radical surgery required? |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Radical surgery required?
|
| Another Attempt |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Another Attempt
|
| Plot Summary Rewrite? |
7 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Plot Summary Rewrite?
|
| Comedian & "End Justifies the Means" |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Comedian & "End Justifies the Means"
|
| Themes Section |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Themes Section
|
| Cleanup needed |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Cleanup needed
|
| Rorschach wont be "reaching civilization" anytime soon |
8 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Rorschach wont be "reaching civilization" anytime soon
|
| Ozymandias -the poem- |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Ozymandias -the poem-
|
| Once Again, Another Substantial Edit |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Once Again, Another Substantial Edit
|
| Is this article still POV? |
5 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Is this article still POV?
|
| An addition |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#An addition
|
| Archived |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Archived
|
| Concise |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Concise
|
| Rorschach and Nihilism--Revisited |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Rorschach and Nihilism--Revisited
|
| Plot Summary cleanup |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Plot Summary cleanup
|
| Brown Shoes22 edit |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Brown Shoes22 edit
|
| Characters in Watchmen |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Characters in Watchmen
|
| Minutemen (comics) merged here |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Minutemen (comics) merged here
|
| Names |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Names
|
| Peacemaker or Prankster? |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Peacemaker or Prankster?
|
| To-do List |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#To-do List
|
| Relevancy of "Film Adaptation" section |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Relevancy of "Film Adaptation" section
|
| Hugo award |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Hugo award
|
| "Paul Greengrass and David Hayter have reportedly dropped out" |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#"Paul Greengrass and David Hayter have reportedly dropped out"
|
| My Edit |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#My Edit
|
| Reference to Outer Limits episode |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Reference to Outer Limits episode
|
| Who is Mister A. ? |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Who is Mister A. ?
|
| Removal of the "Themes" section |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Removal of the "Themes" section
|
| Themes... |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Themes...
|
| Peer Review |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Peer Review
|
| Introduction |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Introduction
|
| Themes section... |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 2#Themes section...
|
| My Edit |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#My Edit 2
|
| Archived |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Archived
|
| Adding a themes section... |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Adding a themes section...
|
| Question#17 |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Question#17
|
| Minutemen reference |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Minutemen reference
|
| Covers |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Covers
|
| Revisions |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Revisions
|
| Quoting from memory |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Quoting from memory
|
| Collaboration of the Month Vote |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Collaboration of the Month Vote
|
| Submitted for copyediting |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Submitted for copyediting
|
| Ambiguous |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Ambiguous
|
| If possible, please clarify this statement |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#If possible, please clarify this statement
|
| Watchmen's a featured article now! |
5 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Watchmen's a featured article now!
|
| Black Freighter section |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Black Freighter section
|
| Thought balloons |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Thought balloons
|
| John Higgins |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#John Higgins
|
| Main image |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Main image
|
| Improvements |
6 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Improvements
|
| Watchmen Backwards |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Watchmen Backwards
|
| After killing Kovacs |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#After killing Kovacs
|
| Front Page |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Front Page
|
| superhero names over real names? |
10 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#superhero names over real names?
|
| Genre self-criticism in Watchmen |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Genre self-criticism in Watchmen
|
| Citation 24 |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Citation 24
|
| Miracleman |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Miracleman
|
| Keene Act? |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Keene Act?
|
| Special protection |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Special protection
|
| Allusions |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Allusions
|
| Marvels Cameo? |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Marvels Cameo?
|
| Smoking pipes |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Smoking pipes
|
| Veidt/Ozymandias - Superhuman? |
11 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Veidt/Ozymandias - Superhuman?
|
| Translations |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Translations
|
| Symbolism deleted section |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Symbolism deleted section
|
| Removed Section for OR |
30 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Removed Section for OR
|
| Rorschach |
14 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Rorschach
|
| Appropriate place for this? |
5 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Appropriate place for this?
|
| Assessment |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Assessment
|
| Übermensch |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Übermensch
|
| Film |
5 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Film
|
| Maxiseries |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Maxiseries
|
| Something missing. |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 3#Something missing.
|
| Spoiler Tags for (end of) Plot Summary |
7 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Spoiler Tags for (end of) Plot Summary
|
| Plot Summary |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Plot Summary
|
| Merchandising. |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Merchandising.
|
| Watching the Watchmen |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Watching the Watchmen
|
| Language and Character References |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Language and Character References
|
| Broken link |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Broken link
|
| IS the former group crimebusters the Watchmen? |
7 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#IS the former group crimebusters the Watchmen?
|
| Captain Metropolis |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Captain Metropolis
|
| Grammatical error |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Grammatical error
|
| Robert Redford |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Robert Redford
|
| Special thanks to Neil Gaiman |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Special thanks to Neil Gaiman
|
| It's Mmeltdowns |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#It's Mmeltdowns
|
| Dan Dreiberg |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Dan Dreiberg
|
| possible new topic/section - Motion Comic of Chapter 1 |
6 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#possible new topic/section - Motion Comic of Chapter 1
|
| Allusions to iconography, art, and history |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Allusions to iconography, art, and history
|
| Editions |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Editions
|
| 'Real' names |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#'Real' names
|
| Images |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Images
|
| Watchmen and Mars in fiction |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Watchmen and Mars in fiction
|
| Super heroes? |
5 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Super heroes?
|
| Effron link |
15 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Effron link
|
| Rorschach's Journal |
50 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Rorschach's Journal
|
| Need a vote on the contents of Rorschach's Journal |
25 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Need a vote on the contents of Rorschach's Journal
|
| Should the journal even be mentioned |
9 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Should the journal even be mentioned
|
| Graphic Novel Link |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Graphic Novel Link
|
| The Movie Link |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#The Movie Link
|
| Richest man in the world? |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Richest man in the world?
|
| Removed Massive and inaccurate spoiler from the introduction |
13 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Removed Massive and inaccurate spoiler from the introduction
|
| References tweaking |
6 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#References tweaking
|
| new pages |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#new pages
|
| Inspirations for Watchmen |
6 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Inspirations for Watchmen
|
| Tales of the Black Freighter |
26 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Tales of the Black Freighter
|
| Characters section - Laurie's description |
5 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Characters section - Laurie's description
|
| Should Rorschach's journal be mentioned in the Plot Summary of The Watchmen? |
33 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 4#Should Rorschach's journal be mentioned in the Plot Summary of The Watchmen?
|
| Caption of Group Photo |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Caption of Group Photo
|
| The reference in the name of the work |
26 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#The reference in the name of the work
|
| Atkinson Link |
21 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Atkinson Link
|
| Reagan Quote Removal |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Reagan Quote Removal
|
| Zack Snyder |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Zack Snyder
|
| Protected Mode? |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Protected Mode?
|
| Spoiler in the lead |
20 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Spoiler in the lead
|
| Criticism |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Criticism
|
| Silk Spectre |
5 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Silk Spectre
|
| RfC: Appropriateness of Spoiler in Lead |
20 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#RfC: Appropriateness of Spoiler in Lead
|
| 2008 Project Fanboy Awards |
17 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#2008 Project Fanboy Awards
|
| Images |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Images
|
| Against Merge Unmerge and reopened for discussion |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Against Merge Unmerge and reopened for discussion
|
| No mention of motion comic? |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#No mention of motion comic?
|
| Coroners and Justice Bill external link |
10 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Coroners and Justice Bill external link
|
| Additional sources that could be cited for in-universe character information |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Additional sources that could be cited for in-universe character information
|
| Watchmensch |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Watchmensch
|
| Include a list of chapters (issues)? |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Include a list of chapters (issues)?
|
| Watchmensch |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Watchmensch 2
|
| Merging the character list |
19 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Merging the character list
|
| Watchmen |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Watchmen
|
| Interesting origins quote |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Interesting origins quote
|
| Recent edits discussion REBOOT |
78 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Recent edits discussion REBOOT
|
| Introductory paragraph |
5 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Introductory paragraph
|
| Ending? |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Ending?
|
| Ozimodius |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Ozimodius
|
| British Literature? |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#British Literature?
|
| United States portal? |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#United States portal?
|
| Film adaption |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Film adaption
|
| Peace of Hadrian |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Peace of Hadrian
|
| Point of divergence |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Point of divergence
|
| Jane Slater named for John Slater |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 1#Jane Slater named for John Slater
|
| Editor had reverted two other editors |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Editor had reverted two other editors
|
| Too many headings and legacy misused |
6 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Too many headings and legacy misused
|
| Publication history |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Publication history
|
| Request for Comment |
42 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Request for Comment
|
| Post-RFC edit |
6 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 5#Post-RFC edit
|
| Sections |
11 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Sections
|
| Working on the to-be-revamped Reception section |
26 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Working on the to-be-revamped Reception section
|
| Is watchmen not influential enough that the 6 main characters can't all have a page? |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Is watchmen not influential enough that the 6 main characters can't all have a page?
|
| Limited series |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Limited series
|
| Spoiler in the opening paragraph |
8 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Spoiler in the opening paragraph
|
| Alan Moore removed from the article by someone |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Alan Moore removed from the article by someone
|
| Obscenity controversies category |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Obscenity controversies category
|
| Titan Books? |
4 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Titan Books?
|
| No need to go into details on DC Rebirth (for now) |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#No need to go into details on DC Rebirth (for now)
|
| The "Mothman Watchmen" merge |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#The "Mothman Watchmen" merge
|
| Before Watchmen & Doomsday Clock |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Before Watchmen & Doomsday Clock
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#External links modified
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#External links modified 2
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#External links modified 3
|
| Duplicated paragraph |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Duplicated paragraph
|
| Background & Creation - date that DC acquired the Charlton characters |
2 |
Talk:Watchmen/Archive 6#Background & Creation - date that DC acquired the Charlton characters
|
| A concern regarding a lede statement's sourcing |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen#A concern regarding a lede statement's sourcing
|
| A Commons file used on this page has been nominated for speedy deletion |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen#A Commons file used on this page has been nominated for speedy deletion
|
| The abyss gazes also |
5 |
Talk:Watchmen#The abyss gazes also
|
| Language |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen#Language
|
| OK |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen#OK
|
| Five Schools of Thought |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen#Five Schools of Thought
|
| In a retrospective review, the BBC's Nicholas Barber described it as "the moment comic books grew up". |
3 |
Talk:Watchmen#In a retrospective review, the BBC's Nicholas Barber described it as "the moment comic books grew up".
|
| The New Frontiersman |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen#The New Frontiersman
|
| Rorschach's mask / dehumanization |
1 |
Talk:Watchmen#Rorschach's mask / dehumanization
|
