Talk:Pariśiṣṭa

Katiya Parisista of the SYV

Modak's list is

1. Yūpalakṣaṇa
2. Chāgalakṣaṇa
3. Pratijña
4. Anuvākasaṃkhya
5. Caraṇavyūha
6. Śrāddhasūtra
7. Śulba
8. Ṛgyajuṣa
9. Pārṣada
10. Āṣṭakāpūraṇa
11. Pravarādhyāya
12. Mūlyādhyāya
13. Uñchaśāstra
14. Nigama
15. Yajñapārśva
16. Mautrika
17. Prasavotthāna
18. Kūrmalakṣaṇa

The additions (besides two parts to Pratijña) seem to be Prātiśākhya, Yājñavalkyaśikṣā, Kratusaṁkhyā, Sarvānukrama, Śuklayajurvidhāna and Mantrabhrāntihara Sūtra; while Pārṣada is missing. Mautrika is definitely a typo; and Hautrika look wrong: it should be Hautraka. rudra (talk) 12:53, 27 February 2008 (UTC)

Okay, Monier-Williams gives Hautraka as the 16th P of K; and gives as a meaning of Pārṣada "a N. given to the Prātiśākhyas". rudra (talk) 13:08, 27 February 2008 (UTC)

Kashikar's list of parisistas ascribed to Katyayana is

1. Yūpalakṣaṇa
2. Chāgalakṣaṇa
3. Pratijña
4. Anuvākasaṃkhya
5. Caraṇavyūha
6. Śrāddhakalpa
7. Śulba
8. Ṛgyajuṣa
9. Pārṣada
10. Iṣṭakāpūraṇa
11. Pravarādhyāya
12. Mūlyādhyāya
13. Uñchaśāstra
14. Nigama
15. Yajñapārśva
16. Hautrika
17. Prasavotthāna
18. Kūrmalakṣaṇa

Kashikar adds six others as "other ancillary texts": a second Pratijña, Sarvānukrama, Yājñavalkyaśikṣā, Kratusaṁkhyā, Mantrabhrāntihara Sūtra and Śuklayajurvidhāna. So there is no disagreement with Modak. rudra (talk) 16:14, 7 March 2008 (UTC)

The reason for the congruence is that the list is in the Caranavyuha (II.4). Kashikar notes that the Caranavyuha and the Pratijna (which also mentions other works) are therefore among the latest of the canon. rudra (talk) 17:03, 7 March 2008 (UTC)