Talk:Alishan railway station

Requested move 6 December 2017

The following is a closed discussion of a requested move. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on the talk page. Editors desiring to contest the closing decision should consider a move review. No further edits should be made to this section.

The result of the move request was: moved as proposed. Any individual inconsistencies or ambiguous titles can be discussed on the talk page of the article in question, but the general consensus is for these moves. (closed by page mover) Bradv 02:29, 17 December 2017 (UTC)

---

• Alishan Station → Alishan railway station
• Badouzi Station → Badouzi railway station
• Badu Station → Badu railway station
• Baifu Station → Baifu railway station
• Baishatun Station → Baishatun railway station
• Balin Station → Balin railway station
• Bao'an Station → Bao'an railway station
• Baoshan Station → Baoshan railway station
• Beihu Station → Beihu railway station
• Beimen Station (Alishan Forest Railway) → Beimen railway station
• Beipu Station → Beipu railway station
• Central Signal Station → Central Signal railway station
• Chang Jung Christian University Station → Chang Jung Christian University railway station
• Checheng Station → Checheng railway station
• Chenggong Station → Chenggong railway station
• Chongde Station → Chongde railway station
• Dacun Station → Dacun railway station
• Dadu Station → Dadu railway station (Taichung)
• Dahu Station → Dahu railway station
• Dajia Station → Dajia railway station
• Dali Station → Dali railway station (Yilan)
• Dalin Station → Dalin railway station
• Daqiao Station → Daqiao railway station
• Daqing Station → Daqing railway station
• Dashan Station → Dashan railway station
• Dawu Station → Dawu railway station
• Daxi Station → Daxi railway station
• Dingpu Station (Yilan) → Dingpu railway station
• Dong-ao Station → Dong-ao railway station
• Dongshan Station → Dongshan railway station
• Douliu Station → Douliu railway station
• Dounan Station → Dounan railway station
• Dulishan Station → Dulishan railway station
• Duolin Station → Duolin railway station
• Erjie Station → Erjie railway station
• Ershui Station → Ershui railway station
• Erwanping Station → Erwanping railway station
• Fangshan Station → Fangshan railway station
• Fengfu Station → Fengfu railway station
• Fengshan Station → Fengshan railway station
• Fengtian Station → Fengtian railway station
• Fengyuan Station → Fengyuan railway station
• Fenqihu Station → Fenqihu railway station
• Fugang Station → Fugang railway station
• Fulong Station → Fulong railway station
• Fuzhou Station → Fuzhou railway station (New Taipei)
• Gangshan Station → Gangshan railway station
• Gongliao Station → Gongliao railway station
• Guishan Station → Guishan railway station
• Guzhuang Signal Station → Guzhuang railway station
• Hanben Station → Hanben railway station
• Heping Station → Heping railway station (Hualien)
• Heren Station → Heren railway station
• Houbi Station → Houbi railway station
• Houli Station → Houli railway station
• Houlong Station → Houlong railway station
• Houtong Station → Houtong railway station
• Houzhuang Station → Houzhuang railway station
• Huatan Station → Huatan railway station
• Hukou Station → Hukou railway station
• Jiabei Station → Jiabei railway station
• Jialu Station → Jialu railway station
• Jiaoliping Station → Jiaoliping railway station
• Jiaoxi Station → Jiaoxi railway station
• Jiji Station → Jiji railway station
• Jingmei Station (TRA) → Jingmei railway station
• Jingwu Station → Jingwu railway station
• Jinlun Station → Jinlun railway station
• Jiuqutang Station → Jiuqutang railway station
• Kangle Station → Kangle railway station
• Lilin Station → Lilin railway station
• Linnei Station → Linnei railway station
• Liujia Station → Liujia railway station
• Liukuaicuo Station → Liukuaicuo railway station
• Liuying Station → Liuying railway station
• Liyuanliao Station → Liyuanliao railway station
• Longgang Station → Longgang railway station
• Longjing Station (Taiwan) → Longjing railway station
• Longquan Station → Longquan railway station
• Longxi Station (TRA) → Longxi railway station
• Lumachan Station → Lumachan railway station
• Luodong Station → Luodong railway station
• Luzhu Station → Luzhu railway station
• Miaoli Station (TRA) → Miaoli TRA station
• Minxiong Station → Minxiong railway station
• Mudan Station → Mudan railway station
• Mululiao Station → Mululiao railway station
• Nan-ao Station → Nan-ao railway station
• Nanjing station → Nanjing railway station (Chiayi)
• Nanke Station → Nanke railway station
• Nanshi Station → Nanshi railway station
• Nanxiang Station (TRA) → Nanxiang railway station
• Nanzi Station → Nanzi railway station
• Neili Station → Neili railway station
• Neishi Station → Neishi railway station
• North Hsinchu Station → North Hsinchu railway station
• Nuannuan Station → Nuannuan railway station
• Pinghe Station → Pinghe railway station
• Pingzhena Station → Pingzhena railway station
• Puxin station → Puxin railway station
• Qidu Station → Qidu railway station
• Qingshui Station → Qingshui railway station
• Rende station → Rende railway station
• Rinan Station → Rinan railway station
• Ruifang Station → Ruifang railway station
• Ruisui Station → Ruisui railway station
• Sandiaoling Station → Sandiaoling railway station
• Sankeng Station → Sankeng railway station
• Sanyi Station → Sanyi railway station
• Shalu Station → Shalu railway station
• Shalun Station → Shalun railway station
• Shanhua Station → Shanhua railway station
• Shanjia Station → Shanjia railway station
• Shengxing Station → Shengxing railway station
• Shenmu Station → Shenmu railway station
• Shetou Station → Shetou railway station
• Shigui Station → Shigui railway station
• Shihcheng Station → Shihcheng railway station
• Shiliu Station → Shiliu railway station
• Shizilu Station → Shizilu railway station
• Shoufeng Station → Shoufeng railway station
• Shuangxi Station → Shuangxi railway station
• Shuili Station → Shuili railway station
• Shuishang Station → Shuishang railway station
• Shuisheliao Station → Shuisheliao railway station
• Shulin Station → Shulin railway station
• Sicheng Station → Sicheng railway station
• Sijiaoting Station → Sijiaoting railway station
• Songzhu Station → Songzhu railway station
• South Shulin Station → South Shulin railway station
• Su'ao Station → Su'ao railway station
• Su'aoxin Station → Su'aoxin railway station
• Tai'an Station (Taichung) → Tai'an railway station
• Taichung Port Station → Taichung Port railway station
• Taimali Station → Taimali railway station
• Taiyuan Station → Taiyuan railway station (Taichung)
• Tanwen Station → Tanwen railway station
• Tanzi Station → Tanzi railway station
• Taoyuan Senior High School Station → Taoyuan Senior High School railway station
• Tianzhong Station → Tianzhong railway station
• Tongluo Station → Tongluo railway station
• Tongxiao Station → Tongxiao railway station
• Toucheng Station → Toucheng railway station
• Toujiacuo Station → Toujiacuo railway station
• Wai-ao Station → Wai-ao railway station
• Wanhua Station → Wanhua railway station
• Wudu Station → Wudu railway station
• Wuri Station → Wuri railway station
• Wuta Station → Wuta railway station
• Xike Station → Xike railway station
• Xincheng Station → Xincheng railway station
• Xinma Station → Xinma railway station
• Xinpu Station (TRA) → Xinpu railway station
• Xinshi Station → Xinshi railway station
• Xinwuri Station → Xinwuri railway station
• Xinying Station → Xinying railway station
• Xizhi Station → Xizhi railway station
• Yangmei Station (Taiwan) → Yangmei railway station
• Yingge Station → Yingge railway station
• Yongjing Station → Yongjing railway station
• Yongkang Station → Yongkang railway station
• Yongle Station (Taiwan) → Yongle railway station
• Yuanli Station → Yuanli railway station
• Yuanlin Station → Yuanlin railway station
• Yuanquan Station → Yuanquan railway station
• Zaoqiao Station → Zaoqiao railway station
• Zhangnaoliao Station → Zhangnaoliao railway station
• Zhaoping Station → Zhaoping railway station
• Zhiben Station → Zhiben railway station
• Zhongli Station (Taoyuan City) → Zhongli railway station
• Zhongli Station (Yilan County) → Zhongli railway station (Yilan)
• Zhongzhou Station → Zhongzhou railway station
• Zhuifen Station → Zhuifen railway station
• Zhuoshui Station → Zhuoshui railway station
• Zhuqi Station → Zhuqi railway station

– Part of an effort to standardize station names across Taiwan. See Wikipedia talk:WikiProject_Taiwan#Station_article_titles. Szqecs (talk) 14:39, 6 December 2017 (UTC) --Relisting. Bradv 13:03, 8 December 2017 (UTC)

• Oppose Creates too many ambiguous titles, e.g. Zhongli railway station AND Zhongli railway station (Yilan). Should be coordination with China (PRC) articles, both use the same official romanization. 78.55.100.175 (talk) 18:36, 9 December 2017 (UTC)

I am designating the one in Taoyuan as primary per WP:PRIMARYTOPIC. Stations that conflict with those in other countries, I've already added the disambiguation. There are even more that would become less ambiguous with the change, such as Yongle, Longjing. Szqecs (talk) 07:05, 10 December 2017 (UTC)

• Maybe – Support conditioned on fixing any issues such as pointed out above. Disambiguate both of the Zhongli stations. Alternatively, just downcase Station to station, and skip the addition of railway; if this creates ambiguity, find and fix those. Either way, I'm in favor of the intent here, of articulating and executing a WP:NCCAPS-compliant title convention for Taiwan. Dicklyon (talk) 23:40, 9 December 2017 (UTC)

The "railway" is necessary to disambiguate between stations such as Beimen. A natural disambiguation is preferred over parenthetical: WP:NCDAB. Szqecs (talk) 07:06, 10 December 2017 (UTC)

• Support per WP:NCCAPS, MOS:CAPS, MOS:PN, and WP:CONSISTENCY with numerous past RMs and various RfCs on "line" and "station" over-capitalization. Any handful of ambiguous results will obviously be fixed with further disambiguation.  — SMcCandlish ☏ ¢ >^ʌⱷ҅_ᴥⱷ^ʌ<  15:54, 13 December 2017 (UTC)
• Support – Policy-compliant and consistent. Also support the global rename of Taiwan MRT stations. — JFG ^talk 10:56, 16 December 2017 (UTC)

---

The above discussion is preserved as an archive of a requested move. Please do not modify it. Subsequent comments should be made in a new section on this talk page or in a move review. No further edits should be made to this section.