Jump to content

Q-principle

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Q-based narrowing)

In the Neo-Gricean approach to semantics and pragmatics championed by Yale linguist Laurence Horn, the Q-principle ("Q" for "Quantity") is a reformulation of Paul Grice's maxim of quantity (see Gricean maxims) combined with the first two sub-maxims of manner.[1] The Q-principle states: "Say as much as you can (given R)." As such it interacts with the R-principle, which states: "Say no more than you must (given Q)."[2][3]

The Q-principle leads to the implicature (or narrowing) that if the speaker did not make a stronger statement (or say more), then its denial is (implied to be) true. For instance, the inference from "He entered a house" to "He did not enter his own house" is Q-based inference, i.e. deriving from the Q-principle.[2]

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Horn, Laurence (1989). A Natural History of Negation. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago press. pp. 193–203.
  2. ^ a b "Implicature" in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy .
  3. ^ "The Gricean Model" in the Encyclopedia of Cognitive Science.