Peter Winch

Peter Winch (1984) University of Illinois Archives

Peter Guy Winch (14 January 1926 – 27 April 1997) was a British philosopher known for his contributions to the philosophy of social science, Wittgenstein scholarship, ethics, and the philosophy of religion. His early book The Idea of a Social Science and its Relation to Philosophy (1958) was an attack on positivism in the social sciences, drawing on the work of R. G. Collingwood and Ludwig Wittgenstein's later philosophy.

Biography

Winch was born on 14 January 1926, in Walthamstow, London. He attended Leyton County High School for boys, before going up to St Edmund Hall, Oxford to read Philosophy, Politics and Economics. Following the outbreak of World War II, he served in the Royal Navy 1944–47, before graduating from the University of Oxford in 1949.

He was a lecturer in philosophy at the Swansea University from 1951 until 1964. He was influenced by his colleagues Rush Rhees and Roy Holland, both experts in the philosophy of Ludwig Wittgenstein. In 1964, he moved to Birkbeck College, University of London, before becoming Professor of Philosophy at King's College London in 1967. During this period, he served as president of Aristotelian Society, from 1980 to 1981. In 1985 Winch moved to the United States to become Professor at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.

He died on the 27 April 1997, in Champaign, Illinois.

He was survived by his wife Erika Neumann and his two sons, Christopher and David.

Thought

Major influences upon Winch include Ludwig Wittgenstein, Rush Rhees, R. G. Collingwood and Simone Weil. He gave rise to a form of philosophy that has been given the name 'sociologism'. He also bears responsibility for a small school of sociology that was prepared to accept his radical criticism of the subject.

Winch saw himself as an uncompromising Wittgensteinian. He was not personally acquainted with Wittgenstein; Wittgenstein's influence upon him was mostly mediated through that of Rush Rhees, who was his colleague at the University College of Swansea, now known as Swansea University, and whom Wittgenstein appointed as one of his literary executors. Winch's translation of Wittgenstein's Vermischte Bemerkungen (as edited by Georg Henrik von Wright) was published in 1980 as Culture and Value (with a new translation by Winch of a revised edition by Alois Pichler appearing in 1998). After the death of Rhees in 1989, Winch took over his position as literary executor.

From Rush Rhees, Winch derived his interest in the religious writer Simone Weil. Part of the appeal was a break from Wittgenstein into a very different type of philosophy which could nevertheless be tackled with familiar methods. Also Weil's ascetic, somewhat Tolstoyan, form of religion harmonised with one aspect of Wittgenstein's personality.

At a time when most Anglo-American philosophers were heavily under the spell of Wittgenstein, Winch's own approach was strikingly original. While much of his work was concerned with rescuing Wittgenstein from what he took to be misreadings, his own philosophy involved a shift of emphasis from the problems that preoccupied Oxford style ‘linguistic’ philosophy, towards justifying and explaining 'forms of life' in terms of consistent language games. He took Wittgensteinian philosophy into areas of ethics and religion, which Wittgenstein himself had relatively neglected, sometimes showing considerable originality. An example is his illuminating treatment of the moral difference between someone who tries and fails to commit murder and someone who succeeds, in his essay "Trying" in Ethics and Action. With the decline of interest in Wittgenstein, Winch himself was increasingly neglected and the challenge his arguments presented to much contemporary philosophy was sidestepped or ignored. In insisting on the continuity of Wittgenstein's concerns from the Tractatus through to the Philosophical Investigations, Winch made a powerful case for Wittgenstein's mature philosophy, as he understood it, as the consummation and legitimate heir of the entire analytic tradition.

Wittgenstein famously said that philosophy leaves the world as it is. Winch takes his ideas into regions that have strong moral and political implications.

Works

Books

Authored

• The Idea of a Social Science and its Relation to Philosophy, London 1958 (second edition, London 1990)
• Ethics And Action, London 1972
• Simone Weil, the Just Balance, Cambridge 1989
• Trying to Make Sense, Oxford 1987

Translated/edited

• Culture and Value, Ludwig Wittgenstein, Translated by Peter Winch, (1980, Revised Edition 1989)
• Studies in the Philosophy of Wittgenstein (ed), 1969

Select articles/book chapters

• "Understanding a primitive society" 1964, American Philosophical Quarterly I, pp. 307–324
• "Ceasing to Exist" Proceedings of the British Academy 68, 1982 (1983)
• "Certainty and Authority". Wittgenstein centenary essays. Royal Institute of Philosophy Supplement. 28: 223–237.(1991)
• "Persuasion". The Wittgenstein Legacy, Midwest Studies in Philosophy. 17: 123–137. (1992)

See also: works by Peter Winch at PhilPapers

Further reading

• Philosophy as the Art of Disagreement On the Social and Moral Philosophy of Peter Winch by Lars Hertzberg
• Peter Winch 1926–97 by Rupert Read [Archived by Wayback Machine]
• Winch, Malcolm, and the Unity of Wittgenstein's Philosophy by Cora Diamond (excerpt from "Peter Winch on the Tractatus and the unity of Wittgenstein’s philosophy")
• PETER WINCH, PHILOSOPHY TEACHER obituary by Kenan Heise for the CHICAGO TRIBUNE (Archived by Wayback Machine)
• The Legendary Peter Winch and the Myth of ‘Social Science Introduction to There is No Such Thing as a Social Science: In Defence of Peter Winch (2008) by Phil Hutchinson, Rupert Read and Wes Sharrock.
• Philosophical Investigations by Ludwig Wittgenstein, Oxford 1958
• Tractatus Logico Philosophicus by Ludwig Wittgenstein, London 1922