File talk:CityEdgeForever.jpg
 | This file does not require a rating on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||
| ||||||||
Contested deletion
[edit]
JJMC89, the image does have the plot summary in the main article for the subject, please don't tag for deletion. It is the entire plot of the episode, which deserves to be on Wikipedia.
Now lets hear a common argument, more specifically, the speedy deletion tag, "the file does not significantly increase readers' understanding of the topic, and its omission would not be detrimental to that understanding", however, there are many reasons why this file is permitted with the rule. The file should be accepted as I have explained in the plot summary underneath the main article for the subject, as an image caption. I've also added the content into the file page.
The second reason that I object to this deletion is due to the fact that the file is the entire plot for the episode that this image is being used in, which is City on the Edge of Forever (South Park). The plot is that the kids are trapped at the edge of a cliff, which is portrayed in the fair-use file.
This concept has been previously done before, as with File:SouthParkWeightGain4000.jpg, and if you can properly explain why this one is accepted within this rule and this one isn't, I will allow you to delete.
My conclusion and summary is that the article does pass Criterion 8, meaning that the file should be detagged, and not deleted. I am asking JJMC89 to remove the deletion template from this file after reading this.
