Jump to content

Ernst Kantorowicz

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Ernst Hartwig Kantorowicz)
Ernst Hartwig Kantorowicz
Ernst Kantorowicz in 1921
Born(1895-05-03)May 3, 1895
Posen, German Empire
DiedSeptember 9, 1963(1963-09-09) (aged 68)
Princeton, New Jersey, United States
NationalityGerman, American
OccupationHistorian
Academic background
Alma materUniversity of Heidelberg
Doctoral advisorEberhard Gothein
Academic work
School or traditionGeorge circle (before 1933)
InstitutionsUniversity of Frankfurt
University of California, Berkeley
Institute for Advanced Study
Main interestsMedieval history
Political theology
Notable worksFrederick the Second
The King's Two Bodies
Influenced

Ernst Hartwig Kantorowicz (May 3, 1895 – September 9, 1963[7]) was a German historian of medieval political and intellectual history and art, known for his 1927 book Kaiser Friedrich der Zweite on Holy Roman Emperor Frederick II, and The King's Two Bodies (1957) on medieval and early modern ideologies of monarchy and the state.[8] He was an elected member of both the American Philosophical Society and the American Academy of Arts and Sciences.[9][10]

Life

[edit]

Early life and education

[edit]

Kantorowicz was born in Posen (then part of Prussia) to a wealthy, assimilated German-Jewish family, and as a young man was groomed to take over his family's prosperous liquor distillery business. He served as an officer in the German Army for four years in World War I. After the war, he matriculated at the University of Berlin to study economics, at one point also joining a right-wing militia that fought against Polish forces in the Greater Poland Uprising (1918–1919) and helped put down the Spartacist uprising in Berlin.[11] The following year, he transferred briefly to the University of Munich, where once again he was involved in armed clashes between leftists and pro-government militias, but soon thereafter settled on the University of Heidelberg where he continued to enroll in economics courses while developing a broader interest in Arabic, Islamic Studies, history, and geography.[12]

While in Heidelberg, Kantorowicz became involved with the so-called George-Kreis or George circle, a group of artists and intellectuals devoted to the German symbolist poet and aesthete Stefan George, believing that George's poetry and philosophy would become the foundation of a great revival of the nationalist spirit in post-war Germany.[13] In 1921, Kantorowicz was awarded a doctorate supervised by Eberhard Gothein based on a slim dissertation on "artisan associations" in the Muslim world.[14]

Frankfurt

[edit]

Despite the furor over the Frederick book, and not having written a formal Habilitationsschrift (second thesis to qualify for a professorial appointment), Kantorowicz received an (honorary) professorship at the University of Frankfurt in 1930, though he remained in Berlin until 1931.[15] By December 1933, however, Kantorowicz had to cease giving lectures due to increasing pressure on Jewish academics under the new Nazi regime, though he gave a subversive "reinaugural" lecture titled "The Secret Germany"—a motto of the George-Kreis—setting out his position in light of the new political situation on November 14 of that year.[16] After taking several leaves of absence, he was finally granted an early retirement with a pension in 1935.[17] He remained in Germany until departing for the United States in 1938, when after the Kristallnacht riots it became clear that the situation for even assimilated Jews such as himself was no longer tenable.[18]

From Berkeley to Princeton

[edit]

Kantorowicz accepted a lectureship at the University of California, Berkeley in 1939.[19] After several years, Kantorowicz was finally able to secure a permanent professorship, but in 1950, he famously resigned in protest when the UC Regents demanded that all continuing faculty sign a loyalty oath disavowing affiliation with any politically subversive movements. Kantorowicz insisted he was no leftist and pointed to his role in an anti-communist militia as a young university student, but nonetheless objected on principle to an instrument which he viewed as a blatant infringement on academic freedom and freedom of conscience more generally.[20]

During the controversy in Berkeley, two eminent German émigré medievalists working in Princeton, Theodore Mommsen (grandson of the great classical historian) and the art historian Erwin Panofsky, persuaded J. Robert Oppenheimer, director of the prestigious Institute for Advanced Study, to appoint Kantorowicz to the Institute's faculty of Historical Studies.[21] Kantorowicz accepted the offer in January 1951 and moved to Princeton, where he remained for the rest of his career.[22]

Works

[edit]

Frederick the Second

[edit]
Main article: Frederick the Second

Although his degree was in Islamic economic history, Kantorowicz's interests soon turned to the European Middle Ages and to ideas about kingship in particular. His association with the elitist and culturally conservative George-Kreis inspired Kantorowicz to undertake writing a sweeping and highly unorthodox biography of the great Holy Roman emperor Frederick II, published in German in 1927 and English in 1931.[23][24] Instead of offering a more typical survey of laws, institutions, and important political and military achievements of Frederick's reign, the book struck a distinctly panegyrical tone, portraying Frederick as a tragic hero and an idealized "Roman German".[25][26]

It included no footnotes and seemed to elide historical events with more fanciful legends and propagandistic literary depictions. The work elicited a combination of bewilderment and criticism from the mainstream historical academy. Reviewers complained that it was literary myth-making and not a work of serious historical scholarship. As a result, Kantorowicz published a hefty companion volume (Ergänzungsband) in 1931 which contained detailed historical documentation for the biography.[27]

The King's Two Bodies

[edit]
Main article: The King's Two Bodies

In 1957, Kantorowicz published his masterpiece, The King's Two Bodies, which explored, in the words of the volume's subtitle, "medieval political theology". The book traced the ways in which theologians, historians, and canon lawyers in the Middle Ages and early modern period understood "the king" as both a mortal individual and an institution which transcends time.[28] Drawing on a diverse array of textual and visual sources, including Shakespeare and Dante,[29] The King's Two Bodies made a major contribution to the way historians and political scientists came to understand the evolution of ideas about authority and charisma vested in a single individual versus transpersonal conceptions of the realm or the state in pre-modern Europe.[30] The book remains a classic in the field.[31]

Lineage in Kantorowicz's work

[edit]

Scholars in recent years have traced the origins of the King's Two Bodies to Kantorowicz's specific time and place in 1920s and 1930s Germany, and driven in part by his wish to respond to contemporaneous theories about the theological origins of modern sovereignty.

Likely due to the polarizing reception of Kantorowicz's first book about the life of Frederick II[32] (Kaiser Friedrich der Zweite) due to its lack of footnotes, Kantorowicz did rigorous research for The King's Two Bodies and cites heavily throughout the book.[33] In Frederick II, the ruler was shown to be the founder of the secular state, at that point a new type of political entity that expressed the wishes of a lay culture that had been spreading for a century in Europe.[34] Scholars draw a direct lineage of intellectual ambitions from the early to late Kantorowicz.

In Frederick II ideas about the relation between the monarch and the state are proposed but only fulfilled in the Tudor legal doctrine Kantorowicz elaborates and interprets in The King's Two Bodies: that "a successful secular state" finds its basis in "an all-encompassing body politic housed in the monarch’s body." Kantorowicz also believed that the doctrines advocated by these jurists-cum-theologians were ultimately fictitious yet emotionally satisfying. He believed that any political theory is based not on truth but non-rational psychological power.

William Shakespeare's play Richard II includes many themes relevant to the book including conceptions of the body politic.

Kantorowicz was concerned with the problem of ideas from the theological or religious world being transferred to the secular, a process that he believed characterized modernity. Thus, theological ideas are made juridical; liturgical political; and the notion of Christendom becomes a "humanistic community of mankind."

Reception

[edit]

Cantor controversy

[edit]

Kantorowicz was the subject of a controversial biographical sketch in the book Inventing the Middle Ages (1991) by the medievalist Norman Cantor. Cantor suggested that, but for his Jewish heritage, the young Kantorowicz could be considered a Nazi in terms of his intellectual temperament and cultural values. Cantor compared Kantorowicz with another contemporary German medievalist, Percy Ernst Schramm, who worked on similar topics and later joined the Nazi Party and served as the staff diarist for the German High Command during the war. In addition to highlighting Kantorowicz's elitist nationalism in the Weimar period, Cantor claimed that Kantorowicz had been under the protection of the Nazi government.[35][36]

Kantorowicz's defenders, including his student Robert L. Benson,[35] responded that although as a younger man Kantorowicz embraced the Romantic ultranationalism of the George-Kreis, he had only contempt for Nazism and was a vocal critic of Hitler's regime, both before and after the war.[36] Other historians who have criticized Kantorowicz in other respects have also since rejected Cantor's arguments, including David Abulafia and Robert E. Lerner.[37][38] Conrad Leyser, summarizing the controversy in his 2016 introduction to The King's Two Bodies, describes Cantor's account as a "tissue of falsehoods and half-truths", but also a predictable reaction to Kantorowicz's own suppression of his German past.[39] Michael Lipkin, also in 2016, concluded that Cantor was right to note the right-wing politics of Frederick the Second in particular, but he "cripples his argument by massaging his story".[36]

Works

[edit]
  • Kaiser Friedrich der Zweite, Georg Bondi, 1927.
  • Das Geheime Deutschland, Vorlesung, 1933.

Works in English

[edit]
  • Frederick II.: 1194–1250 (1931) (online at Archive.org)
  • "A Norman Finale of the Exultet and the Rite of Sarum", The Harvard Theological Review, 34 (2), (1941). doi:10.1017/S0017816000031485. JSTOR 1508128. ISSN 0017-8160.
  • "Plato in the Middle Ages", The Philosophical Review, 51 (3), (1942). doi:10.2307/2180909. JSTOR 2180909.
  • Laudes Regiae: A Study in Liturgical Acclamations and Mediaeval Ruler Worship, University of California Press, (1946). doi:10.1086/ahr/51.4.702.
  • "The Quinity of Winchester", Art Bulletin, Vol. XXIV, (1947). doi:10.2307/3047110. JSTOR 3047110.
  • The Fundamental Issue: Documents and Marginal Notes on the University of California Loyalty Oath, Parker Print. Co., 1950. OCLC 1182841.
  • "Dante's 'Two Suns'", in Semitic and Oriental Studies, 1951.
  • "Pro Patria Mori in Medieval Political Thought", The American Historical Review, 56 (3), (1951). doi:10.2307/1848433. JSTOR 1848433.
  • "Inalienability: A Note on Canonical Practice and the English Coronation Oath in the Thirteenth Century", Speculum, Vol. XXIX, 1954. JSTOR 2846791.
  • "Mysteries of State: An Absolutist Concept and its Late Medieval Origins", Harvard Theological Review, Vol. XLVIII, 1955. doi:10.2307/2846791. JSTOR 1508452.
  • The King's Two Bodies: A Study in Mediaeval Political Theology, Princeton University Press, (1957). doi:10.2307/j.ctvcszz1c. ISBN 0691017042. JSTOR j.ctvcszz1c.
  • Frederick the Second, 1194–1250, Frederick Ungar Publishing Co., 1957. ISBN 1548217115.
  • "The Prologue to Fleta and the School of Petrus de Vinea," Speculum, 32 (2), 1957. doi:10.2307/2849115. JSTOR 2849115.
  • "On the Golden Marriage Belt and the Marriage Rings of the Dumbarton Oaks Collection", Dumbarton Oaks Papers, 14, 1960. doi:10.2307/1291142. JSTOR 1291142.
  • "The Archer in the Ruthwell Cross", The Art Bulletin, 42 (1), 1960. doi:10.2307/3047875. JSTOR 3047875.
  • "Gods in Uniform", Proceedings of the American Philosophical Society, Vol. CV, 1961. OCLC 84680316. JSTOR 985496.
  • "Puer Exoriens: On the Hypapante in the Mosaics of S. Maria Maggiore," Perennitas, 1963.
  • Selected Studies, J.J. Augustin, 1965. OCLC 1600443.

See also

[edit]
  • Harold F. Cherniss, historian of ancient philosophy, friend and colleague of Kantorowicz, helped him secure a position at the Institute at Advanced Study after the 'loyalty oath' affair at Berkeley
  • Kahler-Kreis

References

[edit]
  1. ^ Choudhury, Soumyabrata (2011). "Why the People To Come Will Not, and Must Not, Be Sovereign: Notes on a Political and Mathematical Puzzle". In Bradley, Arthur; Fletcher, Paul (eds.). The Messianic Now: Philosophy, Religion, Culture. Abingdon: Routledge. p. 177.
  2. ^ Merquior, J. G. (1985). Foucault. Berkeley: University of California Press. p. 88.
  3. ^ Monateri, Pier Giuseppe (2018). Dominus Mundi: Political Sublime and the World Order. Oxford: Hart. p. 65.
  4. ^ Dasenbrock, Reed Way (1991). Imitating the Italians: Wyatt, Spenser, Synge, Pound, Joyce. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. p. 250.
  5. ^ Bratsis, Peter (2016). Everyday Life and the State. Abingdon: Routledge. p. 33.
  6. ^ McVicar, Michael (2015). Christian Reconstruction: R.J. Rushdoony and American Religious Conservatism. Chapel Hill: The University of North Carolina Press. p. 28.
  7. ^ Lerner 2017, pp. 376, 385.
  8. ^ Norman F. Cantor, Inventing the Middle Ages, (1991) pp. 79-117.
  9. ^ "APS Member History". search.amphilsoc.org. Retrieved 2022-12-21.
  10. ^ "Ernst Hartwig Kantorowicz". American Academy of Arts & Sciences. Retrieved 2022-12-21.
  11. ^ Friedländer, Saul (2007). Den Holocaust beschreiben (in German). Wallstein Verlag. p. 78. ISBN 9783835301856.
  12. ^ Lerner, Robert E. (2017). Ernst Kantorowicz: A Life. Princeton University Press. p. 59. doi:10.2307/j.ctt21c4v3z. ISBN 9781400882922. JSTOR j.ctt21c4v3z. OCLC 1080549540.
  13. ^ Goldsmith, Ulrich (1959). Stefan George: A Study of his Early Work. New York: Columbia University Press.
  14. ^ Lerner 2017, p. 62.
  15. ^ Lerner 2017, p. 146.
  16. ^ Lerner 2017, p. 168.
  17. ^ Lerner 2017, p. 187.
  18. ^ Lerner 2017, p. 201.
  19. ^ Lerner 2017, p. 221.
  20. ^ Ernst H. Kantorowicz (1950). "The Fundamental Issue: Documents and Marginal Notes on the University of California Loyalty Oath". San Francisco: Parker Printing Co.
  21. ^ Lerner 2017, p. 330.
  22. ^ Lerner 2017, p. 333.
  23. ^ "Ernst Kantorowicz: man of two bodies - Book Review - Biography". TLS. Retrieved 2021-07-02.
  24. ^ Kantorowicz, Ernst. Frederick the Second, 1194–1250, Frederick Ungar Publishing Co., 1957.
  25. ^ Abulafia, David (1997). "Kantorowicz, Frederick II and England". In Benson, Robert L.; Fried, Johannes (eds.). Ernst Kantorowicz. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag. p. 125. ISBN 978-3515069595.
  26. ^ Lerner 2017, pp. 105, 115.
  27. ^ Leyser, Conrad (2016). "Introduction to the Princeton Classics Edition". The King's Two Bodies: A Study in Mediaeval Political Theology. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press. pp. x–xi. ISBN 978-0691169231.
  28. ^ Leyser 2016, pp. xix–xx.
  29. ^ Lerner 2017, pp. 355, 350, 352.
  30. ^ Leyser 2016, pp. ix–x.
  31. ^ Lerner 2017, p. 357.
  32. ^ Translated to English as Frederick the Second: 1194–1250.
  33. ^ Kahn, Victoria (Spring 2009). "Political Theology and Fiction in The King's Two Bodies". Representations. 106 (1): 77–101. doi:10.1525/rep.2009.106.1.77. JSTOR 10.1525/rep.2009.106.1.77.
  34. ^ Monod, Paul (1 August 2005). "Reading the Two Bodies of Ernst Kantorowicz". Leo Baeck Institute Yearbook. 50 (1): 105–123. doi:10.3167/007587405781998534 (inactive 2024-11-13). ISSN 0075-8744.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: DOI inactive as of November 2024 (link)
  35. ^ a b "Defending Kantorowicz," Letter to the New York Review of Books by Robert L. Benson, Ralph E. Giesey and Margaret Sevcenko and response by Robert Bartlett, Aug. 13, 1992.
  36. ^ a b c Lipkin, Michael (15 June 2016). "When Emperors Are No More". The Paris Review. Retrieved 20 December 2019.
  37. ^ Abulafia, David (1997). "Kantorowicz, Frederick II and England". In Benson, Robert L.; Fried, Johannes (eds.). Ernst Kantorowicz. Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag. pp. 125–26. ISBN 978-3515069595.
  38. ^ Lerner 2017, p. 185.
  39. ^ Leyser 2016, p. xiv.

Further reading

[edit]
  • Abulafia, David. "Kantorowicz and Frederick II." History 62(205) (1977): 193–210. JSTOR 24411237.
  • Boureau, Alain. Kantorowicz: Stories of a Historian The Johns Hopkins University Press, 2001. ISBN 9780801866234.
  • Cantor, Norman F. (1st) Inventing the Middle Ages, 1991. pp 79–117. negative view of Kantorowicz. ISBN 0688123023.
  • Daum, Andreas, Hartmut Lehmann, James Sheehan (eds.), The Second Generation: Émigrés from Nazi Germany as Historians. With a Biobibliographic Guide. New York: Berghahn Books, 2016, ISBN 978-1-78238-985-9.
  • Franke, Norman, "‘Divina Commedia teutsch’? Ernst H. Kantorowicz: Der Historiker als Politiker." In: Historische Zeitschrift (291, 2/2010), pp. 297–330 (German)
  • Franke, Norman, ’Honour and Shame’. Karl Wolfskehl and the v. Stauffenberg Brothers: Political Eschatology in Stefan George's Circle. In: Simms, Norman (ed.): Letters and Texts of Jewish History. Hamilton 1998, pp. 89–120
  • Free, John B. "Ernst Kantorowicz. An Accounting", Central European History, 32(2), (1999). JSTOR 4546870.
  • Landauer, Carl. "Ernst Kantorowicz and the Sacralization of the Past", Central European History, Vol. 27(1), (1994). JSTOR 4546389.
  • Lerner, Robert. Ernst Kantorowicz: A Life. Princeton University Press, 2016. ISBN 069117282X.
    • Medieval Scholarship Biographical Studies on the Formation of a Discipline: History, Vol. I, ed. Helen Damico & Joseph B Zavadil, 1995; biographical essays for "Ernst H. Kantorowicz" by Robert E. Lerner and "Percy Ernst Schramm" by Janos Bak, both of whom respond to allegations in Cantor's book. ISBN 9780824068943.
  • Peters, Edward. "More Trouble With Henry: The Historiography of Medieval Germany in the Angloliterate World, 1888–1995." Central European History 28, no. 1 (1995): 47–72. doi:10.1017/S0008938900011249. ISSN 0008-9389.
  • Rust, Jennifer R. "Political Theologies of the Corpus Mysticum: Schmitt, Kantorowicz, and de Lubac" (on The King's Two Bodies) in Political Theology and Early Modernity (University of Chicago Press, 2012): 102–123. doi:10.7208/chicago/9780226314990.001.0001. ISBN 9780226314976.
[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Ernst_Kantorowicz&oldid=1257092310"